Adam Neumann (Adam Neumann) — WeWork (coworking spaces) (WeWork (The We Company))
After WeWork made its IPO filing public on 2019-08-14, its losses and corporate governance problems set off a backlash, and its valuation was cut again and again from $47 billion. Co-founder Adam Neumann resigned as CEO on 2019-09-24, and his super-voting rights were reduced from 10 votes per share to 3. In late October SoftBank put forward a takeover plan under which he left the board to become an observer, the board obtained voting control over his shares, and a consulting fee bought his agreement not to start a rival venture for four years. In 2020 SoftBank withdrew its $3 billion tender offer for shares, the two sides went to court, and they settled in 2021-02. WeWork filed for bankruptcy protection on 2023-11-06. In 2024 Neumann bid through his new company, Flow, to buy it back; the company would not accept the bid and the court also found it not viable, and he gave up in 2024-05. WeWork emerged from bankruptcy on 2024-06-11 under the control of Yardi Systems.
How they were ousted
After the IPO attempt foundered, he resigned as CEO on 2019-09-24 under pressure from largest shareholder SoftBank and some directors, giving up majority voting control. A month later SoftBank's takeover plan removed him from the board as well, leaving him only an observer.
What happened to the board
Neumann did not come back, so no "reckoning with the board after a return" took place. Masayoshi Son, the SoftBank founder who drove the ouster, is still chairman and CEO of SoftBank. Marcelo Claure, who was sent in to take charge, left SoftBank in January 2022 after pay talks broke down and soon ceased to be WeWork's chairman as well; this had nothing to do with Neumann. In 2020, longtime directors Bruce Dunlevie and Lew Frankfort actually stood on the same side as Neumann in suing SoftBank; Dunlevie did not resign as a director until 2023, and the company said it was not because of any disagreement. What really turned over the entire board was the bankruptcy reorganization of 2023–2024: as of 2024-06-11, four of the seven directors come from the new majority owner, Yardi Systems.
Timeline
- WeWork's IPO filing (S-1) made public Parent company The We Company filed its S-1 with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. The filing revealed huge losses, Neumann's control of the company through super-voting shares, and a number of self-dealing transactions between him and the company, drawing criticism from investors and governance experts. [Wikipedia: WeWork] [Fortune]
- Board adds its first female director; "We" trademark deal unwound Harvard Business School professor Frances Frei joined what had been an all-male board. Word also emerged that the deal in which Neumann had sold the "We" trademark to the company for $5.9 million would be unwound. [Wikipedia: WeWork] [Wikipedia: Adam Neumann]
- IPO filing amended in the first curtailment of Neumann's power High-vote shares were reduced from 20 votes per share to 10; his successor as CEO would be chosen by the board; no member of his family could be a director; and his profits from real estate transactions with the company would be returned to it. By this point the valuation the market expected for the IPO had fallen as low as about $15 billion. [Fortune]
- IPO postponed Amid a tepid response from investors, WeWork postponed its listing and roadshow. [Wikipedia: WeWork] [CNBC]
- The Wall Street Journal: some directors plan to ask Neumann to step down The WSJ was first to report that directors linked to SoftBank planned to ask him to resign as CEO. CNBC, citing people familiar with the matter, said Masayoshi Son favored a change and that the board might discuss making him non-executive chairman. The reports also noted that some directors not aligned with SoftBank still supported his staying on. [CNBC] [Wikipedia: Adam Neumann]
- Neumann resigns as CEO and becomes non-executive chairman The company announced, effective immediately, that Artie Minson and Sebastian Gunningham would take over as co-CEOs. His high-vote shares were reduced from 10 votes per share to 3, and he no longer held majority voting control. He said in a statement that the scrutiny directed at him personally had become a significant distraction for the company. [WeWork 官方新聞稿] [TechCrunch] [CNBC]
- S-1 withdrawn; IPO shelved indefinitely The two co-CEOs announced the withdrawal of the IPO filing, saying the company would focus on its core business and return to the public markets in the future. Analysts warned that at its then rate of cash burn, the company could run short of money as early as the first quarter of 2020. [SiliconANGLE]
