John Schnatter (John Schnatter) — Papa John's (Papa John's International)
After his November 2017 remarks criticizing the NFL, founder John Schnatter handed the CEO job to Steve Ritchie on New Year's Day 2018. On July 11, 2018, he resigned as chairman as well after Forbes reported that he had used a racial slur on a media training conference call. Within days he was saying publicly that resigning had been a mistake, and he fought back with his roughly 30% stake, lawsuits, open letters and a website. The board, for its part, formed a special committee, terminated the founder agreement, took back his office, removed him from marketing materials, adopted a poison pill, and finally brought in Starboard Value, whose CEO, Jeff Smith, became chairman. In March 2019 the two sides settled: he dropped his lawsuit and his self-nomination, left the board when his term as a director expired on April 30, 2019, and then sold much of his stake. He has not returned to the company.
How they were ousted
He first stepped down as CEO on 2018-01-01. On 2018-07-11 Forbes reported that he had used a racial slur on a conference call, and he resigned as chairman that day (he later said the board had asked him to step down). Four days later a special committee of independent directors terminated his founder agreement and his right to use office space at headquarters.
What happened to the board
None of the five directors other than Schnatter at the time (Kirtley, Shapiro, Medina, Coleman, Koellner) was purged by him. Shapiro did not stand for reelection at the April 2019 annual meeting (the proxy statement notes that he was promoted to president of Endeavor in December 2018). Kirtley served until 2023, when she retired on reaching the retirement age in the corporate governance guidelines. Coleman rose to independent chairman in March 2023, and Koellner and Medina were still on the list of directors in the 2026 proxy statement. Jeff Smith, the Starboard CEO who took over, stepped down as chairman on his own in early March 2023 as the company bought back most of Starboard's stake. The reports found do not indicate that any of these departures had anything to do with Schnatter.
Timeline
- Blames the NFL for poor results on an earnings call Schnatter, then CEO, said on an earnings call that "The NFL has hurt us," arguing that the league had mishandled the player protests. The stock fell 8.5% that day. [ESPN]
- Company announces he will step down as CEO A company press release announced that COO Steve Ritchie would become CEO effective 2018-01-01, with Schnatter staying on as chairman; the release gave no reason. The company had apologized on Twitter about two weeks after his NFL remarks. [CBS News(AP)]
- Ritchie formally takes over as CEO Steve Ritchie became president and CEO, leaving Schnatter with only his roles as chairman and brand spokesman. [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)] [CBS News(AP)]
- Forbes reports he used a racial slur on a conference call; he resigns as chairman that day Forbes reported that he had used a racial slur during a May 2018 media training conference call with marketing firm Laundry Service. He issued a statement acknowledging it and apologizing, and resigned as chairman. Lead independent director Olivia Kirtley led the board in the interim; he remained a director. (Company filings give the resignation date as July 11; CNBC's report says July 12.) [CNBC] [Papa John's 2018 年度 10-K(SEC)]
- Special committee formed; founder agreement and office sublease terminated the same day All the independent directors formed a special committee, which directed the company to terminate his founder agreement and the sublease of his headquarters office and asked him to stop speaking to the media. The committee also announced it would oversee an outside audit of the company's diversity and inclusion practices and corporate culture. [Franchising.com(Business Wire 新聞稿轉載)] [Papa John's 2018 年度 10-K(SEC)]
- Letter to the board surfaces: resigning was a mistake Media reported that he had written to the board saying it had asked him to step down without any investigation, that he had agreed at the time but now believed it was a mistake, and that he would not allow his and the company's reputations to be unfairly tainted. The reports also said the company was removing his face from pizza boxes and marketing materials. [Fortune]
- Formally demands, as a director, to inspect company documents He made a demand on the company to inspect its books and records under Section 220(d) of the Delaware General Corporation Law. [National Law Review]
