Emperor Hui of Jin, Sima Zhong (Emperor Hui of Jin (Sima Zhong)) — Jin dynasty (Western Jin) (Jin dynasty (Western Jin))
Emperor Hui of Jin, Sima Zhong, was regarded from childhood as unfit to govern, and after his accession power fell first to Empress Jia and then to Sima Lun, Prince of Zhao. In 300 Sima Lun killed Empress Jia and made himself chancellor (xiangguo); in the first month of 301 he simply usurped the throne, shut Emperor Hui in the Jinyong Fortress and also killed the imperial grandson-heir. But he and his chief strategist Sun Xiu handed out offices and titles indiscriminately ("not enough sable, so dog tails are added") and had no popular support; as soon as three princes with armies in the provinces rose, people inside Luoyang changed sides. After Emperor Hui was restored, Sima Lun was made to drink wine laced with gold fragments and died, all four of his sons were executed, Sun Xiu's faction were beheaded or killed themselves, and every official Sima Lun had appointed was dismissed. What was restored, however, was not real power: Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, who had brought him back, immediately became the new dictator, the War of the Eight Princes escalated into full-scale civil war, and Emperor Hui was held hostage by one prince after another for five more years.
How they were ousted
On 3 February 301 (yichou day of the first month, Yongning 1), his great-uncle Sima Lun, Prince of Zhao, sent men who pried his fingers open and took the imperial seal and ribbon, forged an edict of abdication, and ascended the Taiji Hall to proclaim himself emperor; the next day he sent him to the Jinyong Fortress, gave him the title "Retired Emperor" (Taishang Huang), and posted troops to guard him.
How they came back
Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, Sima Ying, Prince of Chengdu, and Sima Yong, Prince of Hejian, raised armies against him, and Sima Lun's forces collapsed north of the Yellow River; on 30 May 301 (xinyou day of the fourth month), Wang Yu, General of the Left Guard, and Sima Cui, Prince of Huailing, both inside Luoyang, led troops into the palace, killed Sun Xiu, and forced Sima Lun to issue an edict welcoming him back to the throne. Several thousand armoured soldiers escorted him from the Jinyong Fortress back to the palace that same day. He had been deposed for less than four months.
What happened to the board
The usurping clique was uprooted within a week. Sima Lun himself was made to drink gold-fragment wine and died on the seventh day after the restoration (5 June 301); before dying he covered his face with a cloth and repeated "Sun Xiu misled me". His four sons, Sima Fu (荂), Fu (馥), Qian and Xu, were all handed to the Minister of Justice (tingwei) and executed. The chief strategist Sun Xiu, together with Xu Chao and Shi Yi, was beheaded on the day of the coup; Sun Xiu's son Sun Hui and his associates Sun Bi, Xie Dan and Luo Xiu were killed in the palace. Zhang Heng (the man in charge of guarding the Jinyong Fortress), Lü He, Sun Mao and Fu Yin, back from the front, were beheaded in the East Market, and Cai Huang killed himself. Zhang Lin had already been killed during the usurpation in an internal feud with Sun Xiu, with his clan exterminated to the third degree. As for Sima Wei, Prince of Yiyang, who had seized the seal, Emperor Hui named him personally, saying "A-Pi pried my fingers open and snatched my seal and ribbon; he must be killed", and he was executed in the fifth month. Sun Xiu's kinsman Sun Qi was beheaded at Xiangyang. The "Book of Jin" (Jin shu) says "all officials who had been employed by Lun were dismissed", leaving the central government offices almost empty, and nearly 100,000 people died in some sixty days of fighting. There were two exceptions. Sima Rong, Prince of Liang, who had been Sima Lun's "zaiheng" (chief minister), changed sides, headed the memorial asking for Sima Lun's execution, came through unscathed and went on to serve as Grand Steward (taizai). Wang Yu, who had led troops into the palace hall for Sima Lun to force the abdication, was "spared execution for his merit" because he turned at the critical moment, but three months later he was caught up in another plot and his clan was exterminated to the third degree.
