Wu Changjiang (Wu Changjiang) — NVC Lighting (NVC Lighting)
NVC Lighting founder Wu Changjiang resigned as chairman and CEO in May 2012; Yan Yan of investor SAIF Partners took over as chairman and Zhang Kaipeng, who came from Schneider, became CEO. After an employee work stoppage and a distributor boycott, he returned to the company in September 2012 as head of an interim operations committee and was reinstated as CEO in January 2013; Yan resigned as chairman in April 2013. But he made it back only by selling shares to Elec-Tech International and bringing in Wang Donglei. In August 2014 the board led by Wang removed him again, and that month a shareholder meeting voted about 95.84% in favor of removing him as a director. He was taken away by police in December 2014 and sentenced at first instance in 2016 to 14 years for misappropriation of funds and embezzlement by an employee. After the case was sent back for retrial, the retrial court of first instance in April 2021 changed the sentence to a fixed-term imprisonment of 10 years.
How they were ousted
Forced resignation: the company announced that he had resigned as chairman, executive director and CEO "for personal reasons"; he later said publicly that he had been forced out.
How they came back
After employees stopped work, distributors stopped placing orders and suppliers stopped deliveries to apply pressure, the board set up an interim operations committee and put him in charge. He returned as CEO in January 2013 and was voted back onto the board at the shareholder meeting that June.
What happened to the board
Both key figures in his ouster left after he came back: CEO Zhang Kaipeng reportedly resigned in November 2012, and chairman Yan Yan resigned as chairman and non-executive director about three months after Wu was reinstated as CEO (April 2013). But this was not the result of his purging the board; it was the result of his selling an 11.81% stake to Elec-Tech in exchange for the new largest shareholder's support. Wang Donglei, who succeeded Yan as chairman, turned around and ousted him in August 2014, and Wu himself ended up in prison. A complete list of how many seats the board had at the time, and of what became of each of the other directors, was not found in this research.
Timeline
- Wu Changjiang and two high school classmates found NVC Wu Changjiang, Du Gang and Hu Yonghong pooled 1 million yuan and set up NVC Lighting in Huizhou. [每日經濟新聞]
- First shareholder dispute: Wu Changjiang left first, but the two partners were the ones who left for good The three founders fought for control, and Wu Changjiang was at one point forced to give up his shares and leave. After distributors came out strongly in his support he returned to the company, and Du Gang and Hu Yonghong each took 80 million yuan and left. [中國經濟週刊(人民網)]
- SAIF Partners invests SAIF invested $22 million; Goldman Sachs followed in 2008 and Schneider in 2011. The company listed in Hong Kong in 2010. [AVCJ] [界面新聞]
- Wu Changjiang resigns as chairman and CEO The company announced that he had resigned as chairman and from all related posts for personal reasons, with SAIF's Yan Yan taking over as chairman. Within days, Zhang Kaipeng, who came from Schneider, was named CEO. [投資界]
- Wu Changjiang posts on Weibo that he was "forced to resign" He publicly called on the board to let him return; the same day, distributors launched a campaign in his support. [投資界]
- Employees stop work; distributors stop placing orders NVC employees in various locations began a work stoppage in protest, and suppliers threatened to set up a new brand. [投資界] [每日經濟新聞]
- Stoppage continues; three-way talks deadlocked A company spokesperson confirmed that the factories were still idle. Distributors and suppliers had formed a preparatory group of more than ten people to set up a separate new company and had begun registering a brand. [每日經濟新聞]
- Distributors hold a rally and plan to strike out on their own NVC's regional operators held a mobilization meeting, preparing to break away from the company and launch another brand. [投資界]
- Core suppliers halt deliveries Yan Yan said the same day that Wu Changjiang's reinstatement would have to await notification from the Hong Kong Stock Exchange. [投資界]
- Open letter in the name of all employees accuses Yan Yan of bad faith The open letter accused Yan Yan of stalling and covertly blocking Wu Changjiang's return; Wu said he would return to the company in his capacity as a major shareholder. [投資界]
- Wu Changjiang returns: named head of the interim operations committee The company announced that the board had decided to set up an interim operations committee and had appointed Wu Changjiang to head it, managing day-to-day operations. [投資界]
- Zhang Kaipeng resigns as CEO Media reported that Zhang Kaipeng had resigned as CEO of NVC Lighting; Yan Yan said Wu Changjiang would not take over. [投資界]
