Emperor Yingzong of Ming (Zhu Qizhen) (Emperor Yingzong of Ming (Zhu Qizhen)) — Ming dynasty (Ming dynasty)
In 1449 Emperor Yingzong, heeding the eunuch Wang Zhen, personally led a campaign against the Oirats; his army was annihilated at Tumu Fortress and he was captured. Yu Qian directed the defence of Beijing, and the court enthroned his younger brother Zhu Qiyu as the Jingtai Emperor, so the emperor in Oirat hands lost his value as a bargaining chip. A year later Yingzong was released; the Jingtai Emperor shut him up in the Southern Palace and stripped his son of the position of crown prince. In 1457, with the Jingtai Emperor gravely ill and without an heir, Shi Heng, Xu Youzhen, Cao Jixiang and others moved first, fetching Yingzong out of the Southern Palace and restoring him. On the sixth day of the restoration Yu Qian and Wang Wen were beheaded in the marketplace; the Jingtai Emperor was demoted to Prince of Cheng and died within a month. But the three leading figures who had restored him came to bad ends as well: Xu Youzhen was banished within half a year, Shi Heng died in prison in 1460, and Cao Jixiang rebelled in 1461 and was executed by slow slicing (lingchi).
How they were ousted
On 1 September 1449 he was captured by the Oirats at Tumu Fortress; on 22 September (the 6th day of the 9th month of Zhengtong 14) the court officials petitioned Empress Dowager Sun and his younger brother Zhu Qiyu, Prince of Cheng, was enthroned (the Jingtai Emperor), while he was honoured from afar as Retired Emperor (Taishang Huang) — replaced while he was not even present. After being released to Beijing in 1450 he was sent straight to the Southern Palace (Nangong) and confined there for seven years.
How they came back
In the small hours of 11 February 1457 (the 17th day of the 1st month of Jingtai 8), taking advantage of the Jingtai Emperor's grave illness, Shi Heng, Xu Youzhen, Cao Jixiang, Zhang Yue and others led troops to break into the Southern Palace, escorted him through the Donghua Gate and into the Fengtian Hall, and restored him to the throne. The episode is known as the “Seizing of the Gate” (Duomen zhi bian).
What happened to the board
The core of those who had enthroned the Jingtai Emperor was almost entirely swept away: Yu Qian and Wang Wen were beheaded and their property confiscated on the sixth day of the restoration (1457-02-16); the Jingtai Emperor himself was demoted to Prince of Cheng on 24 February and died in the Western Palace on 14 March, the Shouling tomb he had built in his lifetime was destroyed, and he was instead buried in the Western Hills with the rites of an imperial prince; the eunuchs Wang Cheng, Shu Liang, Zhang Yong and Wang Qin were put to death; and Fan Guang, a general who had distinguished himself in the defence of Beijing, was killed. The entire Jingtai-era Grand Secretariat was removed — the senior grand secretary Chen Xun was given a hundred strokes of the heavy bamboo and sent into military exile at Tieling, Jiang Yuan and Yu Shiyue were banished to frontier garrisons, Xiao Zi and Shang Lu were struck from the official register and reduced to commoners, and Gao Gu was allowed to retire with gifts of gold and silk; the veteran ministers of the Six Ministries Wang Zhi and Hu Ying retired on grounds of age and were not pursued. Yet “officials of the Jingtai court” did not all suffer: Li Xian, a vice minister of personnel, actually entered the Grand Secretariat and later became senior grand secretary of the Tianshun reign; and Shi Heng, who launched the Seizing of the Gate, was himself a man recommended by Yu Qian and made a marquis under Jingtai. More ironic still, the meritorious officials of the restoration — Xu Youzhen (banished to Jinchi in 1457), Shi Heng (died in prison in 1460) and Cao Jixiang (slow slicing and extermination of his clan in 1461) — all fell within four and a half years, and Yingzong finally ordered that the words “Seizing the Gate” (duomen) were not to be used again.
Timeline
- Enthroned at the age of eight In the 1st month of Xuande 10 Emperor Xuanzong of Ming died and Zhu Qizhen ascended the throne, the following year being designated Zhengtong 1. In the early years Grand Empress Dowager Zhang, together with Yang Shiqi, Yang Rong and Yang Pu, governed on his behalf. [維基百科:明英宗]
- Wang Zhen begins to monopolise power With Grand Empress Dowager Zhang dead and the Three Yangs grown old, the eunuch Wang Zhen, who had attended Yingzong since childhood, took sole control of the government. [維基百科:明英宗] [維基百科:土木堡之變] [維基百科:王振]
- Yingzong leads a campaign against the Oirats in person On the 17th day of the 7th month of Zhengtong 14, disregarding the remonstrances of Minister of Personnel Wang Zhi and others, Yingzong set out with Wang Zhen at the head of an army said to number 500,000, ordering his younger brother the Prince of Cheng to remain in charge of Beijing. The army left two days after the edict was issued, inadequately prepared. [維基百科:土木堡之變] [維基百科:王直 (明朝官員)]
- Empress Dowager Sun orders the Prince of Cheng to act as regent and names a crown prince On the 18th day of the 8th month Empress Dowager Sun ordered the Prince of Cheng to act as regent, and on the 20th she made Yingzong's two-year-old son Zhu Jianshen crown prince. Xu Cheng (Xu Youzhen) proposed moving the capital south and was publicly shouted down by Yu Qian: “Whoever speaks of moving south should be beheaded.” [維基百科:土木堡之變] [維基百科:京師保衛戰] [維基百科:徐有貞]
- The Tumu Crisis: the emperor captured On the 15th day of the 8th month the Ming army was surrounded and routed by the Oirats at Tumu Fortress. More than fifty senior officials, including Zhang Fu, Duke of Ying, and Minister of War Kuang Ye, died in the fighting; Wang Zhen was bludgeoned to death with a hammer by the guards general Fan Zhong; and Yingzong was captured. [維基百科:土木堡之變] [維基百科:明英宗]
- The Prince of Cheng is enthroned as the Jingtai Emperor; Yingzong becomes Retired Emperor On the guiwei day (the 6th) of the 9th month, after the officials had petitioned Empress Dowager Sun, the Prince of Cheng ascended the throne, honoured Yingzong from afar as Retired Emperor, and designated the following year Jingtai 1. From then on the emperor in Oirat hands lost his value as a bargaining chip. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十一〈景帝本紀〉] [維基百科:景泰帝] [維基百科:于謙]