Timeline
- Sima Zhong accedes Emperor Wu of Jin dies; Crown Prince Sima Zhong accedes and makes Jia Nanfeng empress. For the next ten years power is in Empress Jia's hands. [維基百科:晉惠帝]
- Empress Jia has the crown prince killed At the end of 299 Crown Prince Sima Yu was deposed and confined in the Jinyong Fortress, and in 300 he was killed. Sima Lun and Sun Xiu knew in advance but deliberately waited until the crown prince was dead before acting, so that they could use "avenging the crown prince" as their cause. [維基百科:司馬倫] [維基百科:孫秀 (西晉)] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉]
- The Prince of Huainan's uprising fails In the eighth month of the same year, Emperor Hui's younger brother Sima Yun, Prince of Huainan, led 700 men to besiege the chancellor's residence, shouting "The Prince of Zhao has rebelled"; Wang Yu shut the palace side gate, and Sima Yun was defeated and killed. Afterwards Sima Lun received the Nine Bestowments and the chancellor's troops were increased to 20,000. [維基百科:司馬允] [維基百科:王輿 (晉朝)] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉]
- Sima Lun deposes and kills Empress Jia and makes himself chancellor On the guisi day of the fourth month of Yongkang 1, Sima Lun and Sima Rong, Prince of Liang, deposed Empress Jia under a forged edict and killed Zhang Hua and Pei Wei; a few days later they poisoned Empress Jia with gold-fragment wine. Sima Lun made himself chancellor and Commander-in-Chief of all military affairs, on the scale of Sima Yi and Sima Zhao as regents of Wei. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基百科:司馬倫] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉]
- A fake manifestation of Sima Yi's spirit Sun Xiu had the standard-gate officer (yamen) Zhao Feng falsely relay an oracle from Emperor Xuan (Sima Yi) saying "Lun should enter the Western Palace soon", to build momentum for the usurpation. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- "Not enough sable, so dog tails are added" Sima Lun handed out offices and titles indiscriminately, so that even slaves and soldiers held noble ranks and court assemblies were filled with sable-and-cicada caps. Sun Xiu monopolised power, with edicts issued in the morning changed by evening. Zhang Lin's secret plot to remove Sun Xiu failed, and his clan was exterminated to the third degree. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基百科:司馬荂]
- The three princes rise In the third month, Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, raised troops at Xuchang and sent out a call to arms in all directions; Sima Ying, Prince of Chengdu, responded at Ye, his forces reaching more than 200,000; Sima Ai, Prince of Changshan, and Sima Xin, Duke of Xinye, also joined. Sima Yong, Prince of Hejian, at first helped Sima Lun and changed sides only when he saw the two princes' strength. Sima Lun and Sun Xiu were greatly alarmed and sent troops by three routes to resist. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基百科:司馬冏] [維基百科:司馬穎] [維基百科:司馬顒]
- Purging the remaining followers Zhang Heng, Lü He, Sun Mao and others were beheaded in the East Market, and Cai Huang killed himself; in the fifth month Sima Wei, Prince of Yiyang, was executed; the governor of Xiangyang, acting on the Prince of Qi's call to arms, beheaded Sun Qi. The "Zizhi Tongjian" sums up: in the sixty-odd days since the armies rose, nearly 100,000 people died in battle. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基百科:司馬威]
- A new imperial grandson-heir is named; Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, enters Luoyang and takes sole control In the fifth month Sima Shang, Prince of Xiangyang (younger brother of Sima Zang), was made imperial grandson-heir. In the sixth month Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, entered Luoyang at the head of several hundred thousand armoured soldiers, overawing the capital, and took charge of the government as Grand Marshal. [維基百科:晉惠帝] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基百科:司馬冏]
- Wang Yu's clan exterminated to the third degree In the eighth month, Sima Rui, Prince of Donglai, and Wang Yu secretly plotted to depose Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, and the plot leaked; Sima Rui was reduced to commoner status and Wang Yu's clan was exterminated to the third degree. The man who did most to restore Emperor Hui was gone within three months. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基百科:王輿 (晉朝)]