- Elec-Tech buys in and becomes the largest shareholder Wang Donglei's Elec-Tech spent about HK$1.65 billion to buy more than 20% of NVC, 11.81% of it from Wu Changjiang; Wu at the same time subscribed for Elec-Tech shares. [每日經濟新聞] [界面新聞]
- Wu Changjiang reinstated as CEO NVC held a board meeting and a meeting with distributors and formally reappointed Wu Changjiang as CEO; Wang Donglei became a non-executive director. [每日經濟新聞]
- Yan Yan resigns as chairman; Wang Donglei takes over The announcement said Yan Yan was resigning as chairman, non-executive director and member of the remuneration committee because he needed to focus on other business commitments (media reported that the announcement was issued on or about April 5). The announcement did not mention Wu Changjiang's status as a director. [每日經濟新聞]
- Wu Changjiang nominated as a director candidate The company announced that a shareholder had proposed electing Wu Changjiang and Wang Dongming (Wang Donglei's younger brother) as executive directors, with the motion to be put to a vote at the June 21 shareholder meeting. He subsequently returned to the board as an executive director. [新京報] [每日經濟新聞]
- Elec-Tech buys more of Wu Changjiang's shares Elec-Tech bought a further 6.86% stake from Wu Changjiang, leaving him with about 2.54% of NVC. [AVCJ]
- Directors of more than ten subsidiaries all replaced NVC announced the replacement of the directors of more than ten subsidiaries; most of those removed were on Wu Changjiang's side. On July 25 it also published a list of authorized distributors that did not include three related companies belonging to Wu's family. [每日經濟新聞]
- The board removes Wu Changjiang as CEO That afternoon the board passed a resolution by majority, announced that evening: Wu Changjiang was removed as CEO, with Wang Donglei as interim CEO; three vice presidents, Wu Changyong, Mu Yu and Wang Minghua, were dismissed at the same time. The stated reason was that he had, without board approval, allowed three related companies to obtain 20-year brand licenses. [每日經濟新聞] [AVCJ]
- Physical altercation at the Chongqing headquarters Between 15:11 and 15:15, people brought by Wang Donglei got into an argument with Wu Changjiang's assistant and others in an office at the Chongqing headquarters, and it escalated into a physical altercation. [每日經濟新聞]
- The two hold separate media briefings in Chongqing and Beijing, each accusing the other of hollowing out the company Trading in NVC shares was suspended. Wang Donglei accused Wu Changjiang of licensing the brand to related companies and hollowing out the listed company; Wu countered that Wang wanted to hollow out NVC, and said the trademark licenses were lawful. [中國經濟週刊(人民網)] [AVCJ]
- This time the distributors side with the board Nineteen provincial distributors signed a joint statement supporting the removal resolution; by August 14, 29 of the 38 had signed. Wu Changjiang said they had been coerced. [中國經濟週刊(人民網)]
- Extraordinary shareholder meeting removes Wu Changjiang as a director About 95.84% of the shares voted were cast in favor of removing Wu Changjiang as a director and from all his posts on board committees. [每日經濟新聞]
- Wu Changjiang taken away in Beijing The Huizhou Public Security Bureau opened a case on suspicion of misappropriation of funds. After being taken away in Beijing he was transferred to the Huizhou detention center and placed under criminal detention (the judgment counts his custody from December 4). [第一財經] [界面新聞]
- Formally arrested The Huizhou People's Procuratorate carried out his arrest. [每日經濟新聞]
- Trial opens at the Huizhou Intermediate Court Prosecutors alleged that between 2012 and 2014, without board authorization, he had converted company deposits into security deposits to guarantee loans for companies he controlled, with the security deposits totaling about 924 million yuan. [第一財經] [界面新聞]
- Sentenced to 14 years at first instance (date the court made it public) The Huizhou Intermediate People's Court sentenced him to 14 years in prison for misappropriation of funds and embezzlement by an employee, confiscated 500,000 yuan of his property and ordered him to pay back 3.7 million yuan. A co-defendant, the former assistant to the chairman, was sentenced to 3 years, suspended for 3 years. Media accounts differ on the date of sentencing (ranging from late November to December 21); the date used here is when the court made it public. [第一財經] [每日經濟新聞]
- Guangdong High Court quashes the verdict and orders a retrial The grounds were that the facts in the original judgment were unclear and the evidence insufficient. The Huizhou Intermediate Court reopened the case on October 11, 2018, and the retrial was heard on July 25–26, 2019. [每日經濟新聞]
- Retrial verdict at first instance: 10 years' fixed-term imprisonment Seven years for misappropriation of funds and 5 years and 6 months for embezzlement by an employee, combined into a sentence of 10 years, with 500,000 yuan of property confiscated and an order to pay back about 557 million yuan to NVC China. The sentence runs to December 3, 2024. He said he did not accept the verdict and would appeal. [界面新聞] [每日經濟新聞]