- The Defence of Beijing In the 10th month the Oirats, bringing Yingzong with them, broke through Zijing Pass and advanced on Beijing. Yu Qian drew up 220,000 troops outside the nine gates and himself held the Desheng Gate with Shi Heng and Fan Guang; after a five-day standoff the Oirats withdrew. [維基百科:于謙] [維基百科:京師保衛戰] [維基百科:石亨]
- Yang Shan brings him back; Yingzong enters the Southern Palace In the 8th month of Jingtai 1, Yang Shan went as envoy to the Oirats and persuaded Esen to release him. On the bingxu day of the 8th month (the 15th, about 20 September) Yingzong returned to Beijing; the Jingtai Emperor met him at the Dong'an Gate and at once sent him to the Southern Palace to be confined. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十一〈景帝本紀〉] [維基百科:楊善] [維基百科:明英宗]
- The Golden Knife Case In the 6th–7th months of Jingtai 3, a gilt knife and embroidered pouch that Yingzong had given the eunuch Ruan Lang were made out to be tokens of a plot to regain the throne; Ruan Lang died in the imperial prison and those implicated were executed. The informer Lu Zhong later feigned madness, and only then did the investigation stop. [維基百科:明英宗] [維基百科:商輅]
- The Jingtai Emperor changes the crown prince In the 4th month of Jingtai 3, Crown Prince Zhu Jianshen was demoted to Prince of Yi and the emperor's own son Zhu Jianji was installed; Empress Wang, who objected, was deposed. [維基百科:朱見濟] [維基百科:汪皇后] [維基百科:奪門之變]
- The new crown prince dies young; the position of heir is left vacant Zhu Jianji died young (Wikipedia, following the Veritable Records, gives the 2nd month of Jingtai 4; the basic annals of the History of Ming give the 11th month of the same year). The Jingtai Emperor thereafter consistently refused to reinstate Zhu Jianshen. [維基百科:朱見濟] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十一〈景帝本紀〉]
- Officials who ask for the heir to be restored are imprisoned In the 5th month of Jingtai 5, the censor Zhong Tong and the ministry director Zhang Lun submitted memorials asking that the Prince of Yi be reinstated and that audiences be held with the Retired Emperor, and were imprisoned. Afterwards the trees of the Southern Palace were all cut down. [維基文庫:《明史紀事本末》卷三十五〈南宮復辟〉] [維基百科:奪門之變]
- The victors fall out: Xu Youzhen imprisoned On the jihai day of the 6th month of Tianshun 1, Xu Youzhen and Li Xian, over the affair of the censors' impeachment of Shi Heng and Cao Jixiang, had the charge turned back on them and were sent to the prison of the Embroidered Uniform Guard; the next day they were demoted to provincial posts. In the 7th month Xu Youzhen was imprisoned again, and on the guiwei day of the 7th month he was banished to Jinchi. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:徐有貞] [維基百科:曹石之變]
- Yingzong comes to regret it Chen Ruyan (of Shi Heng's faction), who succeeded Yu Qian as Minister of War, was exposed for corruption in less than a year, his ill-gotten goods piled up like a mountain. Yingzong summoned his ministers to look and said with a dark face: Yu Qian was so heavily relied on under Jingtai, yet when he died there was no surplus wealth in his home — how does Chen Ruyan have so much? Shi Heng lowered his head and could give no answer. [維基文庫:《明史》卷一百七十〈于謙傳〉]
- The Jingtai Emperor falls gravely ill and names no heir On the guihai day of the 12th month of Jingtai 7 the Jingtai Emperor fell ill, and the New Year's Day court audience for the following year was cancelled. The officials asked that an heir be established; he refused. Shang Lu's memorial asking for a descendant of Emperor Xuanzong to be named had not yet been sent in. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十一〈景帝本紀〉] [維基百科:商輅]
- Shi Heng and the others conspire On the night of the 16th day of the 1st month, Shi Heng and Zhang Yue settled the plan with Xu Youzhen: to bring troops into the inner palace on the pretext of a frontier alarm. Before leaving home Xu Youzhen took a final farewell of his family: if it succeeded it would be to the benefit of the dynasty; if it failed it would mean the extermination of the household. [維基文庫:《明史紀事本末》卷三十五〈南宮復辟〉] [維基百科:徐有貞]
- The Seizing of the Gate: Yingzong restored Before dawn on the renwu day (the 17th) of the 1st month, Shi Heng, Zhang Yue, Xu Youzhen, Cao Jixiang and others led troops to break down the wall and enter the Southern Palace, and escorted Yingzong to the Donghua Gate; when the gatekeepers would not open, Yingzong himself called out, “I am the Retired Emperor.” At daybreak, when the officials came to court, they found that the man seated in the hall was Yingzong. That same day Yu Qian and Wang Wen were sent to the prison of the Embroidered Uniform Guard. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:奪門之變] [維基百科:明英宗]
- The era name is changed to Tianshun; titles are awarded for merit On the bingxu day of the 1st month, Jingtai 8 was renamed Tianshun 1. Shi Heng was made Duke of Zhongguo, Zhang Yue Marquis of Taiping, Zhang Ni Earl of Wen'an and Yang Shan Earl of Xingji, and Cao Jixiang's adopted heir Cao Qin was made vice commissioner-in-chief. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉]
- Yu Qian and Wang Wen publicly executed On the dinghai day of the 1st month, Yu Qian and Wang Wen were beheaded on the charge of “plotting to bring in and enthrone the son of the Prince of Xiang”, and their property was confiscated. Yingzong had hesitated, saying that Yu Qian truly had merit; Xu Youzhen said that if Yu Qian were not killed the restoration would have no justification. On the same day Chen Xun, Jiang Yuan and Yu Shiyue were banished to garrisons, and Xiao Zi and Shang Lu were struck from the register. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基文庫:《明史》卷一百七十〈于謙傳〉] [維基百科:于謙]
- The Jingtai Emperor demoted to Prince of Cheng On the yiwei day, the first of the 2nd month, by an edict of Empress Dowager Sun, the Jingtai Emperor was demoted to Prince of Cheng and moved to the Western Inner Palace. Thirteen days separated the restoration from the deposition, during which there were nominally two emperors at once. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十一〈景帝本紀〉] [維基百科:奪門之變]