- Neumann turns to JPMorgan for a $5 billion lifeline Neumann, still chairman, approached JPMorgan to raise $5 billion in rescue financing; JPMorgan said it was confident of raising the money but would not underwrite it on the spot. Days later a competing proposal from SoftBank surfaced, along with word that if its plan were rejected it would not honor its existing $1.5 billion funding commitment. [Reuters(Dawn 轉載)]
- SoftBank's takeover plan: Neumann leaves the board WeWork and SoftBank signed a master agreement: SoftBank would provide about $5 billion in new financing, accelerate a $1.5 billion payment and commit to buying up to $3 billion of stock from existing shareholders, raising its stake to about 80%. Neumann would leave the board to become an observer; he could sell up to $970 million of stock, would receive a $185 million consulting fee and a $500 million credit line to repay personal loans, and committed to a four-year noncompete. [Reuters(Dawn 轉載)] [Bloomberg(WealthManagement 轉載)] [Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance]
- Claure explains to employees why Neumann is being paid New chairman Claure told employees that Neumann's exit package was the price that had to be paid to take away his voting rights. The special committee had earlier worried too that the money would provoke a backlash among employees. [Reuters(Dawn 轉載)]
- Board reconstitution takes effect; board gains voting control over Neumann's shares SoftBank's $1.5 billion arrived. The board was changed to 10 seats: 5 for the SoftBank side (Ron Fisher, Marcelo Claure, Steven Langman and two to be filled), Benchmark's Dunlevie, Hony Capital's John Zhao, independent directors Jeff Sine and Mark Schwartz, and Lew Frankfort of the special committee. Claure became executive chairman and Neumann an observer. [WeWork 官方新聞稿]
- Minority shareholder sues Neumann, the directors and SoftBank Shareholder Natalie Sojka filed a class and derivative action in San Francisco Superior Court, alleging that Neumann, the directors and SoftBank had breached their fiduciary duties and wasted corporate assets; the exit package was also among the matters in dispute. [Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance]
- Masayoshi Son publicly admits his mistake SoftBank reported its first operating loss in 14 years (about 704.4 billion yen). At a press conference in Tokyo, Masayoshi Son admitted that his judgment had been faulty and that he had trusted Neumann too much, saying he had learned a harsh lesson. [Business Day(Reuters)]
- WeWork reportedly courting T-Mobile CEO John Legere as its next CEO The WSJ reported that WeWork was in talks with T-Mobile CEO John Legere about becoming its CEO; WeWork declined to comment. In the end the job did not go to him. [Commercial Observer]
- Sandeep Mathrani announced as CEO Real estate veteran Mathrani was appointed and started on 2020-02-18, replacing co-CEOs Minson and Gunningham. [Wikipedia: WeWork] [Wikipedia: Artie Minson]
- SoftBank terminates its $3 billion tender offer SoftBank said several closing conditions had not been met, citing reasons that included criminal and civil investigations facing the company, the uncompleted restructuring of its China joint venture, and the impact of the pandemic. Neumann had stood to sell nearly $1 billion of stock. [Legal 500(Hughes Hubbard & Reed 評析)] [The Register]
- Special committee sues SoftBank on the company's behalf The special committee, made up of Dunlevie and Frankfort, filed suit in the Delaware Court of Chancery asking the court to order SoftBank to complete the purchase or pay damages. SoftBank responded that nothing in the complaint could undo its decision to terminate the offer and that it would defend itself vigorously. [The Register] [CNBC]
- Neumann also sues SoftBank and the Vision Fund Neumann filed suit in Delaware court, arguing that SoftBank had wrongfully terminated the tender offer. SoftBank's chief legal officer, Rob Townsend, responded that his claims were without merit and that under the agreement SoftBank had no obligation to complete the purchase. [CNBC]
- Board adds two new directors and forms a new committee to counter the directors who sued Reports said WeWork would vote that week on adding Alex Dimitrief, former general counsel of GE, and Frederick Arnold, former CFO of Convergex; the two were widely expected to be set against Dunlevie and Frankfort, who had sued. Chancellor Andre Bouchard rejected the two directors' request to block the appointments and the formation of the new committee. [Allwork.Space]
