Kinya Seto (Kinya Seto) — LIXIL Group (LIXIL Group)
On 2018-10-31, Japanese housing equipment giant LIXIL Group abruptly announced that president and CEO Kinya Seto was stepping down. Yoichiro Ushioda, a member of the founding family who held only about 3% of the shares, made himself chairman and CEO and elevated Hirokazu Yamanashi, the chair of the nomination committee, to COO. An investigation by lawyers retained by the company later found that Ushioda's words and actions had led the nomination committee to mistakenly believe Seto intended to resign. Four British and American institutional investors and Keiichiro Ina of the INAX founding family demanded an extraordinary shareholder meeting to remove the two men. Ushioda preempted it by announcing his resignation, and the company put forward an entirely new slate of directors in opposition to Seto. At the shareholder meeting on 2019-06-25, all eight of Seto's nominees were elected; he kept his board seat with 53.7% approval and returned as CEO, about eight months after his removal.
How they were ousted
Yoichiro Ushioda, the chairman of the board and a member of the founding family, led the nomination committee to believe Seto was resigning voluntarily, then had the board vote to strip him of the CEO post.
How they came back
Joined forces with overseas institutional investors and the INAX founding family on a shareholder proposal, won a majority for his own slate of directors at the shareholder meeting, and was reelected CEO by the board afterward.
What happened to the board
Of the 12 directors at the time, 11 were people other than Seto himself. Nine of them (the four inside directors Ushioda, Yamanashi, Kikuchi, Kanamori and Shirai, plus the four outside directors Kawaguchi, Kohda, Judge and Yoshimura) had all left by or on the day Seto returned—Ushioda resigned as a director first, on 2019-05-20, and the others' terms ended at the 2019-06-25 shareholder meeting, about eight months after the change. Only Ina and Kawamoto, who had sided with Seto, stayed on. But two points should be noted: these nine were replaced by the company's own slate, not by Seto acting after his return; and six of the company's other nominees were elected, among them Masatoshi Matsuzaki, who became chairman of the board, and Kazuhiko Otsubo, who stayed on as president of the operating company. Seto's camp held only 8 of the 14 seats.
Timeline
- Kinya Seto takes office as president and CEO Yoichiro Ushioda recruited MonotaRO founder Seto to succeed Yoshiaki Fujimori, who had stepped down after accounting fraud at a Chinese subsidiary caused huge losses. (The source says only June 2016.) [維基百科(日文):瀬戸欣哉] [東洋經濟 Online(2018-11-12)] [Business Insider Japan(2019-06-04)]
- Ushioda also becomes an executive officer Ushioda, who had been serving only as chairman of the board, also took on the role of executive officer (in charge of special assignments), reinserting himself into management. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [FACTA(2018 年 12 月號)]
- Ushioda and Seto meet over a meal The two met over a meal, seen as the direct trigger of the conflict. The later investigation report omitted most of what was said. [NetIB-News(2019-07-02)]
- Nomination committee approves the change of CEO Committee chair Hirokazu Yamanashi said Seto had offered to resign on his own and that the proposed successors were Ushioda (chairman and CEO) and himself (COO). Toward the end of the meeting someone suggested Seto's intentions should be confirmed once more, and Ushioda was to do the confirming. [Business Insider Japan(2019-03-07)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-04-12 報告書全文)] [日本スチュワードシップ研究会(2019-09-24)]
- Ushioda phones Rome and tells Seto to resign Ushioda told Seto, who was on a business trip, that this was the unanimous decision of the nomination committee and would be announced in four days. Seto countered that the medium-term plan had begun only six months earlier and that leaving now would be irresponsible; Ushioda would not budge. [文春(秋場大輔《決戦!株主総会》節錄 1)] [Business Insider Japan(2019-03-07)]
- The board votes to replace Seto Of the 12 directors, 7 voted in favor and 3 against, with 2 absent (not taking part in the vote). Those opposed were Seto, Keiichiro Ina and Ryuichi Kawamoto; outside director Main Kohda left before the vote. There were objections during the meeting, and Ushioda effectively cut off the discussion. [日本スチュワードシップ研究会(2019-09-24)] [FACTA(2018 年 12 月號)] [文春 Online(同書節錄 2,2022-06-09)] [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口利昭律師,2019-05-29)]
- Press conference: Ushioda calls both hired managers great successes The company announced that from November 1 Ushioda would be chairman and CEO and Yamanashi COO, with Seto to step down as president at the end of March 2019. Ushioda said he would take an active part in management, and that he and Seto had never narrowed their differences over how the holding company should be run. [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2018-11-04)] [東洋經濟 Online(2018-11-12)]
