Ma Chien-yung (Ma Chien-yung) — Solar Applied Materials Technology (Solar Applied Materials, TPEx-listed, stock code 1785) (Solar Applied Materials Technology)
Solar Applied Materials, a major sputtering target maker, held a board meeting on 2021-11-05. Hung Pen-chan, a director on the management side, tabled an extraordinary proposal to hold an extraordinary shareholders' meeting at the end of the year for an early re-election of the board; the side of the largest shareholder, TSG (Taiwan Steel Group), promptly reassigned the representative of the corporate director Yu Jing to TSG chairman Wang Chiung-fen and, by 5 to 4, removed chairman Ma Chien-yung and elected Wang Chiung-fen in his place, creating "twin chairmen". The two sides sued each other, each had an independent director convene an extraordinary shareholders' meeting, and each petitioned the court to bar the other from holding its meeting; the Commercial Court barred both, while the Ministry of Economic Affairs refused to register the change of chairman. In early 2022 the two sides settled: TSG sold its stake to allies of the management side at about NT$50 per share, and on March 8 the three directors and two independent directors on the TSG side resigned together. But Ma Chien-yung did not stay in the seat for long as a result: after the board re-election at the shareholders' meeting of 2022-05-31 he handed the chairmanship to Huang Chi-feng and became honorary chairman and chief technology officer; on September 27 he resigned from those two posts as well, and in October he publicly apologised to TSG.
How they were ousted
As the board meeting was about to end, the TSG (Taiwan Steel Group) side abruptly replaced the representative of the corporate director Yu Jing with Wang Chiung-fen to make up five seats, removed him as chairman by 5 to 4 on an extraordinary motion, and elected Wang Chiung-fen as his successor on the spot.
How they came back
He did not recognise the resolution, and the company continued to be run by the existing team as usual; on 2021-12-20 the Ministry of Economic Affairs found that removal by extraordinary motion did not comply with the rules and refused to register the change, so the registered chairman was him throughout. In March 2022 all five directors on the TSG side resigned; he served out his term, and after the shareholders' meeting of 2022-05-31 he himself handed the chairmanship to the president, Huang Chi-feng.
What happened to the board
There were 9 directors at the time of the event, or 8 excluding Ma Chien-yung. The 5 on the TSG side (TSG's representative Lin Hui-cheng, Yu Jing's representative Wang Chiung-fen, Rong Ren Culture and Arts Foundation's representative Huang Chun-yi, plus independent directors Fang Chen-ming and Wu Mei-hui) all resigned on the same day, 2022-03-08, about four months after the removal vote. But they were not purged by Ma Chien-yung: after the two sides settled, TSG sold its shares and exited of its own accord, and the media cited people familiar with the matter as estimating that TSG made a profit of about NT$1.24 billion on the deal. On the management side, Huang Chi-feng and Hung Pen-chan stayed on, and Huang Chi-feng went on to become chairman; by contrast, Wu Chang-po, the independent director who backed Ma Chien-yung, was sued by the Securities and Futures Investors Protection Center for pressing ahead with an extraordinary shareholders' meeting in defiance of the court injunction; the Commercial Court ordered his removal in a judgment on 2023-04-07, and the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal on 2024-11-14. Ma Chien-yung himself gave up the chairmanship less than three months after TSG's exit and left management four months after that.
Timeline
- Eighth board takes office: six directors plus three independent directors The annual shareholders' meeting elected six directors, Ma Chien-yung, Huang Chi-feng, Sheng Yuan Investment (Hung Pen-chan), Rong Ren Culture and Arts Foundation (Huang Chun-yi), Taiwan Steel (Lin Hui-cheng) and Yu Jing, and three independent directors, Wu Chang-po, Wu Mei-hui and Fang Chen-ming. These were the nine seats caught up in the removal vote two years later. [鉅亨網:108 年股東常會改選公告(2019-06-28)]
- Ma Chien-yung sounds out Hsieh Yu-min about the following year's election and gets no clear answer While reporting on the business, Ma Chien-yung raised the allocation of seats in the 2022 board election; Hsieh Yu-min said afterwards that he had replied that the election was still a long way off and asked the management team to discuss it first. Ma Chien-yung, for his part, said the other side gave no direct reply and he sensed trouble, and that he later heard from a TSG-faction director that TSG wanted five seats and would give him only four. [今周刊 1301 期(2021-11-24)] [鏡週刊(2022-10,馬堅勇專訪之二)]
- Solar Applied Materials and Hsin Chuang Environmental sign a supplementary agreement to the land contract The transfer of the Liuying land, sold under a contract signed on 2018-11-09, had still not been completed by the deadline, and the two parties signed a first supplementary agreement extending it. The TSG side later said this agreement had not gone through the board and was not disclosed in the financial statements, and used this as the grounds for removal; the management side said the board had given Ma Chien-yung full authority to handle the matter in 2018. [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-11-18)] [鉅亨網(2021-11-09)]
- Company issues a material information announcement that evening: "new chairman Wang Chiung-fen" The announcement said Ma Chien-yung had agreed to extend the termination deadline of the Hsin Chuang Environmental contract without a board resolution and had not disclosed it to the certifying accountants, so that the second- and third-quarter financial statements were at risk of containing false statements or concealment. On the same day Wu Chang-po, the independent director on the management side, sent a letter saying he would convene an extraordinary shareholders' meeting on December 27. [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-11-05)] [智慧財產及商業法院 110 年度商暫字第 7 號裁定(2021-12-08)]
- Board meeting opens; the agenda is the business report and third-quarter financial statements The meeting began at 1 p.m. The original agenda contained no election and no item on the chairmanship. [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)]
- Ma Chien-yung removed 5 to 4; Wang Chiung-fen elected chairman The TSG side proposed replacing the chairman on the grounds of doubts over the financial statement disclosure of the Liuying land contract; the motion passed 5 to 4, after which Wang Chiung-fen was elected, likewise 5 to 4, and the company seals were obtained. Ma Chien-yung said at the meeting that he would leave and had no objection. [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)] [自由財經(2021-11-07)]
- Hung Pen-chan's extraordinary motion: hold an extraordinary shareholders' meeting on December 27 for a full re-election After the agenda items had been discussed, Hung Pen-chan, a director on the management side, suddenly proposed an early re-election of all nine directors at the end of the year. Huang Chun-yi, a director on the TSG side, and independent director Wu Mei-hui questioned on the spot whether this could be raised as an extraordinary motion, and asked for a recess and for Wang Chiung-fen to be brought in. [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)]
