Arthur T. Demoulas (Arthur T. Demoulas) — Market Basket (Demoulas Super Markets) (Market Basket (DeMoulas Super Markets))

At Market Basket, a family-owned New England supermarket chain, two branches of cousins fought from 1990 to 2014. On 2014-06-23 the board controlled by cousin Arthur S.'s faction fired CEO Arthur T. Employees stopped work, warehouses stopped deliveries and customers boycotted, leaving shelves at the 71 stores nearly bare for about six weeks. On 2014-08-27 Arthur T. and his three sisters agreed to buy the other side's entire 50.5% stake and he returned; the deal closed on 2014-12-12. But the story did not end there: on 2025-05-28 a board nominated by those same three sisters suspended him, and on 2025-09-09 it fired him. He went to court in Delaware seeking reinstatement, lost on 2026-04-20, and said in June 2026 that he would not appeal. As of 2026-11-19 he remains a minority shareholder with about 28% and has not returned to the company.

How they were ousted

The board, controlled by the faction of his cousin Arthur S., resolved not to keep him on as president—in effect firing him outright.

How they came back

After about six weeks of employee walkouts and a customer boycott, he and his three sisters bought the other side's 50.5% stake for about $1.5 billion, and he immediately regained control of operations.

What happened to the board

In 2014, the opposing faction exited as a bloc: Arthur S.'s branch sold its entire 50.5% stake, the deal closed on 2014-12-12 (about three and a half months after his return), Arthur S. and the independent directors elected by his side (Cowan, El-Hage, Weiner) no longer controlled the board, and the two co-CEOs were sidelined the very day he returned. The exact dates on which individual directors left, however, could not be found. The two directors who sided with Arthur T. back then, Shea and Carleton, stayed on until 2025. The counterexample came later: the three sisters who had put up money to rescue him gradually replaced directors, removing Carleton on 2025-01-03 and Shea on 2025-08-07, and on 2025-09-09 fired Arthur T. himself; the court also ruled for the board. In other words, in 2014 it was the faction that ousted him that was swept out, and in 2025 it was he and his allies.

