Emperor Zhongzong of Tang (Li Xian) (Emperor Zhongzong of Tang (Li Xian)) — Tang dynasty (Tang dynasty)
Emperor Zhongzong of Tang, Li Xian, was Wu Zetian's own son. In 684, just after his accession, he was deposed by his mother over a single remark, “What would be wrong with giving the empire to Wei Xuanzhen?”, and exiled to Fangzhou for fourteen years. In 705, with Wu Zetian gravely ill, Chancellor Zhang Jianzhi and four others launched the Shenlong Coup, killed Wu Zetian's favourites the Zhang brothers, and pushed him back onto the throne. But the “reckoning” after this restoration ran in a strange direction: only the Zhang brothers were killed; Wu Zetian, who had deposed him, was honoured as “Zetian Dasheng Emperor” and lived in comfort until her death at the end of that year; the Wu family were merely reduced from princes to dukes, while Wu Sansi was actually advanced to Minister of Works (Sikong) and held power in league with Empress Wei. Those who truly paid were the “Five Princes” who had helped restore him: within a year and a half all had been demoted or killed. In 710 Zhongzong died suddenly; the histories say he was poisoned by Empress Wei and Princess Anle.
How they were ousted
On 26 February 684 (the wuwu day of the second month of Sisheng 1), less than two months after his accession, his mother Wu Zetian assembled the officials at Qianyuan Hall; Chancellor Pei Yan, General Cheng Wuting and others led troops into the palace to announce the order deposing him to Prince of Luling. He was helped down from the hall on the spot and then confined at Fangzhou and Junzhou for fourteen years.
How they came back
Recalled by Wu Zetian in 698 and reinstated as crown prince. On 20 February 705, Zhang Jianzhi and four others led the Yulin Guards into the palace, killed Zhang Yizhi and Zhang Changzong, and forced the ailing Wu Zetian to hand over the throne; he was restored on 23 February (the bingwu day of the first month of Shenlong 1), having been lifted onto a horse at the Eastern Palace and pushed into it.
What happened to the board
Two groups have to be looked at separately. (1) Those who carried out his deposition in 684 did not live to see him return: Pei Yan was beheaded for treason by Wu Zetian at the end of that same year, and Cheng Wuting was killed for speaking up for Pei Yan. Both were disposed of by Wu Zetian herself, not by Zhongzong. The principal, Wu Zetian, was never punished: after being forced to hand over the throne in February 705 she moved to Shangyang Palace, Zhongzong led the officials to pay respects to her every ten days, and she died on 16 December of that year; only her testamentary edict removed her imperial title. (2) Those who stood in his way in 705: Zhang Yizhi and Zhang Changzong were beheaded that day; their brothers Zhang Changqi, Zhang Tongxiu and Zhang Changyi were executed the same day and their heads displayed; their adherents Wei Chengqing, Fang Rong and Cui Shenqing were imprisoned; and the general amnesty expressly stated that “the faction of Zhang Yizhi is not pardoned”. But the Wu clan suffered only a token reduction in rank (Wu Sansi from Prince of Liang to Prince of Dejing Commandery; Wu Yizong and eleven others to dukes), and Wu Sansi was soon advanced to Minister of Works with chancellor rank (Tong Zhongshu Menxia Sanpin). Conversely, the five men who restored him (Zhang Jianzhi, Cui Xuanwei, Jing Hui, Huan Yanfan and Yuan Shuji) were in 705 made princes and removed from government, a promotion in name and a demotion in fact; in 706 all were banished to Lingnan, where three were cruelly killed and two died in exile. So this was a restoration that “purged only the favourites, never reached the principal, and in the end purged his benefactors”.
