Emperor Gaozong of Song (Zhao Gou) (Emperor Gaozong of Song (Zhao Gou)) — Song dynasty (Southern Song) (Song dynasty (Southern Song))
In early 1129 the Jin army drove south and Emperor Gaozong of Song fled from Yangzhou all the way to Hangzhou. The escort commanders Miao Fu and Liu Zhengyan, resentful of his favouring of eunuchs and his promotion of Wang Yuan, whose merit lay in running away, mutinied on 26 March, killed Wang Yuan and more than a hundred eunuchs, and forced Gaozong to abdicate in favour of his infant son, changing the era name to “Mingshou”. But the two could not control the armies outside the city: Zhang Jun and others wrote soothing letters while assembling a loyalist army, and twenty-five days later Gaozong was restored. Miao and Liu, holding the iron certificate of immunity from death that Gaozong had granted, fled Hangzhou by night, were pursued by Han Shizhong all the way to Fujian, and in July were executed by dismemberment in the marketplace at Jiankang. Of the five cases this was the most thorough reckoning: even the commander who guarded the palace gate and let the mutineers through, and the chief ministers who were in office and failed to stop the mutiny, were dealt with.
How they were ousted
On 26 March 1129 (the guiwei day of the third month, Jianyan 3), the escort commanders Miao Fu and Liu Zhengyan killed Wang Yuan of the Bureau of Military Affairs and the eunuchs in Hangzhou, surrounded the temporary palace with troops, and forced him to cede the throne to his son Zhao Fu, not yet two years old, with Empress Dowager Longyou ruling from behind the curtain; that night he was moved to Xianzhong Temple (renamed Ruisheng Palace) and kept under guard.
How they came back
Zhang Jun (張浚), Lü Yihao, Han Shizhong, Zhang Jun (張俊), Liu Guangshi and others assembled a loyalist army at Pingjiang and marched south, while the chief minister Zhu Shengfei manoeuvred inside the city; seeing the army close in, Miao and Liu were forced to lead the officials in petitioning him to resume the throne. He returned to the palace and was restored on 20 April 1129 (the wushen day, first of the fourth month), after twenty-five days off the throne.
What happened to the board
None of the core of the coup escaped: Miao Fu, Liu Zhengyan and Miao Fu's younger brother Miao Yi were executed by dismemberment in the marketplace at Jiankang on 22 July 1129 (the xinsi day of the seventh month), less than four months after the mutiny; the chief planner Wang Shixiu was seized by Han Shizhong in person, tried and beheaded in the marketplace; Wu Zhan, commander of the Central Army, who had opened the palace gate to the rebels, was beheaded on the sixth day after the restoration (26 April); the Red Heart Army leaders Wang Junfu and Ma Rouji were killed by their own subordinates; Zhang Kui fled into Chong'an and was hunted down and killed; Miao Yu and Miao Fu's two sons had already died, and Miao Fu's wife and Liu Zhengyan's wife and children were publicly executed. The civil official Shi Ximeng, who had chimed in below the tower with “comply with the request of the three armies”, was banished under supervision to Jiyang Military Prefecture. Even those who took no part and merely failed to stop it were held to account: in July Gaozong, on the grounds that “the ministers at the helm were unable to defend the state with their own persons”, stripped of their posts the chief minister Zhu Shengfei — who inside the city had in fact been manoeuvring on his behalf throughout — along with Yan Qi and Lu Yundi, and Zhang Cheng was ordered to reside in Hengzhou. Three groups were not purged: ordinary officers and men (the edict stated explicitly that only the ringleaders would be pursued), women who had been abducted or hired (all released after Wang Yi, Vice Minister of the Court of Judicial Review, spoke up), and the infant ruler who had been put on the throne, Zhao Fu — who on the day of the restoration was instead made crown prince, but died of illness three months later.