- Stock falls 14% in a day On the day the new appointments took effect, the stock fell from 1,780 yen the previous day to close at 1,530 yen. [日本スチュワードシップ研究会(2019-09-24)] [FACTA(2018 年 12 月號)]
- FACTA reports an MBO and a move to Singapore were the ideas behind it The magazine reported that Ushioda had explained to the board an idea of taking the company private, merging it with a Singapore company and listing there, and named CVC as a possible backer. (December issue; exact publication date unknown.) [FACTA(2018 年 12 月號)]
- Ushioda and Yamanashi brief institutional investors At a small briefing, Ushioda said the change was made because Seto's ability as CEO was simply too poor. Investors did not accept that explanation. [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)] [日本スチュワードシップ研究会(2019-09-24)]
- Marathon sends a letter of questions to all directors Britain's Marathon Asset Management sent a letter of questions and asked for the minutes of the board and nomination committee meetings to be released. The company refused to release the minutes on the grounds that Marathon was not a shareholder of record, and gave no substantive reply to the letter. [日本スチュワードシップ研究会(2019-09-24)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)]
- Nikkei Business reports LIXIL studied an MBO and might leave Japan The report said the company had internally studied a management buyout and moving out of Japan. [NetIB-News(2019-07-02)]
- Company releases a "summary version" of the investigation report Lawyers from Nishimura & Asahi were retained by the company to investigate. The 18-page report was cut to 8 pages and released in the company's name. The summary found that Ushioda's words and actions had led the nomination committee to mistakenly believe Seto intended to resign, but that the board resolution had no defect sufficient to affect its validity. [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)] [Business Insider Japan(2019-03-07)] [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口利昭律師,2019-05-29)]
- Outside director defends the change at an investor briefing Outside director Tsutomu Kawaguchi said the board had long had doubts about Seto's management approach. Investors pointed out that this appeared nowhere in the report summary. [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)]
- Four institutional investors plus Ina demand an extraordinary shareholder meeting Four institutions—Marathon, Indus Capital, Polar Capital and Taiyo Pacific—together with director Keiichiro Ina (jointly holding more than 3% but less than 5%) demanded an extraordinary shareholder meeting to remove Ushioda and Yamanashi as directors. [日本スチュワードシップ研究会(2019-09-24)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-05-17)]
- Yamanashi becomes president Seto stepped down as president at the end of March, remaining only a director; Yamanashi became president and COO. [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2018-11-04)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-04-12 瀨戶提案)] [NetIB-News(2019-04-10)]
- Seto holds a press conference: a shareholder proposal and a bid to return as CEO Seto announced a joint proposal with Ina to elect eight directors at the June shareholder meeting, himself included (four inside, four outside), with the aim of returning as CEO if it passed. [NetIB-News(2019-04-10)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-04-12 瀨戶提案)] [現代 Business(町田徹,2019-05-28)]
- Full investigation report released Under pressure from major shareholders, the media and the Tokyo Stock Exchange, an extraordinary board meeting agreed unanimously to release the full 17-page text (partly redacted). The full text says that a majority of directors, outside directors included, were "deferential" toward Ushioda. The same day Ushioda gave interviews to the Yomiuri Shimbun and Weekly Toyo Keizai, saying he believed Seto's intention to resign had been sincere. [東洋經濟 Online(2019-04-12 報告書全文)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-04-12 潮田專訪)] [日本スチュワードシップ研究会(2019-09-24)] [文春 Online(同書節錄,2022-06-24)]
- Investors petition the Tokyo District Court to convene an extraordinary shareholder meeting themselves Worried that the company was stalling, the shareholder side asked the court for permission for shareholders to convene and chair the extraordinary meeting themselves. [日經 Business(2019-04-15)] [現代 Business(町田徹,2019-05-28)]
- Company sets this day as the record date for the extraordinary shareholder meeting The company said it would hold the extraordinary shareholder meeting in mid-to-late May, with April 15 as the record date. According to people involved, Ushioda had no intention of bowing to the demand for his removal. [日經 Business(2019-04-15)]
- Emergency press conference: huge loss; Ushioda announces his resignation and shifts the blame to Seto At a press conference in Roppongi, Tokyo, the company revised its full-year result from a profit of 1.5 billion yen to a loss of 53 billion yen because of an impairment at Italian subsidiary Permasteelisa. Ushioda announced he would resign as a director on May 20 and as CEO at the June shareholder meeting; Yamanashi would not stay on as a director after the meeting. Ushioda said he was taking responsibility for having appointed Seto, not trying to dodge the extraordinary shareholder meeting. [文春 Online(同書節錄,2022-06-24)] [文春(同書節錄 4,2022-07-08)] [現代 Business(町田徹,2019-05-28)] [Reuters(2019-04-23,Yahoo 轉載)]