Timeline
- Li Xian made crown prince After his second elder brother Li Xian (李賢) was deposed, Li Xian (李顯) became crown prince; he later married Wei Xuanzhen's daughter as crown princess. [維基百科:唐中宗] [維基百科:韋皇后]
- Gaozong dies; Li Xian takes the throne In the twelfth month of Hongdao 1, Emperor Gaozong of Tang died and Crown Prince Li Xian succeeded, with his mother Wu Zetian presiding over the court as Empress Dowager. [維基百科:唐中宗] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百三]
- Moved to confinement at Fangzhou and Junzhou The Prince of Luling was first moved to Fangzhou, a few days later to the former residence of the Prince of Pu in Junzhou, and later back to Fangzhou. Consort Wei went with him and on the way gave birth to the future Princess Anle. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百三] [維基百科:韋皇后] [維基百科:安樂公主]
- Pei Yan beheaded After Xu Jingye rose in arms, Pei Yan urged the Empress Dowager to return the government to Ruizong, was accused of harbouring designs of his own, and in the twelfth month was beheaded in front of the Duting Post Station in Luoyang; Cheng Wuting was also killed for speaking up for him. The two men who carried out Zhongzong's deposition died at Wu Zetian's hands within a year. [維基百科:裴炎] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百三]
- “If I gave the empire to Wei Xuanzhen, what would be wrong with that?” Zhongzong wanted to make his father-in-law Wei Xuanzhen Director of the Chancellery and also to give a fifth-rank post to his wet nurse's son; Chancellor Pei Yan argued hard against it, and Zhongzong, in anger, made this remark. Alarmed, Pei Yan reported it to the Empress Dowager, and the two plotted to depose him. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百三] [維基百科:裴炎]
- Deposed to Prince of Luling On the wuwu day of the second month, the Empress Dowager assembled the officials at Qianyuan Hall; Pei Yan, with Liu Yizhi, Cheng Wuting and Zhang Qianxu, led troops into the palace to announce the order and had the emperor helped down from the hall. Zhongzong asked, “What is my crime?” The Empress Dowager replied: you wanted to give the empire to Wei Xuanzhen, and you say you have committed no crime? [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百三] [維基百科:唐中宗]
- His younger brother Li Dan made emperor On the jiwei day of the second month Li Dan, Prince of Yu, was installed (Ruizong); government was decided by the Empress Dowager, and the new emperor lived in a separate hall with no say. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百三] [維基百科:唐睿宗]
- Wu Zetian declares herself emperor and changes Tang to Zhou Wu Zetian made herself emperor and created many members of the Wu clan princes; Wu Sansi was made Prince of Liang. [維基百科:武三思] [維基百科:武則天]
- The Prince of Luling is recalled and reinstated as crown prince Wu Chengsi and Wu Sansi sought to be named crown prince; Di Renjie persuaded Wu Zetian by asking “which is closer, aunt and nephew or mother and son?” Wu Zetian recalled Li Xian to Luoyang and made him crown prince again. [維基百科:武則天] [維基百科:唐中宗] [維基百科:安樂公主]
- His children ordered to die for offending the two Zhangs Li Xian's eldest son by his principal wife, Li Chongrun, and his daughter Princess Yongtai were ordered by Wu Zetian to take their own lives for discussing the Zhang Yizhi brothers. [維基百科:唐中宗] [維基百科:張易之]
- Zhang Jianzhi becomes chancellor at eighty On the recommendation of Di Renjie and Yao Chong, Zhang Jianzhi became chancellor in the tenth month of Chang'an 4 and began his preparations: he placed Yang Yuanyan, Huan Yanfan, Jing Hui and Li Zhan in command of the Left and Right Yulin Guards and won over Li Duozuo. [維基百科:神龍革命] [維基百科:張柬之]
- The Shenlong Coup: the two Zhangs killed, the throne forced On the guimao day of the first month of Shenlong 1, Zhang Jianzhi, Cui Xuanwei, Huan Yanfan and others led more than 500 Yulin soldiers to the Xuanwu Gate and sent Li Duozuo and Wang Tongjiao to the Eastern Palace, where the wavering crown prince was lifted onto a horse. They broke through the gate into the palace, killed Zhang Yizhi and Zhang Changzong in a corridor of Yingxian Palace, and surrounded Changsheng Hall, where Wu Zetian was. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七] [維基百科:神龍革命]
- The crown prince as regent On the jiachen day of the first month, an edict made the crown prince regent and declared a general amnesty; Yuan Shuji was made chancellor, and ten envoys were sent out to reassure the prefectures. Zhang Changqi and others were beheaded and their heads displayed with those of the two Zhangs south of Tianjin Bridge. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七]
- Wu Zetian hands over the throne On the yisi day of the first month, the Empress Dowager passed the throne to the crown prince. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七] [維基百科:唐中宗]
- Zhongzong restored He took the throne on the bingwu day of the first month and declared a general amnesty, from which only Zhang Yizhi's adherents were excluded; the Prince of Xiang was given the added title Anguo Prince of Xiang, and Princess Taiping the title Zhenguo Princess Taiping. Wu Zetian moved to Shangyang Palace, and on 3 March of that year the dynastic name was restored to Tang. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八] [維基百科:唐中宗]