- Fan Guang killed; Li Xian enters the Grand Secretariat On the guimao day of the 2nd month, Commissioner-in-chief Fan Guang, who had distinguished himself in the defence of Beijing, was killed; on the same day Li Xian, a vice minister of personnel under Jingtai, entered the Grand Secretariat. Gao Gu had retired three days earlier. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:范廣]
- The Prince of Cheng dies in the Western Palace On the guichou day of the 2nd month the Prince of Cheng died, aged thirty, with the posthumous name “Li”; the Shouling tomb was destroyed and he was buried in the Western Hills with the rites of an imperial prince. Noble Consort Tang was buried with him; Yingzong had wanted the deposed Empress Wang to follow him in death as well, but was dissuaded by Li Xian. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十一〈景帝本紀〉] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:景泰帝] [維基文庫:《明史紀事本末》卷三十五〈南宮復辟〉]
- Shi Heng dismissed In the 8th month of Tianshun 3 Shi Biao was imprisoned, and on the gengwu day of the 10th month Shi Heng was dismissed for his offences; at the same time the court allowed those who had falsely claimed merit in the Seizing of the Gate to come forward and have their records corrected. Li Xian explained to Yingzong that the Seizing of the Gate had not been necessary; Yingzong ordered that the words “Seizing the Gate” were not to be used again, and more than four thousand who had falsely claimed merit were stripped of their rewards. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:明英宗] [維基百科:石亨]
- Shi Heng dies in prison On the guimao day of the 1st month of Tianshun 4, Shi Heng was imprisoned and soon died in prison; in the 2nd month Shi Biao was publicly executed. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:石亨]
- The Cao–Shi Rebellion: Cao Qin rises in arms On the gengzi day of the 7th month of Tianshun 5, Cao Jixiang and his adopted heir Cao Qin rebelled, killing Lu Gao, a commander of the Embroidered Uniform Guard, the left censor-in-chief Kou Shen and others; they failed to take the Imperial City and were put down by troops under Sun Tang. On the guimao day (10 August) Cao Jixiang was executed by dismemberment in the marketplace and his clan exterminated. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:曹吉祥] [維基百科:逯杲]
- Yingzong dies; his final edict ends the burial of consorts with the emperor In the 1st month of Tianshun 8 Yingzong died, his final edict abolishing the burial of palace consorts with the deceased emperor. Crown Prince Zhu Jianshen (the one deposed years before by the Jingtai Emperor) ascended the throne as Emperor Xianzong. [維基百科:明英宗] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉]
- Xianzong rehabilitates Yu Qian In Chenghua 1 a censor submitted a memorial protesting the injustice; Xianzong said that as crown prince he had often heard that Yu Qian had been wronged. Yu Qian's son Yu Mian was pardoned and allowed to return, and Yu Qian's office was restored and sacrifices granted. In the same year the titles obtained through the Seizing of the Gate by Zhang Yue's son and others were revoked. [維基百科:于謙] [維基文庫:《明史》卷一百七十〈于謙傳〉] [維基百科:張軏 (太平侯)]
- Xianzong restores the Jingtai Emperor's imperial title In Chenghua 11, Xianzong restored his uncle's status as emperor with the posthumous title “Gongren Kangding Jing Emperor”, and the tomb of the Prince of Cheng was enlarged into an imperial mausoleum (the Jingtai Mausoleum). [維基百科:景泰陵] [維基百科:景泰帝]
People
- Emperor Yingzong of Ming (Zhu Qizhen) (Zhu Qizhen (Emperor Yingzong of Ming)), 1427-11-29 — Emperor of the Ming (the Zhengtong Emperor) → Retired Emperor (1449–1457) → restored as the Tianshun Emperor. Eldest son of Emperor Xuanzong of Ming; his mother was Empress Sun. He came to the throne in 1435 at the age of eight (by Chinese reckoning); in the early years Grand Empress Dowager Zhang and the “Three Yangs” governed on his behalf; after 1442 the eunuch Wang Zhen monopolised power. In 1449 he personally led a campaign against the Oirats and was captured at Tumu Fortress. Succeeded as crown prince in the 1st month of Xuande 10 (1435), with the era name Zhengtong. The Jingtai Emperor Zhu Qiyu was his half-brother; Empress Dowager Sun was his birth mother; Wang Zhen was the eunuch who had attended him since childhood; Yuan Bin and Ha Ming were the men who stayed with him through his captivity. After his restoration in 1457 he changed the era name to Tianshun, dealt in turn with Xu Youzhen, Shi Heng and Cao Jixiang, and relied on Li Xian. He died on 23 February 1464 and was buried at Yuling; his deathbed edict abolished the practice of burying palace consorts with the deceased emperor. [維基百科:明英宗] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉]
- The Jingtai Emperor, Zhu Qiyu (Emperor Daizong of Ming) (Zhu Qiyu (Jingtai Emperor)), 1428-09-21 — Prince of Cheng → regent → emperor (enthroned 1449-09-22). Second son of Emperor Xuanzong of Ming; his mother was Worthy Consort Wu. He was made Prince of Cheng after Yingzong's accession. When Yingzong went on campaign he was ordered to remain in charge of Beijing. After the Tumu Crisis, Empress Dowager Sun first ordered him to act as regent (the 18th day of the 8th month); on the 6th day of the 9th month, at the petition of the court officials, he ascended the throne, and the following year was designated Jingtai 1. Yingzong's half-brother. After his accession he relied heavily on Yu Qian, who held Beijing, but when Yingzong returned he shut him up in the Southern Palace, and he also stripped his nephew Zhu Jianshen of the position of crown prince in favour of his own son. On 24 February 1457 (the yiwei day, the first of the 2nd month) he was demoted to Prince of Cheng and moved to the Western Inner Palace (Xinei); on 14 March (the guichou day) he died in the Western Palace, aged thirty, with the posthumous name “Li” (“the Perverse”). The Shouling tomb was destroyed and he was buried in the Western Hills with the rites of an imperial prince; Noble Consort Tang was forced to die and be buried with him. In the Chenghua era Emperor Xianzong restored his imperial title. [維基百科:景泰帝] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十一〈景帝本紀〉] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:景泰陵]