Timeline
- Zhao Gou takes the throne at Yingtian Prefecture After Jin troops carried off Emperors Huizong and Qinzong, Zhao Gou, Prince of Kang, took the throne as Emperor Gaozong of Song and changed the era name to Jianyan. [維基百科:宋高宗] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Miao Fu escorts the Empress Dowager to Hangzhou On the yimao day of the twelfth month of Jianyan 2, Empress Dowager Longyou arrived in Hangzhou; Miao Fu, commander of her escort, quartered his 8,000 men at Fengguo Temple. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基百科:苗傅]
- Miao Fu is caught at Jianyang Between the fifth and sixth months, Miao Fu abandoned his army, changed his name, and fled by night to Jianyang disguised as a merchant; he was recognised by the local strongman Zhan Biao and handed over to Han Shizhong, then put in a caged cart and sent to the imperial temporary residence. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- The rout at Yangzhou In the second month of Jianyan 3, as Jin troops closed in, Gaozong rode in armour from Yangzhou to Zhenjiang and then, on Wang Yuan's advice, moved on to Hangzhou. Wang Yuan used more than ten large ships to carry valuables to Hangzhou, and people in Hangzhou said these had been seized from wealthy residents he had killed when suppressing Chen Tong. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Wang Yuan is promoted into the Bureau of Military Affairs On the xinsi day of the third month, Wang Yuan was appointed Associate Signatory Official of the Bureau of Military Affairs. Everyone said the eunuchs had recommended him; Miao Fu, who considered himself a veteran general, was indignant. The next day the court issued an edict excusing Wang Yuan from presenting and countersigning Bureau business, but it was too late to calm things. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉]
- The plot leaks The eunuch Kang Lü obtained a document signed at the end with “田” and “金” (code for Miao and Liu), reported it to Gaozong and notified Wang Yuan; that night Wang Yuan posted 500 soldiers in ambush around Tianzhu Temple, and the city's residents stayed behind closed doors. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- The mutiny: Wang Yuan killed, the temporary palace besieged On the guiwei day of the third month, Miao and Liu set an ambush under a bridge in the north of the city; Wang Yuan was dragged from his horse as he left court, and Liu Zhengyan killed him with his own hand. The rebels surrounded Kang Lü's residence and killed every beardless man they found; more than a hundred eunuchs died. Wu Zhan, who was guarding the gate, opened it and let them in. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基百科:王淵 (宋朝)]
- The exchange between the tower and the ground Gaozong climbed the gate tower and questioned them from the railing; Miao Fu harshly reproached him for trusting eunuchs and for unfair rewards and punishments. Gaozong promoted the two on the spot, but the rebels did not withdraw; he handed over Kang Lü, who was cut in two at the waist, and still they did not withdraw. Miao Fu went further: Your Majesty should never have taken the throne; what will happen when Emperor Qinzong comes back? [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Forced to abdicate and moved to Xianzhong Temple Miao and Liu demanded that the Empress Dowager take charge of government and that peace be negotiated with Jin, then demanded that a crown prince be installed. It was very cold, and Gaozong sat on a bamboo chair in the gate tower, which had no curtains; when the Empress Dowager was brought, he rose and stood by a pillar. The Empress Dowager argued hard but to no effect. Gaozong sent word that he was willing to abdicate, and privately told Zhu Shengfei: deal with the present first and plan afterwards; if it fails, it will not be too late to die then. That night he was moved to Xianzhong Temple. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- The Empress Dowager rules from behind the curtain; Gaozong becomes the “Ruisheng Renxiao Emperor” On the jiashen day of the third month, the Empress Dowager began to rule from behind the curtain and a general amnesty was declared; Xianzhong Temple was renamed Ruisheng Palace, with only fifteen eunuch attendants left there. On the same day the rebel-controlled court reassigned Han Shizhong and Zhang Jun (張俊). [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉]
- The amnesty reaches Pingjiang; Zhang Jun refuses to bow On the bingxu day of the third month the amnesty proclamation reached Pingjiang; Zhang Jun (張浚) sensed that something was wrong and refused to bow to it. The next day a letter from Lü Yihao in Jiangning described the coup in anguished terms, and Zhang Jun decided to raise troops; the day after that, Zhang Jun (張俊) brought his troops to Pingjiang and tearfully accepted his orders. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:張浚]
- Era name changed to Mingshou On the jichou day of the third month the era name was changed to Mingshou. At the same time Zhang Jun (張浚) wrote to Miao and Liu praising their loyalty and righteousness, to put them at ease. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:趙旉]
- Zhang Jun sends Feng Fan into the city and summons the circuits On the xinmao day of the third month, Zhang Jun (張浚) sent the jinshi graduate Feng Fan to Hangzhou to ask that Gaozong personally take charge of essential affairs; he then sent proclamations to all the circuits and arranged for Lü Yihao and Liu Guangshi to assemble at Pingjiang. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- Han Shizhong reaches Changshu On the guisi day of the third month Han Shizhong brought his troops to Changshu, and three days later to Pingjiang, wanting to advance at once. Zhang Jun (張浚) said he had already sent someone to keep the other side calm with soothing words; with the emperor in their hands, they could not afford to be hasty. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:韓世忠]