- The board adopts a poison pill The board adopted a limited-duration shareholder rights plan: a general threshold of 15%, and a 31% threshold for Schnatter and his affiliates, originally due to expire after one year. According to his complaint, he was the only director who abstained. [Papa John's 2018 年度 10-K(SEC)] [Schnatter 第二次修正訴狀(SEC 附件 99.2)]
- Stock tumbles after the poison pill is announced On Monday the stock fell as much as 8.3% intraday, to $47.29. Reports quoted people familiar with the matter as saying he regretted resigning as chairman. They also mentioned a Forbes article, citing 37 current and former employees, that alleged problems with the company's culture; his representative said the article contained numerous errors. [Bangor Daily News(Bloomberg 稿)]
- Sues in the Delaware Court of Chancery to inspect documents He argued that the independent directors had either acted without adequate information or planned a "coup" in advance, and sought to inspect communications between the directors and their lawyers. The company responded that the litigation was needless and wasteful. According to the proxy statement, the board formally elected Kirtley chairman the same day (the 10-K gives the date as July 27). [Fox 17(CNN Wire)] [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)]
- In an interview: once the truth is out, I can be back in the ads In a telephone interview with The Associated Press, he said resigning as chairman was a "mistake" and that the problems were caused by the board and management; once the public understood the full story, he could return to the TV and radio ads. The company, citing a celebrity index, said trust in him had already declined after his NFL remarks. [WJLA(AP)]
- Launches the SavePapaJohns website and runs full-page newspaper ads He launched SavePapaJohns.com, posting court filings, press releases and letters, and ran a full-page ad in Louisville's Courier Journal saying the board wanted to silence him. The company responded that it should not be dependent on one individual. [Fox Business] [CBS News]
- Open letter to franchisees: the problem is at the top NRN reported that he had posted on the website a letter to franchisees accusing CEO Ritchie of lacking the ability for the job, saying there were cultural problems among the company's top leadership, stating that he had recommended in June that Ritchie be replaced, and criticizing director Mark Shapiro by name. The company called the claims false. [Nation's Restaurant News]
- Second lawsuit: accuses special committee members of breaching their fiduciary duties As a shareholder, he sued the members of the special committee and CEO Ritchie in the Delaware Court of Chancery, seeking to have the poison pill rescinded, the termination of his role as spokesman reversed, and his eviction from his headquarters office blocked. [National Law Review] [Nation's Restaurant News]
- International president O'Hern abruptly retires Senior executive Timothy O'Hern notified the company that he was retiring effective immediately; the company said it was for personal reasons and unrelated to the culture investigation. [WTVR(CNN Wire)]
- CNBC: he approached private equity firms about buying back the company; spokesman denies it CNBC reported that he had approached private equity firms about teaming up to buy back the company, that several had declined out of reputational concerns, and that the company was also in contact with potential buyers. His spokesman said that day that the report was completely false. According to his complaint, the board that same day expanded the special committee's mandate to cover alternative transactions such as financings. [Fox Business] [LEX 18] [Schnatter 第二次修正訴狀(SEC 附件 99.2)]
- Sends a letter demanding changes to the poison pill's "acting in concert" provision He demanded that the company amend or suspend the provision by October 23. On October 22 he attached the letter to an amended 13D filing and said he had no confidence in the board or management. [Schnatter 第二次修正訴狀(SEC 附件 99.2)]
- Filing shows he has hired a financial adviser Restaurant Dive reported that in an SEC filing the previous Friday he said he had retained a financial adviser to evaluate options for enhancing shareholder value but had no specific plan as yet. The report said Trian, the most active potential buyer, had reportedly pulled out in November. [Restaurant Dive]