- Yu Qian (Yu Qian), 1398 — Minister of War and Junior Guardian (in charge of military affairs under Jingtai). A native of Qiantang, Zhejiang; jinshi of Yongle 19. During the Xuande era he served for nearly twenty years as grand coordinator of Henan and Shanxi with the rank of right vice minister of war, and was once imprisoned for offending Wang Zhen. In 1448 he came to the capital as left vice minister of war. Remained in charge of the Ministry of War when Yingzong went on campaign; after the Tumu Crisis he was promoted to Minister of War, shouted down the proposal to move the capital south, and directed the Defence of Beijing. When the officials asked the Prince of Cheng to take the throne and the prince declined again and again, it was Yu Qian who spoke up: “We act for the state, not for private interest.” Shi Heng and Fan Guang were both generals he had recommended. He had publicly rebuked Xu Cheng (Xu Youzhen) for advocating the move south, and he refused Shi Heng's request for a reward for Yu's own son; both men bore him a grudge for it. Imprisoned on the day of the restoration (11 February), falsely accused of “plotting to bring in and enthrone the son of the Prince of Xiang”, and convicted of treason; on 16 February (the dinghai day of the 1st month) he was publicly executed and his property confiscated, and his family were sent to frontier garrisons. When his home was searched there was no surplus wealth in it. He was rehabilitated at the start of the Chenghua era, given the posthumous name Sumin in Hongzhi 2, and this was changed to Zhongsu in the Wanli era. [維基百科:于謙] [維基文庫:《明史》卷一百七十〈于謙傳〉] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉]
- Wang Wen (Wang Wen), 1393 — Junior Guardian, Minister of Personnel and Grand Secretary of the Jinshen Hall (grand secretary under Jingtai). A native of Shulu in Zhili, originally named Wang Qiang; jinshi of Yongle 19. He served successively as surveillance commissioner of Shaanxi, chief minister of the Court of Judicial Review, and left censor-in-chief. Summoned to the capital after the Tumu Crisis to head the Censorate; in Jingtai 3, on Gao Gu's recommendation and with the help of the eunuch Wang Cheng, he entered the Grand Secretariat — the first time a minister of the second rank had done so. When word came that the Oirats would release Yingzong and the officials were discussing the rites of welcome, he demanded sharply, “Can the Retired Emperor really come back?”, and no one dared discuss it further. Together with Yu Qian he was accused of plotting to enthrone a prince from an outlying fief. Imprisoned together with Yu Qian on the day of the restoration. He argued his innocence vigorously; Yu Qian laughed and said this was what Shi Heng and the others wanted, and arguing was useless. On 16 February he was beheaded in the marketplace with Yu Qian and his property confiscated. [維基百科:王文 (永樂進士)] [維基文庫:《明史》卷一百七十〈于謙傳〉] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉]
- Chen Xun (Chen Xun), 1385 — Junior Guardian, Minister of Revenue and Grand Secretary of the Huagai Hall (senior grand secretary under Jingtai). A native of Taihe, Jiangxi; zhuangyuan (top graduate of the palace examination) of Yongle 13; entered the Wenyuan Pavilion in Zhengtong 9. Entered the Grand Secretariat in Zhengtong 9 (1444); after the Tumu Crisis he supported Yu Qian in holding Beijing, was valued by the Jingtai Emperor, and rose to Grand Secretary of the Huagai Hall. One of the grand secretaries rewarded before the Jingtai Emperor changed the heir; Xu Youzhen once curried favour with him by presenting a jade belt, and he repeatedly recommended Xu Youzhen and even advised him to change his name. After Yingzong's restoration he was implicated in the Yu Qian case, given a hundred strokes of the heavy bamboo and sent into military exile at the Tieling Guard. In 1461, after the false accusations of Shi Heng and the others were exposed, he was released as a commoner; he died of illness a year later (1462) and was subsequently rehabilitated. [維基百科:陳循] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:奪門之變]
- Shang Lu (Shang Lu), 1414-03-16 — Left Vice Minister of War and Grand Secretary of the Left Secretariat of the Heir Apparent (grand secretary under Jingtai). A native of Chun'an, Zhejiang; he placed first in the provincial, metropolitan and palace examinations alike — the “triple first” (sanyuan jidi; zhuangyuan of Zhengtong 10). After the Tumu Crisis he entered the Grand Secretariat to take part in confidential affairs on the recommendation of Chen Xun and Gao Gu; in 1450 he was sent to Juyong Pass to welcome the Retired Emperor. During the Golden Knife Case he advised that the informer Lu Zhong was not to be believed, which brought the investigation to a halt; when the Jingtai Emperor was gravely ill he drafted a memorial asking that “a descendant of Emperor Xuanzong, the Zhang Emperor” be made heir, but before the memorial could be sent in, Yingzong was restored that very night. Summoned on the day of the restoration to draft the restoration edict; because he refused Shi Heng's private request to add clauses, he was impeached by the remonstrance officials and imprisoned, and after the eunuch Xing'an explained on his behalf he was struck from the official register and reduced to a commoner. In Chenghua 3 (1467) Emperor Xianzong recalled him to the Grand Secretariat; he died in 1486 — the only Jingtai-era grand secretary to make a comeback. [維基百科:商輅] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉]
- Gao Gu (Gao Gu), 1391 — Junior Guardian and Grand Secretary of the Jinshen Hall (grand secretary under Jingtai). A native of Xinghua in Zhili; jinshi of Yongle 13; served under five reigns. Entered the Grand Secretariat in Zhengtong 10 (1445); rose to Grand Secretary of the Jinshen Hall during the Jingtai era. Jointly recommended Shang Lu for the Grand Secretariat with Chen Xun, and also recommended Wang Wen; he too was rewarded before the change of heir. Not punished: after Yingzong's restoration he was granted gold and silk and allowed to retire (the History of Ming places this on the gengzi day of the 2nd month, about 1 March 1457). He died in the 1st month of 1460 and was posthumously made Grand Guardian at the start of the Chenghua era. [維基百科:高穀] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉]
