Isaac II Angelos (Isaac II Angelos) — Byzantine Empire (Angelos dynasty) (Byzantine Empire (Angelos dynasty))
Isaac II came to the throne by accident in a popular uprising in 1185; in ten years he lost Bulgaria, and his reign was marked by heavy taxation and misgovernment. In 1195 he was blinded and supplanted by his own elder brother Alexios III and imprisoned for eight years. His son, the young Alexios, escaped in 1201 and, by promising to pay two hundred thousand silver marks, diverted the Fourth Crusade, originally bound for the Holy Land, to Constantinople. In July 1203 Alexios III abandoned the city and fled, and Isaac was restored — but he was blind and enfeebled, real power lay with his son, and the brother who had overthrown him had already run off with the gold; all he could do was imprison his sister-in-law. Father and son could not pay the money promised and, caught between the crusaders and the angry citizens, lasted only six months: at the end of January 1204 they were overthrown by the courtier Alexios Doukas (Alexios V Doukas, nicknamed Mourtzouphlos, "bushy-browed"), Isaac died soon afterwards and his son was strangled; in April Constantinople was captured and sacked by the crusaders.
How they were ousted
In April 1195, while he was hunting in Thrace, his elder brother Alexios (Alexios III Angelos) was proclaimed emperor in the army camp; Isaac was seized at Stagira, blinded, and imprisoned back in Constantinople.
How they came back
His son Alexios (IV) escaped to the West and promised a huge sum to have the Fourth Crusade take him home; in July 1203 the crusaders attacked the city, Alexios III fled by night with the treasury, and the next day the people of the city released the blind Isaac from prison and restored him to the throne, to reign jointly with his son from 1 August.
What happened to the board
Strictly speaking, after his restoration Isaac was able to settle scores with almost no one; "partial" is entered because that group did indeed come to bad ends later, though mostly not at his hands. Of the two protagonists of the 1195 usurpation: Alexios III fled the night before the restoration with about a thousand pounds of gold and his daughter Irene, and the troops Isaac and his son sent to Thrace in pursuit failed to catch him; he was later captured by the crusader leader Boniface and held until about 1209, then in 1211 captured again by his son-in-law, the Nicaean emperor Theodore I Laskaris, and confined in a monastery in Nicaea, where he died the same year — it was the Latins and his own son-in-law who dealt with him. Empress Euphrosyne, abandoned by her husband, was imprisoned at once by the restored regime, the only principal dealt with on the spot; in 1204 she escaped again, and ended her days at Arta in Epirus. In addition, Alexios IV, to raise money, confiscated the property of his "enemies", of whom no list survives. Those who faced no reckoning: Theodore Laskaris, Alexios III's son-in-law, was imprisoned for a time, escaped in September 1203 and later founded the Empire of Nicaea; Niketas Choniates, who held office under both regimes, stayed in his post all the same. Conversely, Alexios Doukas, whom the restored regime released from prison and promoted, overthrew and killed father and son six months later.