- The eunuchs are purged again On the jiawu day of the third month, Zeng Ze and Lan Gui were banished to Lingnan, and Miao Fu then sent men after Zeng Ze to behead him. Miao and Liu wanted to guard Ruisheng Palace with their own soldiers and to take Gaozong to Huizhou or Yuezhou, but were blocked. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- The loyalist vanguard sets out On the wuxu day of the third month, Zhang Jun (張浚), thinking Han Shizhong had too few men, assigned him 2,000 of Zhang Jun's (張俊) troops, and they set out from Pingjiang. Only then did Miao and Liu understand that Zhang Jun meant to attack them, and they forced the court to issue an edict demoting him to Vice Militia Commissioner of Huangzhou. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- A proclamation to the whole country On the renyin day of the third month, Zhang Jun (張浚) received the demotion order; fearing the army's morale would collapse, he lied to his officers and men that it was an order summoning him to court. The same day Lü Yihao arrived at Pingjiang, and the two had their aides draft a proclamation denouncing the rebels. Hearing that loyalist troops were gathering in force, Miao and Liu went to Zhu Shengfei and Feng Fan to discuss a restoration. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- The restoration is agreed at the Council Hall On the dingwei day of the third month, Zhu Shengfei summoned Miao and Liu to the Council Hall to discuss the restoration and led the officials in submitting three memorials; the two went to Ruisheng Palace for an audience. The day before, the main army of Lü Yihao and Zhang Jun (張浚) had already set out from Pingjiang. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉]
- Gaozong is restored On the wushen day, the first of the fourth month, the Empress Dowager issued an edict returning the government, Gaozong went back to the palace, and the people of the capital rejoiced. That day the Empress Dowager was honoured as Empress Dowager Longyou and Zhao Fu was made crown prince. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:趙旉]
- The Battle of Linping; Miao and Liu flee by night On the gengxu day of the fourth month the Jianyan era name was restored. The loyalist army reached Linping, where Miao Yi and Ma Rouji held the line of the river; Han Shizhong led the vanguard in hard fighting, broke them, and advanced to the Beiguan gate. Miao and Liu went to the Council Hall to collect their iron certificates of immunity, then opened the Yongjin Gate at night and fled with 2,000 picked troops; they tried to set fires along the way, but heavy rain kept them from catching. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- The loyalist army enters the city; the Empress Dowager withdraws the curtain On the xinhai day of the fourth month, Lü Yihao and Zhang Jun (張浚) entered the city and saw Gaozong, and the Empress Dowager ended her regency. Han Shizhong seized Wang Shixiu with his own hands and handed him over for interrogation. Within days Zhu Shengfei was dismissed as chief minister and Lü Yihao took over. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉]
- Wu Zhan beheaded On the jiayin day of the fourth month, Wu Zhan, the Central Army commander who had opened the palace gate to the rebels, was beheaded; Shi Ximeng, who had gone along with the rebels, was placed under registered custody in Jiyang Military Prefecture. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- Miao Fu flees south; Han Shizhong volunteers to pursue Miao Fu ravaged Fuyang, Tonglu, Shouchang, Quzhou, Changshan and Yushan along his route, burning bridges and seizing civilians to be tattooed and pressed into his army. Han Shizhong volunteered to put down the rebels and was appointed Military Commissioner of Jiangzhe. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:韓世忠]
- The Chixin Army changes sides On the gengchen day of the fifth month, Miao Fu's commanding officer Zhang Yi and others beheaded Wang Junfu and Ma Rouji and came over to surrender. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Liu Zhengyan captured at Pucheng On the jichou day of the fifth month, Han Shizhong defeated the rebels at Pucheng and captured Liu Zhengyan alive; Miao Fu escaped again. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基百科:韓世忠] [維基百科:劉正彥 (宋朝)]
- Miao Fu and Liu Zhengyan are dismembered at Jiankang On the xinsi day of the seventh month, Han Shizhong returned in triumph and presented his prisoners; Miao Fu, Liu Zhengyan and Miao Yi were executed by dismemberment at Jiankang. Wang Yi, Vice Minister of the Court of Judicial Review, argued that the women who had been abducted or hired were innocent, and Gaozong ordered all of them released except the two men's wives and children. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Rewards and accountability On the guiwei day of the seventh month, Han Shizhong was advanced to Acting Junior Guardian and Military Commissioner of two commands. The next day (jiashen) Gaozong issued an edict: the ministers in power at the time of the Miao-Liu Mutiny had failed to defend the dynasty; Zhu Shengfei, Yan Qi and Lu Yundi were stripped of their posts, and Zhang Cheng was ordered to reside in Hengzhou. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉]
- Crown Prince Zhao Fu dies of illness Zhao Fu, the child ruler whom Miao and Liu had put on the throne and Gaozong's only son, died of illness at Jiankang, aged just over two. [維基百科:趙旉]