- Fan Guang (Fan Guang) — Vice commissioner-in-chief and deputy regional commander of the capital garrisons. A native of Liaodong and hereditary assistant commander of the Ningyuan Guard. After the Tumu Crisis he was made deputy regional commander on Yu Qian's recommendation; in the Defence of Beijing he was first to charge into the enemy lines and pursued the Oirats as far as Zijing Pass. Recommended by Yu Qian; assisted Shi Heng in commanding the integrated divisions (tuanying). Slandered by Shi Heng for criticising the greed and licence of Shi Heng's subordinates; he was also on bad terms with Zhang Yue. After Yingzong's restoration he was falsely accused by Shi Heng of being a partisan of Yu Qian and of plotting to enthrone a prince from an outlying fief, and was put to death (the History of Ming places this on the guimao day of the 2nd month, about 4 March 1457); his son was sent to a garrison in Guangxi, and his wife, children and residence were given to surrendered soldiers. He was rehabilitated at the start of the Chenghua era. [維基百科:范廣] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉]
- Wang Zhi (Wang Zhi), 1379 — Minister of Personnel and Grand Guardian of the Heir Apparent. A native of Taihe, Jiangxi; jinshi of Yongle 2. He spent more than twenty years in the Hanlin Academy and became Minister of Personnel in Zhengtong 8. Before Yingzong's campaign he led the officials in strenuous remonstrance and was left behind in charge at Beijing; he continued as Minister of Personnel under Jingtai, considered himself not the equal of Yu Qian, and deferred to him in everything. In 1450 he pressed hard for an envoy to be sent to bring Yingzong back, saying bluntly, “One must be sent; do not leave cause for regret,” which displeased the Jingtai Emperor. After Yingzong's restoration he retired on grounds of age and was not pursued. In his later years he himself said: had I entered the Grand Secretariat back then, I would certainly not have escaped being banished to Liaoyang after His Majesty's restoration. He died in 1462, aged eighty-four. [維基百科:王直 (明朝官員)]
- Shi Heng (Shi Heng) — Marquis of Wuqing and regional commander in charge of the integrated divisions (tuanying). A native of Weinan, Shaanxi; he inherited his father's post as assistant commander of the Kuanhe Guard and was skilled at mounted archery. In 1449 he was defeated at Yanghekou, fled back alone on horseback, and was demoted. While the Prince of Cheng was regent he was brought back on Yu Qian's recommendation to command the Five Armies Division; in the Defence of Beijing he won merit holding the Desheng Gate and was made Marquis of Wuqing. He was a man raised up by Yu Qian's own hand, yet the two fell out when he requested a reward for Yu Qian's son and Yu Qian rebuked him for favouritism. When the Jingtai Emperor was gravely ill he received orders at the bedside, saw that the emperor would not last, and turned to plot with Zhang Yue and Cao Jixiang to bring in and enthrone Yingzong. Credited with the foremost merit in the Seizing of the Gate, he was promoted to Duke of Zhongguo, and more than four thousand of his relatives and associates obtained office by falsely claiming merit. Thereafter he interfered in government to excess: in 1459 his nephew Shi Biao was imprisoned, and in the 10th month of the same year he was dismissed; in the 1st month of 1460 (the guimao day of the 1st month of Tianshun 4) he was imprisoned and soon died in prison, Shi Biao was publicly executed, and the family property was confiscated. [維基百科:石亨] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:曹石之變]
- Xu Youzhen (originally named Xu Cheng) (Xu Youzhen), 1407 — Left vice censor-in-chief. A native of Wu County in Southern Zhili; jinshi of Xuande 8. He was versed in astronomy, water conservancy and the art of war; during the Jingtai era he won merit by repairing the breach of the Yellow River at Shawan. After the Tumu Crisis he was publicly shouted down by Yu Qian for proposing a move south and was mocked by the court officials; for a long time he could not gain promotion, and only after changing his name to Xu Youzhen did he make his mark through river control. When Shi Heng and Zhang Yue were ready to act, Xu Bin, chief minister of the Court of Imperial Sacrifices, recommended him as the man to devise a plan; that night's operation (bringing troops into the inner palace on the pretext of a frontier alarm) was of his planning. He had long nursed a grudge against Yu Qian. He entered the Grand Secretariat on the day of the restoration and was later made Earl of Wugong and put in charge of the Wenyuan Pavilion; it was his remark “If Yu Qian is not killed, this undertaking has no justification” that made up Yingzong's mind. But within half a year he had fallen out with Shi Heng and Cao Jixiang: in the 6th month of 1457 he was imprisoned and demoted to Guangdong, in the 7th month he was imprisoned again, and on the guiwei day of the 7th month he was banished as a commoner to Jinchi in Yunnan. After the fall of Cao and Shi he was released and returned home; he died in 1472. [維基百科:徐有貞] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基文庫:《明史》卷一百七十〈于謙傳〉]
- Cao Jixiang (Cao Jixiang) — Eunuch; after the restoration promoted to eunuch of the Directorate of Ceremonial and supreme commander of the Three Great Divisions. A native of Luanzhou in Yongping; in his early years he came up under Wang Zhen, and he served as army supervisor in the Luchuan campaigns, the expedition against the Uriyangkhai and other wars. During the Jingtai era he shared charge of military affairs with Yu Qian; the Mingshi Jishi Benmo says Yu Qian's authority overshadowed his, and that for this reason the whole pack of petty men hated Yu Qian. Conspired with Shi Heng, Xu Youzhen and Zhang Yue in the Seizing of the Gate; his adopted heir Cao Qin was made Earl of Zhaowu on that account. After Shi Heng's fall he feared for himself and secretly kept a band of men sworn to die for him. On 7 August 1461 (the gengzi day of the 7th month of Tianshun 5) Cao Qin rose in arms, failed in his attack on the Imperial City and died by throwing himself into a well; three days later (the guimao day) Cao Jixiang was executed by dismemberment in the marketplace and his clan exterminated. [維基百科:曹吉祥] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:曹石之變] [維基文庫:《明史紀事本末》卷三十五〈南宮復辟〉]