- Sima Lun usurps the throne On the yichou day of the first month of Yongning 1, Sima Wei and Luo Xiu seized the seal and ribbon by force, and Man Fen, Prefect of the Imperial Secretariat, and others presented the seal and ribbon in an "abdication"; Sima Lun led 5,000 troops in through the Duan Gate, ascended the Taiji Hall and took the throne, changing the era name to Jianshi. Emperor Hui was sent out through the west gate of the Hualin Garden to the Jinyong Fortress. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Emperor Hui becomes "Retired Emperor" On the bingyin day of the first month, Emperor Hui was honoured as Retired Emperor and the Jinyong Fortress renamed Yongchang Palace; the imperial grandson-heir was demoted to Prince of Puyang. Sima Lun made his heir Fu (荂) crown prince, and Sun Xiu became Palace Attendant and Director of the Palace Secretariat. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- The imperial grandson-heir is killed On the guiyou day of the first month, Sima Lun killed Sima Zang, Prince of Puyang. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基百科:司馬臧]
- Fighting on two fronts, Yangdi and Huangqiao In the fourth month (summer), Zhang Hong and others repeatedly defeated the Prince of Qi's army around Yangdi; the Prince of Chengdu's vanguard was first defeated at Huangqiao with more than 10,000 casualties, but on Lu Zhi's advice advanced instead of retreating and then routed Sun Hui, Shi Yi and Xu Chao. On hearing that the army north of the Yellow River had been defeated, Sun Xiu hid in the Palace Secretariat and did not dare come out. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉]
- Defection inside Luoyang; Emperor Hui restored On the xinyou day of the fourth month, Wang Yu and Sima Cui led more than 700 camp soldiers into the palace through the southern side gate and attacked and killed Sun Xiu, Xu Chao and Shi Yi. Wang Yu stationed troops at the Yunlong Gate and forced Sima Lun to issue an edict saying "I was misled by Sun Xiu; now I welcome the Retired Emperor back to the throne, and I shall go home to farm". Sima Lun was sent back to his private residence, and Emperor Hui was escorted back to the palace that same day. The assembled ministers bowed their heads to the ground and begged forgiveness, and Emperor Hui said: it is not your fault, gentlemen. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基百科:王輿 (晉朝)]
- General amnesty and change of era name On the guihai day of the fourth month, Emperor Hui issued an edict commending the three princes, Wang Yu and Sima Cui, proclaimed a general amnesty, changed the era name to Yongning, and decreed five days of public feasting. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Sima Lun ordered to die; his four sons executed On the dingmao day of the fourth month, on the memorial of Sima Rong, Prince of Liang, and others, Yuan Chang of the Imperial Secretariat was sent bearing the imperial credentials to order Sima Lun to die, and all four of his sons were executed. Every official Sima Lun had appointed was dismissed. On the same day Sima Ying, Prince of Chengdu, arrived in Luoyang, and two days later Sima Yong, Prince of Hejian, also arrived. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基百科:司馬倫]
- Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, is killed Sima Yong, Prince of Hejian, submitted a memorial calling for a campaign against the Prince of Qi, Sima Ai, Prince of Changsha, struck in Luoyang, and Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, was beheaded outside the Changhe Gate. The War of the Eight Princes entered the phase in which the princes took turns holding the emperor hostage. [維基百科:司馬冏] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基百科:八王之亂]
- Emperor Hui dies in Luoyang On the gengwu day of the eleventh month of Guangxi 1, Emperor Hui died in the Xianyang Hall, aged forty-eight. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基百科:晉惠帝]
People
- Emperor Hui of Jin, Sima Zhong (Sima Zhong (Emperor Hui of Jin)), 259-02-13 — Emperor of Western Jin → "Retired Emperor" (confined in the Jinyong Fortress) → restored. Second son by the empress of Emperor Wu of Jin, Sima Yan; made crown prince in 267 and married Jia Nanfeng, daughter of Jia Chong, in 272. The "Book of Jin" says the whole court knew he was unfit to govern; Emperor Wu once set him written questions as a test, and he passed only because Consort Jia found someone to answer for him. Acceded in 290 after Emperor Wu's death. Sima Lun was the younger brother of his grandfather Sima Zhao (his great-uncle); Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, was his cousin; Sima Ying, Prince of Chengdu, was his own younger brother. During his reign he was controlled first by Empress Jia, then by Sima Lun and the princes. Remained a puppet after his restoration: held hostage in turn by Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, Sima Ai, Prince of Changsha, Sima Ying, Prince of Chengdu, Sima Yong, Prince of Hejian, and Sima Yue, Prince of Donghai. Died on 8 January 307 (gengwu day of the eleventh month, Guangxi 1) in the Xianyang Hall in Luoyang, aged forty-eight; the histories record poisoning from eating cakes, and it was rumoured that Sima Yue, Prince of Donghai, was responsible. [維基百科:晉惠帝] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉]
