Michael Woodford (Michael Woodford) — Olympus (Olympus)
Briton Michael Woodford was promoted to president of Olympus in April 2011 and also became CEO on October 1. After pressing for answers about several questionable acquisitions and advisory fees, he was removed by the board on October 14, two weeks into the CEO job. He handed documents to Britain's Serious Fraud Office and other authorities, the stock collapsed, chairman Tsuyoshi Kikukawa resigned on October 26, and on November 8 the company admitted it had been hiding investment losses since the 1990s. Woodford at one point sought to return with a new board, but neither Japan's institutional shareholders nor the company's main banks supported him, and he gave up on January 6, 2012. At an extraordinary shareholder meeting on April 20, 2012, the entire old board stepped down. Kikukawa and two others were arrested, convicted in 2013 (with suspended sentences), and later ordered to pay about 59.4 billion yen in damages.
How they were ousted
Fired: chairman Tsuyoshi Kikukawa called an extraordinary board meeting at which every director present voted to remove him as president and CEO. He was not allowed to speak or vote, and kept only a directorship with no executive authority.
What happened to the board
The board that removed him vanished entirely within six months: Tsuyoshi Kikukawa resigned as chairman and president 12 days later and left the board about six weeks later; executive vice president Hisashi Mori was dismissed; and the remaining directors all stepped down at the extraordinary shareholder meeting on April 20, 2012, including Shuichi Takayama, who had taken over as president. Kikukawa, Mori and former statutory auditor Hideo Yamada were arrested in February 2012 and convicted in July 2013 (with suspended sentences); in 2019 a high court ordered the three to pay about 59.4 billion yen, and the Supreme Court made the ruling final in 2020. But it was not Woodford who brought them to account—he did not return, and the new board was dominated by people from the company's banks. The exact size of the board at the time was not found in this research.
Timeline
- Woodford promoted to president and COO He succeeded Tsuyoshi Kikukawa as president, becoming Olympus's first foreign president; Kikukawa became chairman and CEO. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [Wikipedia: Olympus Corporation]
- Monthly magazine FACTA reports on questionable acquisitions Japanese magazine FACTA published a report on irregularities in Olympus's acquisitions (Wikipedia gives two publication dates, July 10 and July 30). Woodford saw it only after a German colleague pointed it out, and then pressed Hisashi Mori and others for answers. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [維基百科日文版:オリンパス事件]
- Woodford starts writing letters demanding answers Between September 23 and October 11 he wrote six letters in all to Hisashi Mori and Tsuyoshi Kikukawa questioning the governance of the acquisitions, copying the later ones to the auditors, and he commissioned PwC to investigate. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Woodford also becomes CEO The board approved the move in a vote on September 30; Kikukawa gave up the CEO post and stayed on as chairman. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Extraordinary board meeting removes Woodford Kikukawa called an extraordinary board meeting, arrived late, set aside the original agenda and moved to remove Woodford from his posts. Every director present voted in favor; Woodford was barred from voting as an interested party. The company said there was too wide a gap between him and the rest of the management team over direction and methods. Kikukawa took the posts of president and CEO himself. [Olympus 新聞稿] [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- About 250 billion yen in market value wiped out in a day Market capitalization was 673 billion yen the day before the dismissal and 422 billion yen at that day's close. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Hisashi Mori: we may sue Woodford On a conference call with investors, Mori said the company might take legal action against Woodford over the leak of internal information. Woodford had already returned to London, handed documents to Britain's Serious Fraud Office and asked for police protection. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Olympus defends three acquisitions The company defended its acquisitions of three small companies, Altis, News Chef and Humalabo, while booking a 55.7 billion yen impairment. The next day Nomura and JPMorgan suspended coverage of the stock. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Tsuyoshi Kikukawa resigns as chairman and president; Shuichi Takayama takes over Kikukawa stepped down on the 12th day after Woodford's dismissal. The same day Woodford told Bloomberg Television that the entire board should go, and said he was willing to return if those directors left. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [維基百科日文版:菊川剛]
- Takayama blames the share price fall on Woodford The new president said at a press conference that Woodford's leaks had damaged corporate value. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Third-party committee set up The investigation was led by former Supreme Court justice Tatsuo Kainaka. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Olympus admits hiding losses The company admitted improper accounting, saying acquisition funds had been used to cover investment losses dating back to the 1990s, and named Kikukawa, Mori and Yamada. Mori was dismissed as executive vice president and Yamada resigned. Takayama said he had known nothing about it beforehand. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [Wikipedia: Michael Woodford (executive)]