Timeline
- Bulgaria breaks away Tax increases to pay for the army and his own wedding set off the revolt of the Vlachs and Bulgarians at the end of 1185, which later became the Second Bulgarian Empire. Isaac's repeated campaigns failed (Tryavna in 1190, Arcadiopolis in 1194). [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos]
- Isaac comes to the throne in a popular uprising Stephen Hagiochristophorites, henchman of Andronikos I, came to arrest him; he killed the man, fled into Hagia Sophia, and was acclaimed by the crowd. Andronikos I was handed over to the mob and killed on 12 September. [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos]
- Imprisoned in the Great Palace, then moved to the Diplokionion The blind Isaac was first held in the Great Palace and later moved to the Diplokionion on the Golden Horn; his son, the young Alexios, was imprisoned too. The new emperor called off the war against Bulgaria. [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos] [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos]
- Supplanted and blinded by his brother while hunting Isaac was preparing another campaign against Bulgaria and was hunting in Thrace when his elder brother Alexios was proclaimed by the army. Isaac was arrested at Stagira, blinded, and taken back to the capital. The date is given as either 8 or 9 April; the Alexios III article says March. [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera]
- Empress Euphrosyne accused of adultery and sent to a convent Her brother and son-in-law denounced her for an affair with the minister Vatatzes; Vatatzes was executed, and she was stripped of her imperial robes and confined in the convent of Nematarea, to be recalled in the spring of 1197. [Wikipedia: Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos]
- The young Alexios escapes to the West Two Pisan merchants smuggled him out of the city. He took refuge with his brother-in-law Philip of Swabia; that winter at Hagenau he met Boniface, leader of the crusade. [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos] [Wikipedia: Boniface I, Marquis of Montferrat]
- The crusaders take Zara Unable to pay the Venetians for their passage, the crusaders took the Christian city of Zara on the Adriatic for Venice, for which Pope Innocent III excommunicated them (lifted for the non-Venetians in February 1203). [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade] [Wikipedia: Enrico Dandolo]
- Icons melted down and property confiscated, yet only half is raised To pay the crusaders, Alexios IV confiscated church treasures and his enemies' property, raising only a hundred thousand silver marks. Niketas Choniates saw the melting down of sacred vessels as the turning point in the empire's decline. [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos] [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade]
- The young Alexios's terms reach Zara His envoys offered two hundred thousand silver marks, ten thousand soldiers, church union and other terms in exchange for the crusaders overthrowing Alexios III. The fleet sailed at the end of April. [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade] [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos]
- The crusader fleet arrives at Constantinople About two hundred ships arrived carrying the crusaders and Venetians. Alexios III tried to buy them off with money, without success. [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)]
- Euphrosyne imprisoned; Alexios Doukas released The new regime at once imprisoned the former empress; Alexios Doukas, held for two years by Alexios III, was released and appointed protovestiarios. Theodore Laskaris, Alexios III's son-in-law, was also imprisoned, and escaped in September. [Wikipedia: Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera] [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Theodore I Laskaris]
- The chain across the Golden Horn is broken The crusaders crossed the Bosporus and took the Tower of Galata; the Venetian ship Eagle broke the chain barring the Golden Horn, and the fleet sailed into the harbour. [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade] [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)]
- The crusaders encamp opposite the Blachernae Palace The crusaders took the young Alexios to the foot of the walls to show him to the citizens, hoping they would open the gates to welcome him; the response in the city was cool. [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)] [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos]
- General assault: the Venetians seize about 25 towers The land walls were held by the Varangian Guard; a stretch of the sea walls was taken by the Venetians, who set fires to cover their withdrawal. Alexios III led seventeen divisions out of the Gate of St Romanus and withdrew without fighting. [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos]
- Alexios III flees by night That night (the night of the 17th to the early hours of the 18th) he fled by ship to Develtos, taking his daughter Irene and about a thousand pounds of gold and leaving the empress and his other daughters in the city. The siege article dates the assault and the night flight to the 18th. [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)]