- Sima Lun, Prince of Zhao (Sima Lun, Prince of Zhao) — Chancellor (xiangguo) and Commander-in-Chief of all military affairs → proclaimed himself emperor (era name Jianshi). Ninth son of Sima Yi and uncle of Emperor Wu of Jin. While garrisoning Guanzhong he was unfair in punishments and rewards, provoking a revolt of the Di and Qiang, and was recalled to Luoyang. The "Book of Jin" says he was "unlearned and could not read" and deferred to Sun Xiu in everything. After returning to the capital he curried favour with Empress Jia; in 300, in the name of avenging the crown prince, he deposed and killed Empress Jia, killed Zhang Hua and Pei Wei, and made himself chancellor, with arrangements modelled on the precedent of Sima Yi and Sima Zhao as regents of Wei. Emperor Hui's great-uncle. When Empress Jia had the crown prince killed, he in fact knew in advance and even urged it on from the sidelines, so as to have a pretext for seizing power afterwards. On 30 May 301 Wang Yu forced him to issue an edict welcoming Emperor Hui back to the throne, in which he said he would "retire to the fields in old age", and he was sent back to the Jinyong Fortress. Sima Rong, Prince of Liang, submitted a memorial asking for his execution, and on 5 June (dingmao day of the fourth month) Yuan Chang of the Imperial Secretariat, bearing the imperial credentials, ordered him to die; he drank bitter wine with gold fragments, covering his face with a cloth and saying "Sun Xiu misled me". [維基百科:司馬倫] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Sun Xiu (Sun Xiu) — Palace Attendant (shizhong), Director of the Palace Secretariat (zhongshu jian), General of Agile Cavalry (Sima Lun's chief strategist). A native of Langya whose family had followed the Way of the Five Pecks of Rice for generations; in his early years a minor clerk in Langya commandery, later Sima Lun's confidant. Already in Guanzhong he was blamed as the chief culprit in provoking the Di and Qiang revolt. Came to the capital with Sima Lun. He first advised Sima Lun to stand by while the crown prince was killed and then depose Empress Jia in the name of revenge; afterwards he forged portents and the edict of abdication, single-handedly stage-managing the usurpation. After Sima Lun proclaimed himself emperor, Sun Xiu could alter edicts at will and even wrote edicts himself on blue paper, with orders issued in the morning changed by evening. Emperor Hui's new empress, Yang Xianrong, was also his arrangement (Yang's maternal grandfather Sun Qi was of his clan). After hearing that the army north of the Yellow River had been defeated, he did not dare leave the Palace Secretariat. On 30 May Wang Yu attacked with troops; he shut the gates and resisted, the soldiers climbed the walls and set fires, and as he fled with Xu Chao and Shi Yi he was beheaded by Zhao Quan and his head displayed. His son Sun Hui was killed the same day. [維基百科:孫秀 (西晉)] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基百科:羊獻容]
- Sima Wei, Prince of Yiyang (Sima Wei, Prince of Yiyang) — Cavalier Attendant-in-Ordinary and concurrently Palace Attendant → Prefect of the Palace Secretariat (zhongshu ling). A member of the Western Jin imperial clan, of the line of Sima Fu (孚) and Sima Wang; childhood name A-Pi. The "Book of Jin" says he was violent by nature and fawned on Sima Lun. Served as Cavalier Attendant-in-Ordinary at the end of the Yuankang era; during the usurpation he was in charge of transmitting edicts. The man who personally snatched the seal and ribbon from Emperor Hui's hands. After Sima Lun's fall, Emperor Hui said: "A-Pi pried my fingers open and snatched my seal and ribbon; he must be killed." He was executed in the fifth month of 301. [維基百科:司馬威] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉]
- Sima Fu (荂) (with his younger brothers Fu (馥), Qian and Xu) (Sima Fu and his brothers) — Sima Lun's crown prince; the three younger brothers were made Prince of Jingzhao, Prince of Guangping and Prince of Bacheng. Sima Lun's four sons. The "Book of Jin" assesses them thus: Fu (荂) was shallow and vulgar, Fu (馥) and Qian were benighted and vicious, Xu was stupid, obstinate and frivolous, and they were at odds with one another and slandered each other. After their father proclaimed himself emperor, Fu (荂) was made crown prince and the other three were made princes, all serving as Palace Attendants with military commands. Zhang Lin once wrote secretly to Sima Fu (荂) asking him to get rid of Sun Xiu; Fu handed the letter to his father, which led to Zhang Lin's death. At the same time as Sima Lun was ordered to die, the four were arrested and handed to the Minister of Justice, and all were executed. On the point of death Sima Fu (馥) said to Sima Qian: it was you who brought ruin on the whole family. [維基百科:司馬荂] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Zhang Lin (Zhang Lin) — Clerk for communications (tongshi lingshi) → General of the Guards. Originally a clerk for communications; acted as an inside man when Empress Jia was deposed in 300; on the night of the usurpation he led troops to garrison the palace gates. Promoted to General of the Guards after Sima Lun proclaimed himself emperor. Had long been on bad terms with Sun Xiu, and also resented not being allowed to open his own office (kaifu). Died at the hands of his own side before Emperor Hui was even restored: he wrote secretly to the crown prince Sima Fu (荂) asking that Sun Xiu be executed, and the letter was passed on to Sun Xiu; Sima Lun held a banquet in the Hualin Garden, had him seized and killed, and exterminated his clan to the third degree. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基百科:司馬荂] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Zhang Heng, Lü He, Sun Mao, Fu Yin, Cai Huang (Zhang Heng, Lü He, Sun Mao, Fu Yin, Cai Huang) — Generals of Sima Lun's faction. Zhang Heng and Lü He were already inside men when Empress Jia was deposed in 300; after the usurpation Zhang Heng was ordered to guard Emperor Hui in the Jinyong Fortress with troops. Lü He, Cai Huang and others led troops out through the Eban Pass to resist the Prince of Qi. Held key posts because they took part in both of Sima Lun's coups. Zhang Heng was the man directly guarding Emperor Hui. After Emperor Hui's restoration, Zhang Heng, Lü He, Sun Mao and Gao Yue returned from the Yangdi front, and Fu Yin returned to Luoyang after being defeated; all were beheaded in the East Market. Cai Huang surrendered to the Prince of Qi and killed himself after returning to Luoyang. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Sima Rong, Prince of Liang (Sima Rong, Prince of Liang) — "Zaiheng" (chief minister) of Sima Lun's court → Grand Steward (taizai) after Emperor Hui's restoration. A senior member of the Western Jin imperial clan. In 300 he came forward together with Sima Lun to depose Empress Jia under a forged edict. Served as Grand Steward after Empress Jia was deposed; honoured as zaiheng after Sima Lun proclaimed himself emperor. Nominally the highest official of the usurper's court. But some people also wanted to rally behind him to kill Sima Lun, and Sun Xiu therefore moved him away from positions of real power. Not purged: as soon as Sima Lun fell, he headed a memorial saying "Lun, Prince of Zhao, and his sons are wicked rebels and should be executed", and the officials concurred. He then served as Grand Steward and concurrently Minister over the Masses (situ). [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉]
- Wang Yu (Wang Yu) — General of the Left Guard. Originally Assistant Director of the Left in the Imperial Secretariat. In 300, when Sima Yun, Prince of Huainan, raised troops against Sima Lun, it was he who shut the palace side gate and blocked him, for which he was promoted to General of the Left Guard. Sima Lun's man: it was he who led armoured soldiers into the hall on the day of the usurpation to intimidate the palace guard. After the three princes rose he secretly looked for an opening; once the army north of the Yellow River was defeated, he turned around, led 700 soldiers of his own camp into the palace through the southern side gate, killed Sun Xiu and forced Sima Lun to issue an edict stepping down. First he helped with the deposition, then he carried out the restoration. Emperor Hui's edict commended him for "personally leading his own camp" to behead Sun Xiu, and the "Book of Jin" says he was "spared execution for his merit". But in the eighth month of the same year he plotted with Sima Rui, Prince of Donglai, to depose Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi; the plot leaked and his clan was exterminated to the third degree. [維基百科:王輿 (晉朝)] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉]
- Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi (Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi) — General-in-Chief Guarding the East, garrisoned at Xuchang. Grandson of Sima Zhao and son of Sima You, Prince of Qi; Emperor Hui's cousin. When Sima Lun deposed Empress Jia in 300, it was he who led men into the palace to arrest her. Afterwards squeezed out of the capital by Sima Lun and Sun Xiu and sent to garrison Xuchang. First to call for an uprising: he first killed his fellow plotter Wang Chumu and sent the head to Sima Lun as a show of loyalty; once his plans were settled he sent a call to arms in all directions, agreeing with the Prince of Chengdu, the Prince of Hejian, the Prince of Changshan and the Duke of Xinye on a joint campaign. In the sixth month of 301 he entered Luoyang at the head of several hundred thousand armoured soldiers and took charge of the government as Grand Marshal (da sima), becoming the new dictator. At the end of 302 Sima Yong, Prince of Hejian, submitted a memorial calling for a campaign against him, and Sima Ai, Prince of Changsha, struck in Luoyang; on 26 January 303 he was beheaded outside the Changhe Gate, repeatedly