- Nippon Life cuts its stake but says it still backs the company In the week to November 18, Nippon Life cut its stake from 8.18% to 5.11% and Mitsubishi UFJ from 10% to 7.6%. Nippon Life said publicly that it would support Olympus from its current position. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Woodford returns to Tokyo He returned to Japan to meet investigators and, under police escort, met Olympus employees. [Wikipedia: Michael Woodford (executive)]
- Kikukawa and Mori leave the board; Yamada resigns as auditor The three resigned ahead of the next day's board meeting; the remaining directors said they would resign once the company's rebuilding was on track. Woodford attended the November 25 board meeting and said those who truly cared about the company should step down as soon as possible. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Woodford resigns as a director and prepares a proxy fight He said the company needed a new, untainted board and that he had his own plan: to bring a new team back through a proxy fight. In the first half of December he canvassed for support without success. [Wikipedia: Michael Woodford (executive)] [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Olympus reportedly plans a capital increase that would dilute Woodford's allies Media reported that the company planned a share arrangement that would reduce the voting power of shareholders supporting Woodford. The next day prosecutors searched Olympus headquarters. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Woodford abandons his bid to return He announced he was abandoning the proxy fight, citing the lack of support from Japanese institutional shareholders and the heavy strain on his family over the 12 weeks. His lawyers turned instead to a claim in London over his dismissal from a four-year contract. [Wikipedia: Michael Woodford (executive)] [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Takayama announces he will resign in April Takayama said at a press conference that he would resign as president at the extraordinary shareholder meeting in late April. The same month the Tokyo Stock Exchange designated Olympus a "security on alert," allowing it to keep its listing. [維基百科日文版:高山修一] [維基百科日文版:オリンパス事件]
- Seven arrested, including Kikukawa, Mori and Yamada The special investigation unit of the Tokyo District Public Prosecutors Office arrested the three former executives for violating the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act, along with those who assisted them, including Akio Nakagawa and Nobumasa Yokoo. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [維基百科日文版:菊川剛]
- Extraordinary shareholder meeting: the entire old board steps down Shareholders voted on a new slate of 11 directors and the restated financial statements. Hiroyuki Sasa became president, and the nominee for chairman was Yasuyuki Kimoto, a former senior Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation executive. Woodford came to Tokyo one last time to attend and ask questions, which the board declined to answer. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [Wikipedia: Michael Woodford (executive)]
- Olympus board approves a settlement with Woodford The settlement was reportedly worth about 10 million pounds. The company announced 2,700 job cuts at the same time. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [Wikipedia: Michael Woodford (executive)]
- The company and three former executives plead guilty Olympus and Kikukawa, Yamada and Mori admitted in court to conspiring to file false financial statements. Three days later the company announced it would accept a 50 billion yen investment from Sony. [Wikipedia: Olympus Corporation]
- Tokyo District Court convicts the three; all sentences suspended Kikukawa: 3 years, suspended for 5; Yamada: 3 years, suspended for 5; Mori: 2 years and 6 months, suspended for 4. The company was fined 700 million yen. [日本經濟新聞]
- High court orders the three to pay about 59.4 billion yen In the shareholder derivative suit, Kikukawa, Yamada and Mori were ordered to pay the company about 59.4 billion yen (the lower court had awarded about 59 billion in 2017). The Supreme Court rejected their appeal on October 22, 2020, making the ruling final. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [維基百科日文版:オリンパス事件]
People
- Michael Woodford (Michael Woodford), 1960-06-12 — Olympus president and CEO (two weeks into the CEO job). Born in Britain in 1960. After his parents divorced he moved to Liverpool with his mother at age seven; graduated from Millbank College of Commerce. A longtime road safety campaigner, he was awarded an MBE in 2002. Joined KeyMed, Olympus's British medical equipment subsidiary, as a salesman in 1981 and became its managing director in 1991. In 2008 he took charge of the European business and joined the Olympus board; he was promoted to president and COO on April 1, 2011, and also became CEO on October 1. The man who promoted him was Tsuyoshi Kikukawa himself: in 2008 he flew to Tokyo intending to resign over the company's purchase of Gyrus, and Kikukawa instead gave him the European business and a board seat. Three years later, what he was investigating were the acquisitions made on Kikukawa's watch. Resigned as a director on November 30, 2011, and abandoned his bid to return on January 6, 2012, turning instead to a claim in London over his dismissal from a four-year contract. The Olympus board approved a settlement on June 8, 2012, reportedly worth about 10 million pounds. He has since written a book, worked as a corporate governance consultant and devoted himself to road safety charity work. [Wikipedia: Michael Woodford (executive)] [維基百科日文版:マイケル・ウッドフォード] [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Tsuyoshi Kikukawa (Tsuyoshi Kikukawa), 1941-02-27 — Olympus chairman (also took the posts of president and CEO after removing Woodford). Born in 1941 in Saijo, Ehime Prefecture; graduated from Keio University's Faculty of Law in 1963. Joined Olympus in 1964, served as president of its U.S. sales subsidiary, and ran advertising and public relations