Puyi (the Xuantong Emperor) (Puyi (Xuantong Emperor)) — Qing dynasty (Great Qing Empire) (Qing dynasty (Great Qing))
Puyi came to the throne at three and abdicated at six, continuing after his abdication to live in the Forbidden City as "emperor". On 1 July 1917 Zhang Xun's pigtailed troops occupied key points in Beijing and he was put back on the throne — for just 12 days in all. Li Yuanhong refused to hand over power, took refuge in the Japanese legation, asked Vice President Feng Guozhang to act in his place, and reappointed Duan Qirui; on 3 July Duan Qirui took an oath at Machang, Tianjin, and formed the "Army to Punish the Rebels", on the 7th an aeroplane dropped three bombs on the palace, and on the 12th the army fought its way into Beijing, Zhang Xun took refuge in the Dutch legation, and Puyi abdicated again. The consequences afterwards were light: Zhang Xun and Kang Youwei were placed on the wanted list and both pardoned within a little over a year; Zhang Zhenfang and Lei Zhenchun, who were arrested and tried, were out of prison within a few months; Puyi himself was not held to account, the favourable treatment continued as before, and he lived in the Forbidden City for another seven years, until Feng Yuxiang's troops removed him from the palace on 1924-11-05. The real consequences lay elsewhere: Duan Qirui, styling himself the man who had "re-created the Republic", refused to restore the old parliament, Sun Yat-sen went south to launch the Constitutional Protection movement, and north and south were divided from then on.
How they were ousted
On 1912-02-12 Empress Dowager Longyu, on terms brokered by Yuan Shikai, issued the edict of abdication on behalf of the six-year-old Puyi; under the Articles of Favourable Treatment of the Qing imperial house, he kept the title of emperor, was to live for the time being in the Forbidden City, and was to receive four million taels a year from the Republic.
How they came back
In 1917 President Li Yuanhong and Premier Duan Qirui fell out, and Li invited the "Pigtail General" Zhang Xun to Beijing to mediate; after forcing Li to dissolve parliament, Zhang Xun entered the palace in the early hours of 1 July with Kang Youwei and others and restored the 11-year-old Puyi to the throne, restyling the year Xuantong 9. This restoration lasted only 12 days, ending on 12 July.
What happened to the board
This question has to be looked at from two sides, and on both sides almost no one faced a reckoning. Those who had made him abdicate: Yuan Shikai had already died of illness in 1916; during the 12 days of the restoration the Qing court, far from being able to settle scores with anyone, issued edicts creating Li Yuanhong a duke of the first class and appointing Feng Guozhang viceroy of Liangjiang, trying to draw the Republic's men in — Li Yuanhong refused and took refuge in the Japanese legation, and Feng Guozhang issued a circular telegram in opposition. So the reckoning for "those who drove him out" was nil. Conversely, the Republic was also lenient with those who had enthroned him: Zhang Xun was placed on the wanted list after taking refuge in the Dutch legation, was pardoned on 1918-10-23 by the new president Xu Shichang, and died of illness in Tianjin in 1923, with Puyi's little court granting him the posthumous title Zhongwu; Kang Youwei fled into a legation and was placed on the wanted list on 17 July, the warrant was dropped on 1918-03-15, and he died in Qingdao in 1927; Zhang Zhenfang, minister of finance, and Lei Zhenchun, minister of war, were arrested and sent before a court for treason (Lei was sentenced to life imprisonment), and were released on bail and freed one after the other in January–February 1918; there is no record of any action against Liang Dingfen, who had gone to the presidential palace to press Li Yuanhong to hand over power, and he died of illness in 1919, receiving the posthumous title Wenzhong. Puyi himself kept the favourable treatment under the protection of Beiyang leaders such as Duan Qirui and Feng Guozhang. The one who really lost his position politically was Li Yuanhong — not purged by the Qing court but brought down by this affair, he announced his resignation by circular telegram on 14 July.