looking back at Emperor Hui as he was led out. [維基百科:司馬冏] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Sima Ying, Prince of Chengdu (Sima Ying, Prince of Chengdu), 279 — General-in-Chief Conquering the North, garrisoned at Ye. Nineteenth son of Emperor Wu of Jin and younger brother of Emperor Hui. He once rebuked Jia Mi to his face for disrespect toward the crown prince and was sent out to garrison Ye. After proclaiming himself emperor, Sima Lun promoted him and granted him the right to open his own office in order to win him over. On receiving the Prince of Qi's call to arms he took Lu Zhi's advice and raised troops, his forces reaching more than 200,000; his vanguard was first defeated and then victorious at Huangqiao, routing Sima Lun's main force, and was the decisive factor on the battlefield. Arrived in Luoyang on the day Sima Lun was ordered to die, then declined honours and returned to his garrison, for a time enjoying great popularity; later he too was drawn into the struggle for power and was killed in 306. [維基百科:司馬穎] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Sima Yong, Prince of Hejian (Sima Yong, Prince of Hejian) — General Pacifying the West, garrisoned in Guanzhong. Grandson of Sima Fu (孚), younger brother of Sima Yi; a more distant relative, sent to garrison Guanzhong because of his reputation for worthiness. Garrisoned Guanzhong from 299. Bet on both sides: at first he sided with Sima Lun, having Xiahou Shi, who had answered the Prince of Qi's call, cut in two at the waist, sending the Prince of Qi's envoy bound to Luoyang, and dispatching Zhang Fang with troops to help Sima Lun; only when the army reached Huayin and he heard that the forces of the Princes of Qi and Chengdu were strong did he recall Zhang Fang and switch to the two princes. Because he changed sides early, he was not called to account afterwards and was still listed among the "three princes" who received commendation; Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, however, never forgave him for having sided with Sima Lun. He went on to become one of the main actors in the civil war and died in 306. [維基百科:司馬顒] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Sima Cui, Prince of Huailing (Sima Cui, Prince of Huailing) — Imperial Secretary (shangshu) (Duke of Guangling). A member of the Western Jin imperial clan, at the time an Imperial Secretary with the title Duke of Guangling. Nothing else about his life is recorded in the sources found. Was inside Luoyang at the time of the coup. Together with Wang Yu he led more than 700 soldiers into the palace through the southern side gate; Emperor Hui's edict says he "jointly laid the great plan". Commended by name in Emperor Hui's restoration edict; no source has been found for his later career. [維基百科:王輿 (晉朝)] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基百科:晉惠帝]
- Imperial Grandson-Heir Sima Zang (Sima Zang), 297 — Imperial grandson-heir (Emperor Hui's grandson). Son of Crown Prince Minhuai, Sima Yu. After his father was killed by Empress Jia in 300, Sima Lun made him imperial grandson-heir in order to win popular support. Made imperial grandson-heir in the fifth month of 300. Emperor Hui's only surviving heir in the direct line. After usurping the throne, Sima Lun demoted him to Prince of Puyang, moved him to the Jinyong Fortress together with Emperor Hui, and killed him soon afterwards, aged five. [維基百科:司馬臧] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
Moves to block a return
- Seize the token first, then produce the document: Sima Wei, Prince of Yiyang, and Luo Xiu, a Gentleman of the Yellow Gate, were sent into the palace to wrest the seal and ribbon from Emperor Hui's hands, and an edict of abdication was forged; Wang Yu and Sima Ya led armoured soldiers into the hall and used threats and inducements on the Three Divisions' commanders (the palace guard), and no one dared object; that night Zhang Lin and others held the gates. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基百科:司馬威]
- On the bingyin day of the first month, Emperor Hui was moved to the Jinyong Fortress at the north-west corner of Luoyang (the place used since Cao Wei specifically to confine deposed emperors and empresses), honoured as "Retired Emperor", with Jinyong renamed "Yongchang Palace", and Zhang Heng was sent with troops to guard him. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基百科:金墉城]
- Remove the lawful heir: Emperor Hui's grandson, the imperial grandson-heir Sima Zang, was first demoted to Prince of Puyang and then killed on the guiyou day of the first month (11 February), aged only five; at the same time Sima Lun made his own son Sima Fu (荂) crown prince and made his other three sons princes, all with military commands. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基百科:司馬臧] [維基百科:司馬荂]