- Court rules he may inspect documents The Delaware Court of Chancery largely granted him inspection of four categories of documents, covering directors' communications before the special committee was formed about changing his relationship with the company, including communications on personal accounts and devices. The court rejected the company's argument that his purpose was improper, but also excluded some communications with lawyers. [National Law Review] [Fortune(Bloomberg 稿)]
- Board approves Starboard investment; he votes against On Sunday evening the board approved Starboard Value's $200 million preferred stock investment, with Schnatter voting against; the alternative financing proposal he had submitted over the weekend was rejected. Jeff Smith became chairman, Sanfilippo and Ritchie joined the board, and the board grew to 9 seats. [Bangor Daily News(Bloomberg 稿)] [Papa John's 2018 年度 10-K(SEC)]
- Starboard deal announced The company announced the deal and signed the governance agreement; Kirtley said the transaction concluded a strategic review that had lasted about five months. The stock rose as much as 12% in premarket trading. [Bangor Daily News(Bloomberg 稿)] [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)]
- Amended complaint shifts the attack to the poison pill and the Starboard governance agreement He filed a second amended complaint (Schnatter v. Shapiro) against Shapiro, Medina, Kirtley, Coleman, Koellner and the company, asking the court to declare invalid the poison pill (or its definition of acting in concert) and the voting and standstill provisions of the governance agreement. [Schnatter 第二次修正訴狀(SEC 附件 99.2)] [Law.com]
- Settlement announced: he agrees to leave the board The two sides settled: he dropped his lawsuit and his self-nomination and would resign once an independent director agreed on by both sides was chosen, with his term otherwise expiring at the annual meeting. The company removed the poison pill's acting-in-concert provision and dropped the requirement that Starboard vote with the board. He said he was pleased to have reached an agreement and supported the new leadership of Smith and Starboard. [CNBC] [Yahoo Finance(路透)]
- Board adds two more independent directors Dollar Shave Club CEO Michael Dubin and Him For Her founder Jocelyn Mangan joined, bringing the board to 11 seats. [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)] [Nation's Restaurant News]
- Term as director expires; he formally leaves the board His term as a director expired on the day of the annual meeting and he did not stand again; he has held no formal position at the company since. Mark Shapiro likewise did not stand for reelection at this meeting. [CNBC] [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)]
- Sells heavily, cutting his stake from about 31% to about 19% He sold about 3.4 million shares to UBS in a private placement for $157.5 million; together with about 400,000 shares sold on the open market, he had sold 3.8 million shares since May. He was still the largest shareholder at the time and pledged not to sell any more before August 19. [CNBC]
- Rob Lynch becomes CEO; Ritchie leaves The company named Arby's president Rob Lynch as CEO, effective immediately, replacing Ritchie; by then Schnatter's stake had fallen to 16.7%. The company had also signed Shaquille O'Neal as the new face of the brand. [CNBC]
- WDRB interview: "The day of reckoning will come" In an interview with Louisville television station WDRB, he said Ritchie and the board had used the incident to take the company from him, singled out Kirtley and Shapiro, and said the pizza no longer tasted the same. He ended with the line "The day of reckoning will come." The company did not immediately respond. [TheWrap] [CNBC]
- Filing shows his stake is down to about 6.1% The company's 2020 proxy statement, based on his 13D/A filing of 2020-02-13, shows him holding about 1.946 million shares, or 6.1%—no longer a stake that could sway a shareholder meeting. [Papa John's 2020 年委託書(SEC)]
- Kirtley announces her retirement on reaching the age limit The company announced that Olivia Kirtley had reached the retirement age in the governance guidelines and would not stand for reelection at the 2023 annual meeting when her term expired. [Papa John's 8-K(SEC)]
- Jeff Smith steps down as chairman; Coleman takes over NRN reported that Smith had resigned as a director effective immediately and that Christopher Coleman, a director since 2012, had been elevated to independent chairman; the company bought back most of Starboard's stake at $82.52 a share. A director who had taken part in ousting Schnatter thus rose to chairman. [Nation's Restaurant News]