People
- Emperor Gaozong of Song (Zhao Gou) (Zhao Gou (Emperor Gaozong of Song)), 1107-06-12 — Emperor of the Southern Song (acceded 1127). Ninth son of Emperor Huizong of Song and younger brother of Emperor Qinzong, originally enfeoffed as Prince of Kang. After the Jin army carried off the emperors Huizong and Qinzong in 1127, he took the throne at Yingtian Prefecture and fled south. After the Jingkang Incident he took the throne at Yingtian Prefecture (present-day Shangqiu) as the only remaining imperial prince of the Song house. Miao Fu and Liu Zhengyan were originally the commanders escorting the Empress Dowager and the imperial son to Hangzhou; Wang Yuan and Kang Lü were his favourites; Empress Dowager Longyou, née Meng, had been Emperor Zhezong's empress. After his restoration he reigned until 1162, abdicated in favour of his adopted son Emperor Xiaozong, lived for twenty-five years as retired emperor, and died in 1187 aged eighty. The Wikipedia article on the Miao–Liu Mutiny holds that the mutiny left him distrustful of military commanders for the rest of his life. [維基百科:宋高宗] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Miao Fu (Miao Fu) — Escort commander, Militia Commissioner of Dingzhou (after the mutiny, self-appointed Chief Commander of the Imperial Encampment Commission and Military Commissioner of the Wudang Army). A native of Shangdang from a line of generals: his grandfather Miao Shou was Commander-in-Chief of the Palace Command under Emperor Shenzong, and his father Miao Lü took part in the Xihe frontier expansion. In 1127 he came under Gaozong's command with Liang Yangzu's forces; at the end of 1128 he was ordered to escort Empress Dowager Longyou south and was stationed at Hangzhou with 8,000 men. He prided himself on being a veteran general from a family with generations of merit, yet was only a titular militia commissioner, and resented seeing Wang Yuan suddenly raised to the Bureau of Military Affairs through eunuch connections. During the mutiny he told Gaozong to his face: Your Majesty trusts eunuchs; soldiers with merit go unrewarded, while those who curry favour with the inner attendants get fine posts. After the restoration he fled by night with the iron certificate, running south through Fuyang, Tonglu, Quzhou and Xinzhou. After his defeat he changed his name, disguised himself as a merchant and fled to Jianyang, where the local strongman Zhan Biao recognised him and handed him over to Han Shizhong. On 22 July 1129 (the xinsi day of the seventh month) he was executed by dismemberment in the marketplace at Jiankang together with his younger brother Miao Yi and Liu Zhengyan. [維基百科:苗傅] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉]
- Liu Zhengyan (Liu Zhengyan) — Deputy Chief Commander of the Right Army of the Imperial Encampment, Prefect of Weizhou (after the mutiny, Deputy Chief Commander of the Imperial Encampment Commission). His father Liu Fa was Military Commissioner of Xihe at the end of the Northern Song and was killed in battle against the Western Xia. His first post was Audience Attendant (gemen zhihou). In 1128, on the recommendation of Wang Yuan, a former subordinate of his father, he was made prefect of Haozhou and promoted to Deputy Chief Commander of the Right Army of the Imperial Encampment; Wang Yuan also assigned him 3,000 picked troops. In the second month of 1129 he was ordered to escort the imperial son and the palace ladies to Hangzhou. Wang Yuan was the patron who had promoted him, but later took back the troops he had assigned him, and the two fell out; he was also dissatisfied that the rewards for inducing bandits to surrender were too meagre. He killed Wang Yuan with his own hands. In May 1129 he was defeated and captured alive by Han Shizhong at the Yuliang post station in Pucheng, and on 22 July was executed by dismemberment at Jiankang. At his execution he loudly cursed Miao Fu, saying they had failed only because Miao had not followed his plans. His wife and children were publicly executed. [維基百科:劉正彥 (宋朝)] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Wang Shixiu (Wang Shixiu) — Grand Master of the Palace (zhong dafu), aide to Miao Fu. An aide to Miao Fu and, with Zhang Kui, Wang Junfu and Ma Rouji, one of the planners of the mutiny. Nothing else about his life is recorded in the sources found. Took part as an aide in settling the plan: first kill Wang Yuan, then get rid of the eunuchs. During the mutiny the chief minister Zhu Shengfei deliberately cultivated him, promised him a court post, and communicated with Miao and Liu through him. On the day the loyalist army entered the city (23 April) he was seized by Han Shizhong in person and handed over for interrogation, and afterwards beheaded in the marketplace. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Wu Zhan (Wu Zhan) — Commander of the Central Army (guarding the palace gate). The History of Song records that while guarding the palace gate he was secretly in league with Miao Fu and ushered the rebels in to memorialise that “Miao Fu is not betraying the state, only ridding the realm of a scourge”; it was also he whom Gaozong ordered to seize Kang Lü and hand him to the rebels. No source was found for the rest of his life. Then commander of the Central Army, responsible for the gates of the temporary palace. The inside man who worked with those outside. After the loyalist army entered the city, Gaozong wept holding Han Shizhong's hand and asked him to get rid of Wu Zhan; Han Shizhong pretended to strike up a conversation, broke his middle finger and seized him on the spot. He was beheaded in the marketplace on 