- Buy support with offices: that year's candidates recommended from the provinces under the xianliang, xiucai and xiaolian categories were all appointed without examination, all serving commandery governors and county magistrates were made marquises, fellow conspirators were promoted out of turn, and even slaves and servants received noble ranks. There were not enough sable tails for official caps, so dog tails had to be used instead, and people of the time coined the saying "not enough sable, so dog tails are added"; so many marquises were created that seals could not be cast fast enough. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四] [維基百科:八王之亂]
- Guard against the outlying princes: Sun Xiu promoted Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, to General-in-Chief Guarding the East as a gesture of appeasement, while placing confidants and former subordinates of the Prince of Zhao on the staffs of the Princes of Qi, Chengdu and Hejian to watch them. After the three princes rose, Sima Lun and Sun Xiu forged a memorial from the Prince of Qi asking for help and published it at court and in the provinces, pretending that the Prince of Qi was being besieged by "bandits of unknown origin". [維基百科:八王之亂] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Send troops by three routes to block them: Sun Fu, Zhang Hong, Sima Ya and others were sent out through the Yanshou, Eban and Chenggao passes with 24,000 men in total to resist; in addition a Daoist priest was made "General of Great Peace", men were dressed in feathered robes to impersonate the immortal Wang Qiao on Mount Song, and writings from the immortals were produced saying that Sima Lun's reign would last long. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
Rumors
- (Anecdotes from his reign, year unknown) Emperor Hui was an idiot: on hearing that the common people were starving to death, he asked "Why don't they eat meat porridge?"; on hearing frogs croak, he asked "Are they croaking for the government or for private persons?" [Still unclear] "Book of Jin", Annals of Emperor Hui Both stories come from the "Book of Jin", an official history compiled in the Tang dynasty, and the traditional verdict (for example Wang Fuzhi calling him "a puppet of clay and wood") relies on them in judging him dull-witted. But the same "Book of Jin" also records that on his restoration he said "it is not your fault, gentlemen" and clearly remembered who had pried his fingers open to take the seal. Just how far his intelligence extended cannot be settled on the basis of these few anecdotes. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基百科:晉惠帝] [維基百科:司馬威]
- The spirit of Sima Yi manifested itself and said "Lun should enter the Western Palace soon"; Sima Lun becoming emperor was the mandate of Heaven. [Proven false] Spread by the standard-gate officer Zhao Feng at Sun Xiu's direction Both the "Book of Jin" and the "Zizhi Tongjian" state explicitly that this was "falsely making up words from the spirit of Emperor Xuan". Sima Lun and Sun Xiu were in any case superstitious believers in shamans and spirits, and even set up a separate temple to Emperor Xuan on Mount Beimang. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi, had not rebelled; he was being besieged by unknown bandits and had memorialised the court for help. [Proven false] The "memorial from the Prince of Qi" forged by Sima Lun and Sun Xiu The "Zizhi Tongjian" states explicitly that they "forged a memorial from Jiong", the aim being to conceal from court and country the fact that imperial princes had taken up arms. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Emperor Hui voluntarily abdicated the throne to Sima Lun. [Proven false] The edict of abdication issued by Sima Lun's court The edict was "forged" by Sima Wei, and the seal and ribbon were wrested from Emperor Hui's hands. The edict issued after Emperor Hui's restoration says Sima Lun "greedily occupied the Heavenly throne", and Emperor Hui himself said that Sima Wei pried his fingers open to take the seal. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基百科:司馬威]
- Sima Lun was merely a puppet led by the nose by Sun Xiu; the usurpation was entirely Sun Xiu's idea. [Still unclear] Sima Lun, on the point of death, said "Sun Xiu misled me"; Emperor Hui's restoration edict also says "the former Prince of Zhao, Lun, was misled by Xiu" The "Book of Jin" says Sima Lun was illiterate and deferred to Sun Xiu in everything; but the benefits of deposing Empress Jia and taking the throne all went to him and his four sons, and the "misled" account also made it convenient for the court to use milder wording about a member of the imperial clan. How responsibility should be divided between principal and follower is not settled in the histories. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉]
- Emperor Hui was poisoned by Sima Yue, Prince of Donghai. [Still unclear] A rumour at the time (Wikipedia entry "Emperor Hui of Jin") The histories record that he died of poisoning after eating cakes; there is no firm evidence of who the poisoner was. Sima Yue held power at the time and is the prime suspect, but this is only a rumour. [維基百科:晉惠帝]
