Wang Zhidong (Wang Zhidong) — Sina.com (SINA Corporation) (SINA.com (SINA Corporation))
Wang Zhidong founded Stone Rich Sight in 1993, merged it at the end of 1998 with Daniel Chiang's Sinanet to form Sina.com, became chief executive in 1999 and took the company public on Nasdaq in April 2000. After the dot-com bubble burst the share price fell from a peak of more than US$50 to US$1.60, and on 2001-06-01 the board removed him, saying publicly that he had resigned of his own accord. After three weeks of silence, on 06-25 he went back "to work" at the Beijing office wearing a Sina uniform and held a press conference, saying he had never resigned and doubted the legitimacy of his removal; he held 70% of "Sina Internet", the entity holding the licence for Sina's China website, and this was his only bargaining chip. That evening the board publicly announced the termination of all his posts; the two sides then negotiated through lawyers, he signed a separation agreement on 07-30 and handed over the equity on 08-15, founded Dianji Technology in December of that year, and never returned to Sina.
How they were ousted
On 2001-06-01 the board, meeting in California, removed him as chief executive, president and director by four votes in favour with the chairman abstaining; publicly this was first described as a "resignation for personal reasons", a second vote of five to nil was held on 06-16 to make it good, and on 06-25 it was publicly announced as a "termination".
What happened to the board
On the day of the removal the board had 6 members including him, and not one of the other 5 left because of him. Chairman Daniel Chiang stayed until March 2006; Duan Yongji later even rose to chairman and left the board only in March 2008; Lip-Bu Tan, Pehong Chen and Ter Fung Tsao were all still independent directors in the 2011 annual report (at least another ten years after the events; exact dates of departure were not found). Daniel Mao, who took over as chief executive, lasted only two years, resigning in May 2003, but the company's account was that he retired with his task accomplished, nothing to do with Wang Zhidong.
Timeline
- With funding from the Stone Group, Wang Zhidong founds Stone Rich Sight Wang Zhidong left Suntendy and, with funding from the Stone Group, founded Stone Rich Sight as general manager, later launching the Chinese platform software RichWin. [維基百科:王志東] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- First round of international financing: Walden leads with US$6.5 million Three firms led by Walden invested US$6.5 million. Before the financing closed, Wang Zhidong put the whole of the company's 21% of technology shares in his own name, which was the main source of his later holding in Sina. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Wang Zhidong and Daniel Chiang meet for the first time Both said afterwards that they reached agreement in less than half an hour. Three months later Stone Rich Sight and Sinanet merged and took the name Sina. [新浪科技:王志東記者會實錄(2001-06-25)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Stone Rich Sight and Sinanet merge; Sina.com is formed After the merger Daniel Chiang was chairman and chief executive and Wang Zhidong president. Chinese Wikipedia gives the founding date as both 11-30 and 12-01. [維基百科:王志東] [維基百科:新浪] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Jim Sha is out; Wang Zhidong becomes chief executive At the end of August, Jim Sha, the chief executive brought in in March 1999, demanded the resignation of Wang Zhidong and others; with the support of Pehong Chen, Duan Yongji, Lip-Bu Tan and others the board chose Wang Zhidong instead. Two years later the same directors replaced him. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)] [SINA.com 2000 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)]
- Sina lists on Nasdaq The offer price was US$17 a share, raising about US$68 million, and the share price later surged at one point to around US$55. To comply with China's controls on internet content businesses, "Sina Internet", which operated the China website, was not put into the listed company and was instead held 70% by Wang Zhidong and 30% by Wang Yan. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- chinadotcom proposes a merger According to Caijing, at the end of March chinadotcom formally proposed a merger with Sina, and later proposed a plan under which its subsidiary hongkong.com and Sina would each hold half; the board was interested and appointed Wang Zhidong to lead the talks. Around 20 May the negotiations broke up in acrimony. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Share price falls to US$1.60; directors and executives gather in California The day before the board meeting, Sina's shares closed at US$1.60. Most of the directors and senior executives had already arrived in California, and the board meeting originally scheduled to discuss the chinadotcom merger turned into a discussion of replacing the chief executive. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Board removes him as chief executive and director by four votes in favour with one abstention The meeting was held at the Westin hotel in Palo Alto, California; Wang Zhidong was the last to arrive and knew nothing beforehand. The directors voted in front of him, with Daniel Chiang abstaining and the other four in favour, removing him as director as well; chief operating officer Daniel Mao became chief executive and Wang Yan was promoted to president. Company documents state that his employment and directorship ended on this day. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)] [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [維基百科:新浪]