26 April (the jiayin day of the fourth month). [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Wang Junfu, Ma Rouji, Zhang Kui (Wang Junfu, Ma Rouji, Zhang Kui) — Red Heart Army officers, adherents of Miao Fu. Wang Junfu and Ma Rouji were both men of Yan, and their unit was known as the “Red Heart Army”; before the mutiny Zhang Kui incited the soldiers by saying “kill Wang Yuan and the eunuchs and every one of you can be rich”, and during the confrontation he quoted the Mencius: “the people are the most important, the ruler the least”. Miao Fu's officers and advisers. Wang Junfu had said privately to Zhu Shengfei that “the two generals have loyalty to spare but too little learning”, from which Zhu Shengfei judged there was still room to turn things round. Gaozong's edict pursued only the ringleaders: Miao, Liu and these three among others. On 22 May 1129 (the gengchen day of the fifth month) Zhang Yi, one of Miao Fu's commanding officers, and others beheaded Wang Junfu and Ma Rouji and came over; Zhang Kui fled into Chong'an with the remnants and was hunted down and killed by troops sent by Han Shizhong. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Wang Yuan (Wang Yuan), 1077 — Chief Commander of the Imperial Encampment Commission, Co-Signatory of the Bureau of Military Affairs. A native of Xizhou and a north-western frontier officer by background, he had served in the campaign against Fang La and the attack on the Liao. Han Shizhong was his subordinate in his early years. After Gaozong's accession he served as Chief Commander of the Imperial Encampment Commission; in the second month of 1129, as the Jin army neared Yangzhou, he advised Gaozong to go south to Hangzhou, and in the third month he was promoted into the Bureau of Military Affairs. The spark for the mutiny: during the retreat from Yangzhou he used warships to carry his own household goods, yet because of his ties to the eunuch Kang Lü he received only a light penalty and was even promoted. On the day of the mutiny, as he left court, he was dragged from his horse by ambushers under a bridge in the north of the city and killed by Liu Zhengyan's own hand; his head was hung up on display. After the mutiny was put down he was posthumously made Commander Unequalled in Honour (kaifu yitong sansi), and Han Shizhong saw to his funeral. [維基百科:王淵 (宋朝)] [維基百科:苗劉兵變] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- Kang Lü (Kang Lü) — Administrator of the Palace Domestic Service (eunuch). Superintendent of Gaozong's princely household when he was still Prince of Kang; he had accompanied him on his mission to the Jin camp. After Gaozong's accession he presumed on imperial favour to wield influence and was rude to the generals; on the flight south his clique seized commoners' houses by force and went shooting ducks and watching the tidal bore. Before the mutiny he obtained a secret document marked with the code characters “田” (tian) and “金” (jin) and warned Gaozong and Wang Yuan, but was unable to prevent it. Miao Fu demanded his life by name; Gaozong first said “I cannot be without someone to attend me”, but in the end had him found in a loft space and handed over, and he was cut in two at the waist below the tower. After the mutiny was put down he was given the posthumous name “Rongjie”. [維基百科:康履] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- Zhao Fu (the Mingshou Emperor) (Zhao Fu), 1127-07-23 — Duke of Wei → infant ruler placed on the throne (era name Mingshou) → Crown Prince. Gaozong's only biological son, born to Consort Pan (Pan Xianfei) at Yingtian Prefecture. Not yet two years old at the time of the mutiny, he was set up as emperor by Miao and Liu, with Empress Dowager Longyou ruling from behind the curtain. Emperor in name only; no one held him to account for anything. Made crown prince on the day of his father's restoration (formally invested in May). He died of illness at Jiankang on 28 July of the same year; Wikipedia records that while he was ill he was frightened by the noise of a palace attendant knocking over a metal brazier, and his condition worsened. Gaozong had no sons thereafter. [維基百科:趙旉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:宋高宗]
- Empress Dowager Longyou (née Meng) (Empress Dowager Meng (Longyou)), 1073 — Empress Dowager (deposed empress of Emperor Zhezong), regent from behind the curtain during the mutiny. Empress of Emperor Zhezong of Song (once deposed), and Gaozong's senior in the family. Escorted to Hangzhou by Miao Fu at the end of 1128. During the mutiny Miao and Liu brought her out to rule from behind the curtain. Miao and Liu thought she was a figurehead for their side; she defended Gaozong to their faces (the disaster was brought on by Huizong's use of Cai Jing and Tong Guan and had nothing to do with the present emperor), during her regency deliberately showed favour to Miao Fu to put him off his guard, and secretly received Lady Liang to urge Han Shizhong to come to the emperor's aid. On the day of the restoration she issued an edict returning the government, withdrew the curtain three days later, and was honoured as Empress Dowager Longyou. She died in 1131. [維基百科:昭慈聖獻皇后(隆祐太后孟氏)] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基百科:梁夫人(梁紅玉)]
