Maurice Saatchi (Maurice Saatchi) — Saatchi & Saatchi (holding company renamed Cordiant in 1995) (Saatchi & Saatchi (holding company renamed Cordiant in 1995))
Maurice Saatchi and his elder brother Charles founded Saatchi & Saatchi in 1970; by 1986 acquisitions had made it the world's largest advertising group, after which the share price collapsed. In December 1994 David Herro, a fund manager at Harris Associates in Chicago, joined with other shareholders to demand a change, and on 16 December the board removed him as chairman. He would not accept the demotion and resigned on 3 January 1995; six days later seven executives, including acting chairman Jeremy Sinclair, North America head Bill Muirhead and UK head David Kershaw, resigned en masse and set up a rival firm with the brothers, provisionally named the New Saatchi Agency. The old company sued, sought an injunction, pursued a sum of US$40 million and renamed the holding company Cordiant; but the court refused the injunction, major clients such as British Airways followed in May 1995, the two sides settled the same month, and the new firm was named M&C Saatchi. He never returned to the old company: Cordiant split in two in 1997, Saatchi & Saatchi was sold to Publicis in 2000, and what remained of Cordiant was taken over by WPP in 2003.
How they were ousted
US fund manager David Herro applied pressure on behalf of dissatisfied shareholders; on 1994-12-16 the board met for about eight hours and removed him as chairman, leaving him only an honorary post and the chairmanship of a subsidiary; he tendered his resignation on 1995-01-03.
What happened to the board
He did not go back, so no one was "purged" by him. According to the book excerpt in Ad Age, the board then had nine members: former chief executive Robert Louis-Dreyfus resigned as director on the day of the meeting; Jeremy Sinclair, who opposed the dismissal and was made acting chairman, resigned a little over three weeks later (1995-01-09) with two other executives to join him; chief executive Charles Scott, who led the change, was instead promoted to chairman and stayed until handing over on 2003-03-01, a further eight years and more. David Herro, the shareholder who applied the pressure, was still managing funds at Harris Associates in 2026. What actually made this board disappear was the company itself: demerged in 1997, its two halves bought by competitors in 2000 and 2003. Conversely, Maurice himself resigned as a director of his second company, M&C Saatchi, in December 2019 amid an accounting scandal.
Timeline
- The brothers found Saatchi & Saatchi in London Charles had originally run a creative consultancy with Ross Cramer; after Cramer left, his younger brother Maurice joined, and in 1970 they opened under their surname; Jeremy Sinclair was part of the founding team. Around 1975 it obtained a stock market listing through a reverse takeover of Garland Compton. [Wikipedia:Saatchi & Saatchi] [M&C Saatchi 2004 年公開說明書]
- Buys Ted Bates and becomes the world's largest advertising group Acquired more than 35 companies between 1972 and 1987, reaching world number one after buying Ted Bates for about US$500 million in 1986. The share price peaked that year at about 5,300 pence. [Wikipedia:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)]
- Bid for Midland Bank rebuffed; stock market crash a month later The brothers made an approach to acquire the major British bank Midland Bank, which its board rejected; it was widely seen as a miscalculation. On Black Monday, 19 October, the company's share price fell by about a third in a day. [Wikipedia:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)]
- Profits fall for the first time in 18 years; Louis-Dreyfus hired from outside as chief executive Profits fell sharply in 1989 and the company announced the sale of its consulting businesses. Robert Louis-Dreyfus became chief executive and Charles Scott joined to manage finance; over the next two years about 5,200 jobs were cut, and a financial restructuring was completed in 1991. [Wikipedia:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Encyclopedia.com:Saatchi & Saatchi]
- David Herro joins Harris Associates, holding a stake of nearly 10% Herro joined Harris Associates in Chicago in 1992. Wikipedia says he was then managing a stake of about 9.6% in Saatchi & Saatchi for the firm and began to worry that the public quarrel between Scott and Maurice was harming the investment. [Wikipedia:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Harris Associates 官方簡歷]
- Louis-Dreyfus steps down; Charles Scott becomes chief executive Louis-Dreyfus resigned as chief executive and stayed on as a non-executive director, with Scott, whom he had brought in, taking over. From then on the conflict between Scott and Maurice was out in the open. [Encyclopedia.com:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Wikipedia:Robert Louis-Dreyfus]
- The board moves the brothers out of their luxurious offices and removes Charles from the board According to the company history on Encyclopedia.com, the board ordered the brothers to move out of their luxurious offices and voted Charles off the board — he was said to have attended only one board meeting. In March 1994 Ad Age relayed industry accounts that the relocation had only narrowly passed the board. [Encyclopedia.com:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Ad Age(1994 年 3 月)]
- An apparent truce in the spring: a new director comes in to conduct a review, and the employment contract is renegotiated in June Sir Peter Walters, former chairman of BP, joined the board at the start of the year and reviewed the holding company's operations with Scott; Bill Muirhead was transferred to New York in February to run the worldwide advertising business. Adweek said the conflict between Maurice and Scott seemed for a time in the spring to have been resolved; Maurice later mentioned in his claim that his employment contract had been negotiated only in June 1994. [Ad Age:Sagging Saatchi] [Adweek(1994 年回顧)] [Marketing Week] [M&C Saatchi 2004 年公開說明書]
