Julian Dunkerton (Julian Dunkerton) — Superdry (formerly SuperGroup) (Superdry)
Julian Dunkerton, co-founder of the British clothing brand Superdry, handed the chief executive post to Euan Sutherland in 2014 and took charge of product and brand himself, resigning as director and leaving on 2018-03-31. The company then issued a string of profit warnings and its share price fell sharply; he publicly criticised the new strategy and on 2019-03-01, with James Holder, requisitioned a general meeting. The board was unanimously opposed, at least ISS and PIRC among the three proxy advisers recommended voting against, and the board stated in advance that if the resolutions passed the directors would resign or not seek re-election. On 2019-04-02 he was elected by the narrow margin of 51.15%; the chairman, chief executive, chief financial officer and chair of the remuneration committee resigned at once that evening, and the other four non-executive directors gave three months' notice and left on 1 July. He was first interim chief executive and was made permanent in 2020-12, but the company went on losing money and delisted in 2024-07.
How they were ousted
The official account is that he resigned as director of his own accord to attend to other businesses; he later said it was because he could not put his name to the company's new strategy. Strictly speaking he was not fired but left after falling out with the board and the chief executive over direction.
How they came back
Holding about 29% together with the other co-founder, James Holder, he requisitioned a general meeting, got himself and Peter Williams elected to the board by 51.15% to 48.85%, and took over as interim chief executive that evening.
What happened to the board
All 8 directors as of 2019-04-02 left: chairman Peter Bamford, chief executive Euan Sutherland, chief financial officer Ed Barker and remuneration committee chair Penny Hughes resigned immediately on the evening of the general meeting; the four non-executive directors Dennis Millard, Minnow Powell, Sarah Wood and John Smith gave three months' notice, effective 2019-07-01. In other words half went on the day he returned and all within three months. It should be noted that these people resigned of their own accord, as they had said publicly beforehand they would, and were not fired by him; and 74% of shareholders other than the founders voted against. Nor did the company improve after his return; in 2024 it avoided insolvency through a restructuring and delisted.
Timeline
- Superdry founded Dunkerton founded Superdry with James Holder and others; before that he had run Cult Clothing since 1985. (The source gives only 2003.) [Wikipedia:Superdry]
- Peter Bamford becomes chairman Preparing to list, the company brought in former Vodafone director Bamford as non-executive chairman. In March of the same year it listed in London at £5 a share. (The source gives only January 2010.) [Retail Week(2010-01,Bamford 出任董事長)] [Wikipedia:Superdry]
- Dunkerton steps down as CEO; Sutherland takes over The company announced that former Co-operative Group CEO Euan Sutherland would take over, with Dunkerton moving to focus on product and brand. [Wikipedia:Superdry] [Wikipedia:Euan Sutherland]
- Dunkerton sells 4 million shares He sold 4 million shares at £12 each, reducing his stake to about 27%. (The source gives only February 2016.) [Wikipedia:Superdry]
- Two new directors added to the board The company announced Dennis Millard as senior independent director and John Smith as non-executive director, effective 2018-02-01. [FashionUnited(2017-12-19)]
- The company changes its name from SuperGroup to Superdry The holding company formally adopted the brand name. [Wikipedia:Superdry]
- The company announces Dunkerton will leave The company said he had informed the board that he would resign as director on 31 March to devote his time to other businesses and charitable work. He still held about 25% of the shares at the time; chairman Bamford said the two had been discussing when he would leave for some time. [Retail Gazette(2018-03-27)]
- Dunkerton resigns as director He formally left the board. A year later he changed his account, saying it had been because he could not endorse the strategy the company was pursuing. [Retail Gazette(2018-03-27)] [City A.M.(2019-03-01 17:05)]