Timeline

  1. The two branches start suing each other George Demoulas's widow and children sued Mike Demoulas for cheating them out of their shares, and a jury found for the plaintiffs. Weeks later Arthur S. sued Mike again for diverting company assets into his own businesses. Judge Maria Lopez awarded George's branch about $206 million and 50.5% of the shares and ordered Mike to step down as president. (The source says only 1990; month and day unknown.) [Wikipedia:Demoulas family] [Wikipedia:Market Basket (New England)]
  2. Mike and Arthur T. step down under court order Mike Demoulas resigned as president and Arthur T. as vice president; William Marsden took over as president. (The source says only 1999.) [Wikipedia:Demoulas family] [Wikipedia:Market Basket (New England)]
  3. Rafaele Evans swings to Arthur T. Rafaele Evans, a shareholder from George's branch, switched to Arthur T.'s side, giving him a board majority. (The source says only 2002.) [Wikipedia:Market Basket (New England)]
  4. Arthur T. becomes president and CEO Revenue subsequently grew from $3 billion to $4 billion and the workforce from 14,000 to 25,000. (The source says only 2008.) [Wikipedia:Demoulas family]
  5. Evans switches sides again; board majority flips In mid-2013 Rafaele Evans switched her support to Arthur S., giving the Class A directors the majority. (The source says only midyear.) [Wikipedia:Market Basket (New England)] [Supermarket News(2014-04-02)]
  6. First motion to fire him is not put to a vote A motion to replace Arthur T. was on the board's agenda; employees gathered outside in protest, and in the end the board did not take up the motion. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests] [Wikipedia:Market Basket (New England)]
  7. New board issues a memo: special dividend, executive search firm The three new independent directors, Keith Cowan, Nabil El-Hage and Ronald Weiner, sent a memo to employees. The board had approved a $250 million special dividend, replaced the trustees of the profit-sharing plan, hired an executive search firm, applied for a line of credit and set up new audit, compensation, governance, finance and real estate committees. [Supermarket News(2013-09-03)]
  8. Class B directors stay away; board meeting lacks a quorum William Shea and Terence Carleton, the directors on Arthur T.'s side, did not attend Monday's board meeting, leaving it short of a quorum. [Supermarket News(2014-04-02)]
  9. Class A directors sue Class B directors over boycott The Class A side filed suit in Superior Court, accusing Shea and Carleton of deliberately denying the meeting a quorum to block decisions, and asked the court to order the two to attend the April 28 board meeting or to suspend the quorum requirement. [Supermarket News(2014-04-02)]
  10. Class B directors countersue Shea and Carleton countersued the board, saying the majority was using the new committee system to shut them out and withholding meeting minutes and consultants' contracts. They asked the court to let them inspect documents and sit in on the committees. [Supermarket News(2014-04-04)]
  11. The board fires Arthur T. and two senior executives After meeting in Boston, the board announced that Arthur T. would not continue as president and would retain no management responsibilities; vice president Joseph Rockwell and director of operations William Marsden were fired at the same time. Felicia Thornton and James Gooch were named co-CEOs the same day. Marsden said the decision was driven by greed. [CBS Boston/AP(2014-06-23)] [Supermarket News(2014-06-23)]
  12. Employees rally at the Chelsea store; several executives resign About 300 employees rallied in protest at the flagship store in Chelsea, Massachusetts. Several executives resigned that day, including CFO Donald Mulligan and executive vice president Jim Miamis (Boston.com lists seven; Wikipedia says six). [Boston.com(2014-07-22 人物表)] [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests] [NHPR(2014-06-24)]
  13. Headquarters employees issue an ultimatum Headquarters employees demanded that the board reinstate Arthur T., setting a deadline of 4:30 p.m. the next day. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests]
  14. Co-CEOs warn: leave your post and you're fired Gooch and Thornton said employees who abandoned their jobs would be dismissed. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests]
  15. Mass protests begin; warehouse workers and drivers stop deliveries About 2,500 to 3,000 people took part in the protest; about 300 warehouse workers and 68 drivers refused to make deliveries, and store shelves began to empty. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests]
  16. Eight employees who led the protests are fired Those fired included district manager Tom Trainor, facilities supervisor Steve Paulenka, buyers Jim Lacourse and Joe Garon, grocery supervisor Tom Gordon, operations supervisor Joe Schmidt and deli supervisor Mike Kettenbach (Arthur T.'s nephew), among others. (Another Wikipedia entry says seven.) [Boston.com(2014-07-22 人物表)] [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests] [Wikipedia:Market Basket (New England)]
  17. About 5,000 rally at Tewksbury headquarters The same day, Arthur T. issued a statement saying the fired employees should not have been dismissed and should be reinstated, and that the company's success was due to its business model and its employees, not to him personally. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests] [WBUR(2014-07-23)]
  18. Co-CEOs make their first public appeal Thornton and Gooch urged employees to return to work, called the firing of the eight a decision they had no choice but to make, and said they had no intention of changing the company's direction. The same day, protests took place at all 71 stores. [WBUR(2014-07-23)] [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests]
  19. Board meets in Boston; employees rally again The board met at 4 p.m. at the Prudential Center in Boston. Employees held a large rally in Tewksbury the same day, demanding a direct vote to reinstate Arthur T. [WBUR(2014-07-23)]