People
- Wu Changjiang (Wu Changjiang), 1965 — NVC Lighting founder, chairman and CEO. Born in August 1965. At the end of 1998 he and his high school classmates Du Gang and Hu Yonghong pooled 1 million yuan to found Huizhou NVC Lighting. He took the company public in Hong Kong in 2010 and made the Forbes rich list for the first time that year. One of the company's founders. Brought in SAIF Partners (Yan Yan) as an investor in 2006; Goldman Sachs and Schneider later took stakes as well. At the end of 2012 he sold an 11.81% stake to Wang Donglei's Elec-Tech and subscribed for Elec-Tech shares; the two were for a time regarded as allies. Removed as CEO and director in August 2014; taken away by Huizhou police that December. Sentenced to 14 years at first instance in 2016; in August 2018 the Guangdong High Court sent the case back for retrial, and in April 2021 the retrial court of first instance imposed a fixed-term sentence of 10 years (running from 2014-12-04 to 2024-12-03). He said he would appeal; the outcome of the appeal was not found in this research. [每日經濟新聞] [界面新聞] [第一財經]
- Yan Yan (Andrew Yan) (Andrew Yan (Yan Yan)) — Managing partner of SAIF Partners; chairman of NVC Lighting from May 2012. Founding managing partner of SAIF Partners. SAIF invested $22 million in NVC in 2006 and a further $10 million in 2008. Joined the board as the investor's representative; took over as chairman the day Wu Changjiang resigned. Came to know Wu Changjiang when SAIF invested in 2006; theirs was an investor-founder relationship. A 2012 open letter from employees accused him of teaming up with Schneider to take control of the company; he himself said the board had always welcomed Wu's return. Resigned in April 2013 as chairman, non-executive director and member of the remuneration committee; the announcement gave the reason as a need to focus on other business commitments. Wang Donglei succeeded him as chairman. [每日經濟新聞] [AVCJ] [投資界]
- Zhang Kaipeng (Zhang Kaipeng) — Became CEO of NVC Lighting in May 2012 (came from Schneider). Came from within shareholder Schneider Electric. Schneider took a stake of about 9.2% in NVC in 2011. Appointed CEO by the board after Wu Changjiang resigned. Represented strategic shareholder Schneider; Wu Changjiang's side and the distributors made "Schneider's withdrawal from management" one of the preconditions for his return. According to the headline of a PEdaily report dated November 26, 2012, he resigned as CEO of NVC Lighting; Yan Yan said at the time that Wu Changjiang would not take over. [投資界] [投資界]
- Wang Donglei (Wang Donglei), 1964 — Chairman of Elec-Tech; non-executive director of NVC from January 2013, chairman from April 2013, also interim CEO from August 2014. Born in 1964; graduated from Dalian Institute of Technology (now Dalian University of Technology). In 1996 he helped found what became Elec-Tech in Zhuhai, starting out in small household appliances and shifting to LEDs from 2009. In December 2012 Elec-Tech bought more than 20% of NVC for about HK$1.65 billion, becoming its largest shareholder; he joined the board soon after. Allied with Wu Changjiang through the share deal at the end of 2012: he bought Wu's 11.81% stake in NVC, and Wu subscribed for Elec-Tech shares. In 2014 the two fell out over brand licensing, related-party transactions and control. Led the removal of Wu Changjiang in August 2014 and also became interim CEO; he continued as chairman afterward (2016 reports still referred to him as the current chairman). [每日經濟新聞] [每日經濟新聞] [雷士照明董事簡介(公司文件)]
- Du Gang (Du Gang) — NVC Lighting co-founder (left in 2005). Wu Changjiang's high school classmate; at the end of 1998 the three pooled their money to found Huizhou NVC Lighting. Co-founder. A high school classmate of Wu Changjiang and Hu Yonghong. In 2005 the three fought for control; Wu was at one point forced to take 80 million yuan and leave, but the situation reversed after distributors stepped in. In the 2005 shareholder dispute, he and Hu Yonghong each took 80 million yuan and left the company. This was the first time Wu Changjiang was ousted and came back. [中國經濟週刊(人民網)] [每日經濟新聞]
- Hu Yonghong (Hu Yonghong) — NVC Lighting co-founder (left in 2005). Wu Changjiang's high school classmate; at the end of 1998 the three pooled their money to found Huizhou NVC Lighting. Co-founder. A high school classmate of Wu Changjiang and Du Gang; in 2005 he clashed with Wu over business strategy, including the setting up of regional operations centers. In 2005 he and Du Gang each took 80 million yuan and left the company. [中國經濟週刊(人民網)] [每日經濟新聞]
Moves to block a return
- During the work stoppage, chairman Yan Yan's attitude toward Wu's reinstatement reportedly went from accommodating to firm; distributors accused the board of going back on its word. Schneider said it respected and supported the board's resolution. [每日經濟新聞]