- Wang Chiung-fen arrives; Yu Jing's representative is changed on the spot The TSG side produced a reassignment letter from corporate director Yu Jing, changing its representative from Ching Cho-ying, who was attending by video, to Wang Chiung-fen, and demanded that Ching Cho-ying log off. The TSG side thereby went from four seats to five, leaving the management side with four. Wang Chiung-fen later admitted that the reassignment letter had been prepared in advance. [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)]
- Management side issues a material information announcement reversing course: the removal is invalid and Ma Chien-yung is still chairman The management side argued that removing the chairman by extraordinary motion violated Article 3, Paragraph 4 of the Regulations Governing Procedure for Board of Directors Meetings of Public Companies, and also questioned the legality of Yu Jing's reassignment (the Liberty Times finance section records it as a material information announcement of November 6). On the same day Wang Chiung-fen issued a press release saying he would sue Ma Chien-yung for false financial reporting and special breach of trust. [鏡週刊(2021-11-08)] [自由財經(2021-11-07)]
- Wang Chiung-fen is stopped by more than a hundred employees on entering the company; the TSG side holds a board meeting off-site instead Wang Chiung-fen brought a group to the company early in the morning; employees formed a human wall and chanted "You are not the chairman, Ma Chien-yung is". The TSG side held a board meeting outside the company, resolving to remove Ma Chien-yung as chief executive officer, replace the president and the heads of finance and accounting, and separately set an extraordinary shareholders' meeting for December 27. The share price fell nearly 7% intraday that day. [鏡週刊(2021-11-08)] [智慧財產及商業法院 110 年度商暫字第 7 號裁定(2021-12-08)]
- Management side: the seals were handed over by mistake in the confusion; Yu Jing: the reassignment was notarised The management side said in the evening that it had contacted Gerald, Yu Jing's sole shareholder, that the representative was still Ching Cho-ying, and that on November 5 an employee had mistakenly handed over the company's main seal and key in the confusion. Yu Jing issued a press release saying the reassignment was carried out in accordance with the Company Act and notarised, and was received that day by Ma Chien-yung and confirmed by the lawyers present. [鏡週刊(2021-11-08)]
- Ma Chien-yung's press conference: I am the chairman, and TSMC is watching closely Ma Chien-yung held a press conference together with president Huang Chi-feng and chief financial officer Chen Tse-hui, saying that both the TSG side's reassignment of the representative and the removal by extraordinary motion had procedural problems, and asking in return whether the other side had the talent, technology, team and customers. On the same day Wu Mei-hui announced the convening of an extraordinary shareholders' meeting on December 24, and Yu Jing filed its application with the Ministry of Economic Affairs to register the change of chairman. [鉅亨網(2021-11-09)] [自由財經(2021-12-20)] [智慧財產及商業法院 110 年度商暫字第 7 號裁定(2021-12-08)]
- Employees gather at the main gate and make a video backing Ma Chien-yung Employees gathered at the company gate holding cardboard signs reading "Defend Solar" and "Reject TSG" and released a video. On the same day the announcement of Wu Chang-po's December 27 extraordinary shareholders' meeting went up on the Market Observation Post System, a day later than Wu Mei-hui's announcement. [自由財經(2021-11-10)] [智慧財產及商業法院 110 年度商暫字第 7 號裁定(2021-12-08)]
- Wang Chiung-fen produces a recording of the board meeting: he was removed because he was unfit for the job Wang Chiung-fen held a press conference, saying Ma Chien-yung had been removed because he was unfit for the job yet was clinging to the chairman's seat; he also said TSG had never at any point sought to seize control and had always supported Ma Chien-yung's team, and that it was the other side that suddenly wanted to hold an extraordinary shareholders' meeting. [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)]
- The two sides' independent directors each petition the court to bar the other's meeting Wu Chang-po petitioned the Intellectual Property and Commercial Court for a preliminary injunction maintaining a temporary status quo, to bar Wu Mei-hui from convening the December 24 extraordinary shareholders' meeting; TSG likewise petitioned to bar Wu Chang-po from holding the December 27 meeting. [鏡週刊(2021-11-15)]
- Wang Chiung-fen goes to the Taipei District Prosecutors Office to file a complaint and rejects the "vulture" label After holding a press conference Wang Chiung-fen went to the Taipei District Prosecutors Office to file a complaint, describing Solar Applied Materials as being like TSG's godson; he also asserted that Solar Applied Materials was able to enter TSMC's supply chain thanks to the copper alloy targets developed by Fuda Aerospace, a TSG group company. Mirror Media separately reported that TSG had filed complaints against Ma Chien-yung for false financial reporting and special breach of trust, and that Ma Chien-yung had counter-sued the other side for forgery of documents and defamation. [NOWnews(2021-11-19)] [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)]
- Ma Chien-yung hits back with his lawyers: Yu Jing was not nominated, and Wang Chiung-fen is not a director The management side's lawyers said that the person put forward at the November 5 meeting was Wang Chiung-fen as an individual, not the corporate director Yu Jing, and that he personally is not a director, yet the minutes were afterwards changed to record Yu Jing as having been elected. Ma Chien-yung said Fuda was merely doing contract work on Solar Applied Materials' instructions, and called TSG's claims unprofessional, unethical and unbelievable. [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-11-18)]
- Management side announces the "automatic removal" of independent director Wu Mei-hui Solar Applied Materials announced that Wu Mei-hui did not meet Article 3, Paragraph 1, Subparagraph 5 of the independent director regulations and was automatically removed, with her positions on the audit and remuneration committees terminated at the same time. Wu Mei-hui issued a statement saying she held no position at any corporate shareholder holding 5% or more or ranking among the top five; Wang Chiung-fen said the removal of an independent director was not for Ma Chien-yung to decide. [中央社(2021-11-19)] [今周刊 1301 期(2021-11-24)]
- Legislators denounce "stock market vultures" in the Legislative Yuan and name TSG Democratic Progressive Party legislator Wu Ping-jui said a certain group was intervening in the control of listed companies by buying up proxies on a large scale and borrowing from state-owned banks against pledged shares, which amounted to being a stock market vulture; Kuo Kuo-wen, a legislator from the same party, directly named TSG, which had intervened in Solar Applied Materials. Wang Chiung-fen responded that pledging shares is a legal and reasonable way of financing. [今周刊(數位時代轉載,2021-11-25)]
- UMC affiliate Fortune Venture Capital and TXC send letters backing the incumbent team Fortune Venture Capital said it is a shareholder and that Solar Applied Materials is an important supplier to the UMC group, and that it feared a sudden change in the management team would affect quality, supply and R&D; TXC also sent a letter saying it was puzzled and uneasy about the dispute and hoped the existing team would keep running the company. [中央社(科技新報轉載,2021-11-24)]