- Herro confronts the board: share options, the mansion and the share price Herro told the board that the company's financial performance over the past three or four years had been very poor, with the share price down from 5,300 pence in 1986 to around 150 pence. He opposed a share option package of about £5 million that Maurice was asking for, and questioned the spending with the ten pages of photographs in the January issue of Architectural Digest of the renovation of Maurice's country house in Sussex. [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)]
- Eight-hour board meeting: Maurice removed as chairman According to the book excerpt in Ad Age, the board met at 2 p.m. (the source does not state the time zone; it should be London time), with a dozen or so lawyers and advisers present; the board told him that the votes on Herro's side were enough to override the nine-member board, and he later stressed that no shareholder vote had in fact ever been held. During the meeting, former chief executive Louis-Dreyfus resigned as director. The Media Leader, citing the Financial Times, said the brokers Warburg and UBS reported to the board that only 3.2% of shareholders were certain to back Maurice and about 40% would vote for him to go. [Ad Age 書摘] [Ad Age(1994-12-19)] [The Media Leader(轉述金融時報)] [《Cultures of Consumption》結論章]
- Ad Age: the board accepts the shareholders' demands wholesale Ad Age reported that Herro, who claimed to represent nearly 40% of shareholders, led the revolt, and that the divided board agreed to every demand the shareholders made, including removing him from the holding company and renaming the company. Deputy chairman Jeremy Sinclair became acting chairman while the company looked for a permanent candidate. [Ad Age(1994-12-19)]
- The brothers consider opening a rival firm; the company gives him a deadline of 3 January The Christian Science Monitor reported that Maurice was discussing with Charles the opening of a rival firm, targeting clients such as British Airways, Mars and Mirror Group. The board gave him until 3 January to decide whether to accept the honorary post; Scott recommended that the board take "Saatchi" out of the holding company's name. Two days earlier (12-21) the share price stood at 154 pence. [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)]
- Cordiant swings from profit to loss for the year; Scott becomes chairman Cordiant made a pre-tax loss of US$34.5 million in 1995, having earned US$21 million the year before. Bob Seelert became chief executive, and Scott gave up that post to be chairman only. Mars and other clients left one after another; however, Marketing Week's year-end ranking showed that Saatchi & Saatchi's London company still held first place in Britain. [Encyclopedia.com:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Wikipedia:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Crunchbase:Charles Scott] [Marketing Week(1995-12-08)]
- Announces a rival firm, provisionally named the New Saatchi Agency Shortly after the seven resigned, Maurice announced he would open a new firm to compete for the old company's business; the five partners (the brothers plus Sinclair, Muirhead and Kershaw) held equal shares, and the company's registered name was Dress Rehearsal. BA, Mars and the British Conservative Party all said they would review their agency relationships, while Procter & Gamble denied any such intention. [Christian Science Monitor(1995-01-17)] [Encyclopedia.com:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Ad Age:Maurice 1, Saatchi 0 in court wars]
- The two sides sue each other The old company sued first, alleging that Maurice had induced the three executives to leave; Maurice then counter-sued, arguing that the company had unlawfully terminated his employment contract on or about 16 December and that there had been misrepresentations when the contract was negotiated in June 1994. Both sides acted within a week. [Marketing Week]
- Maurice tenders his resignation According to the book excerpt in Ad Age, he first faxed a draft resignation letter on 2 January and on 3 January delivered his resignation to a company most of whose staff were still on holiday. His public line was that Saatchi & Saatchi had been taken over. [Ad Age 書摘]
- Seven senior executives resign en masse in support Seven executives, including acting chairman Jeremy Sinclair, North America chief executive Bill Muirhead and UK head David Kershaw, resigned on the same day; Wikipedia also lists Moray MacLennan, Nick Hurrell, Simon Dicketts and James Lowther. The trade magazine Campaign said it was a devastating blow to the company. [Christian Science Monitor(1995-01-17)] [Wikipedia:Saatchi & Saatchi]
- British Airways' president writes to the press questioning the move; Scott hurries to reassure clients British Airways president Lord King wrote to The Daily Telegraph asking how a Chicago institution holding less than 10% could dictate to the board of a British company. The same day Scott ordered special briefings for clients; about 40 staff working on BA were reportedly persuaded to stay. [Christian Science Monitor(1995-01-17)]
- Charles proposes letting his brother come back; the board refuses Charles, still honorary president, held out an olive branch to the board one weekend: let Maurice come back to run the advertising business and spin it off later. The board quickly refused. Marketing Week noted at the same time that Scott's public relations offensive was beginning to work and the share price was back above £1. [Marketing Week:The turning tides at Saatchi group]
- Clients begin to waver: Mirror Group goes first, and BA holds a four-way pitch Bermuda's The Royal Gazette, drawing on wire reports, said Mirror Group had simply dropped the old company; British Airways put its account of about US$90 million up for a pitch between the new and old Saatchi firms and two other agencies; Mars, Dixons and the Conservative Party were also reviewing their contracts. The report also mentioned that Harris Associates itself was then up for sale. [The Royal Gazette(1995-02-01)]