- Seto hits back that night Shortly after 7 p.m., Seto told more than 20 reporters at a law firm that Ushioda's account did not match the facts; he had reported the risks at Permasteelisa in board materials after taking office. [文春(同書節錄 4,2022-07-08)]
- Ina holds a press conference to explain the shareholder proposal Keiichiro Ina made public the eight-person slate, which included Seto. [現代 Business(町田徹,2019-05-28)]
- Ten senior executives jointly write to the nomination committee In late April, ten senior managers including executive officers wrote to the chair of the nomination committee criticizing the management structure under Ushioda. (The source says only late April.) [日經 Business(2019-05-09)] [現代 Business(町田徹,2019-05-28)]
- Company's nomination committee meets but fails to settle on a slate The committee chair was Barbara Judge. [日經 Business(2019-05-09)]
- Investors withdraw their request for an extraordinary shareholder meeting After the company confirmed in writing that Ushioda would resign as a director on May 20 and Yamanashi would step down after the shareholder meeting, the four institutions withdrew their request. One investor said it felt as if the ladder had been pulled away, leaving no opponent to fight. [日經 Business(2019-05-09)] [現代 Business(町田徹,2019-05-28)]
- Company announces its own slate of directors The nomination committee put forward eight candidates, seven of them outside directors; none of the sitting directors was renominated. The slate used two people from Seto's list, Teruo Suzuki and Kaoru Onimaru, but without obtaining their consent beforehand—they were merely notified the previous day in an email forwarded through Seto. The other six people on Seto's slate were all excluded. [日經 Business(2019-05-13)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-05-13)]
- Ushioda resigns as a director In line with the April 18 announcement and the May 9 written confirmation, Ushioda resigned as a director after that day's board meeting, remaining chairman and CEO until the shareholder meeting. The company also added one more candidate on each of May 17 and May 20. [現代 Business(町田徹,2019-05-28)] [日經 Business(2019-05-09)]
- Suzuki and Onimaru publicly refuse to be company candidates Seven members of Seto's side held a press conference. Teruo Suzuki said he had met director Kikuchi the day before, that Kikuchi could not explain why he had been nominated, and criticized the approach as deeply insincere. Former Supreme Court justice Kaoru Onimaru said the investigation report's fact-finding was vague and its conclusion inconsistent with what preceded it. [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2019-05-25)] [現代 Business(町田徹,2019-05-28)]
- Company finalizes its position: against the shareholder proposal The company's final slate had ten people (nine of them outside directors), and it declared its opposition to the proposal from Seto's side. Each side's own candidates plus two shared candidates, 16 people in all, were put to shareholders for individual votes. [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口利昭律師,2019-05-29)] [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2019-05-25)]
- Company's candidates brief investors Six candidates attended, including Masatoshi Matsuzaki and Zenji Miura. From the stage they described the conflict between Ushioda and Seto as one in which both sides were at fault, and they were unable to answer when investors pressed them on how the removal had come about. [Business Insider Japan(2019-06-04)]
- Shareholder meeting: Seto's entire slate elected Attendance was 629 shareholders, more than three times the previous year's. Yamanashi chaired, and counting the votes took about two hours. All eight on Seto's side (including the two shared candidates) were elected, with Seto himself winning 53.7% approval. Six company candidates were elected; Kenichi Fukuhara (44.9%) and Yo Takeuchi (44.4%) were defeated. Seto's camp held 8 of the 14 seats on the new board. [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-25 15:53)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-26)] [日經 Business(2019-07-03)] [Reuters(2019-06-25,Euronews 轉載)]
- Board reelects Seto as CEO after the meeting Seto returned as representative executive officer, president and CEO; company nominee Masatoshi Matsuzaki became chairman of the board and Kazuhiko Otsubo vice president. Seto said he was glad to be back and wanted to turn the company into one team. [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-25 15:53)] [現代 Business(磯山友幸,2019-06-27)]
- Company discloses each candidate's approval rate The extraordinary report showed that the six nominated only by Seto's side won between 50.8% and 64.6% approval, the company candidates who were elected between 51.3% and 57.9%, and the two shared candidates more than 90%. Seto's approval rate the previous year had been 97.5%. [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-26)] [NetIB-News(2019-07-02)]