- Candidates for the extraordinary shareholders' meeting announced: 11 director and 7 independent director candidates compete for 9 seats The Taiwan Steel Group (TSG) side nominated Wang Chiung-fen, Lin Hui-cheng, Huang Chun-yi and Wu Po-cheng (all as representatives of Taiwan Steel), among others; the management side nominated Ma Chien-yung, Huang Chi-feng, Hung Pen-chan, Pu Pin, Huang Ming-shan and Chung Yi-huan, and put forward Wang Sen-jung, Wu Chang-po and Kao Feng-chi as independent directors. [中央社(2021-11-26)]
- Commercial court bars both sides: neither the December 24 nor the December 27 extraordinary shareholders' meeting may be held The court found that neither side had explained what unlawful conduct or dereliction of duty the sitting directors had committed, that their term would expire on 2022-06-27 anyway, and that it could see no necessity or urgency for an early re-election; the two independent directors each calling a meeting without first reaching a consensus in the audit committee would leave shareholders not knowing which to follow. The ruling also mentioned letters submitted by customers including TSMC, UMC affiliate Fortune Venture Capital and ChipMOS. [智慧財產及商業法院 110 年度商暫字第 7 號裁定(2021-12-08)] [自由財經(2022-01-13)]
- Hsieh Yu-min in an interview: I have no interest in management control; if the wedding is off, the deposit can at least be refunded Interviewed at D-Link headquarters, Hsieh Yu-min revealed that the two sides had met twice in Taipei between late November and early December: TSG demanded to be able to exit at a profit and to have its name cleared, while the management side was only willing to take over the original stake of about 8% at market price, so the talks stalled. [鏡週刊(2021-12,謝裕民專訪全文)]
- The court's enforcement order cannot be delivered to Wu Chang-po Mirror Media reported that Wu Chang-po had moved house and that, as of this day, none of the enforcement orders mailed by the court had been received by anyone. A Securities and Futures Bureau official said that if the meeting were held anyway despite the court's ban, the extraordinary shareholders' meeting would have no effect even if held. [鏡週刊(2021-12-20)]
- Ministry of Economic Affairs refuses the change of registration: the procedure for removing the chairman did not comply with the rules After twice writing to the Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC) for its opinion, the Ministry of Economic Affairs refused registration under Article 388 of the Company Act. Its reasoning was that the grounds for removal involved alleged false financial statements, yet the November 5 board meeting neither sought expert opinion nor held any discussion, so it was hard to find any sudden emergency or legitimate reason for handling the matter by extempore motion, and the defect could not be cured. The management side called it justice being served, and TSG said it would file an administrative appeal; on the same day Wu Mei-hui said she would not appeal the court ruling and would not hold the December 24 meeting. [自由財經(2021-12-20)] [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-12-20)]
- Wu Chang-po holds the extraordinary shareholders' meeting anyway; the meeting resolves to adjourn to January 3 The meeting was scheduled to start at 2 p.m., with attendance of 62.43%. Court personnel came to read out the enforcement order, and the stock transfer agent had also stopped handling shareholder services before the meeting; the TSG side's team of lawyers was present, shareholders shouted, and a clash nearly broke out. Wu Chang-po chaired by video link and, on the ground that an appeal had been filed, proposed an adjournment, to which 85.11% of the shares present agreed. [中央社(2021-12-27)] [最高法院 112 年度台上字第 1752 號裁定(2024-11-14)]
- Investors Protection Center strongly condemns: this meeting is invalid The Securities and Futures Investors Protection Center (SFIPC) said that when it arrived staff were already counting votes, the chair was nowhere to be seen in the venue, and both shareholders and the SFIPC were obstructed when they tried to speak, with the adjournment finally announced by the master of ceremonies. It considered the meeting invalid and the adjournment resolution unlawful, demanded that the January 3 meeting be called off, and said it would assess filing a lawsuit. [工商時報(2021-12-28)]
- Court issues another emergency measure, banning the January 3 meeting as well The commercial court issued an emergency-measure ruling. Solar Applied Materials said in a material information announcement that if the Supreme Court had not set aside the original ruling before January 3, the extraordinary shareholders' meeting would not be held. [匯流新聞網(Yam 轉載,2021-12-30)]
- Court rejects minority shareholders' petition; Wu Mei-hui's status as independent director is unaffected Minority shareholders petitioned to bar Wu Mei-hui from exercising her powers as an independent director, and the commercial court rejected it: it could not find that she was a director, supervisor or employee of TSG, nor could it see that her staying in office would cause concrete harm to the company; her questioning of the agreement and the financial statements at board meetings fell within an independent director's supervisory duties. [鉅亨網(2022-01-04)]
- Supreme Court rejects Wu Chang-po's appeal; the ruling banning the meeting becomes final The Supreme Court held that an independent director cannot exercise the supplementary power to convene meetings at any time on the basis of subjective opinion alone, as that would hinder the company's normal operations. [自由財經(2022-01-13)]
- Taipei Exchange fines Solar Applied Materials NT$500,000 in penalties Two grounds: failing to publish within the deadline the material information that the court had banned the two extraordinary shareholders' meetings; and then, on December 27, issuing a material information announcement saying the extraordinary shareholders' meeting had resolved to adjourn, which amounted to publishing information that was not yet settled and did not match the facts. [工商時報(2022-01-20)]
- A settlement surfaces: Sen Ju's board resolves to sign a letter of intent to buy TSG's stake The two sides agreed a settlement before the Lunar New Year. Sen Ju subsequently explained in stages that it would acquire, at NT$50 per share, the 40,000 lots (40 million shares) of Solar Applied Materials stock held by TSG affiliate E-Sheng Steel; because these privately placed shares were locked up until November, they would first be placed in trust and then taken up by other shareholders such as Jentech and Topco Scientific. People familiar with the matter estimated that TSG's original acquisition cost was nearly NT$19 per share, for a profit of about NT$1.24 billion. [自由財經(2022-02-21)] [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)]
- Solar Applied Materials reverses itself: confirms Yu Jing reassigned its seat to Wang Chiung-fen on November 5 The company said in a material information announcement that, after clarifying with Yu Jing's shareholder Gerald, it confirmed that Yu Jing had changed its representative to Wang Chiung-fen on 2021-11-05. This amounted to withdrawing the management side's earlier claim that "Yu Jing made no reassignment." [自由財經(2022-02-14)]
- Ma Chien-yung on the grand settlement: both sides showed the utmost sincerity Ma Chien-yung did not comment on the details of the deal, saying only that the two sides were moving toward the greatest common ground and that past arguments were in the past. The report also mentioned that TSMC had signed a five-year long-term contract with Solar Applied Materials running to 2026. [自由財經(2022-02-21)]