- Wu Sansi is not purged but made chancellor On the bingyin day of the second month, Zhongzong made Wu Sansi Minister of Works with chancellor rank (Tong Zhongshu Menxia Sanpin); after Wu Sansi declined, he was instead given the honorary rank of Kaifu Yitong Sansi. Zhongzong also went to Wu Sansi's house incognito on many occasions. Xue Jichang and Liu Youqiu urged the Five Princes to get rid of Wu Sansi while they could; they did not listen. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八] [維基百科:薛季昶] [維基百科:武三思]
- The Five Princes are made princes and removed from government Wu Sansi and Empress Wei slandered them day and night and offered a scheme: “make them princes and relieve them of government duties; outwardly they keep honour and favour, in reality they lose power”. Zhongzong did as advised: Jing Hui, Huan Yanfan, Zhang Jianzhi, Yuan Shuji and Cui Xuanwei were made commandery princes on the same day, relieved of their roles in government, and were to attend court only on the first and fifteenth of each month. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八] [維基文庫:《舊唐書》卷七〈中宗睿宗本紀〉] [維基百科:神龍革命]
- The Wu clan suffers only a token reduction in rank At the request of the Five Princes, an edict reduced the Wu clan's titles: Wu Sansi, Prince of Liang, became Prince of Dejing; Wu Youji, Prince of Ding, became Prince of Leshou; and Wu Yizong and eleven others became dukes, “to satisfy public feeling”. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八]
- Wu Zetian dies On the renyin day of the eleventh month, Wu Zetian died at Shangyang Palace, aged eighty-two; her testamentary edict removed her imperial title and styled her Zetian Dasheng Empress. She was buried at Qianling in the fifth month of 706. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八] [維基百科:武則天]
- The Five Princes demoted again and again In the intercalary first month Jing Hui, Huan Yanfan and Yuan Shuji were sent out of the capital as prefects; afterwards Wang Tongjiao's plot to kill Wu Sansi leaked and he was put to death, and the Five Princes were accused of complicity. On the wuyin day of the sixth month all five were demoted to marshals (sima) of prefectures in Lingnan and stripped of their honours and fiefs. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八]
- The deaths of the Five Princes Wu Sansi secretly had Empress Wei's scandals posted up at Tianjin Bridge, then falsely blamed the Five Princes and asked that their clans be exterminated; Zhongzong ordered permanent exile. Wu Sansi then sent Zhou Lizhen (given as Zhou Liyong in the Tongjian) to hunt them down: by the time he arrived Zhang Jianzhi and Cui Xuanwei were already dead; Huan Yanfan was dragged on a bamboo raft and then beaten to death with a staff, Jing Hui was killed by slicing, and Yuan Shuji was forced to drink poison and then beaten to death. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八] [維基百科:桓彥範] [維基百科:袁恕己]
- Crown Prince Li Chongjun rises in arms and kills Wu Sansi In the seventh month of Jinglong 1, Crown Prince Li Chongjun, with Li Duozuo and others, led Yulin soldiers to kill Wu Sansi and his son Wu Chongxun, then attacked the Xuanwu Gate to seize Empress Wei, Princess Anle and Shangguan Wan'er. From the tower Zhongzong called out to the soldiers, promising rich rewards; the soldiers changed sides, Li Duozuo was beheaded, and the crown prince was killed by his own men while fleeing. [維基百科:李重俊] [維基百科:李多祚] [維基百科:唐中宗]
- Yan Qinrong is beaten to death for his memorial In the fifth month of Jinglong 4, Yan Qinrong, Military Administrator (Sibing Canjun) of Xuzhou, submitted a memorial accusing Empress Wei of licentiousness and meddling in government, and Princess Anle and others of plotting to endanger the dynasty. Zhongzong questioned him face to face and then fell silent, but Zong Chuke forged an order and had him dashed to death in the palace courtyard. The Tongjian says Zhongzong was “rather displeased”, and Empress Wei's faction began to grow fearful. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百九] [維基百科:唐中宗]
- Zhongzong dies suddenly On the renwu day of the sixth month, Zhongzong died in Shenlong Hall. The Tongjian records that Ma Qinke and Yang Jun feared their affairs with Empress Wei would be exposed, and Princess Anle wanted her mother to preside over the court and herself to be Crown Princess, so they conspired to put poison in a cake. Empress Wei kept the death secret and moved 50,000 troops to garrison the capital. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百九] [維基文庫:《舊唐書》卷七〈中宗睿宗本紀〉] [維基百科:唐中宗]
- The Tanglong Coup: Empress Wei and Princess Anle killed On the night of the gengzi day of the sixth month, Li Longji, son of the Prince of Xiang, together with Princess Taiping's side, launched a coup, beheaded the Wei clan's generals, and killed Empress Wei, Princess Anle and Shangguan Wan'er. The young emperor Li Chongmao abdicated and Li Dan, Prince of Xiang, was restored (Ruizong); he then rehabilitated the Five Princes and Li Chongjun. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百九] [維基百科:唐隆政變] [維基百科:袁恕己]