- Wang Zhidong leaves the United States for Beijing According to Caijing, he returned to Beijing the day after the board meeting; during this period he telephoned people to say "I have resigned", the reason being disagreement with the board over the merger. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Sina announces: Wang Zhidong has resigned for personal reasons The company issued a press release in California (appearing in the papers on the morning of 06-04 Beijing time) saying he had resigned as chief executive, president and director for personal reasons and would become chief adviser; chairman Daniel Chiang expressed regret and good wishes in the release. The same press release announced a 15% cut in the worldwide workforce by the end of June. [新浪科技(公司新聞稿,2001-06-04)] [江南時報(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-08)]
- His family tells the media: he was dismissed The Jiangnan Times reported in early June that Wang Zhidong said on the telephone only that there were things he could not well say for now; his wife said he had suddenly been notified of his dismissal in the United States and had found it baffling. The new president Wang Yan told reporters that the senior executives had all been summoned to the United States and waited outside the boardroom. [江南時報(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-08)]
- Daniel Chiang goes to Beijing and dines with Wang Zhidong and his wife, without securing a signature Daniel Chiang went to Beijing to call on the regulators and had dinner with Wang Zhidong and his wife, but "did not talk business", and did not manage, as the board had asked him, to get him to sign the resignation agreement. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Sina's senior management hold a press conference and answer internet users on the website Daniel Chiang, Daniel Mao, Wang Yan and Charles Chao came forward to explain; the Q&A on the website still insisted that he had resigned for personal reasons, and dismissed talk of chinadotcom acquiring Sina as irresponsible rumour. At the conference a reporter asked: what if one day he comes out and says he did not resign voluntarily? Daniel Chiang was for a moment unable to answer. [新浪科技:與新浪網領導人的對話(2001-06-08)] [新浪科技:與新浪網領導人的對話—中華網(2001-06-08)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Share price rises for six consecutive trading days after the removal From 06-01 to 06-11 Sina's share price rose from about US$1.60 to a high of about US$2.3, a gain of more than 40%. Caijing read this as the market welcoming the change. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Lawyer's letter: I never voluntarily resigned Wang Zhidong retained the US law firm O'Melveny & Myers, and lawyer Nicholas Groffman wrote to the board saying the 06-01 resolution's statement that he had voluntarily resigned was contrary to the facts. The board had in hand neither resignation papers signed by him nor any formal document of dismissal. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- The ultimatum expires; the board votes again, five to nil The board required him to sign the resignation papers within 12 hours, and he did not respond. After the deadline the board held a conference call and the five directors unanimously resolved to remove him as chief executive, president and director, with Daniel Chiang this time voting in favour; the signed resolutions were faxed to him. This vote was not made public at the time. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Daniel Chiang and his wife visit the Wang home Daniel Chiang and his wife went to the Wang home in Beijing's Asian Games Village to see his newborn twins. The two sides agreed that on 06-25 Wang Zhidong's lawyer would arrange a discussion with Lip-Bu Tan and Daniel Chiang, and Daniel Mao flew to Shanghai for it. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)] [中國新聞網(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-27)]
- The discussion falls through; a late-night remark about "acting by the rules of the game" On Sunday evening Daniel Chiang and Daniel Mao, waiting in Shanghai, were told that Wang Zhidong was not coming. At about 11 p.m. Wang Zhidong, who had just finished a meeting of more than four hours, told Caijing by telephone that he would act by the rules of the game. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Daniel Chiang: from now on it can only be settled in court That evening Daniel Chiang, interviewed by telephone from Taipei by Caijing, said that privately he could understand him but in his official capacity he could only stand with the company, and lamented that perhaps Sina was fated to go through this ordeal. Daniel Mao, just back in Beijing, said he might have lost his last chance of returning to a post at Sina. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- In a Sina uniform and wearing a staff badge, he goes back "to work" at the Beijing office At 9:12 a.m. Wang Zhidong walked into Sina's Beijing office in a blue shirt with the Sina logo and wearing a staff badge, followed by a crowd of reporters. The capacity he used was not chief executive but legal representative of Sina Internet. Reports said president Wang Yan left the company that morning pleading illness. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)] [賽迪網(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-25)] [大紀元(2001-06-25)]