- Investors Protection Center sues to remove independent director Wu Chang-po The SFIPC filed suit in the commercial court under Article 10-1 of the Securities Investor and Futures Trader Protection Act. Mirror Media said this was the first time the SFIPC had brought a removal suit against an independent director in a fight over management control; if it succeeded, Wu Chang-po would be barred from serving as a director or supervisor of a listed or OTC-listed company for three years. [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)]
- Five TSG-side directors resign on the same day The three corporate directors, Taiwan Steel, Yu Jing and the Rong Ren Culture and Arts Foundation, plus independent directors Fang Chen-ming and Wu Mei-hui, resigned citing busy schedules. Wang Chiung-fen said TSG had obeyed the law throughout, had subscribed to a capital increase by invitation rather than buying shares on the market, and that it was the management side that launched the first surprise attack. [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)]
- FSC to amend the rules: removing a chairman by extempore motion will not be allowed The Taipei Times reported that the FSC would amend the Regulations Governing Procedure for Board of Directors Meetings of Public Companies to prohibit proposing the removal of a chairman by extempore motion, with violators liable to fines of NT$240,000 to NT$4.8 million and the Ministry of Economic Affairs also refusing registration; the report cited Solar Applied Materials directly as the example. Taiwanese media dubbed it the "Solar Applied Materials clause." [Taipei Times(2022-05-04)] [鏡週刊(2022-10,馬堅勇專訪之二)]
- Shareholders' meeting re-elects the whole board; Ma Chien-yung hands over the chairmanship The new board has nine seats: Huang Chi-feng, Ma Chien-yung, Jentech founder Chao Yung-chang, Sheng Yuan Investment representative Hung Pen-chan, Sen Chi representatives Cheng Yu-cheng and Li Yun-fang, and independent directors Tung Chun-hung, Kao Feng-chi and Ting Tse-hsiang. At the board meeting afterwards, on Ma Chien-yung's nomination, Huang Chi-feng was elected chairman, and Ma Chien-yung became honorary chairman (and concurrently chief technology officer). [中央社(2022-05-31)] [自由財經(2022-09-28)]
- Ma Chien-yung resigns late at night as honorary chairman and chief technology officer Solar Applied Materials issued a material information announcement in the evening saying Ma Chien-yung had resigned for personal career planning reasons, effective immediately, while remaining a director. He said he had completed his mission for this stage, that he held no shares himself and the stability of the shareholding had to be faced squarely, and so he was handing over to Huang Chi-feng, who does hold shares. [自由財經(2022-09-28)] [鏡週刊(2022-10,馬堅勇專訪之二)]
- Share price hits limit-down intraday, closes down 9.85% Solar Applied Materials closed at NT$29.3, its lowest in more than two years. Ma Chien-yung appealed to investors, saying that although he was no longer chief technology officer he was still a director. [鏡週刊(2022-10,全文)]
- Ma Chien-yung publicly apologizes to TSG; Wang Chiung-fen: justice delayed Ma Chien-yung said the battle for management control had been triggered by his misunderstanding of TSG, and apologized for having described TSG as a vulture; after the Mid-Autumn Festival he had already called on Hsieh Yu-min in person to apologize. Mirror Media reported that the two sides' lawsuit in the Intellectual Property and Commercial Court had held two hearings, and that the judge had suggested Solar Applied Materials and Ma Chien-yung apologize. [ETtoday 財經雲(2022-10-05)] [鏡週刊(2022-10,馬堅勇專訪之一)]
- Commercial court rules to remove Wu Chang-po from his directorship In judgment 2022 (ROC year 111) Shang-Su-Zi No. 4, the Intellectual Property and Commercial Court ordered his removal under Article 10-1 of the Securities Investor and Futures Trader Protection Act. The court found that he convened an extraordinary shareholders' meeting when there was no need to, and that he obstructed service of the ruling and the enforcement order and insisted on holding the meeting and a vote even after court personnel had announced the order. [最高法院 112 年度台上字第 1752 號裁定(2024-11-14)]
- Supreme Court rejects the appeals of Solar Applied Materials and Wu Chang-po In ruling 2023 (ROC year 112) Tai-Shang-Zi No. 1752, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal as not meeting the legal requirements. By this time Solar Applied Materials' legal representative was Huang Chi-feng, and the company and Wu Chang-po were co-appellants. [最高法院 112 年度台上字第 1752 號裁定(2024-11-14)]
- Solar Applied Materials holds another re-election; chairman changes from Huang Chi-feng to Cheng Hsien-sung The shareholders' meeting re-elected all directors, and afterwards Cheng Hsien-sung, chairman of subsidiary Chuang Ju, was chosen as the new chairman, while outgoing chairman Huang Chi-feng continued as president. The report did not mention Ma Chien-yung. [經濟日報(聯合新聞網,2026-05-25)]
People
- Ma Chien-yung (Ma Chien-yung) — Chairman and chief executive officer. From a technical background; served in his early years at the National Chung-Shan Institute of Science and Technology (NCSIST), and by his own account spent about twenty years in defence technology. Joined Solar Applied Materials in 2007; the media call him "Dr. Ma". Mirror Media reported in October 2022 that he was then 65; he himself says he holds no Solar Applied Materials shares (the 2019 election announcement recorded 346,700 shares). Recruited into the company by founder Chen Li-ho. In 2016 Solar Applied Materials was hit by incidents including employees stealing and selling gold and false accounting, and trading in its shares was suspended for a time; the creditor banks asked him to become chairman and clean up the situation. It was during his tenure that TSG became the largest shareholder, through Gloria Material Technology's holding and by subscribing to capital increases and private placements; in the two fights for control in 2018 and 2019, he kept his position only because TSG group chairman Hsieh Yu-min stepped in to mediate. In July 2021 he sounded out Hsieh Yu-min about the allocation of seats in the following year's election and did not get a clear answer, and the relationship between the two sides changed from then on. The removal was not recognised by the competent authority and he served out his term; after the shareholders' meeting of 2022-05-31 he nominated Huang Chi-feng to take over as chairman and himself became honorary chairman and chief technology officer; on 2022-09-27 he resigned from both posts, remaining only a director. On 2022-10-05 he publicly apologised to TSG and Hsieh Yu-min. When he later stepped down as a director could not be found. [鏡週刊(2022-10,全文)] [自由財經(2022-09-28)] [中央社(2022-05-31)] [鉅亨網:108 年股東常會改選公告(2019-06-28)] [ETtoday 財經雲(2022-10-05)]
- Wang Chiung-fen (Wang Chiung-fen) — Chairman of Taiwan Steel; from 2021-11-05 the representative of corporate director Yu Jing Co., Ltd., elected chairman of Solar Applied Materials by the TSG side. A lawyer by background; Mirror Media described him as a trusted right-hand man of TSG group chairman Hsieh Yu-min, and reports also referred to him as chairman of Gloria Material Technology. Not originally a director of Solar Applied Materials. He arrived as the 2021-11-05 board meeting was about to end; the TSG side produced Yu Jing's reassignment letter, he replaced Ching Cho-ying as Yu Jing's representative, and was promptly elected chairman. Handled the investment in and negotiations with Solar Applied Materials on Hsieh Yu-min's behalf. After the removal vote he and Ma Chien-yung each held press conferences trading accusations, and he filed a complaint against Ma Chien-yung for false financial reporting and special breach of trust. The Ministry of Economic Affairs did not register him as chairman. After the two sides settled, Yu Jing's board seat was resigned on 2022-03-08. When Ma Chien-yung apologised in 2022-10, he responded as chairman of Taiwan Steel that this was "justice delayed". [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)] [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)] [自由財經(2022-02-14)] [ETtoday 財經雲(2022-10-05)]