Timeline
- Puyi enthroned Puyi, not yet three, was enthroned in the Hall of Supreme Harmony with the reign title Xuantong, his father Zaifeng, Prince Chun, acting as regent. [維基百科(中文):溥儀]
- The edict of abdication and the Articles of Favourable Treatment Empress Dowager Longyu issued the Imperial Edict of Abdication on Puyi's behalf, accepting the Articles of Favourable Treatment: the title not abolished, temporary residence in the palace, and an annual allowance of four million taels. The English article says this sum was never paid in full. [維基百科(中文):溥儀] [維基文庫:清室優待條件] [Wikipedia: Puyi]
- Li Yuanhong dismisses Duan Qirui In conflict with parliament and the president over the declaration of war on Germany, Duan Qirui was dismissed as premier and left Beijing for Tianjin. From 29 May the military governors of the Beiyang provinces declared independence one after another. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):段祺瑞] [維基百科(中文):黎元洪]
- Li Yuanhong summons Zhang Xun to Beijing by telegram to mediate Zhang Xun arrived in Tianjin on 8 June with several thousand troops; the conditions he set were the dissolution of parliament and a new constitution. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):護法運動]
- Parliament dissolved Foreign minister Wu Tingfang refused to countersign the dissolution order and resigned; that evening Li Yuanhong appointed Jiang Chaozong acting premier to countersign it, and parliament was dissolved. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):黎元洪]
- Zhang Xun enters Beijing On 16 June Zhang Xun had an audience with Puyi at the palace; on the 19th the independent military governors agreed to rescind their independence. On 28 June Kang Youwei entered Beijing secretly. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):康有為]
- The "imperial conference" and the late-night occupation of key points Zhang Xun conferred in secret with Chen Baochen and others on the restoration; that night he sent troops to occupy the railway stations and post office, and sent Liang Dingfen to urge Li Yuanhong to "return the government". [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):梁鼎芬]
- The Xuantong restoration In the early hours Zhang Xun and others entered the palace and seated Puyi on the throne (the Puyi article gives 3 a.m. in the Palace of Heavenly Purity, the restoration article says the Hall of Supreme Harmony, the English article gives 4 a.m.), restyled the year Xuantong 9, and restored the dragon flag. Edicts created Li Yuanhong a duke of the first class, made Zhang Xun minister of state and concurrently viceroy of Zhili and minister for the Northern Ports, appointed Lei Zhenchun, Zhang Zhenfang and others ministers of the various boards, and named Kang Youwei and Xu Shichang president and vice president of the Bideyuan. Sun Yat-sen issued his Declaration against the Rebels the same day. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):溥儀] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- Li Yuanhong takes refuge in the Japanese legation Li Yuanhong refused to hand over power, took refuge in the residence of the Japanese legation's military attaché, and asked Feng Guozhang to act in his place and reappointed Duan Qirui as premier. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):黎元洪] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- Duan Qirui takes his oath at Machang Duan Qirui took an oath at Machang, Tianjin, and formed the "Army to Punish the Rebels"; the same day Feng Guozhang issued a circular telegram from Nanjing opposing the restoration. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟]
- Edict to the provinces to choose delegates to discuss a constitution The restoration court ordered the governors-general and governors of the provinces each to choose three people to come to the capital to deliberate on a constitution and parliament. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟]
- The Army to Punish the Rebels closes in on Beijing Cao Kun, Li Changtai and Chen Guangyuan advanced on Beijing with their troops; Duan Qirui's forces controlled the Beijing–Tianjin railway. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- Feng Guozhang assumes office as acting president in Nanjing The Republic's side now had an acting head of state and a premier, and the restoration court was completely isolated in terms of legitimacy. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):馮國璋]