- Rob Lynch leaves for Shake Shack Shake Shack announced that Lynch would become its CEO on May 20; Papa John's stock fell about 6% that day. [CNBC]
- Latest proxy statement: three directors from that time are still in place Of the 8 director nominees in the 2026 proxy statement, Coleman (chairman), Koellner and Medina were all members of the 2018 special committee; the CEO is Todd Penegor. Schnatter is not on the list. [Papa John's 2026 年委託書(SEC)]
People
- John Schnatter (John Schnatter), 1961-11-22 — Founder, chairman (resigned as chairman 2018-07-11; remained a director and the largest shareholder, with about 30%). Born in Jeffersonville, Indiana; graduated from the local high school in 1980 and earned a business degree from Ball State University in 1983. In 1984 he sold his 1971 Camaro, bought used equipment for about $1,600 and began selling pizzas out of a broom closet in his father's tavern. The company went public in 1993. Founder; longtime CEO, chairman and advertising spokesman. He stayed on as chairman after stepping down as CEO on 2018-01-01. His successor, Steve Ritchie, was his own pick; the other directors at the time had all joined the board while he was chairman. Under the March 2019 settlement he did not stand for reelection; his term as a director expired on 2019-04-30, and he has held no formal position at the company since. He sold shares heavily from May 2019; the company's 2020 proxy statement shows his stake had fallen to about 6.1%. [Wikipedia:John Schnatter] [CNBC] [Papa John's 2020 年委託書(SEC)]
- Steve Ritchie (Steve Ritchie) — President and CEO (from 2018-01-01); also a director from February 2019. Started in 1996 as a customer service representative earning $6 an hour, later became a franchisee himself, and was promoted to COO in 2014. The 2019 proxy statement lists him as 44 at the time, with 22 years at the company. Rose through the ranks. On 2017-12-21 the company announced he would become CEO on 2018-01-01; he joined the board in 2019-02 when Starboard invested. CNBC described him as Schnatter's handpicked successor. The two later fell out: Schnatter says he recommended to the board in June 2018 that Ritchie be replaced, and named him as a defendant in his lawsuit. On 2019-08-27 the company announced that Rob Lynch would take over as CEO; the proxy statement records that day as Ritchie's last day of employment. The company did not state the reason for his departure. No reliable source was found on what he did afterward. [CBS News(AP)] [CNBC] [Papa John's 2020 年委託書(SEC)] [Nation's Restaurant News]
- Olivia Kirtley (Olivia Kirtley) — Lead independent director; led the board from the day Schnatter resigned, was formally elected chairman in late July 2018 and handed over to Jeff Smith on 2019-02-03; member of the special committee. An accountant and business consultant; formerly a CFO and a senior manager at a predecessor firm of Ernst & Young. Also a director of U.S. Bancorp and ResCare. Listed as 68 in the 2019 proxy statement. A director since 2003; has chaired the audit and compensation committees. Worked with Schnatter for more than a decade while he was chairman; no public information was found on personal ties to him. In a November 2019 interview Schnatter accused her by name, along with Ritchie, of taking the company from him. On 2023-02-16 the company announced that she had reached the retirement age in the corporate governance guidelines and would serve out her term without standing for reelection at the 2023 annual meeting, after nearly 20 years on the board. Unrelated to Schnatter. [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)] [Papa John's 8-K(2023-02,SEC)] [TheWrap]
- Mark Shapiro (Mark Shapiro), 1970 — Independent director, member of the special committee; lead defendant in Schnatter's second lawsuit (Schnatter v. Shapiro). Graduated from the University of Iowa in communications in 1992 and joined ESPN in 1993, rising from production assistant to executive vice president of programming and production. CEO of Six Flags from 2005 to 2010, then CEO of Dick Clark Productions; moved to IMG/WME in 2014, became co-president of WME-IMG in 2016 and was promoted to president of Endeavor in 2018. A director since February 2011. In his August 2018 letter to franchisees, Schnatter attacked him, pointing out that Endeavor Global Marketing, a marketing firm under WME|IMG, where he worked, had just won Papa John's marketing contract. In November 2019 he also said Shapiro and Kirtley should go to jail. Did not stand for reelection at the 2019-04-30 annual meeting (he was not removed); in explaining this, the proxy statement mentioned his promotion to president of Endeavor in December 2018. He has continued as a senior executive at Endeavor/TKO. [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)] [Wikipedia:Mark Shapiro (media executive)] [Nation's Restaurant News] [TheWrap]
