🏢 Companies👑 Thrones

Isami Wada (Isamu Wada) — Sekisui House (積水ハウス) (Sekisui House)

In 2017 Sekisui House was defrauded by land swindlers (jimenshi) in a land deal in Gotanda, Tokyo, losing about 5.56 billion yen. At the board meeting of 24 January 2018, chairman Isami Wada, who had held power for twenty years, proposed the dismissal of president Toshinori Abe on the basis of an investigation report by the outside officers; it failed 5 to 5. Abe immediately moved in turn to dismiss Wada, who was forced to resign; the company described it publicly as a generational change. Abe was promoted to chairman and Yoshihiro Nakai became president. At the shareholders' meeting of 23 April 2020, Wada and sitting director Fumiyasu Suguro put forward an 11-person slate of directors in an attempt to regain control; it was voted down, with Wada himself receiving only 6.13%. Abe stepped down as chairman in April 2021, and the shareholder derivative suit against him was dismissed at both first and second instance in 2022.

How they were ousted

Forced to resign: he proposed at the board the dismissal of president Abe (which failed 5 to 5); Abe's side in turn replaced him as chair of the meeting and moved to dismiss him as chairman, and facing a 6-to-4 line-up he announced his resignation.

What happened to the board

Wada did not come back, and the side that forced him out was not purged either. Of the 11 directors of 2018-01-24, the five on Abe's side (Inagaki, Uchida, Nishida, Horiuchi and Nakai) were all re-elected in 2020, and Nakai was still president and CEO in 2026; Abe served three years and three months as chairman before stepping down on 2021-04-27 to become special adviser. It was Wada's side that went first: Iku was already missing from the 2019 slate, Suguro and outside director Saegusa left the board on 2020-04-23, and only Wakui stayed on. The price was reputation: Abe and Inagaki won only around 70% approval at the 2018 and 2020 shareholders' meetings.