People
- Kinya Seto (瀬戸欣哉) (Kinya Seto), 1960-06-25 — Director, representative executive officer, president and CEO. Born in Tokyo. Graduated from the University of Tokyo's Faculty of Economics and joined Sumitomo Corporation in 1983; later earned an MBA from Dartmouth's Tuck School of Business. In 2000 he set up the forerunner of tool e-commerce company MonotaRO as an in-house venture, became its president in 2001 and took it public on the First Section of the Tokyo Stock Exchange in 2009. Recruited in 2016 by Yoichiro Ushioda of the founding family to succeed Yoshiaki Fujimori; took office as president and CEO after the June 2016 shareholder meeting. His relationship with Ushioda was originally that of a professional manager hired by the owner. The two disagreed over the role of the holding company, the handling of overseas subsidiaries and the company's direction. On the board, only Keiichiro Ina and Ryuichi Kawamoto, both from INAX, were on his side. Removed as CEO on 2018-10-31; stepped down as president at the end of 2019-03, remaining only a director. At the 2019-06-25 shareholder meeting all eight candidates he proposed were elected, and the board afterward reelected him president and CEO. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [維基百科(日文):瀬戸欣哉] [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-25 15:53)]
- Yoichiro Ushioda (Yoichiro Ushioda), 1953-12-21 — Director, chairman of the board, member of the nomination committee (made himself chairman and CEO after the ouster). Eldest son of Kenjiro Ushioda, founder of Tostem (formerly Toyo Sash). Graduated from the University of Tokyo's Faculty of Economics. Joined the company in 1977 and was a director by 1980; chairman and CEO in 2006; chairman after the 2011 consolidation into LIXIL Group; chairman of the board from 2012. Personally held about 3% of the shares. Second-generation member of the founding family; went straight into his father's company after graduation. Brought in two professional managers as CEO in succession, Yoshiaki Fujimori and Kinya Seto, and replaced both during their tenures. Most members of the nomination committee were outside directors he had recruited. On 2019-04-18 he announced that he would resign as a director on May 20 and as CEO at the June shareholder meeting, and said appointing Seto was the biggest failure of his 38 years as a director. He left management entirely after the 2019-06-25 shareholder meeting. No reliable source could be found on what he did afterward. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [維基百科(日文):潮田洋一郎] [文春 Online(同書節錄,2022-06-24)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-25 15:53)] [Business Insider Japan(2019-06-04)]
- Hirokazu Yamanashi (山梨広一) (Hirokazu Yamanashi), 1954-04-18 — Outside director, chair of the nomination committee (became COO after the ouster; president and COO from 2019-04). Graduated from the University of Tokyo's Faculty of Economics. Joined Fuji Photo Film in 1978 and McKinsey in 1990, becoming a senior partner in 2003. Moved to AEON as senior managing executive officer in 2014; set up his own office after leaving in 2016. Joined LIXIL Group's board as an outside director in June 2016; chair of the nomination committee from June 2017. Recruited to the board by Ushioda. At the nomination committee meeting on 2018-10-26, he said Seto had offered to resign on his own and that the proposed successors were Ushioda and himself. Went from outside director to COO, then became president on 2019-04-01. On 2019-04-18 he said he would not stay on as a director after the shareholder meeting; he stepped down on 2019-06-25 after chairing that meeting. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [Business Insider Japan(2019-03-07)] [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2018-11-04)] [文春 Online(同書節錄,2022-06-24)] [日經 Business(2019-07-03)]
- Keiichiro Ina (伊奈啓一郎) (Keiichiro Ina), 1949-03-24 — Director, member of the compensation committee. From the founding family of INAX (formerly Ina Seito). Joined Ina Seito in 1974 and held a series of director posts; personally owned about 436,000 shares. Joined the holding company's board after the 2001 merger of Tostem and INAX. Representative of the INAX founding family. At the 2018-10-31 board meeting he and Kawamoto opposed Seto's removal. He later joined overseas institutional investors in demanding an extraordinary shareholder meeting, then submitted a shareholder proposal together with Seto. Named on the shareholder proposal's slate; reelected as a director on 2019-06-25. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [文春 Online(同書節錄 2,2022-06-09)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)] [現代 Business(町田徹,2019-05-28)]
- Ryuichi Kawamoto (Ryuichi Kawamoto), 1952-10-08 — Director, representative executive officer and executive vice president. From INAX, where he was the last president; long responsible for technology, quality and manufacturing within the group. Joined the group's management and board after INAX was merged in. Part of the INAX camp along with Ina; opposed Seto's removal at the 2018-10-31 board meeting. Named on the shareholder proposal's slate; reelected as a director on 2019-06-25. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [文春(秋場大輔《決戦!株主総会》節錄 1)] [文春 Online(同書節錄 2,2022-06-09)] [現代 Business(町田徹,2019-05-28)]