- The blind Isaac is released and restored With the emperor gone, the people of the city released Isaac after eight years' imprisonment and restored him to the throne. The crusaders demanded that he confirm by chrysobull the Treaty of Zara his son had signed. The articles differ by a day on the date (18th or 19th). [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos] [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)] [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos]
- Father and son reign jointly At the crusaders' insistence the young Alexios was crowned co-emperor (Alexios IV). The article says Isaac was enfeebled in body and mind and that his son in fact governed. [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos] [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos] [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)]
- The great fire of Constantinople On 19–21 August, clashes between Greeks and Latins in the city started a great fire that left about a hundred thousand people homeless; at the time Alexios IV was in Thrace with troops, pursuing his uncle. [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade] [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos]
- Father-in-law blinds son-in-law Alexios V fled to Mosynopolis to take refuge with Alexios III and married Eudokia, only to be seized and blinded by his father-in-law — the man who overthrew Isaac blinded the man who killed Isaac's son. [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos]
- Night attack on the Venetian fleet with fire ships fails In early January Alexios IV sent 17 fire ships to burn the Venetian fleet, without success, and the break with the crusaders was complete. [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos]
- The crowd puts forward Kanabos as an alternative emperor Senators, clergy and citizens assembled in Hagia Sophia for three days and finally put forward Nicholas Kanabos; he would not accept. The two emperors took refuge in the Blachernae Palace. [Wikipedia: Nicholas Kanabos] [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos]
- Alexios Doukas stages a coup; Isaac dies Alexios Doukas, sent to seek help from the crusaders, bribed the Varangian Guard and arrested the two emperors between the night of 27 January and the 29th. Isaac died around this time (28 January; another article gives the 25th). [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos] [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos] [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)]
- Alexios V crowned "Mourtzouphlos" was crowned emperor, closed the city gates, strengthened the defences, and levied money from the nobles and officials. Kanabos was arrested and strangled. [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Nicholas Kanabos]
- Alexios IV strangled Peace talks between Alexios V and Dandolo broke down, and Alexios IV died in prison on about the same day. The crusaders used this as their ground for declaring war on the new emperor. [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos] [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)]
- The city falls; Alexios V flees by night The assault of 9 April was repulsed; three days later the crusaders broke in around the Petria Gate. That night Alexios V fled to Thrace in a fishing boat with Eudokia and Euphrosyne; the city was then sacked for three days. [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade] [Wikipedia: Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera]
- Alexios V thrown from the Column of Theodosius He was captured in November by Latins led by Thierry de Loos and tried in Constantinople; he argued that Alexios IV was the real traitor. In December he was executed by being thrown from the top of the Column of Theodosius. [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas]
- Alexios III becomes Boniface's prisoner Alexios III and Euphrosyne fled to the region of Thessalonica and Corinth and finally surrendered to Boniface; in 1205 he tried to escape to Epirus, was caught and brought back, and was held in Montferrat and Thessalonica until about 1209. [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera]
- Ransomed, he turns to the sultan of Rum Michael I of Epirus paid the couple's ransom (about 1209–1210). Alexios III did not settle down quietly but went to Konya to take refuge with Sultan Kaykhusraw I, scheming to seize his son-in-law's Empire of Nicaea. [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Theodore I Laskaris] [Wikipedia: Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera]
- Battle of Antioch on the Maeander: captured by his son-in-law In late spring 1211 (about 17 June) the sultan invaded Nicaea with Alexios III; Theodore I killed the sultan in battle, captured his father-in-law and confined him in a monastery in Nicaea. He died the same year. [Wikipedia: Theodore I Laskaris] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos]
People