- Yan Yan set three conditions for reinstatement: explain to shareholders and the board the matter of his being investigated, deal with the related-party transactions not permitted under the listing rules, and comply strictly with board resolutions. He also said reinstatement had to go through Hong Kong Stock Exchange procedures and would have to await notification. An open letter from employees accused him of using delay to keep Wu Changjiang from returning. [投資界]
- The second time: the board removed him as CEO, dismissed three vice presidents including his brother Wu Changyong, and proposed an extraordinary shareholder meeting to remove him as an executive director. It had already replaced the directors of more than ten subsidiaries in July. [每日經濟新聞]
Rumors
- Wu Changjiang resigned in 2012 because the authorities had summoned him to "assist with an investigation." [Later confirmed] Reported by Chinese financial media during the 2012 turmoil; Yan Yan also made "explaining the investigation to the board" a condition for reinstatement. Wu Changjiang himself told the media that his assistance with the investigation had ended in mid-July, which amounts to acknowledging that it happened; but the substance and conclusions of the investigation were not made public. [投資界]
- NVC would hold a board meeting in Chongqing on July 25 to decide Wu Changjiang's fate; Schneider was willing to withdraw from management. [Still unclear] Market talk, relayed by National Business Daily. Spokespeople for both Schneider and NVC said at the time that they were unaware of the matter; the report could not be confirmed. [每日經濟新聞]
- When SAIF invested in NVC in 2006, Yan Yan and Lin Heping each privately asked for options on 1.5%. [Still unclear] An open letter issued in the name of all NVC employees. This is a one-sided allegation in the open letter alone; none of the reports found in this research verified it independently, and Yan Yan did not comment at the time. [投資界]
- Wu Changjiang ran up gambling debts of about 400 million yuan. [Still unclear] Said by Wang Donglei at an August 2014 press conference, where he produced a recording and claimed Wu Changjiang had admitted it himself. Wu Changjiang denied it, calling it a smear and questioning when the recording was made; the reports offered no independent evidence confirming the amount or the recording's authenticity. [中國經濟週刊(人民網)]
- Wang Donglei was "arrested" after the clash at the Chongqing headquarters. [Proven false] Circulated online. NVC executive director Xiong Jie responded that this was a rumor and that what police had dealt with was a physical altercation between the two sides' security guards; Wang Donglei was still taking reporters' calls on August 10. [每日經濟新聞]
Views
- NVC distributor (anonymous): Accused Yan Yan of going back on his word and said there was nothing to discuss unless Wu Changjiang returned to the board and Schneider withdrew. [每日經濟新聞]
- Peng Xiongjiang (analyst): Believed that Wu Changjiang's and Schneider's positions were fundamentally at odds and that it would be hard for both to remain at the company. [每日經濟新聞]
- Yan Yan (chairman at the time): Said publicly that he wished he could resign as chairman tomorrow, that the board had always welcomed Wu Changjiang's return, and that Wu was the ideal candidate for chairman. [投資界]
- Analysis reported by The Beijing News: Saw it as a case of retreating in order to advance, using an outside party to get back into management and onto the board. [新京報]
- Zhang Xiaofei (president, Gaogong LED Industry Research Institute): Believed the conflict between the two was inevitable and bound to erupt once it had built up far enough. [每日經濟新聞]
- Wu Changjiang himself: Said on Weibo that he bore 80% of the responsibility for things having come to this. [每日經濟新聞]
- Wu Changjiang's defense lawyer: Argued that the retrial court's finding of guilt, with no change in the facts or evidence, was inconsistent with the principle that doubt should be resolved in the defendant's favor. [界面新聞]
Photos & videos
Exchange Square in Central, Hong Kong, home of Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing; NVC Lighting listed in Hong Kong in 2010. Photographed in May 2016. — Ank Kumar / CC BY-SA 4.0- Finet report: NVC management demands that Wu Changjiang be re-elected chairman; the resumption of trading in the shares hits obstacles. (finettalk)
- Finet Hong Kong business news: Wu Changjiang says the securities regulator is investigating Andrew Yan over suspected share price manipulation. (finettalk)
- London Business School China Business Forum 2013: keynote speech by NVC Lighting founder Wu Changjiang. (LBSstudentView)
- Modern TV (現代電視) report: NVC Lighting shares suspended; several senior executives removed. (現代電視FinTV)
- Modern TV (現代電視) report: NVC Lighting votes to remove Wu Changjiang; Wang Donglei talks about the losses from the Wanzhou production halt. (現代電視FinTV)
- Modern TV (現代電視) report: former NVC chairman Wu Changjiang arrested. (現代電視FinTV)