- Aeroplane bombs the Forbidden City; battle of Langfang The Nanyuan aviation school sent an aeroplane that dropped three bombs on the palace, killing one eunuch. The same day the Army to Punish the Rebels defeated Zhang Xun's troops at Langfang. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration] [Wikipedia: Puyi]
- Zhang Xun resigns all his posts The court allowed Zhang Xun to resign as minister of state, viceroy of Zhili, minister for the Northern Ports and other posts; his troops remained inside Beijing. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- Beijing besieged; attempts to persuade him to surrender fail The foreign diplomatic corps and Wang Shizhen urged Zhang Xun to surrender and were refused. The Qing house at one point drafted an abdication edict but did not issue it. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- The Army to Punish the Rebels fights its way into Beijing; the restoration ends The army launched its general assault in the early morning, and after an exchange of fire around the Temple of Heaven the pigtailed troops gave way. In the afternoon Zhang Xun entered the Dutch legation with the help of two Germans. Puyi again announced his abdication — the restoration had lasted 12 days in all. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration] [維基百科(中文):張勳]
- The Qing house declares the restoration edicts revoked Puyi's side wrote to Duan Qirui stating that all edicts issued after 1 July were revoked. [維基百科(中文):溥儀]
- Duan Qirui returns to the capital; Li Yuanhong leaves office Duan Qirui entered Beijing and resumed control of the government; the same day Li Yuanhong announced by circular telegram that he declined to resume office and moved out of the Japanese legation. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):黎元洪]
- Zhang Zhenfang and Lei Zhenchun sent for trial for treason The two were arrested on the way out of Beijing and, together with Feng Delin, dismissed and sent before a court. [維基百科(中文):張鎮芳] [維基百科(中文):雷震春]
- Warrant issued for Kang Youwei; Sun Yat-sen arrives in Guangzhou Duan Qirui's government ordered Kang Youwei's arrest. On the same day Sun Yat-sen arrived in Guangzhou and raised the banner of constitutional protection. [維基百科(中文):康有為] [維基百科(中文):護法運動]
- China declares war on Germany Duan Qirui got his way and declared war on Germany — the very issue that had started the dispute between the presidential office and the cabinet. [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- Sun Yat-sen takes office as generalissimo of the Constitutional Protection military government Duan Qirui did not restore the Provisional Constitution and the old parliament, forming a provisional senate instead; the members who had gone south opened an extraordinary parliament in Guangzhou on 25 August and elected Sun Yat-sen generalissimo on 1 September. [維基百科(中文):護法運動] [維基百科(中文):段祺瑞]
- Lei Zhenchun and Zhang Zhenfang released Zhang Zhenfang had already been released on medical bail in January; on 28 February the two were provisionally released together to serve with Cao Kun's army. [維基百科(中文):雷震春] [維基百科(中文):張鎮芳]
- Warrant for Kang Youwei dropped A presidential order announced that the warrant was dropped. [維基百科(中文):康有為]
- Xu Shichang pardons Zhang Xun The new president Xu Shichang pardoned Zhang Xun — Xu Shichang himself having been named to the Bideyuan in the restoration edicts. [維基百科(中文):張勳] [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟]
- Johnston enters the palace The Briton Reginald Johnston entered the Forbidden City for an audience and thereafter served as Puyi's English tutor. On 14 November of the same year Liang Dingfen died of illness and received the posthumous title Wenzhong. [維基百科(中文):溥儀] [維基百科(中文):梁鼎芬] [Wikipedia: Reginald Johnston]
- Zhang Xun dies of illness in Tianjin Aged 68. The abdicated Qing little court granted him the posthumous title Zhongwu. [維基百科(中文):張勳]
- Puyi expelled from the Forbidden City On 23 October Feng Yuxiang staged the Beijing Coup; on 5 November Lu Zhonglin entered the palace with the Revised Articles of Favourable Treatment, and Puyi was forced to give up the imperial title and left the palace that day. [維基百科(中文):溥儀] [維基百科(中文):修正清室優待條件] [Wikipedia: Puyi]