- Co-founder McKelvey announces his departure Miguel McKelvey announced he would leave WeWork at the end of June; with that, neither founder remained at the company. [Wikipedia: Miguel McKelvey]
- Court refuses to let the new committee drop the special committee's lawsuit The Delaware Court of Chancery denied the company's motion to withdraw the complaint. The court found that the board that set up the new committee was itself conflicted, and criticized the new committee's investigation and conclusions as insufficiently rigorous. The litigation was allowed to continue, with trial set for early 2021. [Legal 500(Hughes Hubbard & Reed 評析)]
- SoftBank settles with WeWork and Neumann They settled before the trial that had been set for March 4. According to reports, SoftBank would buy half of the originally planned $3 billion of stock at the 2019 price; Neumann would sell about $480 million of stock and receive a further $50 million for legal fees and $50 million in previously promised noncompete payments, and a $430 million loan would be extended by five years. He could not attend board meetings for one year, and returning after that would require SoftBank's consent. [Bloomberg(Yahoo Finance 轉載)]
- WSJ reveals Neumann's renegotiated exit terms The WSJ reported that he received $106 million in cash, the ability to sell $578 million of stock, the refinancing of $432 million of debt, and a new stock award worth about $245 million. [Wikipedia: Adam Neumann]
- WeWork lists on the New York Stock Exchange through a SPAC BowX Acquisition's shareholders approved the merger almost unanimously on 10-19, and trading began on 10-21 under the ticker WE at a valuation of about $8 billion, opening at $10.38. The CEO by then was Mathrani; Neumann was no longer part of management or the board. [Commercial Observer]
- Claure leaves SoftBank SoftBank confirmed that COO Claure was leaving. Media reported that he had sought compensation of about $2 billion over several years (partly for his work on WeWork), while Masayoshi Son was willing to pay only tens of millions of dollars. In March of that year Mathrani became WeWork's chairman. [Commercial Observer] [Wikipedia: Marcelo Claure]
- Andreessen Horowitz invests in Neumann's new company, Flow Venture capital firm a16z invested about $350 million, its largest single check, valuing Flow at more than $1 billion; Marc Andreessen was to join Flow's board. Flow is in residential rentals, not coworking. [Commercial Observer]
- Mathrani announces his resignation; Tolley becomes interim CEO WeWork announced that CEO Mathrani would leave on 5-26 to join Sycamore Partners. David Tolley, a former Blackstone partner who had joined the board only in 2023, would fill in on an interim basis; he was made permanent in October. [Bisnow] [AP(Spectrum News NY1 轉載)]
- WeWork files for bankruptcy protection WeWork filed for Chapter 11 reorganization in federal court in New Jersey, listing liabilities of more than $18.6 billion; about 90% of its creditors agreed to convert $3 billion of debt into equity. The filing showed that SoftBank held more than 65%. Neumann issued a statement calling the outcome disappointing. [TechCrunch]
- Neumann's lawyer writes: he wants to buy back WeWork, but the company won't provide information Lawyer Alex Spiro sent a letter on behalf of Neumann and Flow Global saying that requests for information made since December 2023 had gone unanswered, and that the effort had the backing of financing partners including Dan Loeb's Third Point. Third Point promptly clarified that it had had only preliminary conversations and had made no commitment to take part in any transaction. [AP(Spectrum News NY1 轉載)] [Reuters(Business Day 轉載)]
- Flow's bid rises to $650 million; Neumann objects in court to the company's plan Neumann first made a bid of more than $500 million in March, later raised it to $650 million, and filed a statement with the court opposing the company's reorganization plan, calling it undercapitalized and unlikely to last. WeWork, for its part, lined up its own financing; financial adviser PJT said creditors would not accept funding from the Flow side. [Bisnow] [Reuters(Yahoo Finance 轉載)]