- Press conference: I never resigned, and never signed any document In the afternoon he held a press conference at the Jingdu Xinyuan Hotel in Beijing, accompanied by his lawyer, with about 70 reporters present. He said the other directors had merely announced to him that the chief executive was to be replaced, with no notice beforehand and no explanation afterwards; he doubted the legitimacy of this and had asked his lawyers to study it; he also said he was at least still the legal representative of Sina China. Accounts of the starting time vary between 14:30 and 15:00. [新浪科技:王志東記者會實錄(2001-06-25)] [大紀元(2001-06-25)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Sina announcement: Wang Zhidong's posts as chief executive, president and director terminated At 10:56 that evening Sina published on its own website an announcement issued from California saying that, by unanimous decision of the board, his three posts had been terminated, with Daniel Mao as chief executive and Wang Yan as president. The announcement did not mention the vote of 06-16. [新浪科技(公司新聞稿,2001-06-25)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Daniel Chiang's Taipei press conference: calling it a resignation was to protect him Daniel Chiang acknowledged that Wang Zhidong had indeed signed no resignation papers and had not resigned voluntarily, and that the company had described it as for personal reasons to protect him out of consideration; he also said the board's procedure was entirely lawful and its resolution could not be overturned. At one point he said he had not stated a position at the meeting, then withdrew this when pressed by reporters on the contradiction with a "unanimous decision". [鉅亨網報導(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-26)] [中國新聞網(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-27)]
- Transoceanic press conference call: the 70% stake is to be transferred to Sina employees At 5 p.m. Daniel Chiang answered questions from more than 20 reporters, saying that he was no longer an employee of Stone Rich Sight and the 70% stake in Sina Internet would be transferred by law to employees of Sina China; the regulators had indicated they would not interfere in changes of senior management at a company. He also admitted the board had been somewhat hasty in making its decision, and said that if the new team did not deliver results, everyone including himself should be considered for replacement. [新浪科技:姜豐年越洋電話記者會(2001-06-27)]
- Duan Yongji breaks his silence: we just wanted a president who burns money a bit more slowly Stone Group chairman Duan Yongji said at the Chang'an Forum in Beijing that nothing could be more normal than a board changing its chief executive; Stone had invested for eight years, more than ten million yuan, with no return, and his vote in favour was a decision the Stone board had studied again and again. There were two reasons: no plan for profitability could be produced, and there were problems in uniting colleagues. [新華網(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-29)] [中國經濟時報(大紀元轉載,2001-06-29)]
- Share price falls back to US$1.60 After Wang Zhidong's public protest, Sina's share price slid back, returning to US$1.60 by the end of the month. On the day of the press conference the share price fell about 5%. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)] [環球時報(新浪科技轉載,2001-07-06)]
- Sina vice president: this affair is costing the company about a million a day Caijing Shibao (China Business Post) reported that he went back to work at the company for a few days, did not make things difficult for subordinates and had no substantive contact with the executive team. Zhou Mao, executive vice president for China (and his friend of many years), said this period had hurt Sina's business and brand and delayed new projects by at least ten days; one employee estimated the loss at about RMB 1 million a day. [財經時報(大紀元轉載,2001-07-03)]
- Reuters: Wang Zhidong has agreed to hand over his Sina Internet equity Hurst Lin, general manager of Sina in the United States, told Reuters that he had objected at first but that the two sides had now reached a consensus on the board's decision and were asking him to transfer the shares to the persons designated by the company. The previous day Sina's shares rose 5% to close at US$1.68. [路透報導(新浪科技轉述,2001-07-04)]
- The whole of Sina's management issues an open letter backing the board The open letter said the storm over the departure had gradually calmed, that the present management team unanimously supported the board's resolution, and that from now on profitability would be the foundation of the business. [新浪科技:管理層公開信(2001-07-11)]
- Signs a separation agreement and becomes a consultant for one year According to the company's proxy statement, the two sides signed an agreement on this day: he left all his posts and would serve as a consultant until 2002-07-29 at an annual salary of US$275,000; the company accelerated the vesting of a tranche of his options and forgave loans of about US$370,000 and RMB 50,000. The previous day the Beijing Evening News reported him as saying that matters with Sina were entirely in his lawyers' hands and that he was already preparing a new company in a small rented office. [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [北京晚報(新浪科技轉載,2001-07-29)]
- Hands over the Sina Internet equity According to the proxy statement, on this day he transferred his holding in Sina Internet to Daniel Mao and four other employees. The same day Sina announced its results in Hong Kong, and Daniel Mao said the Wang Zhidong question was being dealt with step by step and that the two were still friends. [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [人民網(新浪科技轉載,2001-08-16)]
- Wang Zhidong on his new company: Jin Yong named it "Qingheming" Interviewed in his temporary office at the Friendship Hotel in Beijing, he said the new company was provisionally named Qingheming Network Technology, a name chosen by the novelist Jin Yong (Louis Cha), would make internet-related software, and for now consisted of himself and a secretary; he also said his departure had brought his seven years of building Sina to a close. [中國新聞網(新浪科技轉載,2001-09-07)]
- Sina announces the equity transfer is complete; the storm is over Sina announced that his 70% stake in Sina Internet had been transferred to employees designated by the company: Daniel Mao and Wang Yan each holding 30%, and four other employees 40% between them. The same day it announced completion of the acquisition of 29% of Sun Television Cybernetworks, with Bruno Wu becoming co-chairman. [北京晚報(新浪科技轉載,2001-10-03)] [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)]