People
- Emperor Zhongzong of Tang, Li Xian (Li Zhe) (Li Xian (Emperor Zhongzong of Tang)), 656-11-26 — Emperor of Tang → Prince of Luling (684–698) → Crown Prince (698–705) → restored. Seventh son of Emperor Gaozong of Tang and third son of Wu Zetian, born in Chang'an. First made Prince of Zhou, later Prince of Ying. Became crown prince in 680 after his second elder brother Li Xian (李賢) was deposed, and took the throne after Gaozong's death at the end of 683. Succeeded as crown prince. Wu Zetian was his mother; Empress Wei spent fourteen years with him at Fangzhou; his younger brother Li Dan took the throne he was deposed from; Princess Anle was born on the road into exile. After his restoration he indulged Empress Wei, Princess Anle and Wu Sansi, and demoted and killed the Five Princes. Died in Shenlong Hall on 3 July 710 (the renwu day of the sixth month of Jinglong 4), aged fifty-five; both Books of Tang and the Zizhi Tongjian record that he was poisoned. Buried at Dingling. [維基百科:唐中宗] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百九] [維基文庫:《舊唐書》卷七〈中宗睿宗本紀〉]
- Wu Zetian (Wu Zetian) — Empress Dowager (regent from 684) → Emperor of Wu Zhou (690–705). Empress of Emperor Gaozong of Tang; birth mother of Zhongzong and Ruizong. After Gaozong's death she presided over the court as Empress Dowager; in 684 she deposed Zhongzong, installed Ruizong and held power herself; in 690 she declared herself emperor and changed the dynastic name to Zhou. Zhongzong's own mother, and the person who deposed him; in 698, at the urging of Di Renjie and others, she recalled him and made him crown prince. On 22 February 705 (the yisi day of the first month) she was forced to hand the throne to the crown prince and moved to Shangyang Palace, still honoured as “Zetian Dasheng Emperor”, with Zhongzong paying respects every ten days. She died on 16 December of that year, aged eighty-two, her testamentary edict removing her imperial title; in 706 she was buried with Gaozong at Qianling. She received no punishment of any kind. [維基百科:武則天] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八]
- Pei Yan (Pei Yan) — Director of the Secretariat (Zhongshu Ling; chancellor). A native of Wenxi in Jiangzhou, from the Pei clan of Hedong; passed the mingjing examination. Became chancellor in 680 and Director of the Chancellery (Shizhong) in 681. Promoted to Director of the Secretariat after Zhongzong's accession. When Zhongzong wanted to make his father-in-law Wei Xuanzhen Director of the Chancellery, he firmly opposed it; after Zhongzong said “What would be wrong with giving the empire to Wei Xuanzhen?”, it was he who reported it to the Empress Dowager, plotted the deposition with her, and personally led troops into the palace to announce the order. Not purged by Zhongzong: in the winter of the same year as the deposition (684), when Xu Jingye rebelled, he urged Wu Zetian to return the government to Ruizong, was accused of harbouring designs of his own, and in the twelfth month was beheaded in Luoyang and his property confiscated; his household had no savings. After Ruizong's restoration he was posthumously made Grand Commandant. [維基百科:裴炎] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百三]
- Zhang Yizhi (Zhang Yizhi) — Director of the Lintai (Palace Library), Duke of Heng (favourite of Wu Zetian). A native of Yifeng in Dingzhou and a grand-nephew in the clan of Zhang Xingcheng, chancellor under Emperor Taizong of Tang; handsome and skilled in music. Brought into the palace in 697 on the recommendation of his younger brother Zhang Changzong to attend on Wu Zetian. In her last years Wu Zetian was bedridden, the chancellors went months without seeing her, and much government business passed through the Zhang brothers' hands. In 701 Zhongzong's eldest son Li Chongrun and his daughter Princess Yongtai were ordered to take their own lives precisely for offending the two Zhangs. On 20 February 705 (the guimao day of the first month of Shenlong 1) he was cut down by Zhang Jianzhi and the others in a corridor of Yingxian Palace; his head, with those of his brothers, was displayed south of Tianjin Bridge. [維基百科:張易之] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七] [維基百科:唐中宗]
- Zhang Changzong (Zhang Changzong) — Minister of the Imperial Stud (Sipu Qing), Duke of Ye (favourite of Wu Zetian). Younger brother of Zhang Yizhi, known as “Sixth Young Master” (Liulang). By imperial order he compiled the Sanjiao zhuying with Li Jiao, Zhang Yue and others. Entered the palace in 697 on the recommendation of Princess Taiping. Shared control of the court with Zhang Yizhi in the last years of Wu Zhou; his brothers Zhang Changqi, Zhang Changyi and others all held high office. Killed on the same day as Zhang Yizhi. Zhang Changqi, Zhang Tongxiu and Zhang Changyi were also arrested and beheaded. [維基百科:張昌宗] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七]