Timeline

  1. Sekisui House signs the contract to buy the "Umikikan" land in Gotanda and pays a deposit of 1.4 billion yen Through an intermediary buyer, Sekisui House signed a contract with a person claiming to be the landowner to buy the land of the former inn "Umikikan" in Nishi-Gotanda, Tokyo, and paid a deposit of 1.4 billion yen that day. [維基百科日文版(積水ハウス地面師詐欺事件)]
  2. Balance of 4.9 billion yen paid early Sekisui House paid the balance of 4.9 billion yen (holding back a further 700 million). Wada's side later questioned why, when the real landowner had repeatedly sent warnings by content-certified mail that the contract was fake, the company still brought the payment forward, and used bank cashier's cheques rather than a transfer. [維基百科日文版(積水ハウス地面師詐欺事件)] [Business Insider Japan(2020-02-18)]
  3. Legal Affairs Bureau rejects the registration; the landowner is found to be fake The Legal Affairs Bureau gave notice that the application for registration had been rejected and that the documents submitted by the self-styled landowner were forged; only then did the company learn it had fallen victim to land swindlers. [維基百科日文版(積水ハウス地面師詐欺事件)] [政治山(2018-04)]
  4. Sekisui House announces it has been defrauded The company announced publicly that it had been deceived in a land transaction; it had paid about 6.3 billion yen, and the final loss was 5.559 billion yen. [維基百科日文版(積水ハウス地面師詐欺事件)] [PRESIDENT Online(2018)]
  5. Tokyo Metropolitan Police accept the criminal complaint; the outside officers form the Investigation and Countermeasures Committee The Second Investigation Division of the Tokyo Metropolitan Police Department accepted the company's criminal complaint. The same month the outside corporate auditors and outside directors formed the Investigation and Countermeasures Committee to investigate the course of the transaction and responsibility for it. [維基百科日文版(積水ハウス地面師詐欺事件)] [現代ビジネス(取締役會經過)]
  6. The company calls it a "generational change" The same day the company announced that from 1 February Wada would become director and senior adviser, Abe would be promoted to chairman, Yoshihiro Nakai, 52, would become president and Inagaki would be promoted to vice chairman. At the press conference Abe said it was for the sake of rejuvenation; asked about any connection with the fraud case, he replied that there was none. [PRESIDENT Online(2018)] [現代ビジネス(取締役會經過)]
  7. Boardroom battle: Abe's dismissal fails 5 to 5, and Wada is forced out instead The meeting began at 2 p.m. at the Osaka head office with 11 directors present. Chairman Wada proposed Abe's dismissal on the grounds that the investigation report found the president bore the heaviest responsibility; with Abe out of the room, the 10 voted 5 to 5, short of a majority. On returning, Abe proposed replacing the chair of the meeting with Inagaki (passed 6 to 5) and then proposed Wada's dismissal; with Wada out of the room the line-up was 6 to 4, and Wada announced his resignation. [現代ビジネス(取締役會經過)] [現代ビジネス(2020-02-18)] [維基百科日文版(和田勇)] [The社史(地面師事件と会長・社長交代)]
  8. The new regime begins: Abe chairman, Inagaki vice chairman, Nakai president Wada was demoted to director and senior adviser, Abe took office as representative director and chairman, and Nakai as representative director and president; the company also set up a new management committee. [The社史(地面師事件と会長・社長交代)] [維基百科日文版(和田勇)]
  9. The company publishes only a "summary" of the investigation report, not the full text In a timely disclosure the company set out the course of events, the causes and responsibility: the Investigation and Countermeasures Committee considered that Abe, president at the time, had not grasped the full picture of the transaction and its serious risks, and bore heavy management responsibility. The full report was not published, on the grounds of avoiding copycat crimes, the confidentiality of the investigation, and privacy. [The社史(地面師事件と会長・社長交代)]
  10. The company announces it will not sue Abe An individual shareholder demanded that the company hold Abe liable, and the company announced it would not sue. At the same time the proxy advisers ISS and Glass Lewis recommended that shareholders vote against the re-election of Abe and Inagaki. [政治山(2018-04)] [NetIB-News(データ・マックス,2018-04-19)]
  11. Shareholders' meeting: only 69% for Abe and 73% for Inagaki; Wada leaves the board The 67th annual shareholders' meeting was held in Osaka and all the company's proposals passed, but the approval rates for Abe and Inagaki were far below the 95% or more for the other directors. Wada ceased to be a director on expiry of his term, keeping only the title of senior adviser. The following month an individual shareholder filed a shareholder derivative suit. [NetIB-News(データ・マックス,2018 年股東會)] [The Philadelphia Inquirer(2018-04-27)] [The社史(地面師事件と会長・社長交代)] [The社史(2020 年株主提案)]