after returning to Japan. Became a director in 1993 and president in 2001. An insider who rose through the ranks; after ten years as president he became chairman with representative authority in April 2011. Woodford was the successor he had personally promoted. He called the extraordinary board meeting of October 14, set aside the scheduled agenda on the spot and moved to remove Woodford from his posts. Resigned as chairman and president on October 26, 2011, and left the board on November 24. Arrested by the special investigation unit of the Tokyo District Public Prosecutors Office on February 16, 2012; sentenced on July 3, 2013, to 3 years in prison, suspended for 5 years. In a shareholder derivative suit, a high court in 2019 ordered him, Mori and Yamada to pay about 59.4 billion yen, and the Supreme Court made the ruling final in October 2020. [維基百科日文版:菊川剛] [日本經濟新聞] [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Hisashi Mori (Hisashi Mori) — Olympus executive vice president, director. Joined Olympus in April 1981 and became a director in June 2006, later rising to executive vice president. He was Woodford's main point of contact when he pressed for answers about the acquisitions. A finance executive promoted from within. From late September 2011 Woodford wrote six letters to him and Kikukawa pressing them on governance problems with the acquisitions. Takayama, who took over as president, said he learned of the hidden losses only when Mori explained them to him. The company announced his dismissal as executive vice president on November 8, 2011, and he left the board on November 24. Arrested in February 2012; sentenced in July 2013 to 2 years and 6 months, suspended for 4 years, and later held jointly liable for about 59.4 billion yen in damages. [日本經濟新聞] [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [Wikipedia: Michael Woodford (executive)]
- Hideo Yamada (Hideo Yamada) — Olympus full-time statutory auditor. Olympus's full-time statutory auditor, named by the company and by Takayama as one of those chiefly responsible for hiding the losses. An insider by background; at the time of the events he attended board meetings as a statutory auditor. Named alongside Kikukawa and Mori as the three principals acknowledged by the company. Resigned in November 2011; arrested in February 2012; sentenced in July 2013 to 3 years, suspended for 5 years, and later held jointly liable for about 59.4 billion yen in damages. [日本經濟新聞] [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Shuichi Takayama (Shuichi Takayama), 1950-01-13 — Olympus senior managing director; became president on October 26, 2011. Born in 1950 in Niigata Prefecture; graduated from the electrical engineering department of Nagaoka National College of Technology. Joined Olympus in 1970 and made his career in medical endoscope development; became senior managing executive officer in April 2011. Promoted from within; chosen as president by the board after Kikukawa resigned. The insider who took over after Kikukawa resigned. He first blamed the fall in the share price on Woodford, and only two weeks later admitted the company had hidden losses and apologized. Said on January 18, 2012, that he would resign at the extraordinary shareholder meeting in April; on April 20 he resigned from all posts and left the company. A report by the committee investigating directors' liability had found six sitting directors to be liable. [維基百科日文版:高山修一] [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [Wikipedia: Michael Woodford (executive)]
- Hiroyuki Sasa (Hiroyuki Sasa), 1955-09-14 — Olympus president from April 2012. Graduated from Waseda University's School of Science and Engineering and its graduate school. Joined Olympus in 1982 and spent many years in the medical division; became an executive officer in 2007. Nominated by the company as the new president when the old board stepped down; proxy adviser ISS had recommended that shareholders vote against him. He was the company's internal candidate in place of the "clean board" Woodford wanted to bring in, paired with Yasuyuki Kimoto (a former senior Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation executive) as the nominee for chairman. Served seven years as president, handed over to Yasuo Takeuchi in April 2019 and remained a director until June 2020. [維基百科日文版:笹宏行] [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Koji Miyata (Koji Miyata) — Former Olympus director. A retired former director of Olympus. Came forward on his own after the events to voice support. Set up the Olympus Grassroots website calling on the company to clean house thoroughly, and launched a petition among employees calling for Woodford's reinstatement. The petition did not change the outcome; what he did afterward was not found in this research. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
Moves to block a return
- Three days after the dismissal, executive vice president Hisashi Mori said on a conference call with investors that the company might sue Woodford for leaking internal information. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- At a press conference, new president Shuichi Takayama blamed the fall in the share price on Woodford's disclosures, saying the leaks had damaged corporate value. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Nippon Life, the largest Japanese institutional shareholder, said it would continue to support Olympus "from its current position," yet in the same week cut its stake from 8.18% to 5.11%; Mitsubishi UFJ also cut its stake from 10% to 7.6%. Only foreign investors such as Southeastern, Harris and Baillie Gifford supported Woodford's return. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Media reported that Olympus was planning a share issuance arrangement that would dilute the voting power of shareholders supporting Woodford. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation, the main creditor bank, warned Woodford that his proxy fight would not succeed. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [維基百科日文版:マイケル・ウッドフォード]