- High Court in London refuses the injunction; the new firm wins its first two clients After a three-day hearing the judge refused the old company's application for an injunction, allowed the three former executives to do preparatory work not involving competition, and ordered the old company to bear both sides' costs; when they could formally join, and whether the Saatchi name could be used, were left to the full trial in the spring. At the same time the new firm announced its first two clients: Mirror Group and Gallaher's Silk Cut cigarettes, both transferred from the old company. (Date inferred from reports.) [Marketing Week(1995-02-17)] [The Media Leader] [Ad Age:Maurice 1, Saatchi 0 in court wars]
- The old company turns to pursuing the US$40 million Adidas payment The day after its defeat, the old company brought a new suit against the brothers, arguing that the settlement of about US$40 million they received over the Adidas share option dispute should belong to the company. Maurice replied that it was a private matter. No public report was found of how this case was finally resolved. [Marketing Week(1995-02-17)] [Marketing Week:The turning tides at Saatchi group]
- Shareholders approve the name change; the holding company becomes Cordiant Shareholders voted on 16 March and it took effect the next day; the logo was designed by group company Siegel & Gale. The same week the old company brought back Jennifer Laing to replace Kershaw as chairman of the London company and bought her small agency, Laing Henry. [Design Week(1995-03-23)] [Marketing Week:… as Laing returns]
- British Airways gives its worldwide account to the new firm; Qantas follows Ad Age reported that in early May 1995 BA moved its worldwide advertising business of about US$96 million from the old company to New Saatchi; the Australian airline Qantas then also transferred its international account of about US$35 million. Ad Age later said that winning BA was the key to the new firm finding its feet immediately and sustaining an international network. [Ad Age:Qantas picks New Saatchi agency] [Ad Age:Saatchi at 5] [The Irish Times(2005-07-06)]
- Out-of-court settlement; the new firm is named M&C Saatchi M&C Saatchi, Cordiant, the brothers and others signed an agreement giving the new firm the right to use the name "M&C Saatchi"; the former executives could start work from the end of May but could not poach any more Cordiant staff before the end of the year, and Maurice withdrew his claims for wrongful dismissal and severance pay. The new firm's revenue in its first full year was £8.1 million. [M&C Saatchi 2004 年公開說明書] [The Media Leader]
- Maurice made a life peer Less than two years after being driven out of his own company, he was created Baron Saatchi, of Staplefield, and entered the House of Lords as a Conservative. M&C Saatchi also took on the Conservative Party's advertising. [Wikipedia:Maurice Saatchi] [Wikipedia:M&C Saatchi]
- Cordiant shareholders approve splitting in two An extraordinary general meeting in London approved the demerger of Cordiant into two listed companies: Saatchi & Saatchi plc and Cordiant Communications Group (centred on Bates), each holding half of the media buying company Zenith; only about 30 small shareholders attended. Kevin Roberts became chief executive of Saatchi & Saatchi; Design Week said Scott would be non-executive chairman of both companies for a year. [Adweek] [Encyclopedia.com:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Design Week(1997-04-24)]
- France's Publicis announces it is buying Saatchi & Saatchi Publicis acquired Saatchi & Saatchi plc through a share exchange, with Adweek estimating the value of the deal at about US$1.9 billion; in September 2000 Publicis issued a press release saying the acquisition had been completed on the timetable announced on 20 June. The old company bearing the brothers' surname was from then on a subsidiary of a French group. [Publicis Groupe 新聞稿(2000 年 9 月)] [Adweek] [Encyclopedia.com:Saatchi & Saatchi]
- Charles Scott hands over the chairmanship of Cordiant The company had said in September 2002 that he would leave once a successor was found; on 2003-01-30 it announced that Nigel Stapleton, 56, would take over from 1 March. The chief executive who had forced out the founder spent about 13 years in all at the company. [Cordiant 公告(2003-01-30)] [The Media Leader(2002)]
- WPP moves to acquire the troubled Cordiant On 2003-04-28 major client Allied Domecq withdrew its account from Bates, and Cordiant's debt restructuring talks broke down. WPP made its offer on 19 June and, by buying up most of the company's debt, beat Publicis and the hedge fund Cerberus; the total price was about £276 million, of which the equity was worth only about £10 million. [Euromoney(2003-09-01)] [The Star(2003-06-21)]
- WPP's acquisition takes effect; Cordiant ceases to exist as a company Active Value, a major shareholder with about a quarter of the shares, voted in favour in the end; Cordiant's shares were delisted on 16 July and the acquisition took effect on 1 August. The holding company that had been renamed from Saatchi & Saatchi was thus absorbed into WPP. [Euromoney(2003-09-01)] [Wikipedia:Cordiant Communications Group]
- M&C Saatchi lists on AIM in London The prospectus stated a placing price of 125 pence a share, with admission and dealings set to begin at 8 a.m. (London time) on 2004-07-14. Sinclair was chairman and Kershaw chief executive, with Maurice and Muirhead as executive directors; Charles had not been involved in management since 1997. [M&C Saatchi 2004 年公開說明書]
- British Airways leaves M&C Saatchi BA announced a review of its worldwide advertising account of about £60 million in July 2005 and chose Bartle Bogle Hegarty in October, ending more than twenty years of working with the Saatchi brothers. The flagship client won from the old company also left, ten years on. [The Irish Times(2005-07-06)] [Adweek]