- Neumann abandons his bid to buy back WeWork After the bankruptcy judge found earlier in May that his bid was not viable (it did not deal with about $4 billion of debt), Neumann told The New York Times' DealBook that he would no longer bid, and criticized the company's reorganization plan as unrealistic. The winning proposal was a $450 million plan led by Yardi Systems and others. [Fortune] [Reuters(Yahoo Finance 轉載)]
- Court approves WeWork's reorganization plan The bankruptcy court approved the reorganization plan, eliminating about $4 billion of debt. Yardi Systems acquired a majority stake through its affiliate Cupar Grimmond. [Wikipedia: WeWork] [AP(Spectrum News NY1 轉載)]
- WeWork exits bankruptcy; board completely replaced WeWork completed its reorganization as a private company. Tolley stepped down as CEO and director, and John Santora took over on 6-12. The new seven-member board: four seats for Yardi Systems (including founder Anant Yardi), one for King Street, one for SoftBank Investment Advisers, plus Santora. [WeWork 官方新聞稿] [AP(Spectrum News NY1 轉載)]
- Flow launches coworking brand Workflow Having failed to buy back WeWork, Neumann's Flow announced its own coworking business, Workflow, stressing that it does not sign long-term leases. [Wikipedia: Adam Neumann]
People
- Adam Neumann (Adam Neumann), 1979-04-25 — WeWork co-founder, CEO and chairman (2010–2019). Born in Beersheba, Israel; served in the Israeli Navy from 1996 to 2001. He then moved to New York to attend Baruch College, left in 2002 just short of graduating to start a business, and went back to finish his degree only in 2017. In 2008 he and Miguel McKelvey first started Green Desk, a shared office space; in 2010 the two co-founded WeWork, where he was CEO until 2019. He and McKelvey met while working in the same office building in New York. Benchmark's Bruce Dunlevie was the earliest major investor; SoftBank's Masayoshi Son became the biggest backer from 2017, and invested again in January 2019 at a $47 billion valuation. After resigning as CEO he was removed from the board as well and never returned to WeWork. In 2022 he founded Flow, a residential rental company, which received about $350 million from Andreessen Horowitz. In 2024 his bid to buy back the bankrupt WeWork failed, and that October Flow launched its own coworking brand, Workflow. [Wikipedia: Adam Neumann] [Commercial Observer] [Fortune]
- Masayoshi Son (Masayoshi Son), 1957-08-11 — Chairman and CEO of SoftBank Group; the man at the helm of WeWork's largest shareholder. Born in Tosu, Saga Prefecture, Japan; went to the United States to study at the University of California, Berkeley, earning a bachelor's degree in economics in 1980. Founded SoftBank in 1981, starting out in software distribution and computer publishing. Not on WeWork's board himself; invested in WeWork through SoftBank and the Vision Fund and designated directors. In January 2019 SoftBank invested a further $2 billion at a $47 billion valuation. Neumann's most important backer. On 2019-09-22 media outlets cited people familiar with the matter as saying he favored replacing Neumann; he later publicly admitted that he had trusted Neumann too much. Still chairman and CEO of SoftBank Group. SoftBank booked huge losses on WeWork and held more than 65% of it when it went bankrupt; after the reorganization the SoftBank group still has one seat on the seven-member board. [Wikipedia: Masayoshi Son] [CNBC] [Business Day(Reuters)] [WeWork 官方新聞稿]
- Marcelo Claure (Marcelo Claure), 1970-12-09 — COO of SoftBank Group; executive chairman of WeWork from October 2019. Born in Guatemala City; graduated from Bentley College in the United States in 1993 (economics and finance). Founded mobile phone distributor Brightstar in Miami in 1997, in which SoftBank later bought a majority stake; CEO of Sprint from 2014 and COO of SoftBank from 2018. Assigned by Masayoshi Son. In the October 2019 takeover plan he negotiated with Neumann in New York, and on 2019-10-30 he became executive chairman of WeWork as a SoftBank-designated director. Masayoshi Son's right-hand man: SoftBank first acquired Brightstar, the company he founded, then put him in charge of Sprint. He and Neumann were adversaries at the negotiating table: his job was to buy out Neumann's voting rights and board seat. SoftBank confirmed his departure on 2022-01-28; media reported that the cause was a breakdown in pay talks (he had sought about $2 billion over several years). Mathrani then took over as WeWork's chairman in March 2022. He later founded Claure Group and Bicycle Capital and became group vice chairman of Shein. [Wikipedia: Marcelo Claure] [Commercial Observer] [Reuters(Dawn 轉載)]