- The new slate of directors proposed by the company was built around people from its banks: Yasuyuki Kimoto, the nominee for chairman, came from Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation, and Hideaki Fujizuka was formerly of Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ. Foreign shareholders criticized this as undue influence by creditor banks, but the slate was still put to a vote at the extraordinary shareholder meeting. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
Rumors
- The huge advisory fees and acquisition payments made by Olympus flowed to organized crime ("antisocial forces"), and the small companies it acquired were fronts for the yakuza. [Still unclear] The Sankei Shimbun reported that the intermediaries might be linked to antisocial forces; The New York Times reported that an investigators' memo named companies as connected to the Yamaguchi-gumi. Woodford also hinted that there were "forces" behind the board. Tatsuo Kainaka, chairman of the third-party committee, said no such facts had been confirmed up to that point; the later criminal convictions were for false financial statements. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Woodford was removed not because of a "clash of management styles" but because he was investigating the accounts. [Later confirmed] Woodford's own account to the media and Britain's Serious Fraud Office after his removal; the company's press release said the gap over management direction and methods was too wide. On November 8 the company admitted using acquisition funds to cover up investment losses dating back to the 1990s, and the deals he had questioned were the very means of concealment. The three principals later pleaded guilty and were convicted. [Olympus 新聞稿] [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Olympus planned to issue shares to dilute the foreign shareholders supporting Woodford. [Still unclear] Media reports in December 2011. Woodford gave up in January 2012, and the arrangement never came into play in his fight; it was not until September 2012 that the company announced it would accept an investment from Sony. No formal company response to the report was found in this research. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [Wikipedia: Olympus Corporation]
Views
- Michael Woodford himself: He said the entire board had to go, describing the directors as toxic; if they left, he was willing to return and clean things up. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- John Gapper (Financial Times columnist): He argued that the three may have believed they were loyally covering for their predecessors, but that this was corporate deception all the same; neither the board nor the auditors had done their duty. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- William Pesek (Bloomberg columnist): He attributed the problem to a Japanese corporate culture that refuses to admit mistakes, and to weak accountability and disclosure. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- The Economist: Argued that the scandal reflected a mindset that treats rules as flexible, and that Japan's governance system needed to change. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Foreign shareholders Southeastern, Harris Associates and Baillie Gifford: These three foreign institutions, which together held about 14%, called for Woodford's reinstatement, seeing him as the best person to clean up the company. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Michael Woodford himself: He said Japanese institutional investors had stayed silent from start to finish, which deeply disappointed him; this was also the main reason he gave up. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal] [Wikipedia: Michael Woodford (executive)]
- ISS (proxy advisory firm): Recommended that shareholders vote against Hiroyuki Sasa as president and against approving the financial statements, on the grounds that approval could narrow the scope for pursuing liability later. [Wikipedia: Olympus scandal]
- Michael Woodford himself: He said in an interview that Japan had not learned its lesson from the affair and had instead become even less transparent. [Wikipedia: Michael Woodford (executive)]
Photos & videos
The Olympus office building in Hatagaya, Shibuya, Tokyo (labeled "head office" on Commons), 2009 — Kamemaru2000 / CC BY-SA 3.0
The Shinjuku Monolith building in Nishi-Shinjuku, Tokyo, July 2011; Olympus was headquartered here at the time of the events — Aimaimyi / CC BY-SA 3.0
The third-generation Olympus PEN camera at the 2011 Good Design exhibition, photographed five days before the company admitted concealing losses — na0905 / CC BY 2.0
The trading floor of the Tokyo Stock Exchange, December 26, 2011 — Dick Thomas Johnson from Tokyo, Japan / CC BY 2.0
The Olympus OM-D E-M5 camera, May 2012 — Vincent Lee (이덕희) / CC BY-SA 3.0
The Shinjuku Monolith building, July 2012 — Rs1421 / CC BY-SA 3.0
An Olympus endoscope, photographed in 2014 — Kitmondo Marketplace / CC BY 2.0
Medical devices under the Gyrus ACMI brand; Olympus bought Britain's Gyrus in 2008 — PeterEasthope / CC BY-SA 4.0- Woodford in an interview with Bloomberg: he would be glad to be sued by Olympus (Bloomberg Originals)
- AFP: whistleblower Woodford arrives in Japan (AFP News Agency)
- AFP: back in Tokyo, Woodford accuses the board of ruining the company (AFP News Agency)
- Woodford's full press conference at the Japan National Press Club (jnpc)
- ANN: Woodford's press conference announcing he is giving up his bid to return as president (part 1 of 14) (ANNnewsCH)
- AFP: Olympus extraordinary shareholders' meeting approves a new board (AFP News Agency)
- Kyodo News: Olympus extraordinary shareholders' meeting; new president Hiroyuki Sasa and the new management team take office (共同通信 KYODO NEWS)