- Maurice resigns as a director of M&C Saatchi Accounting problems came to light at M&C Saatchi in 2019, with the amount recognised revised up from £6.4 million to £11.6 million, and the share price fell from about £4 in March to below £1. On the evening of 10 December Maurice resigned together with three independent directors (Lord Dobbs, Sir Michael Peat and Lorna Tilbian). This time it was he who walked out of the boardroom. [City A.M.(2019-12-11)] [Wikipedia:Maurice Saatchi]
- The "Three Amigos" announce their handover M&C Saatchi announced that the three founders Sinclair, Kershaw and Muirhead were stepping down: Moray MacLennan would become chief executive from 2021-01-01 and Gareth Davis, former chief executive of Imperial Tobacco, would become chairman; Sinclair and Kershaw left on 2020-12-31, and Muirhead was due to leave the board in March 2021. With that, all five of those who walked out together in 1995 had left the board of the second company they founded. [City A.M.(2020-11-19)] [The Drum(2020-11-19)] [London South East]
People
- Maurice Saatchi (later Lord Saatchi) (Maurice Saatchi (Lord Saatchi)), 1946-06-21 — Co-founder; chairman of the holding company. Born in Baghdad, Iraq, the third of four brothers. Took a first-class honours degree in sociology at the London School of Economics in 1967 and first spent about three years at the publisher Haymarket. Founded Saatchi & Saatchi with his elder brother Charles in 1970, making its name with the 1979 "Labour isn't working" poster for the Conservative Party. Co-founder. After his brother's original partner Ross Cramer left, he left Haymarket to join his brother's firm, and the two opened for business under their surname in 1970; sources differ on when he became chairman (Ad Age says March 1985, the M&C Saatchi prospectus says 1980). He and Charles are full brothers; Jeremy Sinclair was a founding member of the company, Bill Muirhead joined in 1971–1972 and David Kershaw in 1982, all long-standing subordinates who had worked with them for ten or twenty years. Chief executive Charles Scott was a finance executive who came in only after the company's financial troubles in 1989–1990, and the two were long at odds; he publicly called Scott and Herro people who could only count. Removed as chairman on 1994-12-16 and resigned on 1995-01-03, immediately founding M&C Saatchi; he never returned to the old company. Made a life peer in 1996 and co-chairman of the Conservative Party from 2003 to 2005; resigned as executive director of M&C Saatchi on 2019-12-10 amid that company's accounting scandal. [Wikipedia:Maurice Saatchi] [Ad Age(生平年表)] [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)] [City A.M.(2019-12-11)]
- Charles Saatchi (Charles Saatchi), 1943-06-09 — Co-founder; honorary president (already voted off the board in December 1993). Born in Baghdad, Maurice's elder brother. Attended Christ's College secondary school in London and the London College of Communication; joined Benton & Bowles as a copywriter in 1965, and in 1967 set up the creative consultancy CramerSaatchi with art director Ross Cramer. Recognised in the industry as the company's creative core, he is also a major collector of contemporary art and opened the Saatchi Gallery in 1985. Co-founder. According to the company history on Encyclopedia.com, in December 1993 the board moved the brothers out of their luxurious offices and voted him off the board — he was said to have attended only one board meeting; thereafter he kept only the title of honorary president. Maurice's elder brother. After his brother was removed, he at one point proposed to the board that his brother come back to run the advertising business, and was turned down; he then stated in court papers that he intended to join his brother's new firm as soon as possible and planned to sue the old company for "constructive dismissal". Resigned as honorary president in 1995 and became one of the five founding partners of M&C Saatchi; that company's prospectus says he had not been involved in management since 1997, and at the 2004 flotation his stake fell from 13.7% to 7.0%. He has since been known as an art collector. (The exact date of his resignation was not found.) [Wikipedia:Charles Saatchi] [Encyclopedia.com:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Marketing Week:The turning tides at Saatchi group] [The Media Leader] [M&C Saatchi 2004 年公開說明書]
- David Herro (David Herro) — Representative of a major shareholder: fund manager at Harris Associates in Chicago (not a director). A native of Wisconsin, USA; bachelor's degree from the University of Wisconsin–Platteville in 1983 and a master's in economics from the Milwaukee campus in 1985. Joined Principal Financial Group in 1986 to manage an international equity fund, moved to the State of Wisconsin Investment Board in 1989, and joined Harris Associates in 1992, founding and managing the Oakmark International fund. A 2009 report said he was then 48 and had been a meat salesman; his exact date of birth was not found. He was not on the board and intervened as a shareholder: Wikipedia says that in 1992 he managed a stake of about 9.6% in Saatchi & Saatchi for Harris Associates; at the end of 1994 he claimed to represent nearly 40% (other reports say about a third) of dissatisfied shareholders and demanded that the board replace the chairman. He had no personal relationship with Maurice; it was purely investor versus management. He was unhappy that the public infighting between Scott and Maurice was dragging down the share price, opposed a share option package of about £5 million that Maurice was asking for, and questioned the spending before the board with the ten pages of photographs Architectural Digest had published of the renovation of Maurice's country house. On the question of the change he was on the same side as chief executive Scott. Stayed at Harris Associates after the affair, later becoming a partner and co-chief investment officer for international equities, and deputy chairman from 2015; named International Fund Manager of the Year by Morningstar in 2006 and 2016, and still appearing on financial programmes as a fund manager in early 2026. This affair became the battle he is best known for. [Wikipedia:David Herro] [Harris Associates 官方簡歷] [IR Impact(2009-03-31)] [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)] [Wikipedia:Saatchi & Saatchi]