- Hsieh Yu-min (Hsieh Yu-min) — Group chairman of TSG (Taiwan Steel Group); not himself on the Solar Applied Materials board. Second generation in the steel industry, who once carried NT$8.5 billion in debt before turning things around. The TSG group includes several listed steel companies such as Gloria Material Technology, Chiu Yang and Chun Yu, and in recent years has taken control of Taiwan Styrene Monomer and D-Link in succession. Mirror Media reported in December 2021 that he was then 65. After taking over Gloria Material Technology, TSG acquired the Solar Applied Materials stake along with it; in Solar Applied Materials' several subsequent cash capital increases and private placements, he said he would subscribe to any shortfall. The TSG side held more than 8% through E-Sheng Steel, making it the largest corporate shareholder. In 2018 founder Chen Li-ho wanted to come back and fight for control, and in 2019 the foreign investor Gerald wanted to gain control; both times he mediated, which is how Ma Chien-yung kept the chairmanship. Ma Chien-yung normally reported to him regularly on the business. Decided in January 2022 to sell the shares and exit, and the five directors on the TSG side resigned on March 8; he said he would rather use the profit to set up a professional baseball team. After the 2022 Mid-Autumn Festival Ma Chien-yung called on him to apologise; he said he could understand, but that the affair had done great damage to TSG. [鏡週刊(2021-12,謝裕民專訪全文)] [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)] [鏡週刊(2022-10,全文)] [自由財經(2021-12-20)]
- Lin Hui-cheng (Lin Hui-cheng) — Director (representative of Taiwan Steel Co., Ltd.). The experience recorded in the 2019 election announcement was chairman of Chun Yu Works, a TSG group company. Elected a director of the eighth board at the annual shareholders' meeting in June 2019 as the representative of Taiwan Steel. The TSG side's fixed seat on the board. He was also on the slate of directors TSG nominated for the extraordinary shareholders' meeting in November 2021. Taiwan Steel's board seat was resigned on 2022-03-08; the stated reason was a heavy workload. [鉅亨網:108 年股東常會改選公告(2019-06-28)] [中央社(2021-11-26)] [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)]
- Huang Chun-yi (Huang Chun-yi) — Director (representative of the Rong Ren Culture and Arts Foundation). The experience recorded in the 2019 election announcement was president of Jin Zhi Fu Asset Management. Elected at the annual shareholders' meeting in June 2019 as the representative of the Rong Ren Culture and Arts Foundation. Mirror Media listed him as a TSG-faction director; at the 2021-11-05 board meeting, when Hung Pen-chan tabled the extraordinary motion for an extraordinary shareholders' meeting, he questioned the procedure on the spot. The Rong Ren Culture and Arts Foundation's board seat was resigned on 2022-03-08. [鉅亨網:108 年股東常會改選公告(2019-06-28)] [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)] [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)]
- Wu Mei-hui (Wu Mei-hui) — Independent director; member of the audit committee and the remuneration committee. The experience recorded in the 2019 election announcement was president of the alumni association of Ming Chuan University's School of Communication. Elected an independent director at the annual shareholders' meeting in June 2019. At the 2021-11-05 board meeting she questioned Ma Chien-yung's agreement with Hsin Chuang Environmental and the financial statement disclosure; on November 9 she announced the convening of an extraordinary shareholders' meeting on December 24. The management side alleged that she had described herself as chief of staff of the TSG group and accompanied Wang Chiung-fen at a press conference, and so lacked independence; she denied holding any position at any of TSG's top five corporate shareholders. On 2021-11-19 the management side announced her "automatic removal", but on 2022-01-04 the Commercial Court dismissed a minority shareholder's petition to have her suspended from exercising her duties, finding that she could not be determined to be a director, supervisor or employee of TSG. She complied with the court injunction and did not hold the December 24 meeting, and resigned on 2022-03-08. [中央社(2021-11-19)] [鉅亨網(2022-01-04)] [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)] [鉅亨網:108 年股東常會改選公告(2019-06-28)]
- Fang Chen-ming (Fang Chen-ming) — Independent director. Legal background; the experience recorded in the 2019 election announcement was chief legal officer of Mao Hong Electric Power. Elected an independent director at the annual shareholders' meeting in June 2019. He was on the slate of independent directors the TSG side nominated for the extraordinary shareholders' meeting in November 2021 (Wu Mei-hui, by contrast, was not nominated); Mirror Media listed him as one of the two TSG-faction independent directors who resigned. Resigned on 2022-03-08 together with the other four on the TSG side. [中央社(2021-11-26)] [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)] [鉅亨網:108 年股東常會改選公告(2019-06-28)]
- Wu Chang-po (Wu Chang-po) — Independent director. Retired as manager of the Hsinchu branch of Taiwan Cooperative Bank; also served as an independent director of Taimide Tech, resigning in March 2022. Elected an independent director at the annual shareholders' meeting in June 2019. Regarded as the management side's independent director. On 2021-11-05 itself he sent a letter saying he would convene an extraordinary shareholders' meeting on December 27 for a full re-election, and he petitioned the court to bar Wu Mei-hui from holding her meeting; Tien Chen-ching, the management side's lawyer, said he did not know him. Went ahead with the extraordinary shareholders' meeting on 2021-12-27 in defiance of the court injunction. The Securities and Futures Investors Protection Center sued for his removal in February 2022; the Commercial Court ordered his removal in a judgment on 2023-04-07, finding that he had obstructed service by terminating his lawyer's mandate, moving his household registration and other means, and had insisted on holding the meeting; the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal on 2024-11-14. He was no longer on the list of new directors elected on 2022-05-31. [最高法院 112 年度台上字第 1752 號裁定(2024-11-14)] [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)] [中央社(2021-12-27)] [鏡週刊(2021-12-20)] [鉅亨網:108 年股東常會改選公告(2019-06-28)]
- Hung Pen-chan (Hung Pen-chan) — Director (representative of Sheng Yuan Investment Co., Ltd.). The experience recorded in the 2019 election announcement was vice president of Quanta Computer; Sheng Yuan Investment held about 10.4 million shares when elected. Elected at the annual shareholders' meeting in June 2019 as the representative of Sheng Yuan Investment. A director on the management side. After the agenda items had been discussed at the 2021-11-05 board meeting, it was he who tabled the extraordinary motion calling for an extraordinary shareholders' meeting on December 27 to re-elect all nine directors, which was the trigger for the whole affair. Continued as a director at the 2022-05-31 shareholders' meeting as the representative of Sheng Yuan Investment. [鉅亨網:108 年股東常會改選公告(2019-06-28)] [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)] [中央社(2022-05-31)]