- After the second profit warning, Dunkerton says his return is the only way The company issued its second profit warning in less than two months, with the share price down about 80% from its peak. He told the media there had been a string of wrong decisions over the past year and that his return was the only option for saving the company. (The source gives only mid-December.) (The source gives only December 2018.) [Retail Gazette(2018-12-24)]
- Sky News: Dunkerton preparing to requisition an extraordinary general meeting According to Sky News, citing City sources, he was working with advisers to requisition an extraordinary general meeting to have himself elected back, which could cost the chairman and CEO their jobs. [Retail Gazette(2018-12-24)]
- Dunkerton criticises third-quarter results He called it the worst quarter in the company's 34 years, enough to prove the strategy was wrong. (The source gives only February 2019.) [FashionUnited(2019-04-03)]
- Dunkerton and Holder formally requisition a shareholders' meeting The two, together holding nearly 29%, proposed electing Dunkerton and Boohoo chairman Peter Williams to the board. The board responded that it was unanimously opposed; the company had 21 days to fix the date of the meeting. The share price rose 2.8% that day. [City A.M.(2019-03-01 17:05)] [Superdry 公告:臨時股東會結果(RNS,2019-04-02)]
- The board hits back with a circular and sets the vote for 2 April The circular unanimously recommended rejection and warned that if the resolutions passed, the members of the board would leave. The company said institutional shareholders strongly supported the current plan. In early trading that day the shares fell 1.1% to 516.7 pence. [Proactive Investors(2019-03-11)] [Superdry 公告:臨時股東會結果(RNS,2019-04-02)]
- Proxy adviser ISS recommends voting against ISS considered that part of the company's poor performance was attributable to Dunkerton's own past decisions, and recommended rejecting him and Williams. Dunkerton and Holder issued a joint statement expressing disappointment, saying ISS rarely supports shareholders proposing a change of strategy in any case. [Retail Gazette(2019-03-20)]
- Eve of the vote: PIRC also opposed; only one of the three largest shareholders has declared support Proxy adviser PIRC followed ISS in recommending rejection. Reports said his canvassing had not yet built decisive momentum, with only one of the three largest institutional shareholders in support. Williams stated publicly that if elected he would not be the two founders' representative. [TheIndustry.fashion(2019-03-29)]
- Extraordinary general meeting: 51.15% to 48.85% The meeting was held in the morning at Investec's headquarters on Gresham Street, London. Proxy votes before the meeting stood at about 50.75% in favour; in the end Dunkerton received 34,778,300 votes (51.15%), with 33,216,523 against (48.85%), and Williams's figures were almost identical. Schroders and Investec Asset Management supported him. [Superdry 公告:臨時股東會結果(RNS,2019-04-02)] [Retail Gazette(2019-04-02)] [City A.M.(2019-04-02 18:23)]
- Bamford: 74% of the other shareholders voted against The chairman said in the results announcement that the board accepted the outcome of this narrow majority and would meet the two new directors immediately to deal with what followed. [Superdry 公告:臨時股東會結果(RNS,2019-04-02)]
- That evening four resign immediately and another four give three months' notice Chairman Bamford, CEO Sutherland, CFO Barker and remuneration committee chair Hughes resigned with immediate effect; the four non-executive directors Millard, Powell, Wood and Smith would step down on 1 July. Dunkerton became interim CEO and Williams chairman; brokers UBS and Investec also resigned. (City A.M.'s report was timed 18:23.) [City A.M.(2019-04-02 18:23)] [FashionUnited(2019-04-03)] [Reuters(2019-04-03,Euronews 轉載)]
- Shares fall more than 11% in a day The market's reaction to the overnight exodus of the top team was to sell; the shares had already fallen 64% over the past year. Analysts said short-term turmoil was inevitable and the priority was to find a CFO of sufficient calibre. [Reuters(2019-04-03,Euronews 轉載)]
- The four remaining non-executive directors step down Millard, Powell, Wood and Smith left on the expiry of their notice, completing the departure of the entire former board. [FashionUnited(2019-04-03)]