- Charles Scott (Charles (Charlie) Scott) — Chief executive of the holding company; director. From a finance background. After the company's profits fell for the first time in 1989, Robert Louis-Dreyfus was brought in as chief executive and he joined at the same time as finance director (Wikipedia says 1989, Crunchbase's data says 1990); promoted to chief operating officer in 1992 and became chief executive in 1993. No citable source was found for his year of birth or earlier career. Came in with Louis-Dreyfus's turnaround team to manage finance, and took over as chief executive after Louis-Dreyfus left. In early 1994 he reviewed the holding company's operations together with the new director Sir Peter Walters, former chairman of BP. Long at odds with Maurice; their infighting seemed to have subsided in the spring of 1994 and broke out again in December. Maurice publicly mocked him and Herro as "bean counters". The academic work Cultures of Consumption names him alongside Herro as the leaders of the putsch. Rose still higher after forcing out the founder: gave up the chief executive post in 1995 to become chairman of Cordiant, and after the 1997 demerger was for a time non-executive chairman of both new companies. In September 2002 the company announced that he would leave once a successor was found, and on 2003-03-01 Nigel Stapleton took over as chairman of Cordiant; five months later Cordiant was acquired by WPP. [Wikipedia:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Crunchbase:Charles Scott] [Adweek(1994 年回顧)] [Ad Age:Sagging Saatchi] [Design Week(1997-04-24)] [The Media Leader(2002)] [Cordiant 公告(2003-01-30)]
- Jeremy Sinclair (Jeremy Sinclair), 1946 — Deputy chairman of the holding company, director; became acting chairman after Maurice was removed. Born in Newcastle, England; attended Rannoch School in Scotland and Watford College of Art and Technology. Joined Cramer Saatchi in 1968, became a founding member of Saatchi & Saatchi in 1970, creative director in 1973, chairman of the UK company in 1982 and deputy chairman of the group in 1986. The "Labour isn't working" poster was his work. With Charles Saatchi from 1968, part of the founding team when the firm opened in 1970, rising all the way to deputy chairman of the group. The brothers' most senior partner. He later said that the majority of the board chose to bow to pressure from American shareholders and dismiss Maurice, and that he had advised against it at the time; he also said he did not intend to spend years repairing something he had warned others not to break. Only a little over three weeks after being made acting chairman, he resigned on 1995-01-09 together with six other executives, becoming a founding partner of M&C Saatchi and its chairman at the 2004 flotation. Awarded a CBE in 2017; stepped down and left M&C Saatchi on 2020-12-31 after the accounting scandal. [Wikipedia:Jeremy Sinclair] [Christian Science Monitor(1995-01-17)] [Dave Dye 專訪(2015-04-27)] [M&C Saatchi 2004 年公開說明書] [City A.M.(2020-11-19)]
- Bill Muirhead (Bill Muirhead), 1946 — Chief executive and president of Saatchi & Saatchi Advertising Worldwide (based in New York); reported to be one of the three directors who resigned. Born in Adelaide, Australia; moved to London as a teenager, attended St Dunstan's College and studied commercial art. Joined Ogilvy in 1970 and Saatchi & Saatchi in 1971–1972 as one of its earliest account executives, handling clients including British Airways; later ran the European business and was transferred to New York in February 1994. Came in as an account executive a year or two after the company was founded (the prospectus says 1971, Wikipedia says 1972) and rose to chief executive of the worldwide advertising business. A veteran who had followed the brothers for more than twenty years, known in the industry together with Sinclair and Kershaw as the "Three Amigos". The old company alleged in its claim that Maurice induced him to leave, and there were separate proceedings against him in New York. Resigned on 1995-01-09, becoming a founding partner and executive director of M&C Saatchi. Also Agent General for South Australia in London from 2007, and awarded the Order of Australia in 2013; in November 2020 the company announced that the three founders would hand over, and he was due to leave the board in March 2021. [Wikipedia:Bill Muirhead] [M&C Saatchi 2004 年公開說明書] [The Royal Gazette(1995-02-01)] [London South East(2020 年 11 月公告摘要)]
- David Kershaw (David Kershaw), 1954-02 — Chairman and chief executive of Saatchi & Saatchi's UK company; reported to be one of the three directors who resigned. British; attended Bedales School, took a bachelor's degree in politics and economics at Durham University and an MBA at London Business School. Entered the industry as a trainee at Wasey Campbell-Ewald in 1977, joined Saatchi & Saatchi in 1982, became managing director in 1990 and was promoted to chairman and chief executive of the UK company in 1994. Joined in 1982 after completing his MBA, and in twelve years rose to the top post in the UK company. The youngest of the three executives who walked out, known with Sinclair and Muirhead as the "Three Amigos". After he resigned, the old company brought back Jennifer Laing to take his place in London. Resigned on 1995-01-09, becoming a founding partner of M&C Saatchi and its chief executive from the 2004 flotation. During the 2019 accounting scandal he offered to resign, was told this was not in the company's interests and stayed on; stepped down on 2020-12-31, succeeded by Moray MacLennan. [Powerbase:David Kershaw] [M&C Saatchi 2004 年公開說明書] [Marketing Week:… as Laing returns] [City A.M.(2019-12-11)] [City A.M.(2020-11-19)]