- Wu Sansi (Wu Sansi) — Prince of Liang (Wu Zhou) → Minister of Works (Sikong) with chancellor rank (Tong Zhongshu Menxia Sanpin) under Zhongzong. A native of Wenshui in Bingzhou and a nephew of Wu Zetian. Made Prince of Liang after Wu Zetian declared herself emperor in 690; he sought to be named crown prince but was rebuffed by Di Renjie. Rose through his aunt Wu Zetian; after Zhongzong's restoration he regained power through his ties with Empress Wei and Shangguan Wan'er, and his son Wu Chongxun married Princess Anle. Zhang Jianzhi and the others left him untouched when they killed the two Zhangs; Xue Jichang and Liu Youqiu both urged that “weeds must be pulled up by the roots”, but the Five Princes did not listen. Not purged by Zhongzong; on the contrary, he rose higher still. In 705 he was merely reduced from Prince of Liang to Prince of Dejing Commandery, was then advanced to Minister of Works, and directed the demotion and killing of the Five Princes, declaring that “whoever is good to me is a good man”. On 7 August 707 he was killed at home when Crown Prince Li Chongjun rose in arms. The one who struck was Zhongzong's son, not Zhongzong; after his death Zhongzong even posthumously made him Grand Commandant and Prince Xuan of Liang. [維基百科:武三思] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八] [維基百科:李重俊]
- Zhang Jianzhi (Zhang Jianzhi), 625 — Vice Director of the Fengge (Secretariat) and Tong Pingzhangshi (chancellor). A native of Xiangyang in Xiangzhou and a jinshi graduate; selected for office in 689 through the special examination for the worthy and good, he served as prefect of Hezhou and Shuzhou and as chief administrator of Jingzhou. Became chancellor in 704 at the advanced age of eighty. Recommended to Wu Zetian first by Di Renjie and later by Yao Chong. Mastermind of the Shenlong Coup: he placed Yang Yuanyan, Huan Yanfan, Jing Hui and Li Zhan in command of the Yulin Guards and talked Li Duozuo into joining. After the restoration he was made Duke of Hanyang Commandery; in the summer of 705 he was made Prince of Hanyang and stripped of real power as chancellor. In 706 he was falsely accused of conspiring with Wang Tongjiao and demoted to Marshal (Sima) of Xinzhou; he had already died in exile before the killer sent by Wu Sansi arrived. Rehabilitated after Ruizong took the throne in 710. [維基百科:張柬之] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八] [維基百科:神龍革命]
- Cui Xuanwei (Cui Xuanwei), 639 — Vice Director of the Luantai (Chancellery) and Tong Pingzhangshi (chancellor). Of the Cui clan of Boling; passed the mingjing examination and was advanced by Di Renjie. Became Vice Minister of the Tianguan (Ministry of Personnel) in 701 and later chancellor. Personally promoted by Wu Zetian. On the night of the coup Wu Zetian said to him: the others all rose on someone's recommendation; you alone I raised myself. Are you here too? One of the Five Princes. Made Prince of Boling and removed from government; in 706 demoted first to prefect of Junzhou, then to Marshal (Sima) of Baizhou, and died on the road into exile. [維基百科:崔玄暐] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八]
- Jing Hui (Jing Hui) — General of the Left Yulin Guard. A native of Jiangzhou who passed the mingjing examination at twenty; served as prefect of Weizhou, chief administrator of Luozhou and Right Assistant Director of the Zhongtai (Department of State Affairs), and was known for his ability. In early 705 Zhang Jianzhi placed him as a general of the Yulin Guards, giving him control of the palace troops. One of the Five Princes; after the restoration he memorialised asking that the princely titles of the Wu clan be reduced, and so earned Wu Sansi's hatred. Xue Jichang urged him to get rid of Wu Sansi while he was at it; he said the great matter was settled and the man was no more than meat on the chopping block. Made Prince of Pingyang and removed from government; in 706 demoted to Marshal (Sima) of Yazhou and killed by slicing by Zhou Lizhen (given as Zhou Liyong in the Tongjian), whom Wu Sansi had sent. [維基百科:敬暉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八]
- Huan Yanfan (Huan Yanfan), 653 — General of the Right Yulin Guard. A native of Danyang in Runzhou and a descendant of Huan Yi of the Eastern Jin; recommended by Di Renjie, he rose to Vice Censor-in-Chief and Vice Minister of Justice (Sixing Shaoqing). Placed as a general of the Yulin Guards before the coup. One of the Five Princes; on the night of the coup he demanded to Wu Zetian's face that she hand over the throne. Zhongzong also granted him the surname Wei, joining him to the empress's clan. Made Prince of Fuyang and removed from government; in 706 demoted to Marshal (Sima) of Shuangzhou and stripped of the granted surname. On the way, in Guizhou, the killer tied him to a bamboo raft and dragged him until the flesh was gone and the bone showed, then beat him to death with a staff. [維基百科:桓彥範] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七]