- The new board begins filling seats The company announced Helen Weir as senior independent director and Alastair Miller as chair of the audit committee, effective 11 July; on 29 July it added Georgina Harvey (chair of the remuneration committee) and Faisal Galaria. [FashionUnited(2019-07-26)]
- Dunkerton becomes permanent CEO His interim contract had run to April 2021; the company made the appointment permanent. It also announced that chairman Williams would step down in 2021 once a successor was found; CFO Nick Gresham had already left in October after only 16 months. [Reuters(2020-12-16,Investing.com 轉載)]
- Peter Sjölander becomes chairman Williams stepped down as chairman and left the board, succeeded by former Helly Hansen CEO Sjölander. [TheIndustry.fashion(2021-04)]
- Annual loss of £148 million The company borrowed on an overdraft facility from Hilco, pursued £35 million of cost savings, and sold its Asia-Pacific brand rights for US$50 million. In September of the same year trading in its shares was briefly suspended because of a delay in the audit. (The source gives only 2023.) [Wikipedia:Superdry]
- Dunkerton says he will not bid for the company He had earlier evaluated buying the whole company, and on this day declared he would not make an offer; Hilco's financing was extended by six months and increased. The two sides turned to other options, such as an equity raise underwritten by him. [Wikipedia:Superdry] [Just Style(2024-07)]
- Superdry delists from the London Stock Exchange Shareholders had earlier approved a restructuring plan including a £10 million equity raise to avoid insolvency. The last day of trading was 12 July, and the delisting took effect at 8 a.m. on 15 July (the source does not state the time zone; the UK was on summer time). [Just Style(2024-07)] [Wikipedia:Superdry]
People
- Julian Dunkerton (Julian Dunkerton), 1965-03-01 — Co-founder and largest shareholder (about 18%); director until 2018-03 (responsible for product and brand). Born in London; moved with his family to Herefordshire at 14, where his father and stepmother ran an organic cider business. At 19 he borrowed £2,000 and founded Cult Clothing with Ian Hibbs (1985), and in 2003 founded Superdry with James Holder and others. Founder. The company listed in London in March 2010; he was chief executive until 2014-10-22 and then became the director for product and brand. Sutherland was the person he handed over to in 2014; Bamford was the chairman brought in before the 2010 listing, and the two worked together for eight years. Holder was the design partner he had met in the Cult Clothing days. Elected director on 2019-04-02 and took over as interim chief executive, becoming permanent chief executive on 2020-12-16. He has continued to lead the company since it delisted on 2024-07-15. [Wikipedia:Julian Dunkerton] [Wikipedia:Superdry] [Superdry 公告:臨時股東會結果(RNS,2019-04-02)] [Reuters(2020-12-16,Investing.com 轉載)]
- James Holder (James Holder) — Co-founder and major shareholder (about 29% together with Dunkerton). Originally ran the skatewear brand Bench; met Dunkerton in the Cult Clothing days, and in 2003 they founded Superdry together, with him responsible for design. Co-founder; no longer on the board at the time of the events. Dunkerton's business partner; on 2019-03-01 the two jointly requisitioned a general meeting, and they issued a joint statement rebutting ISS. Supported Dunkerton's return as a shareholder; no reliable source was found on whether he himself took up a post at the company again. [Wikipedia:Superdry] [City A.M.(2019-03-01 17:05)] [Retail Gazette(2019-03-20)]
- Peter Williams (Peter Williams) — Director candidate nominated by Dunkerton's side (chairman of Boohoo). Former chief executive of Selfridges and chairman of ASOS; at the time of the events chairman of the online clothing retailer Boohoo. Nominated by Dunkerton and Holder, elected on 2019-04-02 with 51.15%, and chosen as chairman that evening. He stated publicly that he had been introduced to Dunkerton only recently through a broker they both knew, and that once elected he would not be the two founders' representative. Served two years as chairman, stepping down and leaving the board on 2021-04-29, succeeded by Peter Sjölander, former chief executive of Helly Hansen. This is an example of "those who helped him back did not stay long either". [TheIndustry.fashion(2019-03-29)] [Superdry 公告:臨時股東會結果(RNS,2019-04-02)] [TheIndustry.fashion(2021-04)] [Reuters(2020-12-16,Investing.com 轉載)]