- Isaac II Angelos (Isaac II Angelos), 1156-09 — Byzantine emperor (1185–1195, 1203–1204). Born September 1156; his father was Andronikos Angelos Doukas and his mother Euphrosyne Kastamonitissa, of a collateral branch of the imperial Komnenos family. In his early years he took part in plots and revolts against Andronikos I. On 1185-09-11 a henchman of Andronikos I came to arrest him; he killed the man on the spot, took refuge in Hagia Sophia, and was acclaimed emperor by the crowd; Andronikos was killed by the mob the next day. Alexios III was his full elder brother; after his accession he paid a ransom for his brother, then adrift abroad, and gave him the title of sebastokrator. After his restoration he was weak in body and mind from blindness and eight years' imprisonment, and real power lay with his son. Arrested in the coup at the end of January 1204, he died soon afterwards; the article says "reportedly of shock". The articles differ on the date: 25 or 28 January. [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos] [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)] [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas]
- Alexios III Angelos (Alexios III Angelos), 1153 — Sebastokrator; emperor 1195–1203. Born c. 1153, Isaac's elder brother. Went into exile about 1183 after plotting against Andronikos I, and spent several years at the courts of Saladin and other Muslim rulers. Returned to his brother's court before 1190. In 1195, taking advantage of Isaac's absence on a hunt, he was proclaimed emperor by the army; his wife Euphrosyne managed the nobility in the capital on his behalf. Isaac's full elder brother, who owed his brother both his ransom and his title. After his night flight in 1203-07 he moved about Thrace; in 1204 he blinded Alexios V, who had come to him for refuge, and then surrendered to Boniface; in 1205 he tried to escape to Epirus, was caught and brought back, and was held in Montferrat and Thessalonica until about 1209. Once ransomed he took refuge with Kaykhusraw I, sultan of Rum; in 1211 he accompanied the sultan's invasion of Nicaea, was captured at the Battle of Antioch on the Maeander by his son-in-law Theodore I, and was confined in a monastery in Nicaea, where he died the same year. [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Theodore I Laskaris] [Wikipedia: Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera]
- Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera (Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera), 1155 — Empress of Alexios III. Born c. 1155, daughter of Andronikos Doukas Kamateros; married Alexios Angelos c. 1169. The coup of 1195-04-08 was backed by her from within the capital: she organised supporters among the nobility, took control of the palace, and silenced opposition with bribes. Isaac's sister-in-law. During her husband's reign she was regarded as the real power behind the throne, issuing orders herself and altering her husband's decrees. In 1196 she was accused of adultery by her own brother and her son-in-law, and was confined to a convent for about six months before being recalled. When her husband fled in 1203 he left her in the city, and the new regime imprisoned her at once. In April 1204 she escaped with her daughter Eudokia and Alexios V, rejoined her husband, and was captured with him by Boniface; about 1209–1210 she was ransomed by her cousin Michael I of Epirus, lived out her last years at Arta, and died about 1210–1211. [Wikipedia: Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas]
- Alexios IV Angelos (Alexios IV Angelos), 1182 — Son of Isaac II; co-emperor (1203–1204). Born c. 1182, son of Isaac II; his mother may have been Irene Tornikina. Imprisoned along with his father when the latter was deposed in 1195, but not harmed. Smuggled out of Constantinople in 1201 by two Pisan merchants, he took refuge with his brother-in-law, the German king Philip of Swabia. His offer to the crusaders: two hundred thousand silver marks, ten thousand soldiers, five hundred knights to be stationed permanently in the Holy Land, twenty ships, and the submission of the Greek Church to the pope. This promissory note later brought down both father and son. Crowned co-emperor on 1203-08-01. By confiscating church treasures and his enemies' property he raised only half (a hundred thousand marks), antagonising the citizens without placating the crusaders. Imprisoned by Alexios Doukas at the end of January 1204, he was strangled in prison on about 8 February. [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos] [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade]
- Alexios V Doukas ("Mourtzouphlos") (Alexios V Doukas “Mourtzouphlos”), 1140 — Protovestiarios; emperor February–April 1204. Surnamed Doukas; the nickname refers to his thick, overhanging eyebrows. His family background is unclear and his year of birth unknown (c. 1140 is only an estimate). For his involvement in the coup of John Komnenos "the Fat" in 1200 he was imprisoned by Alexios III from about 1201. Released when Isaac was restored in July 1203 and appointed protovestiarios — he was a man the restored regime itself set free and itself promoted. Reportedly the lover of Eudokia, daughter of Alexios III. In January 1204 the two emperors sent him to seek help from the crusaders; instead he bribed the Varangian Guard and had the emperors seized. Crowned on about 5 February, he led the defence of the city. On the night of 12 April, when the city fell, he fled in a fishing boat; at Mosynopolis he married Eudokia, only to be blinded by his father-in-law Alexios III. Captured by the Latins in November 1204, he was tried in Constantinople for treason against Alexios IV, and in December was executed by being thrown from the top of the Column of Theodosius. [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos]