- Yuan Shuji (Yuan Shuji) — Vice Minister of Justice (Sixing Shaoqing) and concurrently Marshal (Sima) of the Prince of Xiang's household. A native of Dongguang in Cangzhou. Served as Vice Minister of Justice in Wu Zetian's Chang'an era, concurrently managing the household affairs of Li Dan, Prince of Xiang. On the day of the coup he accompanied the Prince of Xiang in commanding the Southern Office troops against any contingency, and arrested Zhang Yizhi's adherents. One of the Five Princes, and also a man of Li Dan, Prince of Xiang. Made Prince of Nanyang and removed from government; in 706 demoted to Marshal (Sima) of Douzhou. He was forced to drink several sheng of yege (gelsemium) juice, did not die, and was finally beaten to death. Rehabilitated after Ruizong took the throne in 710. [維基百科:袁恕己] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八]
- Li Duozuo (Li Duozuo), 654 — Grand General of the Right Yulin Guard. A general of Mohe origin who commanded the palace troops and guarded the north gate for more than twenty years. Talked into joining the coup by Zhang Jianzhi; went in person to the Eastern Palace to fetch the crown prince. The armed core of the coup; later became a close confidant of Crown Prince Li Chongjun. Made Prince of Liaoyang Commandery for his service. In 707 he joined Crown Prince Li Chongjun in rising to kill Wu Sansi; when they attacked the Xuanwu Gate, Zhongzong called out from the tower and the soldiers changed sides. He was beheaded below the tower, his two sons died with him, and the family property was confiscated. [維基百科:李多祚] [維基百科:李重俊] [維基百科:唐中宗]
- Empress Wei (Empress Wei) — Empress. Of the Wei clan of Jingzhao; her father was Wei Xuanzhen. She was made crown princess when Zhongzong was crown prince. When Zhongzong was deposed in 684 she went with him to Fangzhou; her father died in exile in Qinzhou, and her four younger brothers died in Rongzhou. Made empress on Zhongzong's accession in 684; empress again after the restoration in 705, taking part in government. At Fangzhou, Zhongzong wanted to kill himself every time he heard a court envoy was coming, and it was she who talked him out of it. After the restoration she joined Wu Sansi in pushing aside the Five Princes. After Zhongzong's death she put Li Chongmao on the throne and presided over the court herself. In the Tanglong Coup of 21 July 710 she fled into the Flying Cavalry (Feiqi) camp, where she was killed and her head displayed; she was posthumously reduced to commoner status. [維基百科:韋皇后] [維基百科:唐隆政變] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百九]
- Princess Anle, Li Guo'er (Princess Anle), 685 — Princess (youngest daughter of Zhongzong and Empress Wei). Born while her parents were on the road into exile at Fangzhou; Zhongzong took off his robe to wrap her in, hence the name Guo'er (“wrapped child”). Her first marriage was to Wu Chongxun, son of Wu Sansi. After Zhongzong's restoration she wielded overwhelming influence and sold offices and titles; her appointees were known at the time as “slant-sealed officials”. Repeatedly demanded to be named “Crown Princess” (heir to the throne), and together with her husband bullied Crown Prince Li Chongjun. Killed in the Tanglong Coup; posthumously degraded to “Rebellious Commoner”. [維基百科:安樂公主] [維基百科:唐隆政變] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百九]
- Li Dan, Prince of Xiang (Emperor Ruizong of Tang) (Li Dan (Emperor Ruizong of Tang)), 662-06-22 — Puppet emperor, 684–690 → Prince of Xiang. Eighth son of Gaozong and youngest son of Wu Zetian; Zhongzong's younger brother. Made emperor in 684 the day after his brother was deposed, but government was decided by the Empress Dowager and he had no say; under Wu Zhou he stepped back to become Prince of Xiang. He had sat in his brother's seat, but on the day of the coup he led the Southern Office troops on his brother's side. After Zhongzong's restoration he was given the added title Anguo Prince of Xiang and made Grand Commandant, and was not called to account. He took the throne a second time after the Tanglong Coup of 710 and rehabilitated the Five Princes; died in 716. [維基百科:唐睿宗] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七] [維基百科:唐隆政變]
- Shangguan Wan'er (Shangguan Wan'er), 664 — Jieyu → Zhaorong (consort ranks; in charge of drafting edicts). Granddaughter of Chancellor Shangguan Yi; as an infant she was taken into the palace as a servant when her grandfather was condemned, and later handled Wu Zetian's edicts and documents. Rose in Wu Zetian's time; made Zhaorong after Zhongzong's restoration and continued to handle imperial edicts. The Tongjian records that because of her connection with Wu Sansi she exalted the Wu clan at every turn when drafting edicts; when Li Chongjun rose in arms he demanded her by name. After Zhongzong's death she drafted his testamentary edict together with Princess Taiping, seeking to have the Prince of Xiang assist in government as a counterweight to Empress Wei. On the night of the Tanglong Coup she came out to meet them holding the draft of the testamentary edict, but Li Longji still ordered her beheaded. Her tomb was discovered in Xianyang in 2013. [維基百科:上官婉兒] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百九] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八]