- Zhang Yue (Zhang Yue), 1393 — Commissioner-in-chief, in overall command of the capital garrison troops. A native of Xiangfu, Henan; third son of Zhang Yu. He had served in the campaigns against Luchuan and in Guizhou. Rose by accumulated merit to commissioner-in-chief of the Front Army and overall command of the capital garrison troops; in Jingtai 2 he was imprisoned for being “arrogant, licentious and lawless”, and released soon afterwards. Brought in Yingzong together with Shi Heng and Cao Jixiang; on bad terms with Fan Guang. Made Marquis of Taiping; the History of Ming records that he worked behind the scenes in the deaths of Yu Qian, Wang Wen and Fan Guang, and that in taking bribes and corrupting government he was second only to Shi Heng. He died of illness in 1458 — a natural death, as these things went; but the title inherited by his son Zhang Jin was revoked by Emperor Xianzong in 1465. [維基百科:張軏 (太平侯)] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉] [維基百科:奪門之變]
- Yang Shan (Yang Shan) — Left censor-in-chief, concurrently in charge of the Court of State Ceremonial. A native of Daxing in Northern Zhili, with only the lowest (xiucai) degree; he served as a ritual official during the Yongle era and was known for his eloquence. He was with the army at the Tumu Crisis and escaped back to Beijing. Sent as envoy to the Oirats in 1450; the Jingtai Emperor's edict contained no words about bringing Yingzong back, so he paid for the gifts out of his own pocket and persuaded Esen to release him. The man who brought Yingzong back, and also one who took part in the Seizing of the Gate seven years later. After the Seizing of the Gate he was made Earl of Xingji and concurrently Minister of Rites. He died in 1458 and was posthumously made Marquis of Xingji; the title inherited by his son was revoked early in Xianzong's reign. [維基百科:楊善] [維基百科:奪門之變] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉]
- Empress Dowager Sun (Empress Xiaogongzhang) (Empress Dowager Sun) — Empress dowager (Yingzong's birth mother). Empress of Emperor Xuanzong of Ming and birth mother of Yingzong. Took charge in the emergency after the Tumu Crisis: on the 18th day of the 8th month she ordered the Prince of Cheng to act as regent, and on the 20th she made Yingzong's son Zhu Jianshen crown prince; in the 9th month she granted the officials' petition that the Prince of Cheng take the throne. The enthronement of the Jingtai Emperor had her assent, but on condition that the crown prince remained Yingzong's son. After Yingzong's restoration, the edict demoting the Jingtai Emperor to Prince of Cheng was issued in her name. After Yingzong's restoration she was given the honorific title “Empress Dowager Shenglie Cishou”, and her natal family also benefited from the Seizing of the Gate. She died in 1462 (the 9th month of Tianshun 6). The History of Ming says she did not at first know that Yu Qian had been killed, and sighed for several days on hearing of it. [維基百科:孝恭章皇后(孫太后)] [維基文庫:《明史》卷一百七十〈于謙傳〉] [維基百科:景泰帝]
- Li Xian (Li Xian), 1408 — Right Vice Minister of Personnel (under Jingtai) → senior grand secretary of the Tianshun reign. A native of Dengzhou, Henan; jinshi of Xuande 8. He accompanied Yingzong on the northern campaign and escaped back to court at the Tumu Crisis. In Jingtai 2 a memorial of his won favour, and he served successively as vice minister of war, of revenue and of personnel. An official of the Jingtai court, yet he entered the Grand Secretariat after Yingzong's restoration (March 1457); at one point he was squeezed out and imprisoned by Shi Heng and Cao Jixiang, but was soon reinstated. Retained and promoted: he became the most trusted grand secretary of the Tianshun reign. It was he who pointed out to Yingzong that “the Jingtai Emperor had no son; the throne would have been yours sooner or later, and there was no need at all to seize the gate”, whereupon Yingzong distanced himself from the Seizing-the-Gate officials and stripped those who had falsely claimed merit. He died in 1466. [維基百科:李賢 (大學士)] [維基百科:明英宗] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉]
Moves to block a return
- The Oirats were willing to release him, but the Jingtai Emperor did not want him back: he told his ministers, “It was you who wanted to enthrone me in the first place,” his edict to the Oirats contained no words about welcoming him home, and he forbade his ministers to send clothing to Yingzong. The envoy Yang Shan sold his own family property to buy gifts and brought the man back by force of eloquence. The welcoming ceremonial drafted by the Ministry of Rites was cut down by the Jingtai Emperor to just “one sedan chair and two horses” to meet him at Juyong Pass. [維基百科:楊善] [維基百科:胡濙] [維基百科:奪門之變]
- As soon as Yingzong returned to Beijing (the bingxu day of the 8th month of Jingtai 1, about 20 September 1450), the Jingtai Emperor met him briefly at the Dong'an Gate and then sent him to the Southern Palace (Chongzhi Palace) under house arrest, guarded by the Embroidered Uniform Guard (Jinyiwei); thereafter even audiences with the officials were not allowed. The History of Ming (Mingshi) describes it as “deeply locked away in the Southern Palace, audiences not permitted”. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十一〈景帝本紀〉] [維基百科:明英宗] [維基百科:景泰帝]
- In the 4th month of Jingtai 3, the Jingtai Emperor stripped Yingzong's eldest son Zhu Jianshen of the position of crown prince, re-enfeoffing him as Prince of Yi, and installed his own only son Zhu Jianji as crown prince. Beforehand he rewarded grand secretaries including Chen Xun, Gao Gu, Shang Lu, Jiang Yuan and Xiao Zi to secure their support; Empress Wang objected and was deposed. After Zhu Jianji died young the following year, the Jingtai Emperor still refused to reinstate Zhu Jianshen, and the position of heir remained vacant. [維基百科:奪門之變] [維基百科:朱見濟] [維基百科:汪皇后]