- Bruce Dunlevie (Bruce Dunlevie) — WeWork director; partner at venture capital firm Benchmark (representing Benchmark). Co-founded Silicon Valley venture capital firm Benchmark in 1995 with Bob Kagle, Andy Rachleff, Kevin Harvey and Val Vaden. Benchmark led WeWork's Series A in 2012; he was WeWork's first major investor and served as a director representing Benchmark. The earliest venture capitalist to bet on Neumann. Reports in September 2019 said Benchmark and other investors blamed Neumann for the collapse in valuation, but it is not clear whether Benchmark led the push to oust him. In 2020, as a member of the special committee, he was on the same side as Neumann in suing SoftBank. Resigned as a WeWork director in 2023 (exact date not found); the company said it was not because of any disagreement with the company. His stake also fell from about 2.9% to about 0.5%. [Wikipedia: Benchmark (venture capital firm)] [InvestorPlace] [CNBC] [Reuters(Dawn 轉載)]
- Lew Frankfort (Lew Frankfort) — WeWork independent director; member of the special committee; former chairman and CEO of luxury brand Coach. Born in the Bronx, New York. Bachelor's degree from Hunter College, MBA from Columbia Business School. Joined Coach in 1979, was chairman and CEO from 1995 and handed over in 2014. Joined WeWork's board as an independent director (year not found); after the October 2019 board reconstitution he stayed on as the special committee's representative. He and Dunlevie made up the special committee, which was responsible for evaluating the two rescue proposals, from SoftBank and JPMorgan, on behalf of minority shareholders and for negotiating the takeover agreement. On 2020-04-07 the two sued SoftBank on the company's behalf for breaching the deal. There is no public record of his personal position on Neumann's ouster. The litigation with SoftBank was settled on 2021-02-26; exactly when he left WeWork's board was not found. [Wikipedia: Lewis Frankfort] [WeWork 官方新聞稿(2019-10-30)] [CNBC]
- Steven Langman (Steven Langman) — WeWork director; co-founder of private equity firm Rhône Group. Co-founded private equity firm Rhône Group with Robert Agostinelli in 1995; the two have run it together since its founding. Rhône has worked with WeWork since 2016 and in March 2017 set up a $400 million real estate fund jointly with WeWork. The year he became a WeWork director could not be confirmed from an accessible source. A longtime director from the Neumann era. After the reconstitution of 2019-10-30 he was listed as one of the five directors designated by SoftBank/the Vision Fund. There is no public record of his personal position during the ouster. Stayed on after the October 2019 reconstitution as a SoftBank-designated director; when he later left the board was not found. [Wikipedia: Rhône Group] [WeWork 官方新聞稿(2019-10-30)]
- Artie Minson (Artie Minson), 1970-10-29 — WeWork co-president and CFO; co-CEO after Neumann stepped down. Bachelor's degree from Georgetown University, MBA from Columbia Business School. Worked at Rainbow Media and AOL and was CFO of Time Warner Cable. Joined WeWork in June 2015 as president and COO, later also overseeing finance. A senior executive recruited by Neumann; on 2019-09-24 the board had him and Sebastian Gunningham take over together as co-CEOs. Replaced in February 2020 by Sandeep Mathrani, whom SoftBank had recruited. CEO of LeafLink from April 2022, later CEO of AI accounting platform Trullion. [Wikipedia: Artie Minson] [WeWork 官方新聞稿(2019-09-24)]
- Sebastian Gunningham (Sebastian Gunningham) — WeWork vice chairman; co-CEO after Neumann stepped down. A former senior Amazon executive who became vice chairman after joining WeWork. Joined WeWork as vice chairman (date not found). A senior executive of the Neumann era; on 2019-09-24 the board had him and Artie Minson take over together as co-CEOs. Replaced along with Minson by Sandeep Mathrani in February 2020; what he did afterward was not found. [CNBC] [Wikipedia: Artie Minson]
- Sandeep Mathrani (Sandeep Mathrani), 1962 — WeWork CEO (2020-02 to 2023-05), later also chairman. Born in Mumbai, India; bachelor's and master's degrees from Stevens Institute of Technology in the United States. CEO of shopping mall operator GGP from 2011 to 2018, then CEO of the retail group at Brookfield Properties. A real estate veteran recruited after SoftBank took over; his appointment was announced on 2020-02-01 and he started on 2020-02-18. Paired with Claure to carry out the restructuring; had never worked with Neumann. Took WeWork public through a SPAC in 2021. Announced his resignation on 2023-05-16, effective 5-26, to join private equity firm Sycamore Partners; founded Atlas Hill RE in September 2024. WeWork filed for bankruptcy half a year after he left. [Wikipedia: Sandeep Mathrani] [Bisnow] [Wikipedia: WeWork]