- Founds Dianji Technology Wang Zhidong founded Beijing Dianji Technology, specialising in collaboration software; in February 2004 it obtained US$13 million in a round led by Fidelity International, and in January 2009 a further round of investment from Legend Capital and others. He never returned to Sina. [維基百科:王志東]
- Daniel Mao, who took his place, resigns as chief executive At 8 p.m. Sina announced that Daniel Mao had resigned as chief executive for personal reasons, succeeded by Wang Yan; Daniel Mao said he had taken on the job in a crisis two years earlier and, with the company now fully profitable, could retire with his task accomplished. He did not stand for re-election as director at the shareholders' meeting of 2003-09-26. [北京晚報(新浪新聞轉載,2003-05-13)] [SINA 2003 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)]
- Daniel Chiang leaves Sina Daniel Chiang, who had fronted for the board at the time, resigned as co-chairman and left Sina in March 2006 (Chinese Wikipedia gives 03-07) to found the Xinchuan group (新傳集團). In May of that year Wang Yan handed over the chief executive post to Charles Chao. [維基百科:新浪] [維基百科:姜豐年] [SINA 2006 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [SINA 2007 年度年報(SEC 20-F,2008-06-30 申報)]
- Duan Yongji leaves the board Duan Yongji, who had become chairman by 2006, left the Sina board in March 2008 (Chinese Wikipedia gives 03-31), succeeded as chairman by Wang Yan. [SINA 2007 年度年報(SEC 20-F,2008-06-30 申報)] [維基百科:新浪]
- Ten years on: Lip-Bu Tan, Pehong Chen and Ter Fung Tsao are still Sina directors In the list of directors in Sina's annual report for 2010 (as of 2011-03-31), the three outside directors who voted at the time were all still there, as independent directors. [SINA 2010 年度年報(SEC 20-F,2011-05-31 申報)]
- Sina is taken private and delisted, led by Charles Chao Sina completed its merger and delisted from Nasdaq. Charles Chao, the chief financial officer who had waited outside the boardroom in 2001, was by then chairman and chief executive. [維基百科:新浪] [維基百科:曹國偉]
- Lip-Bu Tan becomes chief executive of Intel Lip-Bu Tan, described by Caijing at the time as one of Sina's most important directors, was appointed chief executive of Intel on 2025-03-12 and took office on 03-18. [Wikipedia:Lip-Bu Tan] [維基百科:陳立武]
People
- Wang Zhidong (Wang Zhidong), 1967-06-28 — Co-founder, president and chief executive, director of Sina.com (chief executive from August 1999). From Humen, Dongguan, Guangdong; graduated from the Department of Radio Electronics at Peking University in 1988. First worked on a Chinese Windows environment at Peking University Founder; in 1992 he co-founded Suntendy and developed "Chinese Star", and in 1993, with funding from the Stone Group, founded Stone Rich Sight as general manager. Date of birth per Chinese Wikipedia; the biography in Caijing in 2001 gives his year of birth as 1968. Founder. Founded Stone Rich Sight in 1993 and became president after it merged with Sinanet to form Sina.com at the end of 1998; when the then chief executive Jim Sha left in August–September 1999, the board chose him as chief executive. He first met Daniel Chiang on 1998-09-26; both say they reached an understanding within half an hour, and three months later the two companies merged. Duan Yongji was the original backer of Stone Rich Sight; Lip-Bu Tan's Walden was the lead investor in his first round of international financing in 1997; Daniel Mao was originally the director appointed by Walden and moved into the company as chief operating officer in early 1999. Removed on 2001-06-01, returned to the company "to work" in protest on 06-25, signed a separation agreement on 07-30 and handed over the Sina Internet equity on 08-15. Founded Dianji Technology in December 2001 to make collaboration software, and never returned to Sina. [維基百科:王志東] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)] [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [新浪科技:王志東記者會實錄(2001-06-25)]
- Daniel Chiang (Chiang Feng-nien) (Daniel Chiang (Chiang Fong-nien)), 1957-10-07 — Chairman (director from March 1999). From Chiayi, Taiwan; graduated from the Department of Diplomacy at National Chengchi University, took a master's in political economy in the United States, and was once a professional basketball player. Joined Trend Micro in 1988, and in June 1996 founded Sinanet in the United States as chief executive. Date of birth per Chinese Wikipedia. Brought Sinanet into the merger with Stone Rich Sight that formed Sina.com at the end of 1998, first as chairman and chief executive, then as chairman only after Jim Sha was brought in as chief executive in March 1999. He and Wang Zhidong were the two protagonists of the merger and close personal friends; even at the time of the break Wang Zhidong still said publicly that Chiang was someone he would "always respect". After the events Chiang even took his wife to the Wang home to see his newborn boy-and-girl twins. Abstained in the vote on 06-01, voted in favour on 06-16, and thereafter spoke publicly for the board. Co-chairman alongside Bruno Wu from September 2001, he stayed until March 2006, when he left Sina to found the Xinchuan group (新傳集團); later chairman of Pushi Capital (璞石資本), he also funded the National Chengchi University basketball team. [維基百科:姜豐年] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)] [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [SINA 2004 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [SINA 2006 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)]