- Christopher Coleman (Christopher Coleman) — Independent director, chairman of the special committee (per the 2019 proxy statement), chairman of the corporate governance and nominating committee. Group head of banking at Britain's Rothschild & Co; also a non-executive director of Barrick Gold. Listed as 50 in the 2019 proxy statement. A director since 2012. Joined the board while Schnatter was chairman; no public information was found on personal ties. One of the defendants in Schnatter's second lawsuit. Not only stayed on but rose to independent chairman after Jeff Smith stepped down in early March 2023; the March 2026 proxy statement is still signed by him as chairman. [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)] [Nation's Restaurant News] [Papa John's 2026 年委託書(SEC)]
- Laurette Koellner (Laurette Koellner) — Independent director, chair of the audit committee, member of the special committee. Formerly executive chairman of International Lease Finance Corp., an AIG unit, and president of Boeing International; also a director of Celestica, Goodyear and Nucor. Listed as 64 in the 2019 proxy statement. A director since 2014. Joined the board while Schnatter was chairman; no public information was found on personal ties. One of the defendants in Schnatter's second lawsuit. Still serving; the 2026 proxy statement lists her as a director nominee (age 71). [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)] [Papa John's 2026 年委託書(SEC)]
- Sonya Medina (Sonya Medina) — Independent director, member of the special committee. A government and public affairs strategist who has advised the City of San Antonio and Silver Eagle Distributors; worked at the White House earlier in her career. Listed as 43 in the 2019 proxy statement. A director since 2015. Joined the board while Schnatter was chairman; no public information was found on personal ties. One of the defendants in Schnatter's second lawsuit. Still serving; the 2026 proxy statement lists her as a director nominee (age 50). [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)] [Papa John's 2026 年委託書(SEC)]
- Jeffrey Smith (Jeffrey Smith) — Founder and CEO of Starboard Value; chairman of Papa John's from 2019-02-03. Co-founder, CEO and chief investment officer of activist fund Starboard Value. In 2014, with a stake of less than 10%, he replaced the entire board of Darden Restaurants and became its chairman. Listed as 46 in the 2019 proxy statement; also chairman of Advance Auto Parts. Starboard bought $200 million of preferred stock and under the governance agreement obtained the right to nominate two directors; he became chairman directly. Brought in through the strategic review led by the special committee. Schnatter voted against the deal on the board, but at the time of the settlement said publicly that he supported the new leadership Smith and Starboard had brought. Resigned as a director in early March 2023 (reported by NRN on March 2), effective immediately, with Coleman succeeding him as independent chairman. At the same time the company bought back most of Starboard's stake at $82.52 a share, leaving Starboard with about 2%. This was an investor cashing out and had nothing to do with Schnatter. [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)] [Wikipedia:Starboard Value] [Nation's Restaurant News] [CNBC]
- Anthony Sanfilippo (Anthony Sanfilippo) — Independent director (nominated by Starboard, joined 2019-02), member of the special committee. Formerly chairman and CEO of casino operator Pinnacle Entertainment (from 2010 until the company's sale in 2018); before that CEO of Multimedia Games and a senior executive at Harrah's. Listed as 60 in the 2019 proxy statement. Joined the board in 2019-02 together with Jeff Smith under the Starboard governance agreement. Starboard's nominee; no public information was found on personal ties to Schnatter. Still a director nominee in the 2020 proxy statement; he is no longer among the 8 nominees in the 2026 proxy statement. The exact date of and reason for his departure were not found. [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)] [Papa John's 2020 年委託書(SEC)] [Papa John's 2026 年委託書(SEC)]