- David Tolley (David Tolley) — WeWork director (joined 2023), interim CEO, then CEO (2023-10 to 2024-06). A former partner at private equity firm Blackstone. Joined WeWork's board in 2023; became interim CEO on 2023-05-26 after Mathrani left and was made permanent that October. Led WeWork into and through its bankruptcy reorganization. When Neumann tried to buy back the company in 2024, it was the management team he led that Neumann was up against; the company chose the plan backed by its creditors and Yardi. Announced he was stepping down as CEO and director on the day WeWork emerged from bankruptcy; John Santora, formerly of Cushman & Wakefield, took over on 2024-06-12. [WeWork 官方新聞稿] [AP(Spectrum News NY1 轉載)] [Bisnow]
- Miguel McKelvey (Miguel McKelvey), 1974-07-04 — WeWork co-founder, chief culture officer. Grew up in Eugene, Oregon; earned a bachelor's degree in architecture from the University of Oregon in 1999 and played on the school's basketball team for two years. Worked with Neumann on Green Desk in 2008 and co-founded WeWork in 2010, where he was responsible for architectural design and company culture. He and Neumann worked in the same office building in New York and met at a party. Announced on 2020-06-05 that he would leave WeWork at the end of that month. [Wikipedia: Miguel McKelvey]
Moves to block a return
- (The first cut, before he stepped down) To save the IPO, the company amended its filing: Neumann's high-vote shares were reduced from 20 votes per share to 10; his successor as CEO would be chosen by the board (rather than by a committee that included his wife); and no member of his family could serve as a director. [Fortune] [Fortune(治理專家評論)]
- On the same day he resigned as CEO, his high-vote shares were cut again, from 10 votes per share to 3. From then on he no longer held majority voting control, and so lost the ability to replace the board on his own. [TechCrunch] [CNBC]
- SoftBank's takeover plan: Neumann would leave the board and could attend only as an observer; SoftBank would pay him a $185 million "consulting fee" in exchange for a four-year noncompete (other reports described it as a commitment to work only for WeWork for four years). SoftBank COO Claure told employees the next day that the money was the price of taking away his voting rights. [Reuters(Dawn 轉載)] [Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance] [Bloomberg(WealthManagement 轉載)]
- Governance changes took effect: the board was reconstituted with 10 seats, 5 of them designated by SoftBank or the Vision Fund, and Claure became executive chairman. Neumann formally became a board observer, and voting control over the shares in his name passed to the board. [WeWork 官方新聞稿]
- SoftBank terminated its tender offer to buy up to $3 billion of stock from existing shareholders, citing the failure of several closing conditions. Neumann, who could have sold nearly $1 billion of his shares through it, was to have been the biggest beneficiary. [Legal 500(Hughes Hubbard & Reed 評析)] [The Register] [CNBC]
- (Date of report) After the special committee sued SoftBank on the company's behalf, the board, dominated by SoftBank designees, brought in two new directors, Alex Dimitrief and Frederick Arnold, to form a new committee that was widely expected to be used against the two directors who had sued. Chancellor Bouchard declined to block the arrangement. The new committee later determined that the special committee had no authority to sue, and on that basis the company moved to withdraw the lawsuit. [Allwork.Space] [Legal 500(Hughes Hubbard & Reed 評析)]
- One of the settlement terms: Neumann had to give up even his board observer seat for one year; after that, returning as an observer or designating someone else would require SoftBank's consent. (Under the same settlement he also received about $480 million in proceeds from selling shares and two payments of $50 million each; see the timeline.) [Bloomberg(Yahoo Finance 轉載)]
- Neumann's lawyer, Alex Spiro, wrote a letter saying that Neumann and Flow had been asking the bankrupt WeWork since December 2023 for the information needed to make a bid, and that the company had consistently failed to respond or provide it. WeWork said only that it regularly received expressions of interest from outside parties and would review them in the company's best interests. [AP(Spectrum News NY1 轉載)] [Reuters(Business Day 轉載)]