- Tsutomu Kawaguchi (Tsutomu Kawaguchi), 1946-09-28 — Outside director, chair of the audit committee. A certified public accountant by background; by 2018 he had been an outside director of LIXIL Group for seven years. Appointed an outside director for his accounting expertise. According to Daisuke Akiba's book, he had promised Seto beforehand that he would raise an objection, but switched to voting in favor after his own future came up during the meeting. At an investor briefing on 2019-03-07 he said the board had long had doubts about Seto's management approach. The company's slate of nominees announced on 2019-05-13 replaced all sitting directors; he was not on it, and his term ended with the close of the 2019-06-25 shareholder meeting. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [文春 Online(同書節錄 2,2022-06-09)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-05-13)]
- Main Kohda (real name Hisako Sawato) (Main Kohda), 1951-04-25 — Outside director, member of the nomination committee. Novelist, writing full time since 1995. Has served on councils of the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism and on the government's Tax Commission; also an outside director of Japan Tobacco and Japan Exchange Group. Appointed an outside director in June 2013. One of the outside directors recruited by Ushioda, and a member of the nomination committee that approved the personnel change; but she left the 2018-10-31 board meeting before the vote. According to the book's account, she handed Seto a business card on which she had written that she hoped he could stay on as CEO a while longer. The company's slate of nominees announced on 2019-05-13 replaced all sitting directors; she was not on it, and her term ended with the close of the 2019-06-25 shareholder meeting. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [FACTA(2018 年 12 月號)] [文春 Online(同書節錄 2,2022-06-09)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-05-13)]
- Barbara Judge (Barbara Judge), 1946-12-28 — Outside director, member of the nomination committee (chair of the nomination committee in 2019). American-born British lawyer. Formerly a commissioner of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, chairman of the UK Atomic Energy Authority and chairman of the UK Pension Protection Fund. In 2015 she became the first woman to chair Britain's Institute of Directors (IoD); she resigned in March 2018. Appointed an outside director around 2015 (three years in office as of 2018). One of the outside directors recruited by Ushioda. The nomination committee approved the change of CEO on 2018-10-26. After Seto was replaced she became chair of the nomination committee, responsible for selecting the company's slate of directors. The company's slate of nominees announced on 2019-05-13 replaced all sitting directors; she was not on it, and her term ended with the close of the 2019-06-25 shareholder meeting. She died on 2020-08-31. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [FACTA(2018 年 12 月號)] [NetIB-News(2019-04-10)] [日經 Business(2019-05-09)] [Wikipedia:Barbara Judge]
- Hiroto Yoshimura (Hiroto Yoshimura), 1948-11-06 — Outside director, member of the nomination committee and the audit committee. Joined the National Police Agency in 1971 and served as its commissioner general from 2007 to 2009; later chairman of the Police Mutual Aid Association. Appointed an outside director in June 2017. One of the outside directors recruited by Ushioda, and a member of the nomination committee that approved the change of CEO. The company's slate of nominees announced on 2019-05-13 replaced all sitting directors; he was not on it, and his term ended with the close of the 2019-06-25 shareholder meeting. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [FACTA(2018 年 12 月號)] [NetIB-News(2019-04-10)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-05-13)]
- Yoshinobu Kikuchi (Yoshinobu Kikuchi), 1945-04-28 — Director, member of the compensation committee (member of the nomination committee in 2019). From Tostem, which he joined in 1969. Long responsible for personnel, general affairs and legal; formerly vice president of Tostem and executive vice president of the group. Promoted from within; a director from June 2012. A Tostem veteran. In 2019 he explained the company's slate publicly on behalf of the nomination committee, arguing that replacing all sitting directors was the best way to return management to normal. The company's slate of nominees announced on 2019-05-13 replaced all sitting directors; he was not on it, and his term ended with the close of the 2019-06-25 shareholder meeting. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [NetIB-News(2019-04-10)] [日經 Business(2019-05-13)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-05-13)]