- Rob Lynch (Rob Lynch) — President, CEO and director from 2019-08-27 (the successor after the events). Came from Arby's, where he was chief marketing officer from 2013 to 2017 and president from August 2017; during that time Arby's posted 16 consecutive quarters of same-store sales growth. Listed as 43 in the 2020 proxy statement. Recruited from outside by the board after Starboard came in; replaced Ritchie on 2019-08-27, effective immediately. Never worked with Schnatter; it was only after he took the job that Schnatter gave an interview criticizing the company and the quality of its pizza. On 2024-03-21 it was announced he would become CEO of Shake Shack (effective 2024-05-20), a move he made of his own accord. Papa John's stock fell about 6% the day the news was announced. [CNBC] [Papa John's 2020 年委託書(SEC)] [CNBC]
- Timothy O'Hern (Timothy O'Hern) — President of international and chief development officer (a senior executive, not a director). Became a franchisee in 1993 and worked at the company for more than 20 years; took over as president of international in May 2018, and owned 9 franchised restaurants in the United States. A franchisee first, then joined the corporate office. A longtime executive of the Schnatter era; the details of their personal relationship could not be confirmed from the sources actually consulted. Notified the company on 2018-09-05 that he was retiring, effective immediately. The company said it was for personal reasons and unrelated to the culture investigation; he kept his franchised restaurants. [WTVR(CNN Wire)]
Moves to block a return
- The board formed a special committee made up of all the independent directors to review and handle all of the company's relationships with Schnatter. That same day the committee directed the company to terminate his founder agreement (under which he served as advertising and brand spokesman). Schnatter later alleged in a court filing that these terminations were decided within three hours of the committee's formation. [Franchising.com(Business Wire 新聞稿轉載)] [Papa John's 2018 年度 10-K(SEC)] [Nation's Restaurant News]
- The special committee also directed the company to terminate the sublease agreement that gave him office space at the Louisville headquarters, on the grounds that he was no longer involved in running the business—in effect telling him to move out of headquarters. [Franchising.com(Business Wire 新聞稿轉載)] [Bangor Daily News(Bloomberg 稿)]
- In the same press release the company reiterated that he was no longer a spokesman for the company or the brand, and explicitly asked him to cease all media appearances and to stop speaking to the media about the company, its business or its employees. [Franchising.com(Business Wire 新聞稿轉載)]
- Media reported that the company was removing his face from pizza boxes and other marketing materials (no exact record was found of when this actually began; this is the date of the report). The company later changed advertising agencies and launched new ads. CNBC reported that the company spent $5.8 million on rebranding in 2018, including removing his image. [Fortune] [CNBC] [Papa John's 2018 年度 10-K(SEC)]
- The board adopted a limited-duration shareholder rights plan (poison pill): it would be triggered by anyone acquiring 15% or more of the shares without board approval. Schnatter, together with his affiliates and family, held about 30% at the time, so a separate 31% threshold was set for them: a further increase to 31% would trigger the plan. It was originally due to expire on 2019-07-22, with one right distributed per share and a record date of 2018-08-02. The plan also contained an "acting in concert" provision, which Schnatter argued prevented him from even discussing voting with other shareholders. According to his complaint, he was the only director who abstained in the vote. [Papa John's 2018 年度 10-K(SEC)] [Bangor Daily News(Bloomberg 稿)] [Schnatter 第二次修正訴狀(SEC 附件 99.2)]
- After he sued in the Delaware Court of Chancery to inspect company documents, the company called the litigation needless and wasteful. In court it argued that his purpose in seeking inspection was personal rather than related to his duties as a director, and that the separate lawsuit he had filed deprived the inspection of a proper purpose. The court later rejected both arguments. [Fox 17(CNN Wire)] [National Law Review]