People
- Puyi (Puyi), 1906-02-07 — Last emperor of the Qing dynasty (the Xuantong Emperor, 1908–1912; restored for 12 days in 1917). Born 1906-02-07 at the mansion of Prince Chun in Beijing; his father was Zaifeng, Prince Chun. Enthroned in the Hall of Supreme Harmony on 1908-12-02, with the reign title Xuantong. Made emperor in 1908, before he was three years old. He was only six at his abdication, and the English article says no one told him at the time that his reign had ended. At the restoration of 1917 he was 11, and was put on the throne by Zhang Xun and others. Abdicated again on 1917-07-12; the next day the Qing house wrote to Duan Qirui declaring all edicts issued after 1 July revoked. He was not held to account and went on living in the Forbidden City; expelled from the palace on 1924-11-05, he then went to Tianjin, became chief executive of Manchukuo in 1932 and its emperor in 1934, was captured by the Soviet army in 1945, received a special pardon in 1959, and died of illness in Beijing on 1967-10-17. [維基百科(中文):溥儀] [Wikipedia: Puyi]
- Zhang Xun (Zhang Xun), 1854-12-14 — Inspector-General of the Yangtze (concurrently in charge of military affairs in Anhui), commander of the Dingwu Army (the "pigtailed army"). Born 1854-12-14, a native of Fengxin, Jiangxi; enlisted at Changsha in 1884, later served under Yuan Shikai, and became provincial commander-in-chief of Jiangnan in 1911. After the founding of the Republic he insisted on keeping his queue as a sign of loyalty to the Qing house, and was known as the "Pigtail General". In 1913 he took Nanjing on Yuan Shikai's orders, his troops' killing and looting causing a diplomatic incident between China and Japan, and was thereafter stationed at Xuzhou. On 1917-06-01 Li Yuanhong summoned him by telegram to Beijing to mediate the dispute between the presidential office and the cabinet; he reached Tianjin on 8 June, entered Beijing on the 14th, and had an audience at the palace on the 16th. On 30 June he held an "imperial conference" with Chen Baochen and others, and that night sent troops to occupy the railway stations and post office; on 1 July he restored Puyi to the throne, making himself a minister of state, viceroy of Zhili and minister for the Northern Ports, and was created Prince Zhongyong. Resigned all his posts on 8 July; defeated on the 12th, he took refuge in the Dutch legation with the help of two Germans, later moved to the German concession in Tianjin, and was placed on the Republic's wanted list. Pardoned by President Xu Shichang on 1918-10-23, he lived in Tianjin and went into business. Died of illness on 1923-09-12; Puyi's little court granted him the posthumous title Zhongwu, and he was buried at Fengxin. [維基百科(中文):張勳] [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟]
- Kang Youwei (Kang Youwei), 1858-03-19 — President of the Confucian Association, former leader of the Hundred Days' Reform; given a senior post in the Bideyuan (privy council) at the restoration. Born 1858-03-19 in Nanhai, Guangdong. Promoted the Hundred Days' Reform in 1898 and after its failure went into exile abroad, organising the Emperor Protection Society. Returned to China in 1913 and settled in Shanghai as president of the Confucian Association, opposing the republic and advocating constitutional monarchy. Entered Beijing secretly on 1917-06-28 and plotted with Zhang Xun to restore Puyi. The restoration edicts appointed him and Xu Shichang president and vice president of the Bideyuan. On 12 July he fled into a foreign legation in the Legation Quarter, and on 17 July was placed on the wanted list by Duan Qirui's government; a presidential order of 1918-03-15 dropped the warrant. He moved to Qingdao in 1923, and after Puyi left the palace in 1924 even went to Tianjin to visit him. Died suddenly in Qingdao on 1927-03-31; accounts of the cause of death vary. [維基百科(中文):康有為] [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟]