- Lip-Bu Tan (Lip-Bu Tan), 1959-11-12 — Director (representing Walden International, from March 1999). Born in Muar, Johor, Malaya; bachelor's degree in physics from Nanyang University in Singapore, master's in nuclear engineering from MIT, MBA from the University of San Francisco. Founded the venture capital firm Walden International in 1987 and is its chairman. Walden was the lead investor in Stone Rich Sight's first round of international financing in 1997 (US$6.5 million) and its second round in 1999; he joined the board in March 1999 as representative of a major shareholder. Caijing called him one of Sina's most important directors: from early 2001 he went to Beijing many times and spoke privately, one by one, with Wang Zhidong's key subordinates; by 2001-05-31 Walden had sold its holding down from a peak of 5.25 million shares to 2.49 million. The new chief executive Daniel Mao was his former subordinate at Walden. Remained a Sina director after the events, and the 2011 annual report still lists him as an independent director (exact date of departure not found). Chief executive of Cadence from 2009, and became chief executive of Intel on 2025-03-18. [Wikipedia:Lip-Bu Tan] [維基百科:陳立武] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)] [SINA.com 2000 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [SINA 2010 年度年報(SEC 20-F,2011-05-31 申報)]
- Duan Yongji (Duan Yongji), 1946 — Director (chairman of the Stone Group; director from August 1997). Bachelor's degree from Tsinghua University, master's from the Beijing Institute of Aeronautics. Chairman of the Stone Group, known as the "village head of Zhongguancun"; from 2000 also president of Zhongguancun Science and Technology Development, and a member of the National Committee of the CPPCC for several terms. The Stone Group was the original backer of Stone Rich Sight and in 1993 invited Wang Zhidong to found the company; he was a director from August 1997. Wang Zhidong's old employer and early supporter; when Jim Sha demanded Wang Zhidong's resignation in 1999, he was one of the directors who backed Wang firmly. Two years later, however, he voted for the removal, and said it was a decision reached by the Stone board after three meetings. Publicly defended the board after the events, and later became chairman of Sina (listed as co-chairman in the 2004 proxy statement and chairman in 2006). Left the Sina board in March 2008, succeeded as chairman by Wang Yan. [維基百科:段永基] [維基百科:新浪] [新華網(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-29)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)] [SINA 2004 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [SINA 2006 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [SINA 2007 年度年報(SEC 20-F,2008-06-30 申報)]
- Pehong Chen (Pehong Chen), 1957 — Independent director (founder and chief executive of BroadVision, from March 1999). Born in Taiwan; bachelor's degree from National Taiwan University, PhD in computer science from the University of California, Berkeley. Founded Gain Technology, and in 1993 founded the e-commerce software company BroadVision as chairman and chief executive. Invited to become an independent director in spring 1999 as a Chinese entrepreneur in Silicon Valley (the proxy statement says March, Caijing says May). When Jim Sha and Wang Zhidong had their showdown in 1999, he joined Duan Yongji and Lip-Bu Tan in supporting Wang Zhidong for chief executive. His individual remarks on the 2001 removal were not found; according to Caijing, apart from Daniel Chiang's abstention the other four directors all voted in favour. Remained an independent director of Sina after the events and was still on the list in the 2011 annual report (exact date of departure not found). [Wikipedia:Pehong Chen] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)] [SINA.com 2000 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [SINA 2010 年度年報(SEC 20-F,2011-05-31 申報)]
- Ter Fung Tsao (Ter Fung Tsao) — Director (chairman of Taiwan's Standard Foods, from March 1999). Taiwanese entrepreneur; bachelor's degree from National Cheng Kung University, master's and PhD from Colorado State University; worked for many years at Quaker Oats in the United States, and has been chairman of Standard Foods in Taiwan since 1986. The proxy statement of October 2000 records his age as 55; his exact date of birth was not found. A Taiwanese investor on the Sinanet side, who joined the board after the two companies merged in March 1999. Like Daniel Chiang, on the Taiwanese capital side. His individual remarks on the removal were not found; according to Caijing, apart from Daniel Chiang's abstention the other four directors all voted in favour. Remained a Sina director after the events, and the 2011 annual report still lists him as an independent director (exact date of departure not found). [SINA.com 2000 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [鉅亨網報導(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-26)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)] [SINA 2010 年度年報(SEC 20-F,2011-05-31 申報)]
- Daniel Mao (Mao Daolin; reports at the time mostly wrote the name 茅道林) (Daniel Mao (Mao Daolin)), 1963-11-24 — Chief operating officer; became chief executive and joined the board after the removal. Born in Shanghai; bachelor's degree in computer science from Shanghai Jiao Tong University, master's in engineering-economic systems from Stanford University. Joined Walden International in 1993–1994 as a vice president responsible for investments in China and the United States. Date of birth per Chinese Wikipedia. Served as a director of Stone Rich Sight on Walden's behalf from 1997 to early 1999, then moved into the company in early 1999, serving as acting chief financial officer, chief operating officer and in other posts. Originally the director appointed by the investors, he later became Wang Zhidong's deputy. Caijing reported that the senior executives, including him, had all lost confidence in Wang Zhidong before 06-01 and were summoned to the United States to wait outside the boardroom. As chief executive he took the company from loss to profit; on 2003-05-12 he resigned as chief executive for personal reasons, succeeded by Wang Yan, and did not stand for re-election as director at the shareholders' meeting of 2003-09-26. No reliable source was found for what he did afterwards. [維基百科:茅道臨] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)] [北京晚報(新浪新聞轉載,2003-05-13)] [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [SINA 2003 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)]