- After he set up the SavePapaJohns website and took out full-page ads in a Louisville newspaper, the company responded publicly: the company should not and would not be dependent on one individual; customers, employees and other stakeholders supported its separation from him; and nothing he did could distract from his inappropriate remarks. [CBS News] [Fox Business]
- After he wrote to franchisees with accusations against CEO Ritchie and some directors, the company issued a statement calling the claims false and disparaging, and denied that the board had ever asked him to become executive chairman. [Nation's Restaurant News]
- According to Schnatter's complaint, the board expanded the special committee's mandate to cover alternative transactions such as financings. The strategic review led by the special committee ran for about five months and ended with the choice of an outside investor rather than him. [Schnatter 第二次修正訴狀(SEC 附件 99.2)] [Bangor Daily News(Bloomberg 稿)]
- He sent a letter demanding that the company amend or suspend the poison pill's "acting in concert" provision and reply by October 23. According to his complaint, the company made no amendment; a spokesperson merely said the rights plan did not prevent the board from considering any proposal. The provision stayed in place until it was removed in the March 2019 settlement. [Schnatter 第二次修正訴狀(SEC 附件 99.2)]
- Over his objection, the board approved Starboard Value's $200 million purchase of newly issued Series B convertible preferred stock (with an option for another $50 million). The board was expanded from 6 seats to 9; Starboard CEO Jeff Smith became chairman, and Anthony Sanfilippo and CEO Ritchie joined the board. Over the weekend he had submitted an alternative financing proposal on similar terms, which he described as superior; the company rejected it. The governance agreement originally also required Starboard to vote with the board for a period of time. [Papa John's 2018 年度 10-K(SEC)] [Bangor Daily News(Bloomberg 稿)] [Papa John's 2019 年委託書(SEC)]
- Settlement announced: the company had earlier made clear it would not nominate him for reelection, and he had sent notice nominating himself. Under the settlement he withdrew the nomination, dropped his lawsuit against the company and agreed to resign once an independent director acceptable to both sides and unaffiliated with either him or Starboard was chosen; otherwise his term would expire at the 2019 annual meeting. The same day the board extended the poison pill to 2022-03-06 and raised the general threshold from 15% to 20%. On the points in his favor: the "acting in concert" provision was removed, the requirement that Starboard vote with the board was dropped, and the company agreed to provide documents. [CNBC] [Yahoo Finance(路透)] [Papa John's 2018 年度 10-K(SEC)] [Fortune(Bloomberg 稿)]
Rumors
- The board was working to take away even his seat as a director. [Later confirmed] Fortune, relaying a report by The Wall Street Journal Reuters reported that the company later made clear it would not nominate him for reelection. After the 2019-03-05 settlement he withdrew his self-nomination, and he left when his term expired on 2019-04-30. [Fortune] [Yahoo Finance(路透)]
- Forbes, citing 37 current and former employees, alleged problems with the company's culture during his tenure (including surveillance of employees and inappropriate conduct). [Still unclear] Forbes (relayed in a Bloomberg story) His representative said the article contained numerous errors and distortions. The special committee separately commissioned an outside culture audit, but the sources found did not make public findings on the individual allegations. [Bangor Daily News(Bloomberg 稿)]
- Schnatter says that in June 2018 he told the board Ritchie should go, and that the board then asked him to become executive chairman. [Still unclear] Schnatter's letter to franchisees (reported by NRN) The company flatly denies it, saying the board never asked him to serve as executive chairman. Each side holds to its own account, with no third-party confirmation. [Nation's Restaurant News]
- He was approaching private equity firms about teaming up to buy back the company and regain majority control, but several firms declined because of his reputation. [Still unclear] CNBC, citing multiple sources His spokesman said that day that it was completely false. But in December 2018 he disclosed that he had hired a financial adviser, and in February 2019 he submitted an alternative financing proposal to the company. Whether he ever actually approached private equity firms is unsettled. [Fox Business] [Restaurant Dive]