- Liang Dingfen (Liang Dingfen), 1859 — Puyi's tutor; commissioner for tree-planting at the Chongling mausoleum. Born 1859; jinshi of 1880 and compiler at the Hanlin Academy; demoted five grades during the Sino-French War for impeaching Li Hongzhang, he later joined Zhang Zhidong's staff. After the founding of the Republic he spent three years planting trees at the Chongling, the Guangxu Emperor's mausoleum, and on Chen Baochen's recommendation became tutor to Puyi. A close courtier of the abdicated Qing little court. Sent by Zhang Xun to the presidential palace on the night of 30 June to demand, on behalf of the Qing house, that Li Yuanhong "return the government". The article records no action taken against him after the restoration failed. Died of illness in Beijing on 1919-11-14; Puyi granted him the posthumous title Wenzhong. [維基百科(中文):梁鼎芬] [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟]
- Zhang Zhenfang (Zhang Zhenfang), 1863 — Chairman of the Yien Yieh Commercial Bank; minister of state and minister of finance at the restoration. Born 1863, a cousin of Yuan Shikai. Founded the Yien Yieh Commercial Bank in 1915, serving as its chairman and general manager. Appointed cabinet minister of state and minister of finance on 1 July. A pamphlet of the time, The Inside Story of the Restoration, called the restorationists the "new Thirteen Guardians", and called him and Lei Zhenchun "double monarchist offenders" — having had a hand both in Yuan Shikai's bid to be emperor and in this restoration. As the restoration was about to fail he and Lei Zhenchun prepared to leave Beijing and were arrested on the way; on 15 July he was dismissed and sent before a court for treason. In January 1918 he was released on medical bail to Tianjin, and was formally freed in 1920; he remained chairman of the Yien Yieh Commercial Bank and died of illness in 1933. [維基百科(中文):張鎮芳] [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):雷震春]
- Lei Zhenchun (Lei Zhenchun), 1864 — Former head of the Capital Military Law Enforcement Office; minister of war at the restoration. Born 1864, a native of Suzhou, Anhui. Became head of the Capital Military Law Enforcement Office in 1914. Appointed minister of war on 1 July. Like Zhang Zhenfang a former subordinate of Yuan Shikai, he took part in the restoration with him. Arrested together with Zhang Zhenfang on the way out of Beijing; stripped of office on 15 July and sent before a court for treason, he was sentenced to life imprisonment. On 1918-02-28 he and Zhang Zhenfang were provisionally released to serve with Cao Kun's army. Died in 1919. [維基百科(中文):雷震春] [維基百科(中文):張鎮芳]
- Duan Qirui (Duan Qirui), 1865-03-06 — Premier (dismissed on 23 May, reinstated on 2 July); organiser of the Army to Punish the Rebels. Born 1865-03-06; with Wang Shizhen and Feng Guozhang one of the "Three Heroes of Beiyang". In January 1912 he joined other Beiyang generals in a circular telegram that helped bring about the republic; the article says that for this, for resisting Yuan Shikai's bid to be emperor and for the campaign against Zhang Xun, he had the reputation of having "thrice created the republic". Premier after Yuan Shikai's death; in conflict with President Li Yuanhong over declaring war on Germany, he was dismissed on 1917-05-23 and withdrew to Tianjin. Zhang Xun's entry into Beijing arose precisely from his dismissal. On 3 July he took his oath at Machang, and on the 14th he returned to Beijing and resumed control of the government. Styling himself the hero who had "re-created the republic", he nevertheless refused to restore the Provisional Constitution and the old parliament, provoking Sun Yat-sen's Constitutional Protection movement; on 14 August he got his way and declared war on Germany. He resigned for a time on 1917-11-22, was defeated and driven from office in the Zhili–Anhui War of 1920, served as provisional chief executive in 1924–1926, and died of illness in Shanghai on 1936-11-02. [維基百科(中文):段祺瑞] [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):護法運動] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- Li Yuanhong (Li Yuanhong), 1864-10-19 — President of the Republic of China. Born 1864-10-19. Chosen as military governor of Hubei at the Wuchang Uprising of 1911, later vice president, he succeeded to the presidency after Yuan Shikai died of illness on 1916-06-06. Succeeded according to law after Yuan Shikai's death. Dismissed Duan Qirui on 