Moves to block a return
- The day after deposing him (the jiwei day of the second month), Wu Zetian made his younger brother Li Dan, Prince of Yu, emperor (Ruizong), but all government was decided by the Empress Dowager, and the new emperor lived in a separate hall and was not allowed to take part. With the seat occupied, he had no seat to return to. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百三] [維基百科:唐睿宗]
- He was first confined in a separate residence, then moved to Fangzhou, a few days later moved again to the former residence of the Prince of Pu in Junzhou, and afterwards moved back to Fangzhou, far from the two capitals, under long-term house arrest. The Old Book of Tang describes it as “a rugged, pestilential land, a place of hardship and confinement”. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百三] [維基文庫:《舊唐書》卷七〈中宗睿宗本紀〉]
- In 684 Xu Jingye raised troops at Yangzhou against Wu, and one of his banners was support for the Prince of Luling. Chancellor Pei Yan took the occasion to urge Wu Zetian to return the government to the emperor, was instead accused of harbouring designs of his own, and was imprisoned and beheaded. General Cheng Wuting, who spoke up for Pei Yan, was also killed. After that no one dared raise the question of bringing him back. [維基百科:裴炎] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百三]
- In 690 Wu Zetian declared herself emperor, changed the dynastic name to Zhou, and made many members of the Wu clan princes; afterwards Wu Chengsi and Wu Sansi repeatedly sought to be named crown prince, arguing that “since antiquity no Son of Heaven has taken someone of another surname as heir”. Had that been accepted, Li Xian would never have been restored. [維基百科:武三思] [維基百科:武則天]
- On the day of the coup even he himself stood in the way: when the Yulin Guards came to the Eastern Palace to fetch him, he hesitated and dared not come out, saying that the treacherous ministers deserved to die but he feared alarming his mother, and asking everyone to leave it for another time. Li Zhan said that the generals and ministers had risked their lives and families, and how could His Highness send them all to the boiling cauldron; only then did he come out, and Wang Tongjiao lifted him onto a horse. On seeing him Wu Zetian still said: Is it you? Now that the boys have been killed, you may go back to the Eastern Palace. Huan Yanfan retorted on the spot: how can the crown prince go back again? [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七] [維基百科:神龍革命]
Rumors
- Zhang Yizhi and Zhang Changzong plotted rebellion. [Still unclear] What Zhang Jianzhi and the others told Wu Zetian on the night of the coup This was the stated justification for the coup. That the two Zhangs monopolised the court and caused the deaths of Zhongzong's children is on record, but the charge of “plotting rebellion” was never put through any trial; Zhang Jianzhi and the others themselves admitted to Wu Zetian that “we feared it would leak, and so did not dare report it”. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百七] [維基百科:神龍革命]
- Zhang Jianzhi and the other Five Princes sent men to post up Empress Wei's scandalous conduct and plotted to depose the empress, which was in fact high treason. [Proven false] Report by Censor-in-Chief Li Chengjia after he was ordered to investigate The Zizhi Tongjian states plainly that Wu Sansi “secretly had men” post the notices and then pinned it on the Five Princes; Li Chaoyin, an assistant at the Court of Judicial Review, protested at the time that no one could be convicted without interrogation. Ruizong rehabilitated the Five Princes after taking the throne. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八] [維基百科:袁恕己]
- The private scholar Wei Yuejiang memorialised that Wu Sansi was carrying on an illicit liaison in the inner palace (an affair with Empress Wei) and would surely rebel. [Still unclear] Wei Yuejiang's memorial; Song Jing also said that “people say the empress is intimate with Sansi” Zhongzong was furious on hearing it and wanted the man killed at once; Song Jing insisted the matter should first be investigated, and Zhongzong refused. The Tongjian presents the affair as a rumour of the time, and there is no record of any verification. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八] [維基百科:武三思]
- Zhongzong was killed by Empress Wei and Princess Anle, who put poison in a cake. [Still unclear] Old Book of Tang, New Book of Tang, Zizhi Tongjian All three standard histories record it as poisoning, and this is the traditional accepted view. The Chinese Wikipedia article on Emperor Zhongzong of Tang also lists a theory of death by illness: many members of the Tang imperial house suffered from “wind disease” and “qi disease”, and sudden death at fifty-five is also consistent with an acute cardiovascular or cerebrovascular event. Neither account has verifiable physical evidence, and the question cannot be settled. [維基百科:唐中宗] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百九] [維基文庫:《舊唐書》卷七〈中宗睿宗本紀〉]
Views