- Yoshizumi Kanamori (Yoshizumi Kanamori), 1954-01-23 — Director, member of the audit committee. Joined the company in 1977. Long responsible for finance and accounting; formerly group CFO. Promoted from within; a director from 2007. From the Tostem side. The 2018-10-31 vote was 7 in favor and 3 against, with 2 absent; how individual directors voted was not fully disclosed, and his vote could not be found. The company's slate of nominees announced on 2019-05-13 replaced all sitting directors; he was not on it, and his term ended with the close of the 2019-06-25 shareholder meeting. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [日本スチュワードシップ研究会(2019-09-24)] [NetIB-News(2019-04-10)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-05-13)]
- Haruo Shirai (Haruo Shirai), 1952-02-25 — Director, executive vice president. Joined the company in 1974 and spent his career in sales; formerly vice president of LIXIL in charge of domestic sales in Japan. Promoted from within; newly appointed a director in June 2018. From the Tostem side. His individual vote could not be found. The company's slate of nominees announced on 2019-05-13 replaced all sitting directors; he was not on it, and his term ended with the close of the 2019-06-25 shareholder meeting. [LIXIL 第 76 回定時股東會召集通知(2018-05)] [日本スチュワードシップ研究会(2019-09-24)] [NetIB-News(2019-04-10)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-05-13)]
- Kazuhiko Otsubo (大坪一彦) (Kazuhiko Otsubo) — Vice president of operating company LIXIL (promoted to president and COO of the operating company after the ouster). Joined Toyo Sash in 1981; managing director of Tostem in 2009; representative director and vice president of LIXIL in 2018. Promoted from within; in 2019 he was the only inside director candidate on the company's slate. Ushioda promoted him to president of the operating company when he changed CEOs on 2018-10-31; some outside observers believed Ushioda's influence remained behind him. Elected a director as a company-side candidate. After returning, Seto said he was highly capable and someone he could work with, and kept him on as president of the operating company. This is an example of company-side people not being purged. [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2018-11-04)] [日經 Business(2019-05-13)] [現代 Business(磯山友幸,2019-06-27)]
- Masatoshi Matsuzaki (Masatoshi Matsuzaki) — Outside director candidate nominated by the company (chairman of the board of Konica Minolta). Former president of Konica Minolta; chairman of that company's board at the time. Nominated by the company's nomination committee in May 2019. Had no prior ties to either Ushioda or Seto; the company stressed that none of its candidates had close ties to Ushioda. Elected with 52.5% approval and became chairman of the board, paired with Seto as the returning CEO. [Business Insider Japan(2019-06-04)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-26)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-25 15:53)] [現代 Business(磯山友幸,2019-06-27)]
Moves to block a return
- Refused to release the minutes of board and nomination committee meetings to investors, and gave no substantive reply to their letter of questions. [日本スチュワードシップ研究会(2019-09-24)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)]
- Released only an 8-page summary of the investigation report (the original ran to 18 pages), removing the sections on governance problems and concluding that the resolution was "free of defects." [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)] [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口利昭律師,2019-05-29)] [日本スチュワードシップ研究会(2019-09-24)]
- Had outside director Tsutomu Kawaguchi stress at a briefing that there were problems with Seto's management approach. [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)]
- Pushed the extraordinary shareholder meeting to mid-to-late May and delayed announcing a date; as a result, shareholders petitioned the court for permission to convene it themselves. [日經 Business(2019-04-15)]
- Ushioda preemptively announced he would resign as a director and Yamanashi announced he would step down after the shareholder meeting, depriving the extraordinary meeting "to remove the two" of its target. On the same occasion they blamed a 53 billion yen loss on Seto's tenure and called appointing Seto the biggest failure. [文春 Online(同書節錄,2022-06-24)] [文春(同書節錄 4,2022-07-08)] [Reuters(2019-04-23,Yahoo 轉載)] [日經 Business(2019-05-09)]
- Put forward a separate company slate made up mainly of outside directors, excluding Seto himself and six people on his slate and picking off just two of them (without their consent). [日經 Business(2019-05-13)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-05-13)]
- Formally declared its opposition to the shareholder proposal and, in its explanations to investors, framed the conflict as one in which both sides were at fault. [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口利昭律師,2019-05-29)] [Business Insider Japan(2019-06-04)]
- On the day of the shareholder meeting, the company side controlled the venue and the chair; according to Nikkei Business, Seto's side was put at a disadvantage in arrangements such as waiting rooms and seating on the stage. [日經 Business(2019-07-03)]