- Peter Bamford (Peter Bamford), 1954-03-06 — Chairman. Born in London. A director of Vodafone from 1998 to 2006, running the UK and the Northern Europe, Middle East and Africa region, and also chief marketing officer; earlier in retail at WHSmith, Tesco and Kingfisher. Appointed non-executive chairman in January 2010 as the company prepared to list. Worked with Dunkerton for eight years; said publicly in 2018-03 that the two had long been discussing when Dunkerton would leave. In 2019 he led the board in unanimously opposing his return. Resigned immediately on the evening of the general meeting. He has since been a director of other listed companies (sources differ on his current posts). [Wikipedia:Peter Bamford] [Retail Week(2010-01,Bamford 出任董事長)] [Retail Gazette(2018-03-27)] [City A.M.(2019-04-02 18:23)] [Superdry 公告:臨時股東會結果(RNS,2019-04-02)]
- Euan Sutherland (Euan Sutherland), 1969-02-09 — Chief executive. Born in Edinburgh; worked in marketing and retail at Coca-Cola, Mars, Matalan, Currys and Superdrug, and was later chief operating officer of Kingfisher. Became chief executive of the Co-operative Group in 2013-04 and resigned in 2014-03. On 2014-10-22 the company announced that he would succeed Dunkerton as chief executive. The person Dunkerton handed over to; the two later diverged over product design and online strategy, and Dunkerton called his tenure a "disastrous decline". Resigned immediately on the evening of the general meeting after about five years in the job. Chief executive of the Saga group from 2020-01-06, resigning in 2023-11. [Wikipedia:Euan Sutherland] [Wikipedia:Superdry] [Reuters(2019-04-03,Euronews 轉載)] [City A.M.(Saga 任命 Sutherland)] [Retail Gazette(2019-04-02)]
- Ed Barker (Ed Barker) — Chief financial officer. Chief financial officer at the time of the events; no reliable accessible source was found for his education and career. No exact date of appointment was found. Member of the incumbent management team; the board unanimously opposed the resolutions. Resigned immediately on the evening of the general meeting. No reliable source was found for what he did afterwards. [City A.M.(2019-04-02 18:23)] [FashionUnited(2019-04-03)]
- Penny Hughes (Penny Hughes), 1959 — Non-executive director, chair of the remuneration committee. Born in West Kirby, Cheshire; graduated in chemistry from the University of Sheffield. President of Coca-Cola Great Britain and Ireland at 33, she then served on the boards of many companies, including Vodafone, Reuters, the Royal Bank of Scotland (2010–2018) and Morrisons; chair of Aston Martin from 2018-09. No accessible source was found for the date she joined the Superdry board. Independent director; the board unanimously opposed the resolutions. Resigned immediately on the evening of the general meeting. She remained chair of Aston Martin until early 2020 and was chair of The Gym Group until 2022-07. [Wikipedia:Penny Hughes] [City A.M.(2019-04-02 18:23)] [FashionUnited(2019-04-03)]
- Dennis Millard (Dennis Millard) — Senior independent director. At the time of his appointment he was chairman of Halfords and deputy chairman and senior independent director of Pets at Home, a long-serving director of listed retail companies. Announced in 2017-12 and effective 2018-02-01, succeeding Keith Edelman as senior independent director. Joined the board only two months before Dunkerton left. Gave three months' notice on the evening of the general meeting and stepped down on 2019-07-01; stayed on during the transition to help with the handover. [FashionUnited(2017-12-19)] [FashionUnited(2019-04-03)]
- Minnow Powell (Minnow Powell) — Non-executive director. No reliable accessible source was found for education and career. No exact date of appointment was found. Independent director; the board unanimously opposed the resolutions. Gave three months' notice on the evening of the general meeting and stepped down on 2019-07-01. [FashionUnited(2019-04-03)]