- The Golden Knife Case (6th–7th months of Jingtai 3): in the Southern Palace Yingzong gave the eunuch Ruan Lang a gilt knife and an embroidered pouch, which, after passing through other hands, were denounced by Lu Zhong, a commander of the Embroidered Uniform Guard, and the eunuch Gao Ping as tokens by which Yingzong was contacting the outer court to plot his restoration. Ruan Lang was sent to the imperial prison and died under interrogation by torture, and Wang Yao (the given name is also written with a different character), who was implicated, was executed; neither of them implicated Yingzong, and only then did the case come to a halt. [維基百科:明英宗] [維基百科:奪門之變] [維基百科:商輅]
- Around Jingtai 5–6 (the Mingshi Jishi Benmo places it after the 5th month of Jingtai 5): the supervising secretary Xu Zheng submitted a secret memorial proposing that the Prince of Yi be moved to the provinces, the walls of the Southern Palace raised, the large trees by the walls cut down and the lock on the palace gate filled with molten iron; the Jingtai Emperor was furious and banished him to the garrison at Tieling. But the censor Gao Ping then said that the Southern Palace had many trees and that the unforeseen was hard to guard against, and the trees really were all felled — it was the height of summer, Yingzong was accustomed to resting in their shade, and on learning the reason he was greatly afraid. [維基文庫:《明史紀事本末》卷三十五〈南宮復辟〉]
- In the 5th month of Jingtai 5, the censor Zhong Tong and Zhang Lun, a director in the Ministry of Rites, submitted memorials asking that the Prince of Yi be reinstated as crown prince and that the emperor lead the officials in regular audiences with the Retired Emperor; both were imprisoned. Zhong Tong was later beaten to death with the bamboo, Zhang Lun was kept in custody, and Liao Zhuang and others were likewise flogged at court and demoted over the “proposal to restore the heir”. [維基文庫:《明史紀事本末》卷三十五〈南宮復辟〉] [維基百科:奪門之變] [維基百科:商輅]
Rumors
- The gate of the Southern Palace was locked and the lock filled with molten lead, and food could only be passed in through a small hole. [Still unclear] The version current in later times (the Wikipedia articles on the Seizing of the Gate and the Jingtai Emperor both adopt it) The Mingshi Jishi Benmo records it differently: “the lock of the palace gate should be filled with iron” was a proposal in a secret memorial by the supervising secretary Xu Zheng, and the Jingtai Emperor, angered on hearing it, banished him to a garrison; what was actually carried out was the felling of the trees. The confinement and the guard by the Embroidered Uniform Guard are certain, but on whether the lock was really filled with lead the two accounts do not agree. [維基文庫:《明史紀事本末》卷三十五〈南宮復辟〉] [維基百科:奪門之變] [維基百科:景泰帝]
- Yingzong used a gilt knife and an embroidered pouch as tokens to contact the outer court in secret and plot his restoration. [Proven false] Denounced by Lu Zhong, a commander of the Embroidered Uniform Guard, and the eunuch Gao Ping Those involved denied it to the death; afterwards Lu Zhong had his fortune told and was so frightened that he feigned madness, and Shang Lu and the eunuch Wang Cheng memorialised that the words of a madman were not to be believed. After his restoration Yingzong conferred posthumous honours on Ruan Lang and set up a stele clearing his name, and Gao Ping and Lu Zhong were executed by slow slicing for framing him. [維基百科:明英宗] [維基百科:商輅]
- Yu Qian and Wang Wen plotted with the eunuchs Wang Cheng, Shu Liang and others to bring in the son of the Prince of Xiang to succeed to the throne (the so-called “summoning the Prince of Xiang with the golden tablet”). [Proven false] Shi Heng, Xu Youzhen and others prompted the remonstrance officials to memorialise; the censor-in-chief Xiao Weizhen determined the verdict The History of Ming flatly writes “falsely accused”; under interrogation Yu Qian said this was what Shi Heng and the others wanted and that arguing was useless. After the fall of Shi Heng and Cao Jixiang the truth came out, and at the start of the Chenghua era Xianzong issued an edict rehabilitating him, the patent stating that he had been “jointly envied by powerful villains”. [維基文庫:《明史》卷一百七十〈于謙傳〉] [維基百科:于謙]
- Yu Qian held military power and in fact knew of the Seizing-the-Gate plot beforehand, yet did not stop it. [Still unclear] A conjecture in the late-Ming Guoque by Tan Qian Tan Qian said: Yu Qian paid the closest attention to military matters and had eyes and ears everywhere; had he known nothing at all, how would he have been fit to be Minister of War? Perhaps in the rush of events there was no time to react. This is only a later writer's inference, with no direct source behind it. [維基百科:奪門之變]
- The Seizing of the Gate had Empress Dowager Sun's prior consent, and she even issued an edict in support of it. [Still unclear] A claim cited in the Wikipedia article on Empress Xiaogongzhang That article says Shi Heng and the others obtained the empress dowager's edict in advance and arrested Yu Qian on its authority; but the biography of Yu Qian in the History of Ming records that “the empress dowager did not at first know of Qian's death” and lamented for days on hearing of it. The sources do not agree on how much the empress dowager knew beforehand. [維基百科:孝恭章皇后(孫太后)] [維基文庫:《明史》卷一百七十〈于謙傳〉]
- The Jingtai Emperor did not die of illness but was murdered after his deposition. [Still unclear] Gu Yingtai's early-Qing Mingshi Jishi Benmo: the histories give no clear record of the time of his death, and “with the shadow of the candle and the sound of the axe, the case is not free from doubt” The History of Ming records only that “the prince died in the Western Palace, aged thirty”, with no cause of death; before the coup he was indeed already too ill to hold court. Gu Yingtai merely raised a doubt and had no evidence, and the question remains unresolved to this day. [維基文庫:《明史紀事本末》卷三十五〈南宮復辟〉] [維基文庫:《明史》卷十一〈景帝本紀〉]
Views