Rumors
- It was Seto himself who first said he wanted to resign as CEO. [Proven false] Hirokazu Yamanashi's explanation to the nomination committee; Ushioda also insisted afterward that Seto's intention to resign was sincere The investigation report by lawyers retained by the company found that Ushioda's words and actions had led the nomination committee to mistakenly believe Seto intended to resign; Seto says he had merely been conveying that he was not clinging to the post. Ushioda himself denies misleading anyone. [Business Insider Japan(2019-03-07)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-04-12 報告書全文)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-04-12 潮田專訪)]
- Ushioda wanted to take LIXIL private (an MBO), then move its headquarters to Singapore and relist there; Seto opposed this and was replaced as a result. [Still unclear] FACTA, December 2018 issue; followed up by Nikkei Business on 2019-01-21 Both Japanese Wikipedia and NetIB-News list this as one of the reasons Seto was replaced, and Seto reportedly urged Ushioda not to go ahead at the meal on 2018-10-19. But the investigation report omitted that conversation, and no formal acknowledgment by the company or Ushioda could be found. [FACTA(2018 年 12 月號)] [NetIB-News(2019-07-02)] [維基百科(日文):瀬戸欣哉]
- Ushioda himself had already moved his residence to Singapore. [Still unclear] FACTA, citing people involved Only hearsay quoted by the magazine; no confirmation or denial by the person concerned could be found. [FACTA(2018 年 12 月號)]
- Former CEO Yoshiaki Fujimori was an adviser to CVC, the prospective backer of the MBO. [Still unclear] FACTA, citing people involved Only hearsay quoted by the magazine; no corroborating source could be found. [FACTA(2018 年 12 月號)]
- Ushioda announced his resignation as a director in order to prevent the extraordinary shareholder meeting from being held, while keeping his influence behind the scenes. [Still unclear] The reading of Seto's camp and several media outlets Ushioda himself denies it, saying he was taking responsibility for having appointed Seto. The objective result was that investors withdrew their request for an extraordinary shareholder meeting on 2019-05-09. Reuters reported that he had originally intended to stay on as an adviser, while a company spokesperson said he would leave the board and management. [文春 Online(同書節錄,2022-06-24)] [Reuters(2019-04-23,Yahoo 轉載)] [日經 Business(2019-05-09)]
- Ushioda's influence remains behind Kazuhiko Otsubo, who was elected as a company-side candidate. [Still unclear] A view relayed by Gendai Business (Tomoyuki Isoyama) There is no evidence. After returning, Seto said publicly that Otsubo was highly capable and someone he could work with, and kept him on as president of the operating company. [現代 Business(磯山友幸,2019-06-27)]
Views
- Yoichiro Ushioda (new chairman and CEO): He said both Seto and his predecessor Fujimori had done things he himself could not have done and counted as great successes; it was just that the gap between the two men's understanding of the holding company and the operating company was never closed. [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2018-11-04)] [東洋經濟 Online(2018-11-12)]
- Yoichiro Ushioda: He changed his account, saying the change was made because Seto's ability as CEO was too poor. [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)]
- Masanaga Takano (Marathon Asset Management, Tokyo office): He called it an unprecedented and serious governance violation; the company refused to hand over the minutes and gave no substantive answer to the letter of questions. [東洋經濟 Online(2019-03-24)]
- Yoichiro Ushioda: He said that in hindsight the full text should have been released from the start; he insisted that Seto's intention to resign was sincere, that he had misled no one and that the resolution was valid. [東洋經濟 Online(2019-04-12 報告書全文)] [東洋經濟 Online(2019-04-12 潮田專訪)]
- The head of a U.S. pension fund: He described it as Ushioda's "logic" versus shareholders' "ethics." [日經 Business(2019-04-15)]
- An individual LIXIL shareholder: He believed Ushioda, who had brought Seto in, should himself be held accountable too. [日經 Business(2019-04-15)]
- Yoichiro Ushioda: He said that in 38 years as a director, appointing Seto was his biggest failure. [文春 Online(同書節錄,2022-06-24)] [Reuters(2019-04-23,Yahoo 轉載)]
- Kinya Seto: He criticized the company as being in the grip of a "kingmaker" standing on the sidelines who put his own interests ahead of shareholders'; if he could not win this time, he said, it would become a bad example for Japanese corporate governance. [Reuters(2019-04-23,Yahoo 轉載)]
- Keiichiro Ina (director, INAX founding family): He issued a statement saying the press conference showed no reflection on the governance failure and that the objectives had not yet all been achieved. [日經 Business(2019-05-09)]
- Yoshinobu Kikuchi (director, nomination committee member): He said replacing the entire sitting board was the best way to return management to normal, and stressed that no one on the slate had close ties to Ushioda. [日經 Business(2019-05-13)] [日本經濟新聞(2019-05-13)]