- Sarah Wood (Sarah Wood), 1973 — Non-executive director. Born in Newcastle; graduated in English from the University of Cambridge, with a master's in American literature. Co-founded the video advertising platform Unruly in 2006 and sold it to News Corp in 2015. Appointed non-executive director in 2018. Independent director; the board unanimously opposed the resolutions. Gave three months' notice on the evening of the general meeting and stepped down on 2019-07-01. She has since been a non-executive director of Signal AI, Hambro Perks and other companies. [Wikipedia:Sarah Wood (businesswoman)] [FashionUnited(2019-04-03)]
- John Smith (John Smith) — Non-executive director. COO of Burberry until June 2017, specialising in taking brands global and digital. Announced in 2017-12 and effective 2018-02-01; joined the remuneration and audit committees. Joined the board only two months before Dunkerton left. Gave three months' notice on the evening of the general meeting and stepped down on 2019-07-01. [FashionUnited(2017-12-19)] [FashionUnited(2019-04-03)]
Moves to block a return
- The board said it had been in communication with Dunkerton and Holder since March 2018 but unanimously rejected their proposal, saying his return would be counterproductive and cause serious disruption; it also questioned whether Peter Williams, introduced by the two, could independently represent all shareholders. [City A.M.(2019-03-01 17:05)]
- The circular to shareholders unanimously recommended voting down the two resolutions, laid the main blame for the poor sales of the Autumn/Winter 2018 range on Dunkerton, criticised his sales strategy and leadership style, and stated that if the resolutions passed, the directors would resign or not seek re-election. [Proactive Investors(2019-03-11)] [Superdry 公告:臨時股東會結果(RNS,2019-04-02)]
- Before the general meeting the company brought in former Nike executive Phil Dickinson as creative director, in effect filling the product role Dunkerton had held; some shareholders therefore wanted to give the incumbent team more time. (The source does not give the date of the appointment; the date of the report is used here.) [TheIndustry.fashion(2019-03-29)]
- The company continued to stress publicly that his return would be "extremely damaging" to the company and its prospects, and that his strategy would fail and cause division. [TheIndustry.fashion(2019-03-29)] [Retail Gazette(2019-03-20)]
- After the count, chairman Bamford stressed in the results announcement that, excluding Dunkerton and Holder, 74% of the other shareholders had voted against, and that the board was simply accepting the result of a "narrow majority". [Superdry 公告:臨時股東會結果(RNS,2019-04-02)]
Rumors
- Dunkerton is working with advisers to requisition an extraordinary general meeting to have himself elected back to the board. [Later confirmed] Sky News, citing City sources On 2019-03-01 he and Holder formally made the requisition, confirmed by a company announcement. [Retail Gazette(2018-12-24)] [City A.M.(2019-03-01 17:05)] [Superdry 公告:臨時股東會結果(RNS,2019-04-02)]
- Peter Williams is merely a representative planted by the two founders and cannot be independent. [Still unclear] Superdry board statement Williams denied it in writing, saying he had got to know Dunkerton only recently through a broker's introduction. He left in 2021-04 after two years as chairman; there is no objective verdict on whether he was independent. [City A.M.(2019-03-01 17:05)] [TheIndustry.fashion(2019-03-29)] [TheIndustry.fashion(2021-04)]
- If he is elected, the whole board will go. The board gave this warning in its circular; Dunkerton said he did not think all the directors would really resign, and that only one or two too wedded to the current strategy might have to go. [Later confirmed] Superdry board circular; Dunkerton's response to the media On the evening of the meeting four resigned immediately and the other four stepped down on 2019-07-01; all eight left. [Proactive Investors(2019-03-11)] [Retail Gazette(2019-04-02)] [City A.M.(2019-04-02 18:23)] [FashionUnited(2019-04-03)]
- Superdry's sales have plunged and it may be heading for insolvency proceedings. [Proven false] Retail trade media reports at the end of January 2024 (the Wikipedia article cites RetailDetail and Sky News) The company ultimately avoided insolvency through a restructuring plan plus an equity raise, but at the price of delisting. [Wikipedia:Superdry] [Just Style(2024-07)]