- Trian Fund Management, Wendy's and others were evaluating an acquisition of Papa John's. [Still unclear] Media reports in early October 2018 (cited in both Schnatter's complaint and a Bloomberg story) No acquisition was ever completed; Trian reportedly pulled out in November, and the company wrapped things up on 2019-02-04 with the Starboard investment instead. Reports noted that any deal would be hard to do without the cooperation of Schnatter, who held about 30%. [Bangor Daily News(Bloomberg 稿)] [Schnatter 第二次修正訴狀(SEC 附件 99.2)] [Restaurant Dive]
Views
- Patricia Glaser (Schnatter's lawyer): She told The Wall Street Journal: "He's not going quietly." [Fortune]
- Papa John's company statement: The company said it was saddened and disappointed by his lawsuit, considered the litigation needless and wasteful, and said it had already provided him with the materials he was entitled to as a director. [Fox 17(CNN Wire)]
- John Schnatter (the person concerned): He believes his persona resonated with consumers because it was authentic, and that once the public knows what the board and management did, he can of course return to the ads. [WJLA(AP)]
- Papa John's spokesperson: The company said it is not, and should not be, dependent on one individual, and that stakeholders support separating the brand from him. [CBS News]
- Delaware Court of Chancery (opinion): The court held that the company had not shown his purpose in seeking inspection to be improper, and did not accept his separate shareholder suit as grounds for refusing a director's inspection—in effect rejecting the board's reasons for keeping the documents from him. [National Law Review]
- Olivia Kirtley (special committee member, former chairman): She said the agreement with Starboard concluded a comprehensive strategic review. [Bangor Daily News(Bloomberg 稿)]
- John Schnatter (the person concerned): He said he was pleased to have reached an agreement and to avoid further litigation, and that he supported the new leadership Smith and Starboard had brought; he called the removal of the acting-in-concert provision the key to his agreeing to settle. [CNBC] [Fortune(Bloomberg 稿)]
- Jeffrey Smith (chairman, Starboard CEO): He said he was delighted to welcome Lynch at a pivotal moment in the company's history. [CNBC]
- John Schnatter (the person concerned): He said Kirtley and Ritchie used the race issue to take the company and ruin it, that Kirtley and Shapiro should be in jail, and that the record would eventually be set straight. These are his claims alone; the report did not verify them. [TheWrap]
Photos & videos
A Papa John's store sign, December 2008 — Keith Allison from Owings Mills, USA / CC BY-SA 2.0
A Papa John's store in Durham, North Carolina, with an employee about to take pizzas out for delivery — Ildar Sagdejev (Specious) / CC BY-SA 4.0
Papa John's Cardinal Stadium at the University of Louisville (after the 2010 expansion); Schnatter paid for the naming rights, and on July 13, 2018, the university removed Papa John's from the stadium's name — Perthsider / CC BY-SA 3.0
John Schnatter at Charlotte Motor Speedway, May 26, 2013 — Army Capt. Rick Scoggins, North Carolina National Guard Public Affairs Office North Carolina National Guard / Public domain
Schnatter watching Game 4 of the 2016 World Series at Wrigley Field in Chicago — SecretName101 / CC BY-SA 4.0
Delivery scooters at a Papa John's store in Hoofddorp, the Netherlands, November 2017 — Jordy Schaap / CC BY-SA 4.0
Papa Johns' new headquarters in Atlanta, January 2022 — Miguel Alvarez / CC BY-SA 4.0
The Delaware Court of Chancery building (photographed in November 2022); in July 2018 Schnatter sued in the Court of Chancery to inspect company documents — Nolabob / CC BY-SA 4.0
A Papa Johns store in Asheville, North Carolina, May 2025 — Harrison Keely / CC BY 4.0- CNBC report: Papa John's apologizes for remarks criticizing NFL players' national anthem protests (CNBC)
- Los Angeles Times report: founder Schnatter to step down as CEO (Los Angeles Times)
- NBC Nightly News: Schnatter resigns as chairman after admitting he used a racial slur (NBC News)
- Louisville's WLKY television in an exclusive interview with Schnatter (WLKY News Louisville)
- CNBC report: Schnatter hits back at the board and says resigning was a mistake (CNBC Television)
- CNBC report: Starboard invests, and Jeff Smith becomes chairman of Papa John's (CNBC Television)
- Yahoo Finance report: Schnatter and Papa John's reach a settlement (Yahoo Finance)
- CNBC report: the ousted founder says in an interview that the pizza is not as good as it used to be (CNBC Television)