- Zhu Shengfei (Zhu Shengfei), 1082 — Right Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs and concurrently Vice Director of the Secretariat (chief minister). A native of Caizhou and a jinshi of 1103. After the Jingkang Incident he went to Jizhou to urge Gaozong to take the throne, and was one of his old servants. Appointed chief minister only three days before the mutiny (the gengchen day of the third month). On the day of the mutiny Gaozong had him lowered from the gate tower by rope to negotiate. He then stayed in the city and manoeuvred: asking for private audiences so as to plan in secret, cultivating Wang Shixiu, urging Miao Fu to let Lady Liang leave the city, and finally summoning Miao and Liu to the Administration Chamber to settle the restoration. Removed as chief minister a few days after the restoration; on 25 July (the jiashen day of the seventh month) Gaozong stripped him of his post on the grounds that the ministers in power had failed to defend the state. He later became chief minister again and died in 1144. [維基百科:朱勝非] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉]
- Zhang Jun (張浚) (Zhang Jun), 1097 — Vice minister, left at Pingjiang in charge of the troops. A native of Mianzhu in Hanzhou. When Gaozong fled south he stayed at Pingjiang to direct the troops and gather up scattered soldiers. After Zhu Shengfei was recalled, he was left alone in charge at Pingjiang. The initiator of the loyalist campaign: on receiving the “Mingshou” amnesty he refused to acknowledge it, and arranged to join forces with Lü Yihao, Liu Guangshi, Han Shizhong and Zhang Jun (張俊); at the same time he wrote letters praising the loyalty of Miao and Liu to buy time, and sent Feng Fan into the city to talk them round. During the mutiny Miao and Liu forced the court to demote him to Vice Militia Commissioner of Huangzhou; after the restoration he was promoted to Administrator of the Bureau of Military Affairs, asked to be put in charge of Sichuan and Shaanxi, and served as Pacification and Disposition Commissioner. He died in 1164. [維基百科:張浚] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉]
- Lü Yihao (Lü Yihao), 1071 — Pacification and Military Commissioner of Jiangdong, Prefect of Jiangning. A native of Qizhou and a jinshi of 1094, long engaged in military supply and logistics. Appointed to Jiangning only two days before the mutiny (the xinsi day of the third month). Wrote to Zhang Jun from Jiangning denouncing the coup, then led troops to Danyang and Pingjiang to join forces. At Pingjiang he and Zhang Jun wept together, and he said: if this fails, the worst that can happen is that our clans are wiped out. After the restoration he succeeded Zhu Shengfei as chief minister (Right Vice Director of the Department of State Affairs and concurrently Vice Director of the Secretariat). Died in 1139. [維基百科:呂頤浩] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉]
- Han Shizhong (Han Shizhong), 1089 — General (vanguard of the loyalist army). Rose from the ranks; in his early years he campaigned against Fang La under Wang Yuan. Defeated at Huaiyang in early 1129, he gathered his scattered soldiers and went south by sea. Hearing that Emperor Gaozong had reached Hangzhou, he led his men toward the imperial temporary residence, learned of the mutiny on the way, and joined Zhang Jun at Pingjiang. The murdered Wang Yuan was his old commander; his wife and son were held hostage by Miao Fu. Routed the rebels at the Battle of Linping, captured Wu Zhan and Wang Shixiu after entering the city, then asked to lead the pursuit, capturing Liu Zhengyan at Pucheng and taking Miao Fu into custody. In the seventh month he was rewarded with the titles of Acting Junior Guardian and Military Commissioner (jiedushi) of the Wusheng and Zhaoqing Armies, and Gaozong wrote the characters “Loyal and Brave” for him in his own hand. Died in 1151. [維基百科:韓世忠] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Lady Liang (known to later ages as Liang Hongyu) (Lady Liang), 1102 — Wife of Han Shizhong. Han Shizhong's second wife. Song-dynasty sources call her only Lady Liang or Lady of Yang; the name “Hongyu” first appears in Ming-dynasty drama. At the time of the mutiny she was in Hangzhou with her son Han Liang and was held hostage by Miao Fu. Zhu Shengfei persuaded Miao Fu to let her leave the city to “pacify” Han Shizhong; she reached Xiuzhou in a day and a night and brought her husband news of the situation inside the city. Before leaving the city she was made Lady of Anguo by the Empress Dowager, and after the rebellion was put down she was further made Lady of Huguo; the practice of ennobling the wives of meritorious officials began with her. Died in 1135. [維基百科:梁夫人(梁紅玉)] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Zhang Jun (張俊) (Zhang Jun (general)), 1086 — Commander of the Vanguard Army of the Imperial Encampment. An old subordinate of Gaozong from his time at the Marshal's Headquarters; Miao Fu had belonged to the same force in those years and had fought beside him in suppressing rebellions. At the time of the mutiny he was stationed around Wujiang with 8,000 men. Miao and Liu ordered him transferred to Qinfeng and his troops divided; instead he led his men to Pingjiang to see Zhang Jun (張浚), tearfully accepted the order to come to the emperor's rescue, and detached 2,000 men to serve as Han Shizhong's vanguard. Advanced with Han Shizhong at the Battle of Linping and was promoted for his loyalist service; later counted among the “Four Generals of the Restoration”. Died in 1154. [維基百科:張俊] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- Liu Guangshi (Liu Guangshi), 1086 — Commander-in-Chief of the Palace Command and Military Commissioner of the Five Armies of the Imperial Temporary Residence (stationed at Zhenjiang). A native of Bao'an Military Prefecture from a family of generals, second son of Liu Yanqing. When Jin troops took Yangzhou in the second month of 1129, he fled without fighting. When Gaozong crossed south he was left at Zhenjiang to hold the mouth of the Yangtze. Led his troops to Danyang to join Lü Yihao and the loyalist cause; Wang De, sent out by Miao Fu, also brought his troops over to him. After taking part in the loyalist campaign he was made Grand Commandant and Military Commissioner of Huainan; in the sixth month he accepted the surrender of Han Jun, leader of Miao Fu's remnants. Died in 1142. [維基百科:劉光世] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉]