- Robert Louis-Dreyfus (Robert Louis-Dreyfus), 1946-06-14 — Non-executive director (former chief executive). Born in Paris into the French Louis-Dreyfus family; attended Harvard Business School. Joined the US pharmaceutical market research company IMS in 1982, and when the company was sold in 1988 his investment had multiplied twentyfold. Brought in as chief executive of Saatchi & Saatchi in 1989, he cut about 5,200 jobs within two years and completed a financial restructuring in 1991, stepping down in 1993. Brought in as chief executive to clear up the mess after the company's profits fell for the first time in 1989; after handing over in 1993 to Charles Scott, whom he had brought in, he stayed on as a non-executive director, and ran Adidas from 1994. Scott's old boss, he also had business dealings with the brothers — the brothers held a minority stake in Adidas and later negotiated a settlement of about US$40 million, which became the subject of the old company's suit. According to the book excerpt in Ad Age, he was not present at the start of the meeting on 1994-12-16, and had said he could resign if Maurice wished, which Maurice accepted. Resigned as director during the board meeting that dismissed Maurice. He then concentrated on running Adidas until 2001, and from 1996 was the principal shareholder of the French football club Olympique de Marseille; died of leukaemia in Zurich on 2009-07-04, aged 63. [Wikipedia:Robert Louis-Dreyfus] [Encyclopedia.com:Saatchi & Saatchi] [Ad Age(1994-12-19)] [Ad Age 書摘] [Marketing Week(1995-02-17)]
- Sir Peter Walters (Sir Peter Walters), 1931-03-11 — Non-executive director (newly appointed in early 1994). Born in Birmingham, England; bachelor of commerce from the University of Birmingham in 1952; joined British Petroleum (BP) in 1954 and was its chairman from 1981 to 1990. He was subsequently chairman of Midland Bank (1991–1994) and chairman of SmithKline Beecham (1994–2000), among other posts. Ad Age reported in early 1994 that he was a new director leading a review of the holding company's operations, working closely with chief executive Scott. Midland Bank, which he had chaired, was the very bank the brothers had tried to acquire in 1987 and been rebuffed by. No citable source was found for his position and vote at the meeting of 1994-12-16. When he left the Saatchi & Saatchi/Cordiant board was not found. Died on 2023-07-11, aged 92. [Wikipedia:Peter Walters] [Ad Age:Sagging Saatchi] [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)]
Moves to block a return
- The board did more than take away the chairman's title: according to Ad Age's report that week, it complied with everything the shareholders demanded, including removing him from the holding company's board and taking "Saatchi" out of the company's name. All that was left to him was the post of honorary president of the holding company and the chairmanship of the advertising subsidiary, and he was given until 1995-01-03 to reply. [Ad Age(1994-12-19)] [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)]
- The day after the seven executives resigned en masse, chief executive Charles Scott ordered special briefings for clients, stressing that the company was fundamentally sound; about 40 staff working on British Airways, though invited by Maurice to the new firm, were reportedly persuaded by the company to stay. Company managers also said publicly that they would fight the departed executives helping him set up a new firm. [Christian Science Monitor(1995-01-17)]
- The old company sued Maurice and the three directors who had resigned, alleging that he had induced Bill Muirhead, David Kershaw and Jeremy Sinclair to leave and that they had "conspired to damage the group's business"; reports noted that if it won, the rival firm might not be able to open at all. A New York court also had to decide whether proceedings could continue against Muirhead, the former US head. Maurice counter-sued the company for unlawfully terminating the employment contract he had negotiated only in June 1994. [Marketing Week] [The Royal Gazette(1995-02-01)]
- The non-compete clauses in the contracts: according to a later Ad Age retrospective, Maurice's new partners, apart from his brother Charles, were all bound by contractual non-compete clauses for the new firm's first six months and could not start work. [Ad Age:Saatchi at 5]
- The old company applied to the High Court in London for an injunction to bar Maurice and the three former executives from poaching staff, and was refused. The judge allowed the three to do "preparatory work" for the new firm provided they did not solicit the old company's clients and staff, and ordered the old company to bear both sides' costs for the three-day hearing (estimated at more than US$150,000). Maurice's barrister Gordon Pollock argued that so long as staff were not induced to breach their contracts, hiring people and taking clients away were both lawful. (The date is inferred from Marketing Week's 1995-02-17 report that it was "refused on Monday".) [Marketing Week(1995-02-17)] [The Media Leader] [Ad Age:Maurice 1, Saatchi 0 in court wars]
- The day after the injunction was refused, the old company stepped up its litigation: it sued to recover a settlement of about US$40 million the brothers had negotiated over their minority stake in Adidas (rumoured to be the new firm's capital), and sued to stop the new firm using the name "Saatchi" — the name under which the new firm was then registered was Dress Rehearsal. Maurice said the money was a private matter and had nothing to do with the company. [Marketing Week(1995-02-17)] [Ad Age:Maurice 1, Saatchi 0 in court wars] [Marketing Week:The turning tides at Saatchi group]
- The one and only proposal to "let him come back" was turned down flat by the board: Charles Saatchi, who still held the title of honorary president, put a settlement plan to the board one weekend under which Maurice would return to run the advertising business, to be spun off later. Marketing Week said the board rejected it quickly, and that the proposal did not appear to have been initiated by Maurice himself. [Marketing Week:The turning tides at Saatchi group]