- Huang Chi-feng (黃啓峰) (Huang Chi-feng) — Director and president. President of Solar Applied Materials; personally held about 4.58 million shares at the 2019 election, making him a member of the management team who owns shares. Elected a director in his personal capacity at the annual shareholders' meeting in June 2019. Ma Chien-yung's deputy. During the affair he told the outside world that the company was operating as usual and issued material information announcements asserting that the removal and election resolutions were invalid; on November 8 the TSG side resolved at its off-site board meeting to replace him, but this was not actually carried out. On 2022-05-31 he was nominated by Ma Chien-yung and chosen by the board to take over as chairman; Ma Chien-yung said that he himself held no shares and was handing over to Huang, who did, for the sake of shareholding stability. After the board election at the 2026-05-25 shareholders' meeting the chairmanship passed to Cheng Hsien-sung, and he continued as president. [中央社(2022-05-31)] [鏡週刊(2022-10,馬堅勇專訪之二)] [鏡週刊(2021-11-08)] [經濟日報(聯合新聞網,2026-05-25)] [鉅亨網:108 年股東常會改選公告(2019-06-28)]
- Wu Po-cheng (Wu Po-cheng) — Chief executive officer of Fuda Aerospace (the TSG side's designated choice for president, and a director candidate). Chief executive officer of Fuda Aerospace, a TSG group company. Fuda Aerospace had done contract forging of copper alloy targets for Solar Applied Materials; the TSG side asserted that this was the key to Solar Applied Materials breaking into TSMC's supply chain, while the management side said the technology and intellectual property all belonged to Solar Applied Materials. Not a director of Solar Applied Materials. The TSG side resolved at its off-site board meeting on 2021-11-08 that he would replace Huang Chi-feng as president, and in November he was also put on Taiwan Steel's slate of director candidates. The person the TSG side lined up for when it prepared to take over management. The appointment as president never actually took effect, and the extraordinary shareholders' meeting was never held; reports do not mention what he did afterwards. [鏡週刊(2021-11-08)] [中央社(2021-11-26)] [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-11-18)]
- Kao Feng-chi (Kao Feng-chi) — Lawyer (the management side's independent director candidate in 2021). Practising lawyer; managing lawyer of his firm. On 2021-11-18 he and lawyer Lee Chieh-yi accompanied Ma Chien-yung at a press conference to explain the legal problems with the minutes of the November 5 board meeting; the same month he was put on the management side's slate of independent director candidates. A lawyer for Ma Chien-yung's side. Elected an independent director at the 2022-05-31 shareholders' meeting. [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-11-18)] [中央社(2021-11-26)] [中央社(2022-05-31)]
- Chao Yung-chang (Chao Yung-chang) — Founder of Jentech Precision Industrial (new director in 2022). Founder of the listed company Jentech; Jentech was one of the shareholders that took over the stake when TSG exited. When TSG exited, shareholders including Thintech, Jentech and Topco Scientific took over TSG's stake; he was elected a director at the 2022-05-31 shareholders' meeting. Belongs to the camp of shareholders that took over TSG's stake and supports the existing management team. Elected a director on 2022-05-31; in the same election, Sen Chi also won two seats for its corporate representatives, Cheng Yu-cheng and Lee Yun-fang. [中央社(2022-05-31)] [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)]
- Chen Li-ho (Chen Li-ho) — Founder and former chairman of Solar Applied Materials (no longer on the board at the time of the event). Founder of Solar Applied Materials. Left management after the company was hit in 2016 by incidents including employees stealing and selling gold, false accounting and losses on precious metals trading. Founder. The person who originally recruited Ma Chien-yung into the company. In 2018 he wanted to come back and fight for control but was talked out of it by Hsieh Yu-min; Mirror Media reported that after the 2019 election the board was under the "four-way joint rule" of TSG, Chen Li-ho, Ma Chien-yung and the foreign investor Gerald, and that it was only after he and Gerald both sold their shares that it became a standoff between two sides, Ma Chien-yung and TSG. Had already sold his shares before the 2021 fight for control and took no part in this affair. [鏡週刊(2021-12,謝裕民專訪全文)] [鏡週刊(2022-10,全文)]
Moves to block a return
- Only as the board meeting was drawing to a close did they produce Yu Jing's reassignment letter, replacing its representative Ching Cho-ying with Wang Chiung-fen; having made up five seats, they removed Ma Chien-yung by extraordinary motion and elected Wang Chiung-fen in his place, obtained the company seals, and issued a material information announcement of the new chairman that evening. [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)] [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-11-05)]
- Wang Chiung-fen issued a press release saying he would sue Ma Chien-yung under the Securities and Exchange Act for false financial reporting and special breach of trust, on the grounds that he had extended the land sale contract with Hsin Chuang Environmental without board approval and that the supplementary agreement was not disclosed in the financial statements. Ma Chien-yung called the allegations baseless. [自由財經(2021-11-07)]
- After Wang Chiung-fen led a group to the company and was blocked at the door by employees, the TSG side held a separate board meeting outside the company, resolving to remove Ma Chien-yung as chief executive officer, replace president Huang Chi-feng with Wu Po-cheng, replace the heads of finance and accounting, and hold a separate extraordinary shareholders' meeting on December 27 for a full re-election of the board. [鏡週刊(2021-11-08)] [智慧財產及商業法院 110 年度商暫字第 7 號裁定(2021-12-08)]
- Applied to the Ministry of Economic Affairs, in the name of "new chairman Yu Jing Co., Ltd.", to register the removal of the former chairman and the by-election of a new chairman; on the same day Wu Mei-hui, the independent director on the TSG side, announced she would convene an extraordinary shareholders' meeting on December 24 for a full re-election, three days earlier than the December 27 meeting of Wu Chang-po, the independent director on the management side. [自由財經(2021-12-20)] [智慧財產及商業法院 110 年度商暫字第 7 號裁定(2021-12-08)]
- Wang Chiung-fen held another press conference and went to the Taipei District Prosecutors Office to file a complaint, rejecting the management side's description of TSG as a "vulture"; he also asserted that Solar Applied Materials was able to break into TSMC's supply chain thanks to contract forging of targets by Fuda Aerospace, a TSG group company. [NOWnews(2021-11-19)] [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-11-18)]
- Put forward its own slate of directors: Wang Chiung-fen, Lin Hui-cheng, Huang Chun-yi and Wu Po-cheng to stand as representatives of Taiwan Steel, plus four independent director candidates; solicited proxies through three proxy solicitation firms, Chuan Tung, Chang Long and Lien Chou, and also approached the foreign proxy advisory firms ISS and Glass Lewis. [中央社(2021-11-26)] [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)] [今周刊 1301 期(2021-11-24)]