Moves to block a return
- On the very night of the forced abdication Gaozong was moved out of the temporary palace and lodged in Xianzhong Temple (the Basic Annals of the History of Song give Xianning Temple); the next day it was renamed “Ruisheng Palace” and he was honoured as “Emperor Ruisheng Renxiao”, with only fifteen eunuch attendants left at his side and all the other eunuchs banished to the provinces. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉]
- On the jichou day of the third month the era name was changed to “Mingshou”, replacing Gaozong's “Jianyan” with the infant ruler's era name. Miao Fu wanted to change the era name and Liu Zhengyan wanted to move the capital to Jiankang; the Empress Dowager and Zhu Shengfei, fearing trouble if both were refused, agreed only to the change of era name. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:趙旉]
- Miao and Liu wanted to replace the palace guard with their own troops to “guard” Ruisheng Palace, and also wanted to take Gaozong to Huizhou or Yuezhou; Zhu Shengfei and Zhang Cheng tactfully blocked this. On the same day they had the eunuch Zeng Ze, already banished to Lingnan, pursued and killed. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- Using appointments to break up the armies outside: in the court's name Han Shizhong was transferred to be a superintendent of the Imperial Encampment Commission, and Zhang Jun (張俊) was transferred to be Deputy Commander-in-Chief of Qinfeng with his troops divided; a ministerial directive was also used to press Zhang Jun (張浚) to go to Qinzhou, and someone else was sent to take over Zhang Jun (張俊)'s troops (the appointee refused). After Zhang Jun (張浚) raised his army, they further forced the court to issue an edict demoting him to Vice Militia Commissioner of Huangzhou, to be settled in Chenzhou. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- They held Han Shizhong's wife, Lady Liang, and his son as hostages. Zhu Shengfei turned this round by persuading Miao Fu that it would be better to send her to placate Han Shizhong. The Empress Dowager received Lady Liang, gave her the title Lady of Anguo, and told her to have Han Shizhong come quickly; she reached Xiuzhou in a day and a night. [維基百科:梁夫人(梁紅玉)]
- They sent Miao Yu and Ma Rouji with the Red Heart Army and Wang Yuan's former troops to hold Linping against the loyalist army, and stationed another 3,000 men at Huzhou; they also wanted to detain Feng Fan, the envoy Zhang Jun (張浚) had sent to persuade them, and released him only after being taken in by a forged letter from Zhang Jun. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Even after the restoration they wanted a guarantee of their lives: Miao Fu and Liu Zhengyan demanded iron certificates of immunity from death from Gaozong, who granted them and appointed the two Military Commissioner and Deputy Military Commissioner of Huaixi to get them away from court. The next day the two went to the Administration Chamber to press for the certificates, obtained them, and fled by night through the Yongjin Gate with 2,000 picked troops. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基文庫:《宋史》卷二十五〈高宗本紀二〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
Rumors
- Wang Yuan's dozen or so shiploads of treasure were plundered from wealthy Hangzhou households he killed indiscriminately when suppressing Chen Tong's rebellion. [Still unclear] Street rumour in Hangzhou (the History of Song records it as what “the people of Hangzhou said to one another”) The History of Song records only the rumour and its effect on the army's mood, not any finding on whether it was true. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Han Shizhong's wife was named “Liang Hongyu”. [Proven false] The Ming-dynasty play Shuanglie ji (The Two Heroes) by Zhang Siwei Song-dynasty sources call her only Lady Liang or Lady of Yang, and her given name is not recorded; “Hongyu” is a name that appears only in Ming drama. That she was held hostage and left the city to carry word is, however, on record. [維基百科:梁夫人(梁紅玉)]
- Wang Yuan conspired with the eunuchs to rebel, and so deserved to be killed. [Proven false] The justification given by Miao Fu and Liu Zhengyan when they killed Wang Yuan The History of Song (Song shi) states outright that he was “falsely accused of conspiring with the eunuchs to rebel”. That Wang Yuan owed his promotion to the eunuchs and shipped private valuables during the retreat was generally accepted at the time, but “rebellion” was purely a pretext for the killing; after the mutiny was suppressed, the court granted Wang Yuan posthumous office. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Gaozong's claim to the throne was not legitimate: his elder brother Emperor Qinzong was still alive, so what would happen when he came back? [Still unclear] Miao Fu, shouting up to Gaozong from below the tower This was not a dispute over facts but over legitimacy: Emperors Huizong and Qinzong were indeed being held in the north by the Jin at the time, and the Empress Dowager defended Gaozong on the spot. The Chinese Wikipedia article on the Miao-Liu Mutiny notes that the remark struck Gaozong's sore spot and deepened his fear of losing the throne. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Miao Fu and Liu Zhengyan offered a bounty and sent an assassin to Xiuzhou to kill Zhang Jun (張浚); the assassin instead turned himself in, gave warning, and left without giving his name. [Still unclear] The account from Zhang Jun's side (as cited in the Chinese Wikipedia article on Zhang Jun) The story appears only in the account from Zhang Jun's side; the assassin is nameless, and there is no other corroboration. [維基百科:張浚]