  20. The Boston Globe: Arthur T. is the only buyer still at the table The report said Arthur T.'s side was the only one still bidding for the 50.5% stake; the board denied this. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests]
  21. Co-CEOs promise no penalty for those who return to work They also announced open hiring starting in August. Managers at 68 stores had reportedly prepared a petition pledging to resign en masse. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests]
  22. State attorneys general remind the company to obey labor laws The attorneys general of Massachusetts and New Hampshire reminded the company of the laws protecting dismissed employees. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests]
  23. Arthur T. offers to return as CEO while talks continue He said he was willing to come back as CEO during the negotiations. [AP/WTOP(2014-08-11)]
  24. Company holds job fairs to find replacement workers Employees also protested outside the job fairs. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests] [PBS NewsHour(2014-08-13)]
  25. Part-timers' shifts are cut The company eliminated part-time employees' hours, and many applied for unemployment benefits. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests] [PBS NewsHour(2014-08-13)]
  26. Arthur T.: the other side's terms go far beyond a normal deal He said his offer had not been rejected over price; rather, the other side's counterproposal came with conditions not found in a normal transaction. The Class A shareholders said they were willing to accept his price but not his financing. [AP/WTOP(2014-08-11)]
  27. The three independent directors again urge a return to work The independent directors said people should not treat the matter as a zero-sum game and that they were willing to sit down and talk. The previous week they had proposed letting Arthur T. and his team return to help with operations without controlling the company; Arthur T. said through a spokesperson that this was merely an attempt to stabilize the company before selling it to someone else. [AP/WTOP(2014-08-11)] [WBUR(2014-08-12)]
  28. "Final warning": come back by Friday or lose your job The company sent a final notice to about 200 employees (other sources say as many as 700), with a deadline of August 15. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests] [PBS NewsHour(2014-08-13)]
  29. Massachusetts Gov. Patrick urges employees to go back to work first Deval Patrick said the two sides were close to a deal on price and asked employees to return to work so the company could stabilize. His wife's law firm, Ropes & Gray, happened to represent the independent directors, which drew criticism; he said he had not known beforehand and made a disclosure to the State Ethics Commission. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests] [PBS NewsHour(2014-08-13)]
  30. Return-to-work deadline passes; employees stay out Protests continued on the day of the deadline. The next day the company added security at headquarters and barred the media. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests]
  31. Governors of the two states meet with both sides Massachusetts Gov. Patrick and New Hampshire Gov. Maggie Hassan met separately with the two sides in an attempt to broker a deal. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests] [Wikipedia:Market Basket (New England)]
  32. Arthur T. makes his final offer A spokesperson said it was a fully financed offer on terms highly favorable to the sellers. [WBUR(2014-08-22)]
  33. The two governors announce an agreement in principle The governors said the agreement had not yet been put in writing and the goal was to finish by Sunday. It would give Arthur T. operating authority for a transition period first, while the board agreed to hold off on disciplining employees who had left their posts. [WBUR(2014-08-22)]
  34. Late-night signing: Arthur T.'s branch buys the 50.5% Late Wednesday night, shareholders and the board signed a binding agreement under which the Class B shareholders (Arthur T. and his three sisters) would buy the Class A shareholders' 50.5% stake for more than $1.5 billion. Arthur T. immediately regained day-to-day operating authority; the two co-CEOs would stay on until the deal closed. [WGBH(2014-08-28)] [Boston.com(2014-08-28 各方反應)] [Supermarket News(2014-08-27)]
  35. Arthur T. returns to headquarters and addresses employees On Thursday morning he spoke to employees and protesters at the Tewksbury headquarters. Employees went back to work that day and began restocking. [Boston.com(2014-08-28 各方反應)] [Supermarket News(2014-08-27)]
  36. Fortune: the private equity backer is Blackstone Fortune, citing a person familiar with the matter, said Blackstone was putting up more than $500 million; a Blackstone spokesperson declined to comment. The Boston Globe separately had sources saying no private equity firm was involved. [Fortune(2014-08-28)] [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests]
  37. The two co-CEOs are left on the sidelines The Boston Globe reported that Gooch and Thornton were still coming to work at headquarters and were still the signatories on legal documents, but could not veto decisions by Arthur T.'s team; the employees fired in July had been reinstated. The report said each was being paid tens of thousands of dollars a week under contracts guaranteeing three years. [Boston Globe(2014-09 共同執行長現況)]
  38. Share deal closes The 50.5% stake was formally transferred. The four siblings set up a holding company, DSM Holdco, and deliberately kept all siblings off its board, which was made up of non-family directors, with Bill Shea as chairman and Terence Carleton staying on. [Wikipedia:Market Basket protests] [Arthur T. Demoulas 答辯暨反訴狀(德拉瓦衡平法院,2025-10-01,WBUR 存檔)]
  39. Cracks begin to appear among the siblings According to Arthur T.'s court filing, around 2018 the spouses of two of the sisters demanded that the company pay $10 million to buy out a real estate development company, and relations soured; the sisters then gradually replaced directors. (The year is as stated in the filing and approximate.) [WBUR(2025-10-02)]