- Wang Yan (Wang Yan), 1972-05-25 — General manager of Sina China; promoted to president after the removal. From Beijing; after graduating from the High School Affiliated to Peking University he went to France and took a bachelor's degree in law at the University of Paris. Returned to China in 1996 and helped found Stone Rich Sight's website "SRSnet"; he is the founder of Sina's China website. Joined Stone Rich Sight in 1996; before Sina's listing he and Wang Zhidong held 30% and 70% of Sina Internet respectively. A subordinate whom Wang Zhidong had brought on personally. On the day Wang Zhidong returned to work at the company, reports said he left the office pleading illness; he later told the media that it is normal at a listed company for someone who cannot meet targets to be dismissed by the board. Became chief executive in May 2003, handed over to Charles Chao in May 2006 and became vice chairman, became chairman in 2008, and stepped down as chairman on 2012-08-31, remaining a director. [維基百科:汪延] [維基百科:新浪] [大紀元(2001-06-25)] [北京晚報(新浪新聞轉載,2003-05-13)] [SINA 2007 年度年報(SEC 20-F,2008-06-30 申報)]
- Charles Chao (Charles Chao (Cao Guowei)), 1965-11-10 — Chief financial officer. Born in Shanghai; graduated from the Department of Journalism at Fudan University, then took a master's in journalism in the United States and a master's in professional accounting at the University of Texas at Austin. Joined Sina in September 1999 as vice president of finance, later promoted to chief financial officer. The finance chief during Wang Zhidong's time as chief executive. Caijing quoted him explaining the board's position: if the board still did nothing with the share price having fallen like that, shareholders would sue. Rose steadily after the events: president in September 2005, chief executive in May 2006, and chairman as well from August 2012; when Sina completed its privatisation and delisted on 2021-03-23, he was still at the helm. The chief financial officer who had waited outside the door became the one who took over the company in the end. [維基百科:曹國偉] [維基百科:新浪] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)] [SINA 2006 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)]
- Bruno Wu (Wu Zheng) (Bruno Wu (Wu Zheng)) — Co-chairman who joined only after the events (from September 2001). Executive chairman of Sun Television Cybernetworks Holdings, formerly chief operating officer of ATV. The proxy statement of October 2001 records his age as 34. Joined the board in September 2001 when Sina acquired 29% of Sun Television Cybernetworks, as co-chairman alongside Daniel Chiang; at the same time his affiliates became a major shareholder holding about a tenth of Sina's shares. Had no ties to Wang Zhidong and took no part in the decision to remove him. He was no longer on the list of directors in the proxy statement of October 2002; the exact time and reason for his departure were not found. [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [SINA.com 2002 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [北京晚報(新浪科技轉載,2001-10-03)]
- Jim Sha (James Sha (Sha Zhengzhi)) — Wang Zhidong's predecessor as chief executive (March to August 1999). A Chinese American and veteran manager in Silicon Valley's internet industry. Birth details and detailed education and career were not verified. Recruited jointly by Wang Zhidong and Daniel Chiang in March 1999 as chief executive of the merged Sina. At the end of August 1999 he put to the board a plan to take full control, demanding the resignation of Wang Zhidong and others; the board in the end chose Wang Zhidong. Caijing noted that this led Wang Zhidong to believe mistakenly that he had defeated his opponent single-handedly, overlooking that it was in fact the board's choice. Left the chief executive post in August 1999, succeeded by Wang Zhidong. What he did afterwards was not verified. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)] [SINA.com 2000 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)]
Moves to block a return
- The board did not just replace the chief executive but removed him as a director as well. According to Caijing, the reason the directors discussed beforehand was that if he stayed on the board, the new management team would find it hard to do its job. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- The uniform public line was "resigned for personal reasons", and he was given the title of "chief adviser". According to Caijing, the board at the same time offered terms for him to sign the resignation papers: forgiveness of the debt he owed the company for money borrowed to buy shares (about US$470,000 with interest), plus a year's salary at the chief executive's rate, about US$300,000. He did not sign on the spot. [新浪科技(公司新聞稿,2001-06-04)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- After his lawyer wrote saying he had never voluntarily resigned, the board issued an ultimatum requiring him to sign the resignation papers within 12 hours; once the deadline passed, the board held a conference call and voted again, removing him as chief executive, president and director by five to nil, and the five directors signed two resolutions and faxed them to him. According to Caijing, this was because the company's articles required 75% approval to remove a director; on 06-01 Daniel Chiang had abstained, so the votes in favour were only about 66%, and this second vote in effect closed the procedural gap. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- On the same day that he returned to work at the Beijing office and held a press conference in the afternoon, Sina posted an announcement on its own website at 10:56 p.m.: by unanimous decision of the board, Wang Zhidong's posts as president, chief executive and director had been terminated. The announcement no longer used the word "resignation". [新浪科技(公司新聞稿,2001-06-25)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Chairman Daniel Chiang drew the line at a press conference in Taipei: the company respected his coming to work as the largest shareholder of Sina Internet, but if he tried to influence the company's operations, Sina would not accept it. Chiang also said the company was asking him through lawyers to transfer out the 70% stake in Sina Internet, and that the board's resolution could not be overturned. [鉅亨網報導(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-26)] [中國新聞網(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-27)]