- (Date of report) WeWork lined up its own financing for the reorganization and pressed ahead with its own plan. In a declaration, the company's financial adviser, PJT Partners, said creditors would not agree to funding from a third party (including the Flow side). By this point Flow's bid had been raised to $650 million. [Bisnow]
- (Date of report) Earlier in May, the bankruptcy judge in New Jersey had found Neumann's bid not viable because it did not deal with the roughly $4 billion of debt on WeWork's books; what the court approved was the plan of the company, its creditors and Yardi Systems. Neumann promptly announced he was giving up. [Fortune]
Rumors
- Some WeWork directors and SoftBank planned to ask Neumann to resign as CEO, possibly becoming non-executive chairman instead. [Later confirmed] First reported by The Wall Street Journal; followed up by CNBC, Bloomberg and others Two days later the company formally announced that he had resigned as CEO and become non-executive chairman. [CNBC] [WeWork 官方新聞稿]
- SoftBank's real aim in ousting Neumann was to block the IPO, so that it would not be forced to book a loss on the stake it had bought at a $47 billion valuation. [Still unclear] CNBC, citing two people familiar with the matter and describing this as a view held inside WeWork Neither SoftBank nor WeWork commented at the time. The IPO was indeed withdrawn a week later, but the motive has never been confirmed by anyone involved. [CNBC]
- For leaving the board, Neumann stood to get nearly $1.7 billion from SoftBank: up to $970 million from selling stock, a $185 million consulting fee and a $500 million credit line. [Later confirmed] The Wall Street Journal and Bloomberg, citing people familiar with the matter SoftBank's public statement did not give the amounts, but Claure acknowledged to employees the next day that the money was the price of taking away his voting rights, and later court filings and reports used the same figures. The stock sale portion, however, was not carried out as originally planned because SoftBank withdrew its tender offer, and the amounts he actually received after the 2021 settlement were different. [Bloomberg(WealthManagement 轉載)] [Reuters(Dawn 轉載)] [Bloomberg(Yahoo Finance 轉載)]
- Although Neumann left the board, he could still designate two directors. [Still unclear] Bloomberg, citing one person familiar with the matter The official list of 10 directors announced on 2019-10-30 did not identify any seat as designated by Neumann; no public document could be found confirming or denying the claim. [Bloomberg(WealthManagement 轉載)] [WeWork 官方新聞稿]
- WeWork was in talks with T-Mobile CEO John Legere about becoming its CEO. [Proven false] The Wall Street Journal WeWork declined to comment at the time; in the end it announced on 2020-02-01 that Sandeep Mathrani would become CEO. There is no official word on whether talks actually took place; all that is certain is that he did not take the job. [Commercial Observer] [Wikipedia: WeWork]
- Neumann's plan to buy back WeWork had financial backing from Dan Loeb's hedge fund, Third Point. [Proven false] The letter from Neumann's lawyer, Alex Spiro, to WeWork, as reported by Bloomberg, Reuters and the AP Third Point said publicly that it had had only preliminary conversations with Flow and Neumann and had made no commitment to take part in any transaction. [AP(Spectrum News NY1 轉載)] [Reuters(Business Day 轉載)]
Views
- Charles Elson (Weinberg Center for Corporate Governance, University of Delaware): The problem lay in the dual-class share structure: thanks to those shares, Neumann held all the cards and could turn around and replace the board, so the board could not necessarily fire him. [Fortune]
- Nell Minow (vice chair of ValueEdge Advisors, corporate governance expert): A board has to be independent, not just a potted plant there for show; a company with a governance structure like WeWork's should not go public at all. [Fortune]
- Amy Borrus (deputy director of the Council of Institutional Investors, CII): Welcomed the changes, but said that even at 10 votes per share the founder still had overwhelming control, leaving the board and public shareholders as weak as before. [Fortune]
- Marcelo Claure (SoftBank COO, new executive chairman of WeWork): He told employees that the money was the price that had to be paid to take away Neumann's voting rights. [Reuters(Dawn 轉載)]