- Dunkerton will bid to buy the whole company. [Proven false] The takeover evaluation of early 2024 (earliest source not found) On 2024-03-28 he made clear he would not bid, turning instead to an equity raise. [Wikipedia:Superdry] [Just Style(2024-07)]
Views
- Peel Hunt (broker): Could see no sign that he had won the support of the large institutional shareholders, who seemed still to stand by the current strategy and management team. [Proactive Investors(2019-03-11)]
- ISS (proxy voting adviser): Besides industry headwinds and a warm winter, the company's poor performance also had company-specific causes, some of which stemmed from decisions taken jointly by management at the time and Dunkerton; it therefore recommended voting against. [Retail Gazette(2019-03-20)]
- Julian Dunkerton and James Holder (co-founders): Disappointed by the recommendation; considered the failure of the company's strategy and leadership to be clear, and that they knew how to put it right. [Retail Gazette(2019-03-20)]
- Industry observers (as reported by TheIndustry.fashion): Some thought he was the person best able to fix the problems; others thought his public warfare had hurt the company, and that some of the product and strategy problems he criticised had arisen while he was still there. [TheIndustry.fashion(2019-03-29)]
- Chas Howes (former Superdry CFO, shareholder): Accused the incumbent leadership at the meeting of looking only to their own interests and not the company's. [City A.M.(2019-04-02 18:23)]
- Peter Bamford (chairman): The board was unanimously opposed to the two resolutions, and 74% of shareholders other than the founders were also opposed; but overall a narrow majority was in favour, and the board accepted that. [Superdry 公告:臨時股東會結果(RNS,2019-04-02)]
- Kate Heseltine (analyst, Edison Investment): The resignations are only the tip of the iceberg of the change needed; the truly difficult work of rebuilding starts now. [Reuters(2019-04-03,Euronews 轉載)]
- Peel Hunt analysts: More worried that heads of retail operations would be next to leave; finding a CFO of sufficient calibre is the first priority. [Reuters(2019-04-03,Euronews 轉載)]
- Roger Lawson (UK Individual Shareholders Society, ShareSoc): Hard to say how shareholders should have voted, but the company certainly needed change; he cited Paul Scott of Stockopedia as thinking it reasonable to bring the founder back, while he himself wondered whether the brand had gone out of fashion and would be in no hurry to buy. [ShareSoc(Roger Lawson,2019-04)]
- Alice Price (analyst, GlobalData): The company's results have been weak for years, and its recent difficulties are no surprise. (The source gives only July 2024.) [Just Style(2024-07)]
Photos & videos
Julian Dunkerton, June 2014; in October of that year he handed the CEO role to Sutherland. — Wendy Gage / CC BY-SA 4.0
Euan Sutherland, official photograph from 2013 when he was CEO of the Co-operative Group in the UK; he took charge of Superdry the following year. — The Co-operative / CC BY 2.0
Superdry's flagship store on Regent Street, London, December 2014. — Christine Matthews / CC BY-SA 2.0Superdry flags outside the Regent Street flagship store, late 2011, around the time the share price was at its post-listing peak. — Alibearoly / CC BY 3.0
Superdry store on The Headrow, Leeds, July 2010, four months after the company listed. — Betty Longbottom / CC BY-SA 2.0
Superdry tops in a store, April 2017; product design was at the heart of the dispute between Dunkerton and Sutherland's team. — Tiia Monto / CC BY-SA 4.0
A Superdry store in London, August 2018, the year the company began issuing profit warnings after Dunkerton left the board. — Tiia Monto / CC BY-SA 3.0
Superdry store on Petty Cury, Cambridge, 3 May 2019, a month after Dunkerton returned as interim CEO. — Hugh Venables / CC BY-SA 2.0- Julian Dunkerton, as CEO and co-founder, on Superdry's future, craftsmanship and culture (official brand video) (Superdry India)
- Interview with Superdry CEO Julian Dunkerton by Punchline, the Gloucestershire local business media outlet (Punchline TV)
- Julian Dunkerton at the opening of the new store on the Promenade, Cheltenham (Punchline TV)