- Enrico Dandolo (Enrico Dandolo), 1107 — Doge of Venice. Born c. 1107 in Venice (the year is a later estimate). Lost his sight about 1174–1176. Went as envoy to Constantinople in 1183–1184 and was elected doge in 1192. In 1202 he agreed to transport the crusaders in the Venetian fleet; unable to pay for their passage, the crusaders first took Zara for Venice to offset the debt. He was the creditor who took the young Alexios home. The article notes that historians think he very probably knew the terms the young Alexios offered could never be honoured. After the city fell in 1204 he shipped great quantities of plunder back to Venice, including the four bronze horses of St Mark's; he declined to become emperor of the Latin Empire. Died in Constantinople in May or June 1205 and was buried in Hagia Sophia. [Wikipedia: Enrico Dandolo] [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade]
- Boniface I, Marquis of Montferrat (Boniface I of Montferrat), 1150 — Leader of the Fourth Crusade. Born c. 1150, third son of William V, Marquis of Montferrat; succeeded as marquis about 1192. Chosen as leader of the crusade in 1201 after the death of the Count of Champagne. In the winter of 1201 he spent Christmas at Hagenau with his cousin Philip of Swabia, met the fugitive young Alexios, and discussed using the crusade to take him home. His family was connected to the Angeloi by marriage: Isaac's sister Theodora married his brother Conrad. Vetoed by the Venetians in the election of an emperor in 1204, with Baldwin chosen instead; in 1205 he founded the Kingdom of Thessalonica and married Margaret of Hungary, widow of Isaac II. Alexios III and his wife surrendered to him and were held captive by him. Killed in an ambush on 1207-09-04; his head was sent to Tsar Kaloyan of Bulgaria. [Wikipedia: Boniface I, Marquis of Montferrat] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos]
- Theodore I Laskaris (Theodore I Laskaris), 1175 — Son-in-law of Alexios III, despot; later emperor of Nicaea. Born c. 1175, of noble but not especially distinguished family. Married Anna, daughter of Alexios III, at the end of 1200, was given the title of despot, and was regarded as a possible heir. Entered Alexios III's inner circle through marriage; in 1203 he made a sortie against the besieging crusaders. Sided with his father-in-law against Isaac and his son and the crusaders; imprisoned after his father-in-law fled. Escaped from prison in September 1203, founded the Empire of Nicaea in Asia Minor, and was crowned on 1208-04-06. When his father-in-law brought the sultan of Rum to attack in 1211, he killed the sultan in battle at Antioch on the Maeander, captured his father-in-law and confined him. Died in November 1221 and was buried in the monastery of Hyakinthos in Nicaea, right beside his father-in-law. [Wikipedia: Theodore I Laskaris] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos]
- Nicholas Kanabos (Nicholas Kanabos) — Candidate for emperor put forward in January 1204. Little is known of his life. On 27 January 1204 the senators, clergy and populace of the capital assembled in Hagia Sophia; for three days running no one could be found willing to be emperor, and in the end they put him forward. He was the candidate forced forward by the crowds opposed to Isaac and his son, and he himself never agreed to accept the throne. He had no ties to any side and was an outsider in this turmoil. After Alexios V took power he offered him high office; he refused and took refuge in Hagia Sophia. Once his supporters had dispersed he was arrested and strangled a few days later, perhaps on 5 February, the very day of the new emperor's coronation. (Another article says he died on the steps of the church.) [Wikipedia: Nicholas Kanabos] [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas]
- Niketas Choniates (Niketas Choniates), 1155 — Senior financial official (logothete), historian. Born c. 1155 at Chonae; sent to Constantinople to be educated in 1164, became a judge in 1191, and thereafter held high offices under the Angeloi. Served throughout under Isaac II, Alexios III and Alexios IV. He served the emperors of both sides; the principal account of this period comes from his History (covering 1118–1207). The great fire of August 1203 destroyed his mansion. Dismissed without cause by Alexios V in early 1204. After the city fell he hid in the house of a Venetian friend, left the city by the Golden Gate on 17 April with his pregnant wife and small children, and later took refuge with Theodore I at Nicaea. Died in 1217. [Wikipedia: Niketas Choniates]