- The historians of the Old Book of Tang (official history compiled under the Later Jin of the Five Dynasties): Even worthy ministers cannot prop up a weak ruler. When deposed, Zhongzong suffered every hardship in a pestilential land, and that he came back alive was owing to Zhang Jianzhi and Di Renjie, not to any ability of his own. Yet after his restoration he did not reflect, and indulged his wife and daughter in meddling in government; as a result the clans of Huan Yanfan and Jing Hui were destroyed, and he himself died at the hands of the one who shared his pillow. [維基文庫:《舊唐書》卷七〈中宗睿宗本紀〉]
- Overall assessment in the Chinese Wikipedia article on Emperor Zhongzong of Tang: Apart from Emperor Hui of Jin, who was briefly deposed, he was the first Son of Heaven since Tai Jia of the Shang dynasty to reign twice; but he kept petty men close and worthy ministers at a distance, was dominated by his mother, wife and daughter, and could not control the struggles among the imperial clan and powerful ministers. In frontier defence, sending Zhang Renyuan to build the three Shouxiang (“surrender-receiving”) cities and concluding a marriage alliance with Tibet through Princess Jincheng were contributions of some value. [維基百科:唐中宗]
- Xue Jichang (chief administrator of Luozhou, participant in the coup): He said to Zhang Jianzhi and Jing Hui: the two chief villains are gone, but men like Lü Chan and Lü Lu remain; weeds not pulled up by the roots will grow again. The two replied that the great matter was settled and enough had been killed already. Xue Jichang sighed: I no longer know where I shall die. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八] [維基百科:薛季昶]
- Liu Youqiu (sheriff of Chaoyi, later one of the masterminds of the Tanglong Coup): He said to Huan Yanfan and Jing Hui: with Wu Sansi still there, you will end up without even a place to be buried; if you do not act now, it will be too late for regret. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八]
- Zheng Yin (an official who attached himself to Wu Sansi): He said to Wu Sansi: those five men hold the powers of generals and ministers and have uncommon daring and resourcefulness; deposing the Empress Dowager was as easy for them as turning over a hand. Is your position a match for the Empress Dowager's? Day and night they want to eat your flesh. These words brought Wu Sansi to resolve on getting rid of the Five Princes. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八]
- Yao Yuanzhi (Yao Chong; chancellor, participant in the coup): While everyone else was celebrating, he alone wept. Zhang Jianzhi warned him this would bring trouble; he said: following you gentlemen a few days ago to remove the villains was a subject's duty; grieving today on taking leave of my former sovereign is also a subject's duty, and if I am punished for it I accept that willingly. That same day he was sent out of the capital as a prefect. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷二百八]
Photos & videos
Portrait of Emperor Zhongzong of Tang, Li Xian (painted in a later age). — Unknown (artist died over 100 years ago) / Public domain
Detail of Empress of Tang on Procession, attributed to Zhang Xuan; the figure in the painting is generally thought to be Wu Zetian. — Likely to be Zhang Xuan (张萱) / Public domainThe spirit way at Qianling, Shaanxi. After Wu Zetian died at the end of 705, Zhongzong buried her here with Gaozong in 706. — 猫猫的日记本 / CC BY-SA 3.0
The “Wordless Stele” at Qianling, said to have been erected for Wu Zetian; originally it bore not a single character, and inscriptions were added only from the Ming dynasty onward. — Gary Todd from Xinzheng, China / CC0
Tomb of Princess Yongtai beside Qianling. She was Zhongzong's daughter, ordered to take her own life in 701 for offending the Zhang Yizhi brothers; only after his restoration did Zhongzong rebury her, with the status of “a tomb styled as an imperial mausoleum”. — Gary Todd from Xinzheng, China / CC0
Gate towers in a mural from the tomb of Crown Prince Yide, Li Chongrun. Li Chongrun was Zhongzong's eldest son by his principal wife and died in the same case as Princess Yongtai. — Unknown Tang-era tomb artist / Public domain
Portrait of Empress Wei (woodblock illustration from a Qing-dynasty novel). — Unknown / Public domain
“Appointing officials by slant-sealed orders”, from the Dijian tushuo (The Emperor's Mirror, Illustrated and Discussed): under Zhongzong, Princess Anle and others took money and then bypassed the Secretariat, granting offices by slant-sealed ink edicts; later ages treated this as a cautionary example of misrule. — 张居正 / Public domain
Portrait of Shangguan Wan'er (painted in a later age). — Unknown (scanned from a Chinese book) / Public domain
Cover of Shangguan Wan'er's epitaph, unearthed in 2013, inscribed “Epitaph of the late Zhaorong, Lady Shangguan, of the Great Tang”. — 7th-century artist in China (photograph of epitaph) / Public domain
Portrait of Emperor Ruizong of Tang, Li Dan. He was made puppet emperor when his elder brother was deposed, and took the throne a second time after the Tanglong Coup of 710. — Unknown (artist died over 100 years ago) / Public domain