23 May, summoned Zhang Xun to Beijing to mediate on 1 June, and dissolved parliament under Zhang Xun's pressure on 12 June — in effect inviting Zhang Xun into Beijing himself. The restoration court created him a duke of the first class, which he did not accept. Took refuge in the Japanese legation on the evening of 2 July. After the restoration was put down he announced his resignation by circular telegram on 14 July and moved out of the legation, leaving Beijing for Tianjin on 28 August. He returned to the presidency for a time in 1922, was again forced out by Cao Kun in 1923, and died of illness in Tianjin on 1928-06-03. [維基百科(中文):黎元洪] [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- Feng Guozhang (Feng Guozhang), 1859-01-07 — Vice president, military governor of Jiangsu; acting president during the restoration. Born 1859-01-07, one of the "Three Heroes of Beiyang". Elected vice president on 1916-10-30, based in Nanjing. Li Yuanhong asked him to exercise the powers of the presidency before taking refuge in the legation. The restoration edicts appointed him viceroy of Liangjiang and minister for the Southern Ports; he issued a circular telegram in opposition on 3 July and assumed office as acting president in Nanjing on 6 July. In earlier years he had been in close contact with Zhang Xun, which had even aroused Yuan Shikai's suspicion. Went to Beijing on 31 July to take up the government. He later fell out with Duan Qirui by advocating peaceful unification against Duan's unification by force, left office on 1918-10-10, and died of illness on 1919-12-28. [維基百科(中文):馮國璋] [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟]
- Sun Yat-sen (Sun Yat-sen) — Leader of the Constitutional Protection movement. The articles consulted record only his actions around this event; his biography is omitted. Not part of the Beijing government. Issued his Declaration against the Rebels on 1 July, the day of the restoration. In early July he sailed south by warship with Zhang Taiyan and others, reaching Guangzhou on the 17th, and called on the members of the dissolved parliament to come south. The extraordinary parliament opened on 25 August, he was elected generalissimo of the military government on 1 September, and took office on 10 September. He criticised Duan Qirui for "using a rebel to punish a rebel, a traitor to punish a traitor". [維基百科(中文):護法運動] [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟]
- Reginald Johnston (Reginald Johnston), 1874-10-13 — Puyi's English tutor (from 1919). Born 1874-10-13 in Edinburgh; British Colonial Office official and sinologist. More than a year after the restoration failed, in March 1919, he entered the Forbidden City to teach the 13-year-old Puyi; the English article says it was President Xu Shichang who engaged him. He was not on the scene in 1917, but his Twilight in the Forbidden City (1934) is the principal witness to these years of the "little court". After Puyi left the palace in 1924 he was briefly his adviser, then returned to the Colonial Office, serving as commissioner of Weihaiwei in 1927–1930; professor of Chinese at the University of London from 1931, he even visited Puyi in Manchukuo in 1935. Died on 1938-03-06. [Wikipedia: Reginald Johnston] [Wikipedia: Puyi] [維基百科(中文):溥儀]
Moves to block a return
- The Articles of Favourable Treatment were themselves the line of defence: the title was kept, but only "to be treated with the courtesies due to a foreign sovereign"; residence in the palace was temporary, with a later move to the Summer Palace; palace staff were retained but no more eunuchs could be recruited; the Imperial Guard was transferred to the Republic's Ministry of War. The emperor had a title and no army. [維基文庫:清室優待條件] [維基百科(中文):溥儀]
- Li Yuanhong refused to "return the government" and at 9:30 p.m. on 2 July took refuge in the residence of the Japanese legation's military attaché; before leaving he asked Vice President Feng Guozhang to exercise the powers of the presidency and reappointed Duan Qirui as premier — giving the punitive campaign a lawful basis. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):黎元洪] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- Duan Qirui took an oath at Machang, Tianjin, and sent troops in the name of the "Army to Punish the Rebels"; the same day Feng Guozhang issued a circular telegram from Nanjing opposing the restoration, and on 6 July assumed office as acting president. On 5 July the forces of Cao Kun, Li Changtai, Chen Guangyuan and others closed in on Beijing, and on the 7th defeated the pigtailed troops at Langfang. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):馮國璋] [維基百科(中文):段祺瑞]