- Masayoshi Son (chairman and CEO of SoftBank): He admitted that his judgment had been faulty and that he had trusted Neumann too much, calling it a harsh lesson and saying he should have seen it clearly sooner. [Business Day(Reuters)]
- Joseph Bachelder (special counsel at law firm McCarter & English, executive compensation lawyer): He described the package as extraordinary and hard to find a precedent for; it appeared designed to secure Neumann's stepping down, his surrender of his board seat and voting control, and his acceptance of four years of exclusivity. [Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance]
- Rob Townsend (SoftBank chief legal officer): He said Neumann's claims were without merit, and that under the agreement SoftBank never had an obligation to complete the share purchase. [CNBC]
- Delaware Court of Chancery (ruling in In re WeWork Litigation): The court noted that the board that set up the new committee consisted largely of SoftBank designees and was itself conflicted, and that the new committee's investigation and conclusions were insufficiently rigorous; it therefore refused to allow the suit to be dropped. [Legal 500(Hughes Hubbard & Reed 評析)]
- Marcelo Claure (WeWork executive chairman, SoftBank COO): He said the settlement meant all parties had chosen to do what was best for WeWork's future. The side of the directors who sued had earlier described SoftBank's withdrawal of the offer as a case of "buyer's remorse." [Bloomberg(Yahoo Finance 轉載)]
- Marc Andreessen (co-founder of venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz): He said in a blog post that residential real estate was ready for exactly this kind of change. [Commercial Observer]
- Adam Neumann (WeWork co-founder): He issued a statement saying it was disappointing to see WeWork reach the point of filing for bankruptcy. [TechCrunch]
- Adam Neumann (founder of Flow, in a statement filed with the bankruptcy court): He argued that the company's plan could not hold up: it was severely undercapitalized, would turn cash-flow negative in 2025 and would burn through its cash in 2027. [Bisnow]
- Adam Neumann (in an interview with The New York Times' DealBook): He said WeWork's plan for getting out of its predicament was unrealistic and unlikely to succeed, so he would no longer bid. [Fortune]
Photos & videos
Adam Neumann speaking on stage at TechCrunch Disrupt NY 2015 in New York as co-founder and CEO of WeWork — TechCrunch / CC BY 2.0
At the same TechCrunch Disrupt NY 2015, Neumann talks about WeWork on stage — TechCrunch / CC BY 2.0
Neumann, as a Start Up India participant, calling on Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi in New Delhi — Prime Minister's Office / GODL-India
A WeWork location in Herzliya, Israel, September 2017 — דוד שי / CC BY-SA 4.0
The WeWork coworking space in Jongno Tower, Seoul, September 2018 — Steve46814 / CC BY-SA 4.0
A WeWork location in Midtown Manhattan, New York, photographed a little over a month before the IPO filing was submitted — Ajay Suresh from New York, NY, USA / CC BY 2.0
Marcelo Claure, photographed on October 23, 2019; he became executive chairman of WeWork after SoftBank took control — Garrett Carey / CC BY-SA 2.0
Masayoshi Son meeting the Brazilian government in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, on October 30, 2019 (photo: Brazilian presidency), the day the reshuffle of WeWork's board took effect — Palácio do Planalto from Brasilia, Brasil / CC BY 2.0
A WeWork office building in Buenos Aires, March 2020 — Hnapel / CC BY-SA 4.0
The New York Stock Exchange building, February 2021; WeWork listed here via a SPAC in October of that year — Epicgenius / CC BY-SA 4.0- Neumann on stage at TechCrunch Disrupt NY 2017 on how WeWork runs its spaces (TechCrunch)
- CNBC report: Neumann formally resigns as WeWork CEO; the outlook for the IPO is unclear (CNBC Television)
- Bloomberg report: SoftBank takes control of WeWork; Neumann to leave the board (Bloomberg Television)
- WeWork executive chairman Marcelo Claure in a full interview with CNBC (CNBC Television)
- WeWork rings the opening bell on the day it lists on the New York Stock Exchange (New York Stock Exchange)
- Neumann's first public interview after leaving WeWork (The New York Times DealBook Online Summit) (New York Times Events)
- Reuters report: WeWork files for bankruptcy protection (Reuters)
- Neumann on CNBC talking about his new real estate company, Flow (CNBC Television)