- Teruo Suzuki (former deputy chairman of KPMG AZSA): He said the company could not explain why it had nominated him, and that acting this way was deeply insincere. [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2019-05-25)]
- Daisuke Hamaguchi (director candidate on Seto's side): He said that if this sort of thing is allowed to stand in Japan, foreign investors will give up on Japan. [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2019-05-25)]
- Tetsu Machida (economic journalist, Gendai Business): He argued that the lawyers' investigation looked only at procedure and did not examine Seto's management record; the best approach was to put all 16 candidates to shareholders for individual votes, and the ideal leader would in fact be a third party from outside both camps. [現代 Business(町田徹,2019-05-28)]
- Toshiaki Yamaguchi (lawyer): He pointed out that a committee member nominating himself as CEO and the committee chair as COO amounted to awarding themselves the prize; the outside directors' deference to Ushioda ran counter to the very purpose of having a nomination committee. [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口利昭律師,2019-05-29)]
- Kinya Seto: He said it was good to have won a majority, but making the company better was his job, and the real start was only now. [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-25 23:01)]
- Howard Smith (Indus Capital Partners, U.S.): He said they could not stand by and watch governance fail. [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-25 23:01)]
- Yutaka Suzuki (senior researcher, Daiwa Institute of Research): He said this was probably the first time director candidates put forward by shareholders had been approved at a company of this size. [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-25 23:01)]
- A Japanese domestic institutional investor: It said it could not trust company candidates chosen by members over whom Ushioda still had influence. [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-25 23:01)]
- Shareholders attending the meeting: Some hoped the two sides would stop fighting, stabilize management and deliver profits; others questioned whether a company slate made up almost entirely of outside directors could function. [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-25 15:53)]
- ISS (U.S. proxy advisory firm): According to Nikkei, ISS recommended voting for the six on the company's slate who were later elected and against four on Seto's side, including Seto himself—in effect siding with the company. [日本經濟新聞(2019-06-25 23:01)]
- Kunio Ito (specially appointed professor at Hitotsubashi University, lead author of the "Ito Review"): He argued the problem lay in the information provided to the nomination committee, and that outside directors must exercise independent judgment. [日經 Business(2019-07-03)]
- Takashi Mizukoshi (president, Yano Research Institute): He noted that not only overseas investors but some Japanese institutions also voted for the shareholder proposal, and that Seto now bore a heavy responsibility to return management to normal. [矢野經濟研究所(2019-07-05)]
- Akio Ozeki (corporate consultant, J-CAST columnist): He took the opposite view: Ushioda's methods were problematic, but Seto, as a hired professional manager who had already stepped down without a fight, was wrong to come back and contest the post out of personal feeling; the matter should have ended with both men leaving the stage. [J-CAST 會社 Watch(大關曉夫,2019-07-07)]
Photos & videos
The INAX showroom in Ginza, Tokyo, 2006; Keiichiro Ina of INAX's founding family later joined Seto in submitting a shareholder proposal — Lombroso / Public domain
The LIXIL registered head office building (former Tostem headquarters) in Ojima, Koto, Tokyo, October 2011 — Rs1421 / CC BY-SA 3.0
The Kasumigaseki Building (霞が関ビルディング) in Tokyo, 2012; LIXIL Group was headquartered here during the events — Rs1421 / CC BY-SA 3.0
The LIXIL showroom in Akita, August 2012 — 掬茶 / CC BY-SA 3.0The LIXIL showroom at Nanko, Osaka, August 2014 — Tokumeigakarinoaoshima / CC0
LIXIL:GINZA in Kyobashi, Tokyo, November 2014 — 妖精書士 / CC BY-SA 4.0
Permasteelisa's Australian site (photographed in 2023); in April 2019 the company cut its forecast to a loss because of impairments at this Italian subsidiary — Chris.sherlock2 / CC BY-SA 4.0
The SATIS toilet by INAX/LIXIL — Yuutann1123 / CC BY-SA 4.0- Nikkan Kogyo Shimbun: the press conference at which LIXIL announced Kinya Seto as its next president (日刊工業ビデオニュース)
- Nikkei: Seto's full press conference announcing a shareholder proposal and his bid to return as CEO (日本経済新聞)
- TV Tokyo: Yoichiro Ushioda's emergency press conference, full version (テレ東BIZ ダイジェスト)
- Nikkei: Ushioda's full remarks announcing his resignation, much of them criticism of Seto (日本経済新聞)
- TV Tokyo report: former US Assistant Secretary of State Campbell appears on the slate of LIXIL Group director candidates (テレ東BIZ ダイジェスト)
- Nikkei: Seto returns as CEO after the shareholders' meeting; full press conference by the new management team (日本経済新聞)
- Nikkei Business: the LIXIL corporate governance dispute in five minutes (日経ビジネス(Nikkei Business))