- Gaozong's only son was frightened to death by the Miao-Liu Mutiny, and that is why Gaozong was left without an heir. [Still unclear] The version commonly accepted in later ages (Chinese Wikipedia article on Emperor Gaozong of Song) Zhao Fu did die of illness four months after the mutiny, and Gaozong had no more children afterwards; but the immediate cause recorded in the Chinese Wikipedia article on Zhao Fu is that, while ill, he was startled by the noise of a palace attendant kicking over a metal censer. A causal link with the mutiny cannot be verified. [維基百科:宋高宗] [維基百科:趙旉]
Views
- History of Song (Song shi; official history compiled under the Yuan dynasty): The History of Song places the two in its “Biographies of Rebel Ministers” and calls them “bandits” and “the two villains” throughout; yet it also faithfully records Miao Fu's accusations against the eunuchs and Wang Yuan, as well as the facts that stirred the army's anger, such as Wang Yuan's shipping of valuables and Kang Lü's high-handedness. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- Overall assessment in the Chinese Wikipedia article on the Miao-Liu Mutiny: The coup became a shadow Gaozong could never shake off, leaving him distrustful of military men for the rest of his life and prone to reshuffling his generals; Miao Fu's use of Emperors Huizong and Qinzong to question his legitimacy further deepened his fear of military strongmen and of losing the throne. The article holds that this was connected to his later obstruction of Yue Fei's northern expeditions. [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Investigating Censor Chen Jian: The overbearing general Fan Qiong kept his army back to wait and watch, refused to come to court, and even flayed people to intimidate envoys. Chen Jian was unmoved and said only: General, have you not seen what became of Miao and Liu? Fan Qiong then came to court and was promptly arrested and ordered to take his own life. [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Miao Fu (leader of the mutiny): He told Gaozong to his face: Your Majesty trusts the eunuchs; soldiers who earn merit go unrewarded, while those who curry favour with the palace attendants get fine posts. Huang Qianshan and Wang Boyan ruined the state yet were not banished far away. Wang Yuan would not fight when he met the enemy, yet through Kang Lü he entered the Bureau of Military Affairs, while I, with all my merits, am only a titular militia commissioner. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- Empress Dowager Longyou (née Meng): She told Miao and Liu: the Jin disaster was brought on by Emperor Huizong's employment of Cai Jing, Wang Fu and Tong Guan; what has it to do with the present emperor? The emperor has not failed in virtue; he was merely misled by Huang Qianshan and Wang Boyan, and those two have already been demoted. She also said: even in peaceful times it is hard for a woman holding an infant to preside over government, let alone with a powerful enemy outside. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉] [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
- Wang Junfu (Miao Fu's trusted officer): He said privately to Chief Minister Zhu Shengfei: the two generals have loyalty to spare but not enough learning. Zhu Shengfei passed the remark on to Gaozong and judged that matters could still be worked on gradually. [維基文庫:《宋史》卷四百七十五〈叛臣傳上.苗傅、劉正彥〉]
- Liu Zhengyan (at his execution): At his execution he cursed Miao Fu for not following his plans, which was why they had come to this end. [維基百科:苗劉兵變]
Photos & videos
Seated portrait of Emperor Gaozong of Song (Zhao Gou), National Palace Museum collection. — 國立故宮博物院 / CC0
Four Generals of the Restoration, attributed to Liu Songnian of the Southern Song: Han Shizhong, Zhang Jun (張俊) and Liu Guangshi, who put down the Miao-Liu Mutiny, all appear in it (the fourth is Yue Fei). — Liu Songnian / Public domain
Portrait of Han Shizhong (detail of Four Generals of the Restoration). He pursued Miao Fu and Liu Zhengyan all the way to Fujian. — 劉松年繪 / Public domain
Portrait of Zhang Jun (張俊) (detail of Four Generals of the Restoration). During the mutiny he brought his troops to Pingjiang and tearfully accepted the order to come to the emperor's rescue. — 劉松年繪 / Public domain
Portrait of Liu Guangshi (detail of Four Generals of the Restoration). — 劉松年繪 / Public domain
Portrait of Empress Dowager Longyou, née Meng. Miao and Liu asked her to rule from behind the curtain as their figurehead, but she secretly urged Han Shizhong to come to the emperor's rescue. — Unknown author / Public domain
Seated statue of Zhang Jun (張浚) (Shrine of Zhang, Duke of Wei, Nanxuan Cultural Park). It was he who launched the loyalist army at Pingjiang. — Uploaded by Huangdan2060 / CC BY 3.0
Map of the imperial city of Hangzhou (Lin'an) in the thirteenth century. The mutiny of 1129 took place in front of the gate of the temporary palace in Hangzhou. — Qian Yueyou, edited by G.E. Moule and Henry Yule / Public domain
Handwritten edict from Emperor Gaozong of Song to Yue Fei, 1137, National Palace Museum collection. After the mutiny, Gaozong always both used his generals and guarded against them. — 國立故宮博物院 / CC0
Site of the Yongsi Mausoleum (Gaozong) and Yongfu Mausoleum (Xiaozong) at the Six Song Mausoleums in Shaoxing. — Yumeto / CC BY-SA 4.0
Temple of Han Shizhong. — 鲍向阳 / CC BY-SA 3.0