- Eudokia Angelina (Eudokia Angelina) — Daughter of Alexios III. Daughter of Alexios III and Euphrosyne. First married to Stefan Nemanjić II of Serbia; the marriage broke down around 1200 and she was sent back, costing Byzantium its ally in the Balkans. Daughter of the emperor. Reportedly the lover of Alexios Doukas; when her father fled in 1203 she and her mother were left in the city. On 1204-04-12 she and her mother escaped with Alexios V, and she married him at Mosynopolis; her husband was promptly blinded by her father. She later remarried, to Leo Sgouros, lord of the Corinth region. [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera]
Moves to block a return
- Blinding. By Byzantine custom a blind man could no longer be emperor; having seized his younger brother, Alexios III had him blinded — even though Isaac had years earlier paid to ransom him from captivity in Antioch. [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos]
- Imprisonment: first in the Great Palace, later moved to the Diplokionion (Double Columns) on the Golden Horn. The guard was not strict; Isaac could still correspond with his family, and is said to have asked his daughter Irene, married to the German king, to find a way to rescue him. [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos]
- He also imprisoned his nephew, the young Alexios (without harming him), and took the throne under the surname "Komnenos", attaching himself through his maternal line to the more prestigious old dynasty; at the same time he lavished money to buy support, which the article says directly ruined the state's finances. [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos]
- After the crusader fleet arrived he tried to buy them off with money, without success; a sortie at Scutari by his son-in-law Theodore Laskaris was also repulsed. [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Theodore I Laskaris]
- On the day the crusaders attacked the city he led seventeen divisions out of the Gate of St Romanus and drew them up, far outnumbering the enemy, yet withdrew into the city without giving battle. That night he fled with the gold. [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos]
- After fleeing the capital he still controlled Thrace, establishing himself successively at Adrianople and Mosynopolis and trying to set up anew; Alexios IV led troops out of the city against him and took only a few towns. [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos]
Rumors
- Empress Euphrosyne committed adultery with the minister Vatatzes. [Still unclear] The accusation of her brother Basil Kamateros and her son-in-law Andronikos Kontostephanos. Vatatzes was executed on account of it and the empress was confined to a convent; but six months later she was reinstated through the efforts of her relatives and went on wielding power. The Alexios III article says only that her ally Vatatzes was killed on the emperor's orders. Whether the accusation was true is unsettled. [Wikipedia: Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera] [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos]
- The diversion of the crusade to Constantinople was agreed at Hagenau at Christmas 1201 among Boniface, Philip of Swabia and the young Alexios. [Still unclear] The Boniface article records that the three discussed the matter at the time; the Alexios IV article says "reportedly". That the three met is recorded; how far the discussion went cannot be verified. The formal terms did not reach the crusaders at Zara until 1203-01-01, and the fleet had gone to Zara in the first place to pay off the debt to Venice for the ships. [Wikipedia: Boniface I, Marquis of Montferrat] [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos] [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade]
- The pope's letter forbidding attacks on Christians did not reach the crusaders in time. [Still unclear] The account in the Fourth Crusade article. The article says only that it "may not have arrived in time". What is certain is that after Zara fell the pope excommunicated the crusaders, and the leaders kept this from their men. [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade]
- Dandolo had long known that the young Alexios could not pay, and deliberately took the crusade to Constantinople. [Still unclear] The inference of modern historians. What the Fourth Crusade article says is that historians think he "very probably knew" these promises could not be honoured; this is conjecture about motive, without direct evidence. [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade] [Wikipedia: Enrico Dandolo]
- Alexios Doukas was the lover of Eudokia, daughter of Alexios III. [Still unclear] The account in the sources as relayed by the article ("reportedly"). That the two married at Mosynopolis in April 1204 is recorded; whether there was an earlier liaison rests only on rumour. The Euphrosyne article, however, states it as fact. [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Euphrosyne Doukaina Kamatera]