Views
- The historians of the "Book of Jin" (official history compiled under the Tang dynasty): An unworthy son sat on the throne of the Son of Heaven; power did not issue from the emperor, and government fell into the hands of petty men. When a state is overthrown, if it is not because someone has arisen who overturns the natural order, it is because the ruler is benighted—could it be that Emperor Wu of Jin did not know his own son? [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉]
- "Book of Jin", Biography of Lun, Prince of Zhao: Sima Lun had no learning and could not read; Sun Xiu had only a cunning, petty cleverness and was greedy, lecherous and fond of gain. Those who worked with them were all wicked flatterers who knew only how to scramble for power and profit and had no far-sighted plans. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉]
- Wang Fuzhi (thinker of the late Ming and early Qing): He described Emperor Hui as "a puppet of clay and wood"—like a clay or wooden figure, manipulated by others at will. [維基百科:晉惠帝]
- A saying current in Luoyang at the time: "Not enough sable, so dog tails are added." — There were so many officials that the sable tails used to decorate official caps ran short, and dog tails had to make up the number. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷五十九〈趙王倫、齊王冏等傳〉] [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Lu Zhi (adviser to Sima Ying, Prince of Chengdu): He told the Prince of Chengdu: the Prince of Zhao has usurped the throne, and men and gods alike are outraged; if Your Highness follows the people's hopes and marches against him in a just cause, the people will come without being summoned. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Sun Xun (military adviser to Sima Xin, Duke of Xinye): Someone advised the Duke of Xinye that "the Prince of Zhao is close kin and strong, the Prince of Qi is distant kin and weak; you should follow the Prince of Zhao". Sun Xun said loudly before everyone: the Prince of Zhao is a wicked rebel and the whole realm should join in executing him; what do near or distant, strong or weak have to do with it! [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Sun Qi (kinsman of Sun Xiu, General Pacifying the South): He believed that the excessive offices and ranks his sons and nephews had received from Sima Lun were bound to bring disaster on the family, and sent his youngest son to reproach them, but they would not listen; unable to stop them, he could only weep bitterly. Later he was indeed beheaded. [維基文庫:《資治通鑑》卷八十四]
- Emperor Hui of Jin himself: The ministers knelt and asked to be punished, and he said "it is not your fault, gentlemen"; but of Sima Wei, who had snatched his seal and ribbon, he said he must be killed. [維基文庫:《晉書》卷四〈惠帝紀〉] [維基百科:司馬威]
Photos & videos
Portrait of Emperor Hui of Jin, from the "Illustrated Sequel to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms" (Xiuxiang Sanguo yanyi xubian), printed by Guangbaisong Zhai, Shanghai, in Guangxu 19 of the Qing (1893) (a woodcut illustration for a novel, not a likeness from life). — 金人瑞《繡像三國演義續編》,上海廣百宋齋,1893 年 / Public domain
Portrait of Sima Lun, Prince of Zhao; woodcut from the same book. — 金人瑞《繡像三國演義續編》,上海廣百宋齋,1893 年 / Public domain
Schematic map of the fiefs and garrison posts of the other princes at the time of Sima Lun's usurpation in 301. — SY / CC BY-SA 4.0
Portrait of Sima Jiong, Prince of Qi; woodcut from the same book. He was the first to call for an uprising against Sima Lun, and two years later was himself killed. — 金人瑞《繡像三國演義續編》,上海廣百宋齋,1893 年 / Public domain
Portrait of Sima Ying, Prince of Chengdu; woodcut from the same book. — 金人瑞《繡像三國演義續編》,上海廣百宋齋,1893 年 / Public domain
Portrait of Jia Nanfeng, Emperor Hui's empress; woodcut from the same book. Deposed and killed by Sima Lun in 300, she died in the Jinyong Fortress. — 金人瑞《繡像三國演義續編》,上海廣百宋齋,1893 年 / Public domain
Map of the situation during the War of the Eight Princes. — SY / CC BY-SA 4.0
Map of the military garrisons of Western Jin and the fiefs of the eight princes. — Jason22 at Chinese Wikipedia / Public domain
"Ji Shao Shields the Emperor" from a Korean printed edition of the "Samgang Haengsildo": in the later stage of the War of the Eight Princes, the Palace Attendant Ji Shao died on the battlefield shielding Emperor Hui with his own body—after his restoration Emperor Hui was still being dragged onto battlefields by the princes. — 偰 循 setsu, jun / Public domain
Page from the "Book of Jin" (on display at the Hangzhou branch of the China National Archives of Publications and Culture). The account of Emperor Hui's deposition and restoration is found mainly in this book's "Annals of Emperor Hui" and "Biography of Lun, Prince of Zhao". — Yumeto / CC BY-SA 4.0