- An aeroplane from the Nanyuan aviation school dropped three bombs on the Forbidden City, killing one eunuch and doing slight damage. The English article calls this the first recorded aerial bombing by a Chinese air force. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration] [Wikipedia: Puyi]
- Wanted notices and trials afterwards: on 15 July Zhang Zhenfang, Lei Zhenchun and Feng Delin were dismissed and sent before a court for treason; on 17 July a warrant was issued for Kang Youwei; Zhang Xun was also placed on the wanted list after Puyi's abdication. [維基百科(中文):張鎮芳] [維基百科(中文):雷震春] [維基百科(中文):康有為] [維基百科(中文):張勳]
- The finishing blow seven years later: after staging the Beijing Coup, Feng Yuxiang used the Revised Articles of Favourable Treatment to abolish the imperial title for ever and cut the annuity to 500,000 yuan, and sent Lu Zhonglin to remove Puyi from the Forbidden City that same day. The English article says he was given three hours to leave. [維基百科(中文):修正清室優待條件] [維基百科(中文):溥儀] [Wikipedia: Puyi]
Rumors
- At the Xuzhou conference the provincial military governors all signed their names on a piece of yellow satin in favour of restoration; Duan Qirui's side first pretended to agree, then turned round and launched the punitive campaign. [Still unclear] The recollections of Su Xilin, a subordinate of Zhang Xun (Selected Cultural and Historical Materials, vol. 41); Ye Gongchuo, Duan Qirui's head of communications, also said the military governors and politicians feigned approval and toyed with Zhang Xun. All are after-the-fact recollections by people involved; the yellow satin is said to have been bought by Hu Siyuan for 200,000 silver dollars, and the whereabouts of the object are unknown. The Chinese article lists these testimonies without ruling on their credibility; the English article says only that other officials supported the restoration. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- Duan Qirui deliberately let Zhang Xun into the capital. [Still unclear] The recollections of Zeng Yujun, Duan Qirui's confidant: Duan said Zhang Xun's entry into the capital meant he had "fallen into our trap", and Xu Shuzheng said he should first be allowed to go ahead. Again only testimony in the nature of recollection. The Duan Qirui article itself makes no mention at all of his tacitly allowing or exploiting the restoration beforehand, saying only that his dismissal triggered the restoration and that he then sent troops to suppress it. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):段祺瑞]
- Li Yuanhong agreed to hand power back to the Qing house. [Proven false] The claim of the restoration edicts. The English article states plainly that the restoration edicts falsely claimed Li Yuanhong's consent; in fact Li refused to hand over power, took refuge in the Japanese legation, and appointed Feng Guozhang acting president and Duan Qirui premier again to put it down. [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration] [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [維基百科(中文):黎元洪]
- Puyi was seated on the throne at 3 a.m. in the Palace of Heavenly Purity. [Still unclear] The Puyi article. The Zhang Xun Restoration article says he was enthroned in the Hall of Supreme Harmony; the English article says the proclamation was made at 4 a.m. The three accounts differ. [維基百科(中文):溥儀] [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟] [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- The pilot who dropped the bombs on the Forbidden City was Pan Shizhong. [Still unclear] One version listed in the English article. The other version is Qin Guoyong; the English article gives both. That three bombs were dropped and that one eunuch was killed are points on which all the articles agree. [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration] [Wikipedia: Puyi]