- Appraisal appended to the biography of Yu Qian, History of Ming (official history compiled under the Qing): Yu Qian cared for the state and forgot his own household; the safety of the realm hung on him, and his merit was very great. When the calamity of the Seizing of the Gate broke out suddenly, Xu Youzhen, Shi Heng and their gang joined forces to drive him to his death, and at the time everyone cried out at the injustice. And those three in a short while met disaster one after another — public judgement takes a long time to settle. [維基文庫:《明史》卷一百七十〈于謙傳〉]
- Appraisal appended to the basic annals of Emperor Jing, History of Ming (official history compiled under the Qing): He accepted the throne amid chaos and steadied people's minds; a powerful enemy struck deep and yet the dynasty stood secure, so that he has the merit of having refounded it. But he was in haste to change the crown prince and kept his elder brother locked deep in the Southern Palace with no audiences allowed, with no trace of fraternal feeling, and in the end let petty men strike while he was ill, so that he did not come to a good end — a pity. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十一〈景帝本紀〉]
- Appraisal appended to the basic annals of Emperor Yingzong, History of Ming (official history compiled under the Qing): He inherited the flourishing age of the Renzong and Xuanzong reigns, yet was captured because Wang Zhen usurped power and provoked a war; after his restoration he still could not put Wang Zhen out of his mind, which was truly muddle-headed. In neither period of his reign was there any very bad governance, and the release of the “Commoner of Jian” (Jian shuren) and the abolition of the burial of palace consorts with the emperor were acts of virtue fit to be a model for later ages. [維基文庫:《明史》卷十二〈英宗後紀〉]
- Gu Yingtai (early-Qing historian, author of the Mingshi Jishi Benmo): When the Jingtai Emperor lay critically ill the officials could have asked Yingzong to resume the throne in the regular way, yet it was turned into a frantic midnight grab for the throne; the two words “Seizing the Gate” meant that Yingzong came by the throne improperly and the Jingtai Emperor did not come to a good end, leaving both brothers the poorer. [維基文庫:《明史紀事本末》卷三十五〈南宮復辟〉]
- Zhao Yi and Luo Dongyang (contemporary Ming historians, authors of a biography of Emperor Yingzong of Ming): Apart from changing the crown prince and deposing Empress Wang, two acts that were unpopular, the Jingtai Emperor took the throne in a time of peril and cleared up the mess Yingzong had left behind; by the standards of the time he can be called a ruler who refounded the Ming. [維基百科:景泰帝]
- Wu Jin, Marquis of Gongshun (a military official in attendance on Yingzong): When news of a frontier alarm arrived and Yingzong's face was full of worry, Wu Jin, at his side, said: if Yu Qian were still here, he would not have let the enemy go so far. Yingzong had nothing to say in reply. [維基文庫:《明史》卷一百七十〈于謙傳〉]
- Li Xian (senior grand secretary of the Tianshun reign): The Jingtai Emperor had no son, and Empress Dowager Sun, who had placed Yingzong on the throne, was still alive; the throne would sooner or later have returned to Yingzong, and there was no need whatever to “seize” it. The Seizing of the Gate was merely a show put on by a group of men seeking promotion and riches for themselves, and had it failed it would instead have dragged Yingzong down with it. [維基百科:明英宗] [維基百科:奪門之變]
- Emperor Xianzong of Ming, Zhu Jianshen (Yingzong's son, the crown prince once deposed by the Jingtai Emperor): He said that while in the Eastern Palace as crown prince he had often heard that Yu Qian had been wronged, and that Yu Qian truly had the merit of securing the dynasty yet died a cruel and innocent death. When some ministers wanted to rake over the old account of the depositions and installations of the Jingtai years, he said those things were in the past, that he did not mind them, and that they were not something for his subjects to raise. [維基百科:于謙] [維基百科:明憲宗]
Photos & videos
Seated portrait of Emperor Yingzong of Ming, Zhu Qizhen, in the collection of the National Palace Museum (painted by court artists). — 國立故宮博物院 / CC0
Portrait of the Jingtai Emperor, Zhu Qiyu. After his elder brother demoted him to Prince of Cheng, his imperial title was not restored until the Chenghua era. — Unknown author / Public domain
Portrait of Yu Qian. The Minister of War who directed the Defence of Beijing, beheaded on the sixth day of Yingzong's restoration. — Unknown artist / Public domain
Schematic map of the Tumu Crisis: the route of Yingzong's campaign in 1449 and the place of his capture. — SY / CC BY-SA 4.0
The Jingtai Mausoleum at Jinshankou in the western suburbs of Beijing. After his death the Jingtai Emperor was buried here with the rites of an imperial prince; the Shouling tomb he had built in his lifetime was destroyed. — 爱上甜食的猫 / CC BY-SA 4.0
The stele of the Jingtai Mausoleum. The site was originally the tomb of the Prince of Cheng and was enlarged into an imperial mausoleum only after his title was restored in the Chenghua era; in the Qianlong reign of the Qing a stele was also erected in front of it. — Charlie fong / CC BY-SA 4.0
Yuling, one of the Thirteen Ming Tombs, where Emperor Yingzong of Ming is buried; because his final edict abolished the practice, this is the first Ming imperial tomb with no palace consorts buried alongside the emperor. — Charlie fong / CC BY-SA 4.0
The tomb of Yu Qian in Hangzhou in 1911. Yu Qian's remains were returned to Hangzhou for burial the year after his death, and in Hongzhi 2 the “Jinggong Shrine” (Shrine of Manifest Merit) was built beside the tomb. — 杭州二我轩照相馆 / Public domain
Yu Qian Shrine. After his rehabilitation in the Chenghua era, Yu Qian's former residence in Beijing was converted into a shrine, and a memorial shrine was also built beside his tomb in Hangzhou. — DarthVachel / CC BY-SA 3.0
Zhihua Temple in Beijing, built by the eunuch Wang Zhen. After his restoration Yingzong even set up a “Jingzhong Shrine” (Shrine of Manifest Loyalty) to Wang Zhen within the temple. — Antigng / CC BY-SA 4.0
Portrait of Yingzong's Empress Qian. While Yingzong was a captive she wept day and night, losing the sight of one eye and becoming lame in one leg. — Unknown / Public domain