- Daniel Chiang said on a press conference call that the 70% stake would be transferred to employees of Sina China in accordance with Chinese regulations. Caijing found that before Sina's listing (2000-04-06) the company had signed a supplementary employment agreement with him: once he ceased to be an employee, he had to transfer the equity in Sina Internet at net book value to employees designated by the company. Sina also designated three or four employees to prepare to take it over, and began applying for a new ICP licence as a fallback. [新浪科技:姜豐年越洋電話記者會(2001-06-27)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Director Duan Yongji said publicly that when Walden invested, the chief executive and two other executives had all signed contracts, one clause of which was that, whatever the reason for leaving the company, they could not work in the same industry for a certain number of years; he said Wang Zhidong's subsequent career might well be restricted as a result. This is Duan Yongji's account alone; the text of the contract was not found. [新華網(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-29)]
- The whole of Sina's management issued an open letter to internet users saying it unanimously supported the board's resolution and hoped this "unnecessary storm" would end soon. In effect it told the outside world that no one inside the company was on his side. [新浪科技:管理層公開信(2001-07-11)]
- The two sides signed a separation agreement: he left all his posts and became a consultant until 2002-07-29 (at an annual salary of US$275,000); the company accelerated the vesting of 134,137 of his options and forgave loans of about US$370,000 and RMB 50,000. On 2001-08-15 he transferred the equity in Sina Internet to Daniel Mao and four other employees; the company announced on 10-02 that the transfer was complete. With that he handed over his only bargaining chip. [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [北京晚報(新浪科技轉載,2001-10-03)]
Rumors
- Wang Zhidong resigned voluntarily for personal reasons and personal interests. [Proven false] Sina's press release of 2001-06-03 and its official Q&A of 06-08 Wang Zhidong publicly denied it on 06-25; the next day chairman Daniel Chiang acknowledged at a Taipei press conference that he had signed no resignation papers and had not resigned voluntarily, and said calling it a resignation was to protect him. The company's proxy statement records that his posts were "terminated" on 2001-06-01. [新浪科技(公司新聞稿,2001-06-04)] [新浪科技:與新浪網領導人的對話(2001-06-08)] [中國新聞網(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-27)] [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)]
- Wang Zhidong was pushed out because he opposed Sina's acquisition by or merger with chinadotcom, and the merger of Sina and chinadotcom has largely been agreed. [Still unclear] The Economic Observer, the Jiangnan Times and other media, citing chinadotcom and people familiar with the matter On 06-08 Sina said in its official Q&A that the acquisition was an irresponsible rumour. What Caijing later established was that chinadotcom did propose a merger at the end of March, that Wang Zhidong led the negotiations, and that they broke down around 20 May; but this was not the main reason for the removal, which was the share price and his inability to produce a response. In the end the merger did not happen. [江南時報(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-08)] [新浪科技:與新浪網領導人的對話—中華網(2001-06-08)] [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉上篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Wang Zhidong will become chief executive of the new FM365 website, a joint venture between Legend (Lenovo) and AOL. [Proven false] Qianlong News, citing a "reliable source" The report itself said readers should judge its truth for themselves. From July onwards Wang Zhidong told the media only that he was preparing his own new company; in September he made public the company's provisional name, and in December he founded Dianji Technology; he did not go to FM365. [千龍新聞網(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-08)] [中國新聞網(新浪科技轉載,2001-09-07)] [維基百科:王志東]
- Wang Zhidong will use his 70% stake in Sina Internet to fight a long-drawn-out lawsuit with the board, or even turn round and acquire Sina. [Proven false] Speculation in many media outlets; Daniel Chiang also said on 06-25 that from now on it could only be settled in court It did not come to litigation. At his press conference on 06-25 he already said he hoped to reach a fair and mutually beneficial arrangement with the board; on 07-04 a Sina executive told Reuters the two sides had reached a consensus, on 07-30 the separation agreement was signed, and on 08-15 he handed over the equity. The company documents found record no related litigation. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)] [路透報導(新浪科技轉述,2001-07-04)] [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)]
- Sina and Wang Zhidong have reached agreement on the Sina Internet equity, and he has agreed to transfer all of it. [Later confirmed] Reuters, citing Hurst Lin, general manager of Sina in the United States; Sina Tech noted when relaying it that it was not yet confirmed The company's proxy statement records that he transferred his holding on 2001-08-15; Sina announced on 10-02 that the transfer was complete. [路透報導(新浪科技轉述,2001-07-04)] [SINA.com 2001 年委託書(SEC DEF 14A)] [北京晚報(新浪科技轉載,2001-10-03)]