- Taking the founders' surname off the sign: shareholders voted to approve it on 1995-03-16, and the holding company was renamed Cordiant the next day (the advertising subsidiary was still called Saatchi & Saatchi). Ad Age said the purpose of the new name was precisely to cut the company off from its founders. [Design Week(1995-03-23)] [Ad Age Encyclopedia:Cordiant]
- It ended in an out-of-court settlement, with the obstruction reduced to transitional restrictions: the former executives could join the new firm from the end of May, but the new firm could not poach any more of Cordiant's existing staff before the end of the year; Cordiant would no longer stop the new firm using the Saatchi name, and the new firm was named M&C Saatchi; Maurice withdrew his claims for wrongful dismissal and severance pay. M&C Saatchi's 2004 prospectus records that the agreement on the use of the name was signed on 1995-05-20. Wikipedia says the old company spent about £11 million on severance and litigation over these departures. [The Media Leader] [M&C Saatchi 2004 年公開說明書] [Wikipedia:Saatchi & Saatchi]
Rumors
- The ousted Maurice will open another advertising agency with his brother and take clients such as British Airways, Mars and Mirror Group with him. [Later confirmed] Reports by the Christian Science Monitor and other media within a week of his removal In January 1995 he announced the new firm; Mirror Group and Silk Cut became its first two clients in February, and British Airways moved its worldwide account over in early May. [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)] [The Media Leader] [Ad Age:Qantas picks New Saatchi agency]
- In the economic climate of the time British Airways is unlikely to change agencies; even if all three major clients leave, the effect on the old company will be only marginal. [Proven false] An unnamed senior advertising executive, and what chief executive Charles Scott told the media; in February 1995 Marketing Week was still saying BA's move to Maurice was "by no means a done deal" In early May 1995 BA gave its worldwide account of about US$96 million to the new firm, and Qantas followed; in 1995 Cordiant swung from a profit the year before to a pre-tax loss of US$34.5 million. But the old company did not collapse, and its London company still ranked first in Britain at the end of that year. [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)] [Marketing Week:The turning tides at Saatchi group] [Ad Age:Qantas picks New Saatchi agency] [Encyclopedia.com:Saatchi & Saatchi]
- The mass walkout of the seven executives was arranged by Maurice in advance: he induced Sinclair, Muirhead and Kershaw to leave and conspired to damage the old company. [Still unclear] The old company's claim; brokers' analysts also told the media that these people would not leave without somewhere to go The court gave no judgment on this: the injunction was refused and the case was settled out of court in May 1995. Sinclair's account in 2015 was that the three decided for themselves to start again, and that the brothers telephoned later to say they wanted to join. There is no third-party document by which to decide between the two accounts. [Marketing Week] [The Royal Gazette(1995-02-01)] [Christian Science Monitor(1995-01-17)] [Dave Dye 專訪(2015-04-27)]
- The Saatchi brothers may set up the new firm as a joint venture with Lowe Bell, the public relations company of their old colleague Tim Bell. [Proven false] A report in The Economist of 1995-01-07, relayed by the Christian Science Monitor; Tim Bell was then advising Maurice The new firm ended up as an independent company with equity split equally among five people, the brothers plus Sinclair, Muirhead and Kershaw; neither the company history nor the account of its founding in the 2004 prospectus mentions any joint venture with Lowe Bell. [Christian Science Monitor(1995-01-17)] [Encyclopedia.com:Saatchi & Saatchi] [M&C Saatchi 2004 年公開說明書]
- The new firm's capital was the settlement of about US$40 million the brothers received over the Adidas share option dispute, and this money should really have belonged to the old company. [Still unclear] The old company's claim in its lawsuit; Marketing Week said the money was "reportedly" the source of the new firm's funding Maurice said it was a private matter unconnected with the company. No public report was found of how this lawsuit was later resolved; the summary of the May 1995 settlement does not mention the money either. [Marketing Week(1995-02-17)] [Marketing Week:The turning tides at Saatchi group]
- M&C Saatchi once wanted to merge again with its old parent Saatchi & Saatchi, and the two sides held informal talks several times. [Still unclear] An exclusive by the trade magazine Campaign (reporter Gideon Spanier) The full report is behind a paywall and only the headline and standfirst were read; no news of a merger actually happening has been seen since, and the two companies remain separate to this day. How far the talks went and who called them off was not found. [Campaign Asia] [Campaign Middle East(2018-10-21)]
- Maurice and the three independent directors resigned in 2019 because the board was split over whether to replace chief executive David Kershaw. [Still unclear] MediaPost, citing unnamed sources and a Bloomberg report The company said only that it accepted the directors' decision to resign; City A.M. reported that the resignations stemmed from disagreement on the eight-member board, and said Kershaw had offered to resign and been told this was not in the company's interests. Those involved have not explained the details publicly. [MediaPost] [City A.M.(2019-12-11)]
Views