- Kang Youwei was poisoned. [Still unclear] Rumour after his sudden death. The article lists several versions, including poisoning and contaminated food, without a settled conclusion. [維基百科(中文):康有為]
Views
- Sun Yat-sen: His judgment on Zhang Xun was that forcing through the restoration was blind loyalty and that the crime of treason deserved death, but that his attachment to his old master was nonetheless pitiable. [維基百科(中文):張勳]
- Zeng Yujun (Duan Qirui's confidant, later recollection): As he recalled it, Duan Qirui said privately that Zhang Xun's coming to Beijing meant he had "fallen into our trap". [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟]
- Reginald Johnston (Puyi's English tutor): In teaching Puyi he maintained that monarchy was superior to a republic and that China needed a benevolent autocrat, and told Puyi that most Chinese hoped for the restoration of the Qing house; at the same time he reported the corruption of the palace eunuchs to the British authorities and recommended that Puyi be moved to the Summer Palace. [Wikipedia: Puyi] [Wikipedia: Reginald Johnston]
- English Wikipedia article "Manchu Restoration": After the restoration failed, the position of the Qing house and the imperial clan became precarious, and the Republic always viewed them with suspicion; Li Yuanhong's fall, meanwhile, let the northern military factions grow in power and left the country more divided. [Wikipedia: Manchu Restoration]
- Chinese Wikipedia article "Zhang Xun Restoration" (張勳復辟): It is generally treated as an episode of the Republic's warlord era and not counted as part of the history of the Qing dynasty. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟]
- Sun Yat-sen: He did not accept that Duan Qirui was the saviour of the republic, criticising this as using one rebel to punish another. [維基百科(中文):護法運動]
- The Inside Story of the Restoration (a pamphlet of the time): Called the participants the "new Thirteen Guardians", and singled out Zhang Zhenfang and Lei Zhenchun as "double monarchist offenders" who had taken part in both the Hongxian monarchy and this restoration. [維基百科(中文):張勳復辟]
- Ouyang Wu (former military commissioner of Jiangxi): He wrote a poem mourning Zhang Xun, using the words "solitary loyalty". [維基百科(中文):張勳]
Photos & videos
Puyi (standing) in 1909 with his father, the regent Zaifeng, and his younger brother: an emperor at three. — 作者不詳 / Public domainThe Qing emperor's edict of abdication, issued on 1912-02-12 (the 25th day of the 12th month of Xuantong 3). — 清遜帝 / Public domain
The young Puyi in the Forbidden City (c. 1917): after his abdication he still lived in the palace as "emperor". — 作者不詳 / Public domain
The "Pigtail General" Zhang Xun: he restored Puyi on 1917-07-01 and 12 days later took refuge in the Dutch legation. — Unknown, photographed in Republic of China / Public domain
Kang Youwei (photographed 1905): he entered Beijing secretly at the end of June 1917 to take part in the restoration and was placed on the wanted list after its failure. — Elmer Chickering / Public domain
Li Yuanhong, President of the Republic of China (1917): he refused to hand over power and took refuge in the Japanese legation. — Putnam Weale, B. L. (Bertram Lenox), 1877-1930 / Public domain
Duan Qirui (photographed 1913): he took his oath at Machang on 3 July to punish the rebels, and afterwards styled himself the man who had "re-created the republic". — 作者不詳 / Public domain
July 1917: acting president Feng Guozhang (front row, eighth from left) with representatives of Nanjing society before leaving for Beijing. — 作者不詳 / Public domain
Troops of the restoration side near the Temple of Heaven in Beijing, 1917; there was an exchange of fire in this area on 12 July. — 作者不詳 / Public domain
1917-07-12: the Army to Punish the Rebels attacking the Imperial City, with soldiers scaling the palace wall (from Putnam Weale's book). — Putnam Weale, B. L. (Bertram Lenox), 1877-1930 / Public domain
The eastern entrance to the Imperial City after the attack by the Army to Punish the Rebels on 1917-07-12 (from Putnam Weale's book). — Putnam Weale, B. L. (Bertram Lenox), 1877-1930 / Public domain
Puyi's bedroom in the Forbidden City after he was expelled from the palace in 1924. — 作者不詳 / Public domain