- Isaac II died of shock on hearing the news of the coup. [Still unclear] The traditional account relayed in the article ("reportedly of shock"). The Fourth Crusade article says "probably of natural causes"; he was blind and enfeebled by then. The dates do not agree either: the Isaac article gives 28 January, the siege article 25 January. No source says that he, like his son, was strangled. [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos] [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade] [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)] [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas]
- Alexios IV was strangled on 8 February. [Still unclear] The inference of modern works. All the articles agree that he was strangled; the date, however, is always qualified with "probably": the Alexios V article says he most likely died on the day the negotiations with Dandolo broke down. [Wikipedia: Alexios IV Angelos] [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)]
Views
- Niketas Choniates (contemporary high official and historian): He rated Isaac very low: incompetent, passive, a harsh taxer who issued contradictory orders; he also blamed him for having detained the German envoys years earlier, which was what brought foreign troops down on the empire. [Wikipedia: Niketas Choniates]
- English Wikipedia article "Alexios III Angelos" (after Bury, Fine, Treadgold): He spent lavishly to keep a throne he had not come by rightfully, ruining the state's finances, with public money going on palaces and gardens; in July 1203, though he clearly had the larger force, he lacked the courage to give battle. [Wikipedia: Alexios III Angelos] [Wikipedia: Siege of Constantinople (1203)]
- Niketas Choniates: Says he was by nature extremely intelligent, but arrogant and lecherous. The article cautions that Choniates was the very man this emperor dismissed without cause, so the judgment may be coloured by personal grievance. [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas] [Wikipedia: Niketas Choniates]
- Niketas Choniates: He saw the melting down of icons and church vessels to pay the crusaders as the turning point in the empire's slide into decline. [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade]
- Modern historians (cited in the Alexios V article): The Latin conquerors may have tried and executed him publicly in order to lend legitimacy to their own new regime by "avenging the lawful emperor". [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas]
- Geoffrey of Villehardouin (crusader commander and chronicler): He claimed that most of the crusaders in fact went to the Holy Land; the article considers that he may have deliberately exaggerated in order to improve the image of those who stayed at Constantinople. [Wikipedia: Fourth Crusade]
- Alexios V (his own defence at trial): When tried by the Latins for "treason against his sovereign Alexios IV", he argued in return that Alexios IV, who had brought in foreign armies, was the one guilty of treason. [Wikipedia: Alexios V Doukas]
- Encyclopædia Britannica, 11th edition (cited in the Isaac article): Says he relied on incompetent favourites and spent the revenues of the provinces on building and on lavish gifts to the church. On this basis the article calls him one of the Byzantine rulers generally acknowledged as least successful, though some stress that the problems he faced were beyond his control. [Wikipedia: Isaac II Angelos]
Photos & videos
Portrait of Isaac II, from the series of imperial portraits in the 15th-century manuscript Mutinensis gr. 122. — Unknown Byzantine scribes / Public domain
Portrait of Alexios III (same manuscript): he blinded and supplanted his younger brother in 1195 and fled by night with the treasury in 1203. — Unknown Byzantine scribes / Public domain
Electrum coin struck at Constantinople during the reign of Alexios III (1195–1203), Dumbarton Oaks collection. — Dumbarton Oaks / Public domain
Lead seal of Empress Euphrosyne: the 1195 coup's support within the capital, imprisoned by the restored regime in 1203. — CNG Goins / CC BY-SA 2.5
Portrait of Alexios IV (same manuscript): the son who brought in the crusaders to rescue his father, strangled in February 1204. — Unknown Byzantine scribes / Public domain
The young Alexios at Zara asking the crusaders to take him home and restore his father Isaac (engraving by Francesco Zanotto). — Francesco Zanotto / Public domain
Engraving by Gustave Doré: Doge Dandolo of Venice preaching the crusade. — Gustave Doré / Public domain
Boniface chosen as leader of the crusade at Soissons in 1201 (painted by Henri Decaisne, 1840s). — Henri Decaisne / Public domain
Portrait of Alexios V "Mourtzouphlos" (same manuscript): released from prison by the restored regime, he overthrew Isaac and his son six months later. — Unknown Byzantine scribes / Public domain
Engraving by Doré: Alexios V negotiating with Dandolo in February 1204; the talks broke down, and Alexios IV was killed on about the same day. — 作者未標示(Wikimedia Commons) / Public domainThe Taking of Constantinople, painted by Palma il Giovane: the crusaders break into the city in April 1204. — Palma Le Jeune (1544–1620) / Public domain
Dandolo's tomb inscription in Hagia Sophia (a memorial set up in the 19th century): he died in Constantinople in 1205. — Myrabella / CC BY-SA 3.0