- Yu Jing and TSG's petition to the Intellectual Property and Commercial Court for a preliminary injunction maintaining a temporary status quo was granted: on provision of NT$1 million as security, Wu Chang-po was barred from convening an extraordinary shareholders' meeting on December 27. (On the same day the court also barred the December 24 meeting of Wu Mei-hui on the TSG side.) They subsequently took the ruling to the Tainan District Court to apply for an enforcement order. [智慧財產及商業法院 110 年度商暫字第 7 號裁定(2021-12-08)] [匯流新聞網(Yam 轉載,2021-12-30)]
- After the Ministry of Economic Affairs rejected the registration of the change of chairman, TSG expressed regret that evening, criticised the Department of Commerce for conducting a substantive review and erring in its findings of fact and application of the law, and announced it would file an administrative appeal. [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-12-20)]
- After Wu Chang-po's extraordinary shareholders' meeting resolved to adjourn until January 3, 2022, the Commercial Court issued a further emergency disposition ruling barring the January 3 meeting; the TSG side also alleged that Wu Chang-po had evaded service by moving his household registration and terminating his lawyer's mandate. [匯流新聞網(Yam 轉載,2021-12-30)]
Rumors
- Ma Chien-yung privately agreed to extend the land contract with Hsin Chuang Environmental Protection and concealed the supplementary agreement from the financial statements, involving false financial statements and aggravated breach of trust. [Still unclear] Raised by the TSG side at the November 5 board meeting and in that evening's material information announcement, and later the subject of a criminal complaint filed by Wang Chiung-fen. Ma Chien-yung denied it, saying the board had given him full authority to handle the matter in 2018. In refusing registration, the Ministry of Economic Affairs noted that this allegation had been neither put to experts nor discussed at the board meeting. No report could be found on whether prosecutors indicted or decided not to indict; in October 2022 Mirror Media wrote only that the two sides had settled. [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-11-05)] [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-11-18)] [自由財經(2021-12-20)] [鏡週刊(2022-10,馬堅勇專訪之一)]
- Yu Jing never reassigned its representative at all; its representative is still Ching Cho-ying, and Wang Chiung-fen's status is invalid. [Proven false] The Solar Applied Materials management side's statement on the evening of November 8, saying it had confirmed this with Gerald, Yu Jing's sole shareholder. Solar Applied Materials itself issued a material information announcement on 2022-02-14 saying that, after clarifying with Gerald, it confirmed Yu Jing had reassigned its seat to Wang Chiung-fen on 2021-11-05. (But a valid reassignment does not mean a valid election as chairman; the Ministry of Economic Affairs still refused registration because the extempore-motion procedure did not comply with the rules.) [鏡週刊(2021-11-08)] [自由財經(2022-02-14)]
- TSG wants to acquire Solar Applied Materials and seize management control: a TSG-side director said TSG would take five seats and give Ma Chien-yung only four. [Still unclear] Ma Chien-yung's account to the media; he said the bank syndicate and customers, on hearing the market rumours, worried that the shareholding was unstable, which is why the management side launched a re-election early. Hsieh Yu-min has consistently denied any interest in management control, saying TSG was a major shareholder to begin with; in October 2022 Ma Chien-yung changed his account, saying it had been a misunderstanding and apologizing, but did not say who that director was. On the other hand, the TSG side did elect one of its own as chairman on November 5 and had also lined up a candidate for president. [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)] [鏡週刊(2022-10,馬堅勇專訪之二)] [鏡週刊(2021-12,謝裕民專訪全文)]
- Solar Applied Materials was able to break into TSMC's supply chain thanks to TSG affiliate Fuda Aerospace developing copper-alloy sputtering targets and helping it break through a technical bottleneck. [Still unclear] Wang Chiung-fen's press conference on November 17. Ma Chien-yung said the technology, equipment, talent and intellectual property all belonged to Solar Applied Materials, that Fuda merely did contract forging as instructed, and that when the work was commissioned in August 2020 Fuda was not yet part of the TSG group; Wang Chiung-fen said forging was the last mile into TSMC's supply chain. Each side tells its own story, and no third party has made a determination. [ETtoday 財經雲(2021-11-18)] [NOWnews(2021-11-19)]
- Independent director Wu Mei-hui once described herself as chief of staff of the TSG group, has an interest in TSG and lacks independence. [Still unclear] Management-side independent director Wu Chang-po and the Solar Applied Materials management side, as the ground for her "automatic removal." Wu Mei-hui denied holding a position at any TSG-related major shareholder. On 2022-01-04, in provisional-injunction proceedings, the commercial court found that it could not determine that she was a director, supervisor or employee of TSG and rejected the petition; this is not a final judgment on the merits, and the court made no finding on whether she ever said those words. [中央社(2021-11-19)] [鉅亨網(2022-01-04)]
- TSG is borrowing from three state-controlled banks to buy more Solar Applied Materials shares. [Still unclear] Ma Chien-yung's statement to Business Today, described as information he had learned. Wang Chiung-fen did not deny that the group borrows against pledged shares, saying only that pledging is lawful and reasonable financing; Business Today found that a high proportion of TSG's holdings in many of its listed and OTC-listed affiliates were pledged, but whether it borrowed specifically to buy Solar Applied Materials shares has not been confirmed. [今周刊 1301 期(2021-11-24)]
- Wu Chang-po moved house to evade service of court documents. [Later confirmed] An investigative report by Mirror Media; the TSG side also made this accusation publicly. The commercial court's judgment of 2023-04-07 found that during the ruling proceedings he terminated his agent's mandate and authority to accept service and moved his household registration, obstructing service of the ruling and the enforcement order; the Supreme Court rejected the appeal on 2024-11-14. [鏡週刊(2021-12-20)] [最高法院 112 年度台上字第 1752 號裁定(2024-11-14)]
Views
- Solar Applied Materials employees (forming a human wall at the company gate): Employees shouted at Wang Chiung-fen that he was not the chairman and that Ma Chien-yung was. Wang Chiung-fen in turn criticized the management side for using employees as weapons. [鏡週刊(2021-11-08)]
- A section chief at Solar Applied Materials (unnamed): He said the action was spontaneous on the employees' part, because Ma Chien-yung often visited the shop floor and was accountable to employees and shareholders; but he also admitted that he was not clear about matters among the top-level shareholders and had heard about them second-hand from senior people inside the company. [自由財經(2021-11-10)]
- Lin Yu-chang (special assistant to Wang Chiung-fen): He said he appreciated the employees' loyalty, and that the matter was not directed at employees but at the corporate governance problems of Ma Chien-yung and Huang Chi-feng. [自由財經(2021-11-10)]