- David Herro (fund manager at Harris Associates, representative of a major shareholder): He pointed out to the board that the company's financial performance over the past three or four years had been very poor and the share price had fallen by more than 90%, and he opposed Maurice's share option package and his spending on his country house. [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)]
- Maurice Saatchi (the party concerned): He publicly described the two as mere "bean counters"; reports said the remark made relations between the two sides even worse. [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)]
- Sir Tim Bell (former colleague, later public relations adviser to Margaret Thatcher): He considered that the brothers had talent, experience and contacts at the highest level, and were fully equipped to start again. [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)]
- Charles Scott (chief executive of Saatchi & Saatchi): He reportedly considered that even if the brothers opened a new firm and took BA, Mars and Mirror Group, the effect on the company's finances would be only marginal — the three together accounted for about 8% of revenue. [Christian Science Monitor(1994-12-23)]
- Campaign (British advertising trade magazine): Considered that the departure of another batch of senior executives so soon after Maurice's resignation was devastating for the company. [Christian Science Monitor(1995-01-17)]
- Lord King (president of British Airways, a major client of the old company): He wrote to The Daily Telegraph that the affair raised major questions of corporate governance, asking how a Chicago institution holding less than 10% could dictate the decisions of a British company's board. [Christian Science Monitor(1995-01-17)]
- Lucy Broke (media analyst, James Capel) and Neil Blackley (media analyst, Goldman Sachs): Both considered it a co-ordinated move: Broke said Maurice and his old team had an understanding, and Blackley said these people would not leave without somewhere to go. [Christian Science Monitor(1995-01-17)]
- Profile of David Herro in IR Magazine (specialist investor relations publication): The report said he was best known for leading the move against Maurice Saatchi, because he and other investors felt Maurice was too free with shareholders' money; but Herro described his fund as not an activist one, preferring to work with management teams that create value for shareholders. [IR Impact(2009-03-31)]
- Maurice Saatchi (the party concerned, interviewed on Saatchi & Saatchi's fortieth anniversary): He said that after the bitterness of the "Saatchi wars" of those days, for the people of the two companies now to come together to celebrate was a plot any publisher would find too far-fetched. [Guardian(Gulf News 轉載)]
- Stephen Armstrong (journalist, The Guardian): He noted that M&C Saatchi was then 7th in Campaign's top 100 and its old parent 16th, so that the side that walked out ranked higher; but he also questioned whether the two, both merely mid-table companies, still mattered so much. [Guardian(Gulf News 轉載)]
- Jeremy Sinclair (deputy chairman and acting chairman at the time): He said the majority of the board chose to bow to pressure from American shareholders, and that he had advised against it; looking back twenty years later on being forced to leave, he thought it a pity, but starting again was great fun. [Dave Dye 專訪(2015-04-27)]
Photos & videos
London Heathrow Airport, April 1991: a British Airways Boeing 757 with the promotion "The World's Biggest Offer" painted on its fuselage; BA was then Saatchi & Saatchi's flagship client and in 1995 followed the brothers to the new firm. — Colin Cooke Photo / CC BY-SA 2.0
Publicis Groupe chief executive Maurice Lévy at the World Economic Forum in Tianjin, September 2008; Publicis bought Saatchi & Saatchi in 2000. — World Economic Forum(攝影:Natalie Behring) / CC BY-SA 3.0
The Saatchi Gallery at the Duke of York's Headquarters in Chelsea, London, photographed in December 2009; after leaving advertising, Charles Saatchi became known for this gallery and his contemporary art collection. — Jack Gavigan / CC BY-SA 3.0
WPP chief executive Martin Sorrell at the World Economic Forum in Davos, January 2010; in 2003 WPP acquired Cordiant, the renamed holding company of Saatchi & Saatchi. — World Economic Forum / CC BY-SA 2.0
80 Charlotte Street in Fitzrovia, London, photographed in May 2011; Saatchi & Saatchi's London company was based in Charlotte Street for many years, and the industry often refers to it simply by the name of the street. — Stephen Richards / CC BY-SA 2.0
34–36 Golden Square, London, photographed in May 2014; this Grade II listed building, completed between 1913 and 1915, is the headquarters of M&C Saatchi. — Stephen Richards / CC BY-SA 2.0
Bill Muirhead, c. 2021; one of the three executives who walked out with Maurice in 1995, later also Agent General for South Australia in London. — 作者不詳(來源:South Australia Club 網站) / CC BY 4.0
Maurice Saatchi at Hatchards bookshop in Piccadilly, London, 30 November 2022. — Edwardx / CC BY-SA 4.0
The Pregnant Man pub in Chancery Lane, London, photographed in May 2026; it was originally the staff bar in Saatchi & Saatchi's Charlotte Street offices, and takes its name from one of the company's advertisements. — Ewan-M / CC BY-SA 4.0- Channel 4 News: presenter Jon Snow interviews Lord Saatchi on how he won the 1979 election campaign for Margaret Thatcher. (Channel 4 News)
- Short interview by The Daily Telegraph: Lord Saatchi on BBC presenter Jeremy Paxman's last edition of Newsnight. (The Telegraph)
- Short film of the company's story on M&C Saatchi's official channel (uploaded 2015). (M&C Saatchi)
- The Wall Street Journal/Barron's interview with David Herro on the global large-cap stocks he sees as undervalued. (The Wall Street Journal)
- CNBC: Harris Associates chief investment officer David Herro on the stocks he favours. (CNBC Television)
- Channels Television news report: Maurice Saatchi leaves M&C Saatchi, the company he founded, amid an accounting scandal. (Channels Television)
- CNBC: Oakmark fund manager David Herro on tariff uncertainty and opportunities amid market turbulence. (CNBC Television)