  40. Steven Collins joins the board Nominated by the three sisters. (The source says only 2019.) [Arthur T. Demoulas 答辯暨反訴狀(德拉瓦衡平法院,2025-10-01,WBUR 存檔)]
  41. Jay Hachigian joins the board The sisters' side removed Charles Roazen, a director for more than twenty years, and replaced him with Hachigian. (The source says only March 2021.) [Arthur T. Demoulas 答辯暨反訴狀(德拉瓦衡平法院,2025-10-01,WBUR 存檔)]
  42. Michael Keyes joins the board Elected by the three sisters. [Arthur T. Demoulas 答辯暨反訴狀(德拉瓦衡平法院,2025-10-01,WBUR 存檔)]
  43. The $1.6 billion in debt from the 2014 buyout is paid off Arthur T.'s spokesperson said that in December 2024 the company paid off the debt taken on to buy back the shares. (The source says only December 2024.) [WCVB(2025-05-28)]
  44. Carleton removed as a director The three sisters removed Terence Carleton, a director for more than twenty years, from the board; the seat was not filled. [Arthur T. Demoulas 答辯暨反訴狀(德拉瓦衡平法院,2025-10-01,WBUR 存檔)]
  45. Hachigian replaces Shea as chairman With Carleton's seat vacant, Collins and Keyes voted to make Hachigian chairman; Shea's opposition was to no avail. [Arthur T. Demoulas 答辯暨反訴狀(德拉瓦衡平法院,2025-10-01,WBUR 存檔)]
  46. The board suspends Arthur T. The board placed Arthur T., his daughter Madeline, his son Telemachus and several executives on paid leave, and retained law firm Quinn Emanuel to investigate whether he was planning a work stoppage. Arthur T.'s spokesperson called it a farce staged to cover a hostile takeover. [WCVB(2025-05-28)] [Boston 25 News/Yahoo(2025-05-30)]
  47. Chairman Hachigian: he has in effect hijacked the company Hachigian said Arthur T. treated the company as his alone and began planning a boycott as soon as the board set limits. Director Keyes said in an interview that for five years the board had been unable to obtain basic information such as capital expenditures and budgets. [Boston 25 News/Yahoo(2025-05-30)] [WCVB(2025-05-30 Keyes 專訪)]
  48. Board upholds the suspension 3–0 (one abstention) Suspended executives Tom Gordon and Joe Schmidt denied planning a work stoppage. [Boston 25 News/Yahoo(2025-05-30)]
  49. The board fires Schmidt and Gordon Director of operations Joseph Schmidt (39 years with the company) and grocery director Tom Gordon (50 years) were fired for insubordination, spreading false statements and visiting two New Hampshire stores after being suspended. The two were among the protest leaders fired and reinstated in 2014. [CBS Boston(2025-07-23)]
  50. The sisters remove Shea from the board Bill Shea, a director for nearly thirty years, was voted out by the three sisters, leaving only Hachigian, Collins and Keyes on the board. In a statement on August 18, Shea said he was removed because he had asked to see the evidence against Arthur T. [Boston 25 News/Yahoo(2025-08-18)]
  51. The two sides enter mediation Mediation was held on September 3 and continued on September 9, without result. [WBUR/NHPR(2025-09-10)] [Boston 25 News/Yahoo(2025-08-18)]
  52. The board votes unanimously to fire Arthur T. Late Tuesday night the board voted to remove him as president and CEO and petitioned the Delaware Court of Chancery to confirm the resolution's validity. Arthur T.'s spokesperson said he was fired at a 10:30 p.m. meeting without a chance to be heard, in violation of the company's bylaws. [WBUR/NHPR(2025-09-10)] [CBS Boston(2025-09-10)]
  53. CFO Don Mulligan named acting CEO The board appointed Don Mulligan, the CFO and treasurer with decades at the company, as acting CEO. In 2014 he had resigned in protest over the firing of Arthur T. [Arthur T. Demoulas 答辯暨反訴狀(德拉瓦衡平法院,2025-10-01,WBUR 存檔)] [Boston.com(2014-07-22 人物表)]
  54. Arthur T. files a 94-page counterclaim seeking reinstatement In a counterclaim in the Delaware Court of Chancery, he alleged that his three sisters conspired to oust him in order to collect larger dividends, and denied planning a work stoppage; he sought only reinstatement, not monetary damages. The board responded that he was fired for not following board directives, not submitting an annual budget and proposing only his own children as successors. [WBUR(2025-10-02)] [Arthur T. Demoulas 答辯暨反訴狀(德拉瓦衡平法院,2025-10-01,WBUR 存檔)]
  55. Delaware court holds a three-day trial Vice Chancellor J. Travis Laster heard the case without a jury, taking testimony from 14 witnesses. (The source says only December 2025.) [InsideLowell(2026-04-20)] [WHDH 7News(2026-04-20)]
  56. Closing arguments conclude Arthur T.'s lawyers argued that the firing stemmed from family discord, not from legitimate doubts about his ability to run the business. [Bloomberg Law(2026-02-25)]
  57. Court rules the firing valid Vice Chancellor Laster found that the board had reasonable grounds to be concerned that Arthur T. had long resisted oversight and to suspect he was preparing a repeat of the 2014 walkout and boycott; Arthur T. could not prove that a majority of the directors acted in bad faith. The judge also acknowledged that he had kept the company profitable for nearly two decades. The board said the company was not for sale and would remain family-owned. [Concord Monitor/NHPR(2026-04-21)] [InsideLowell(2026-04-20)] [WHDH 7News(2026-04-20)]
  58. Chuck Casassa named president; Mulligan retires The board announced the promotion to president of Chuck Casassa, who started as a bagger in 1976. Acting CEO Mulligan retired and became an adviser, and the CEO post was left unfilled. The board said it looked forward to working constructively with Arthur T. as a significant shareholder. [WCVB(2026-04-30)] [CBS Boston(2026-04-30)]
  59. Arthur T. decides not to appeal A spokesperson said he disagreed with the ruling, but that continuing to litigate in a court that generally favors boards would not benefit the company, its employees or its customers; he would keep working to set things right by other means. As of 2026-11-19 no newer developments could be found. [InsideLowell(2026-06-02)]

People

Moves to block a return

Rumors

Views

Photos & videos