- An official of the FSC's Securities and Futures Bureau: The official said they had never encountered this situation before and that it was a first; both the Securities and Futures Bureau and the Ministry of Economic Affairs' Department of Commerce said they were still looking into it and would handle it according to law. [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)]
- A lawyer (quoted by Mirror Media): He believed that Ma Chien-yung, as chair at the time, could have avoided all the later disputes if he had simply declared the meeting adjourned. [鏡週刊(2021-11,全文)]
- Wu Ping-jui and Kuo Kuo-wen (Democratic Progressive Party legislators): Wu Ping-jui criticized intervening in management control through proxy solicitation and borrowing against pledged shares as tantamount to being a stock-market vulture, and Kuo Kuo-wen named TSG as the one meant. [今周刊(數位時代轉載,2021-11-25)]
- Taipei Exchange: The Taipei Exchange did not take much of a position, saying only that it was closely watching all of these moves. [今周刊 1301 期(2021-11-24)]
- Fortune Venture Capital (UMC group; shareholder and customer of Solar Applied Materials): It sent a letter saying it was worried that a sudden change in Ma Chien-yung's team would bring risks to quality, supply and R&D. [中央社(科技新報轉載,2021-11-24)]
- Business Today (Liang Jen-wei, Lu Chueh-sheng): The report reviewed the dozen or so listed and OTC-listed companies TSG has taken over: some turned from loss to profit and multiplied their market value, but foreign institutional ownership of D-Link, Taiwan Styrene Monomer and Gloria Material Technology fell noticeably after the takeover, and most of the group's companies earned less than NT$1.5 per share over the past three years. [今周刊 1301 期(2021-11-24)]
- Second Commercial Division, Intellectual Property and Commercial Court: The ruling noted that the two sat on the same audit committee yet did not first build a consensus, and that holding meetings in quick succession within a few days would only leave shareholders not knowing which to follow and produce multiple slates of directors; matters should return to the normal state of corporate governance. [智慧財產及商業法院 110 年度商暫字第 7 號裁定(2021-12-08)]
- Hsieh Yu-min (chairman of the TSG group): He said TSG was a major shareholder to begin with, so it made no sense to say he was seizing management control; he only hoped this farce would end soon, and asked in return whether Solar Applied Materials was still worth investing in. [鏡週刊(2021-12,謝裕民專訪全文)]
- Foreign proxy advisory firms ISS and Glass Lewis: According to Mirror Media, the two gave opposite recommendations: ISS backed TSG, while Glass Lewis strongly backed Ma Chien-yung. [鏡週刊(2021-12,謝裕民專訪全文)]
- An official of the FSC's Securities and Futures Bureau: The official said that if the meeting were held despite the court's ban, it would have no effect even if held; the regulator would look at three things: investors' interests, whether any laws were broken, and whether it was consistent with corporate governance. [鏡週刊(2021-12-20)]
- Securities and Futures Investors Protection Center: The SFIPC criticized this as an open challenge to public authority and a disregard for shareholders' rights, expressing regret and strong condemnation. [工商時報(2021-12-28)]
- Chang Hsin-ti (chairperson of the SFIPC): She said the Solar Applied Materials case is a negative lesson in corporate governance. [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)]
- A lawyer (quoted by Mirror Media): He believed that from now on independent directors of whichever camp who want to use an extraordinary shareholders' meeting to force an early re-election will have to be more careful, and their reasons will have to be more defensible. [鏡週刊(2022-03,全文)]
- Kao Ching-ping (chief secretary of the FSC's Securities and Futures Bureau): She said several companies had already replaced their chairmen by extempore motion at board meetings, that a matter this significant should not be raised at the last minute, and that this route therefore had to be closed off. [Taipei Times(2022-05-04)]
- Huang Chi-feng (new chairman): He thanked Ma Chien-yung for becoming chairman in 2016 at the company's most critical moment and leading it out of the storm, and said he would carry on that spirit. [中央社(2022-05-31)]
- Ma Chien-yung: He said that if he could do it over, he would probably summon the courage to have one more crucial conversation with Hsieh Yu-min; he hoped that once passions cooled both sides would learn their lessons. [鏡週刊(2022-10,馬堅勇專訪之二)] [鏡週刊(2022-10,全文)]
- Wang Chiung-fen (chairman of TSG): He said this was justice delayed and that TSG had finally been vindicated, and hoped that the regulators, elected representatives and shareholders who had misunderstood TSG could understand that TSG had obeyed the law all along. [ETtoday 財經雲(2022-10-05)]
Photos & videos
The plant and signage of Solar Applied Materials Technology, photographed in August 2008 — 思弦 張 / CC BY 2.0
Headquarters of the Gloria group in Liuying, Tainan, photographed in 2013; Gloria is a TSG group company, and it was after taking over Gloria that TSG obtained its stake in Solar Applied Materials; Wang Chiung-fen is also chairman of Gloria — Supersonic0714 / CC BY-SA 3.0
The Department of Commerce plaque on the exterior wall of the Ministry of Economic Affairs building, photographed in 2013; on 2021-12-20 the Department of Commerce rejected the change-of-chairman registration filed by Wang Chiung-fen's side — Solomon203 / CC BY-SA 3.0
The main entrance of the FSC's Securities and Futures Bureau, photographed in 2013; after the affair the FSC amended the rules of procedure for board meetings, a change known as the "Solar Applied Materials clause" — Solomon203 / CC BY-SA 3.0
North Gate 2A of the Banqiao Station building, leading to the Intellectual Property and Commercial Court (photographed in 2023); the decisions banning the two extraordinary shareholders' meetings and removing Wu Chang-po all came from this court — Solomon203 / CC BY-SA 4.0- Mirror Media: the 2018 tussle over the director by-election, Solar Applied Materials' previous fight for management control (鏡週刊)
- USTV Financial News: Ma Chien-yung's press conference says TSMC is watching closely and the removal was illegal; the TSG camp hits back (USTV 非凡電視)
- FTV News: two rival claimants to the Solar Applied Materials chairmanship; Ma Chien-yung says he is the legitimate chairman (民視新聞網 Formosa TV News network)
- EBC Financial News: the fight over the Solar Applied Materials chairmanship spreads; Ma Chien-yung and Wang Chiung-fen trade barbs from a distance (57東森財經新聞)
- USTV Financial News: Wang Chiung-fen's press conference lists Ma Chien-yung's "three major offences"; the management side hits back (USTV 非凡電視)
- FTV News: Ma Chien-yung alleges the removal was unlawful; Wang Chiung-fen says TSG is not a vulture (民視新聞網 Formosa TV News network)
- TTV News: Ma Chien-yung insists he is the lawful chairman; Wang Chiung-fen says TSG is no vulture (台視新聞 TTV NEWS)
- EBC Financial News: Wang Chiung-fen holds another press conference, saying Solar Applied Materials could not have entered TSMC's supply chain without TSG (57東森財經新聞)
- FTV News: Wang Chiung-fen files a criminal complaint to rebut the "vulture" accusation, saying Solar Applied Materials is like TSG's godson (民視新聞網 Formosa TV News network)
- FTV News: the fight for management control turns into a legal battle; Ma Chien-yung countersues TSG for breaching a confidentiality agreement (民視新聞網 Formosa TV News network)
- EBC Financial News: Ma Chien-yung accused of "sham technology transfer, real leak of secrets"; the management side rejects the claim (57東森財經新聞)
- EBC Financial News: TSG says it is "ready" to take over Solar Applied Materials; Ma Chien-yung's team does not respond (57東森財經新聞)