Views
- Wang Zhidong (the party concerned): He said the problem lay not in some abstract "will of capital": capital is operated by particular people, and when things go wrong it is with people; he also said what he felt was shock, betrayal, and a wish only to go home. [新浪科技:王志東記者會實錄(2001-06-25)] [賽迪網(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-26)]
- Daniel Mao (the succeeding chief executive): He told Caijing that everyone knew he himself would not be in the post for three or five years, the implication being that Wang Zhidong had still had a chance, but after making such a scene could not come back. [《財經》雜誌 2001 年 7 月號〈王志東沉沒〉下篇(新浪科技轉載)]
- Daniel Chiang (chairman): He said it was the board's unanimous decision and there was no question of regret, but admitted the decision had been made in haste, that the two sides had not communicated enough and that the board also bore responsibility; whether it was right or wrong would have to be shown by time and each quarter's results. [新浪科技:姜豐年越洋電話記者會(2001-06-27)]
- Duan Yongji (director; chairman of the Stone Group): He asked in return: people say capital is bloodstained, but is it not bloodstained when managers burn investors' money? He considered that a culture in which "it is easy to invite a god in but hard to send him away" would scare off venture capital. [新華網(新浪科技轉載,2001-06-29)] [中國經濟時報(大紀元轉載,2001-06-29)]
- Zhou Mao (Sina executive vice president for China, Wang Zhidong's friend of many years): He thought Wang Zhidong had been far from calm, perhaps influenced by those around him; it was not appropriate to use equity that had been placed in his name for the sake of the listing to bargain with the board. [財經時報(大紀元轉載,2001-07-03)]
- Caijing Shibao (China Business Post; reporter Li Liang): The report quoted industry figures as saying the confrontation was bad for Sina and for the whole internet industry and had dragged down the share price; but some media also thought the coverage had if anything raised Sina's profile. [財經時報(大紀元轉載,2001-07-03)]
- Hurst Lin (general manager of Sina in the United States, co-founder): He said the board recognised Wang Zhidong's contribution in taking the company public, but the company now needed someone more experienced to lead the team. [路透報導(新浪科技轉述,2001-07-04)]
- Hu Shuli (editor-in-chief of Caijing magazine): She considered the heart of the problem to be institutional: to get round regulation, the company holding the China website's licence was placed in the chief executive's personal name, with the result that the man who stepped down held a bargaining chip he should never have had; what all sides should learn from it was to build a better institutional environment. [《財經》胡舒立評論(新浪科技轉載)]
- Chen Hong (US-based entrepreneur, early Sina investor): He acknowledged Wang Zhidong's contribution to China's internet industry and thought he might have been unable to accept it emotionally, and that the two sides had not communicated enough; but in the United States a chief executive faced with such a decision would usually accept it rationally. [環球時報(新浪科技轉載,2001-07-06)]
- Zhu Min (US-based entrepreneur): He said a listing is only the beginning and any change can happen afterwards; a listed company serves its investors and is not one's own company, and decisions cannot be made too much from a personal standpoint. [環球時報(新浪科技轉載,2001-07-06)]
- Wang Yan (the new chief executive): He said senior executives are professional managers, not owners of the company; those who meet their targets can retire with their task accomplished, and those who do not may be dismissed by the board, and it is under this kind of oversight that listed companies grow. [北京晚報(新浪新聞轉載,2003-05-13)]
Photos & videos
Zhongguancun, Beijing, on 4 June 2001 — the very day the news that Sina had announced Wang Zhidong's "resignation" appeared in the Beijing papers. — wanghongliu / CC BY-SA 3.0
Zhongguancun Street on 4 June 2001. Wang Zhidong was called the "darling of Zhongguancun", and Sina's Beijing office was also in this area. — wanghongliu / CC BY-SA 3.0
Street scene in Zhongguancun, Beijing, on 4 June 2001, as it looked at the time of the events. — wanghongliu / CC BY-SA 3.0
The electronics market on the ground floor of the Hailong Building in Zhongguancun, photographed in May 2003; the next day Daniel Mao, the chief executive who had replaced Wang Zhidong, announced his resignation. (Date of photograph inferred from the file name.) — Yaohua2000 / CC BY-SA 3.0
Map of Sina.com's locations around the world (drawn in 2007 from data on Sina's website). Sina was formed by the merger of Beijing's Stone Rich Sight with Sinanet of the United States and Taiwan, and its board therefore spanned both sides of the Taiwan Strait and Silicon Valley. — Jnlin(中文維基百科) / CC BY-SA 3.0
North entrance of the Sina headquarters building in Beijing, photographed in January 2020. At the helm by then was Charles Chao, chief financial officer at the time of the 2001 events. — N509FZ / CC BY-SA 4.0
South side of the Sina headquarters building in Beijing, photographed in January 2020. — N509FZ / CC BY-SA 4.0
The Friendship Hotel in Beijing, photographed in 2023. After leaving Sina, Wang Zhidong prepared his new company in a temporary office here in September 2001. — N509FZ / CC BY-SA 4.0
The Stone Building in Beijing (completed 1995, formerly the headquarters of the Stone company), photographed in 2024. The Stone Group funded Wang Zhidong's start-up, and its chairman Duan Yongji voted for his removal in 2001. — 大慈树王 / CC BY 4.0
Lip-Bu Tan meeting the US Secretary of Commerce as chief executive of Intel, August 2025. In 2001 he was the Sina director representing Walden. — United States Department of Commerce / Public domain