  12. Wada and sitting director Suguro hold a press conference and put forward an 11-person slate of directors Former chairman Wada and director and senior managing executive officer Fumiyasu Suguro announced a shareholder proposal to elect 11 directors, 7 of them independent outside directors (including the Americans Christopher Brady and Pamela Jacobs), the other 4 being Wada, Suguro, Motohiko Fujiwara and Koji Yamada. Wada said he had no intention of being a representative director again. [Business Insider Japan(2020-02-18)] [東洋経済オンライン(2020-04-05)] [現代ビジネス(2020-03-11)]
  13. The board resolves to oppose the shareholder proposal and puts forward its own 12-person slate The board resolved to oppose it, saying the proposal arose from Wada's private motives; the company's slate had 12 people, with outside directors increased from 3 to 4, all four representative directors staying on and Suguro dropped. The Personnel and Remuneration Advisory Committee also unanimously opposed the 11 candidates of Wada's side. [現代ビジネス(2020-03-11)] [The社史(2020 年株主提案)]
  14. The company announces the shareholders' meeting will instead be held at the Umeda Sky Building, where its head office is located After the government declared a state of emergency on 7 April, the company changed the venue and time of the 23 April shareholders' meeting, citing reasons on the hotel's side. [NetIB-News(データ・マックス,2020 年股東會結果)]
  15. Wada's side applies for a provisional injunction to stop the meeting Wada's side applied to the Osaka District Court for a provisional injunction prohibiting the 23 April meeting, on grounds including that the change of venue increased shareholders' risk of infection. [NetIB-News(データ・マックス,2020 年股東會結果)]
  16. Osaka District Court rejects the provisional injunction The Osaka District Court rejected the application and the shareholders' meeting went ahead as scheduled. [NetIB-News(データ・マックス,2020 年股東會結果)]
  17. Shareholders' meeting votes down the proposal of Wada's side At the 69th annual shareholders' meeting, the company's proposals Nos. 1 to 7 all passed and 12 directors were elected; proposal No. 8 from Wada's side (election of 11 directors) was voted down. The same meeting approved amendments to the articles of incorporation shortening directors' terms to no more than one year and deleting the provision for senior advisers. Suguro left the board the same day. [NetIB-News(データ・マックス,2020 年股東會結果)] [The社史(2020 年株主提案)] [維基百科日文版(積水ハウス地面師詐欺事件)]
  18. Extraordinary report discloses the votes: Abe 69.27%, Wada 6.13% Company side: Abe 69.27%, Inagaki 72.87%, Nakai 85.32%, Uchida 85.97%, all the others above 96%. Wada's side: Brady 30.49%, Jiro Iwasaki 25.48%, Hitomi Kato 18.39%, Suguro 6.17%, Wada 6.13%, and Fujiwara and Yamada only about 2%. [NetIB-News(データ・マックス,2020 年股東會結果)]
  19. The company publishes the outside lawyers' "comprehensive verification report" After the sentences on all members of the land-swindling group became final, the company commissioned three lawyers to conduct a verification and published the full text. The report considered that the case was a fraud by an outside group, the causes being departmental silos, weak checks and balances and low risk awareness; it overturned the 2018 report's conclusion that "particular senior executives bear responsibility", finding no apparent breach of directors' duties. [NetIB-News(データ・マックス,2020-12-17)] [The社史(2020 年株主提案)]
  20. The company announces chairman Abe's retirement Sekisui House announced that Toshinori Abe would step down as chairman. [維基百科日文版(積水ハウス地面師詐欺事件)] [The社史(2020 年株主提案)]
  21. Abe steps down as chairman and becomes special adviser Three years and three months after forcing out Wada, Abe left the chairmanship and became special adviser; president Nakai has also been CEO since April 2021. [PRESIDENT Online(2021-07-24)] [維基百科日文版(阿部俊則)] [The社史(仲井嘉浩)]
  22. Abe appears as a defendant at the Osaka District Court Abe appeared in court in the shareholder derivative suit. Reports said that in May 2017 it had already been reported to him in writing that the landowner might be fake, and that on 30 May he agreed to bring the payment forward. [現代ビジネス(株主代表訴訟)]
  23. Osaka District Court dismisses the shareholder derivative suit The suit in which an individual shareholder demanded that Abe and Inagaki pay the company 5.559 billion yen in damages was dismissed by the Osaka District Court. [維基百科日文版(積水ハウス地面師詐欺事件)]
  24. Osaka High Court dismisses the shareholder's appeal The Osaka High Court upheld the first-instance ruling and dismissed the shareholder side's appeal. [維基百科日文版(積水ハウス地面師詐欺事件)] [The社史(2020 年株主提案)]
  25. Nakai re-elected at the shareholders' meeting with 96.52% Yoshihiro Nakai, whom Wada had regarded as on Abe's side, was still re-elected as director by a large margin eight years after becoming president. [The社史(仲井嘉浩)]

People

Moves to block a return

Rumors

Views

Photos & videos