Mike Ullman (Myron E. "Mike" Ullman III) — J. C. Penney (department store) (J. C. Penney)
Mike Ullman had been CEO of J.C. Penney since 2004. At the end of 2010 hedge fund manager Bill Ackman (Pershing Square) and Vornado's Steven Roth bought large stakes and joined the board in February 2011; in June of that year the company announced that Apple retail chief Ron Johnson would become CEO. Johnson abolished discounts and coupons and switched to shops-within-a-shop, with the result that revenue in fiscal 2012 fell 25% and the company lost US$985 million. On 2013-04-08 the board replaced Johnson and brought back Ullman. Four months later Ackman wrote publicly demanding that Ullman and chairman Engibous be replaced as soon as possible; the board backed Ullman fully. Ackman resigned as director on 12 August and two weeks later sold his entire stake at a loss; Roth also left in September. Ullman stayed until August 2015, when he handed over to Marvin Ellison.
How they were ousted
After major shareholders Bill Ackman and Steven Roth joined the board in early 2011, the board announced on 2011-06-14 that Apple retail chief Ron Johnson would take over; Ullman handed over the CEO role on 1 November and became executive chairman, gave up the chairmanship too at the end of January 2012, and his term as director also ended in 2012. Publicly it was described as a succession, not a firing.
How they came back
Johnson's overhaul cut annual revenue by a quarter; chairman Thomas Engibous personally phoned him on 2013-04-06 asking him to come back, and on 8 April the board replaced Johnson, with Ullman returning immediately as CEO and rejoining the board.
What happened to the board
Of the 11 directors at the time Ullman returned, the two shareholder directors who had pushed the 2011 change both left within six months: Ackman resigned on 2013-08-12 (about four months after the return) and Roth on 2013-09-13 (about five months); Johnson left office the day Ullman returned. In addition Geraldine Laybourne was not on the 2014 re-election slate (date of departure not found). The other 7, including chairman Engibous, all stayed on — and both the 2011 change and the 2013 recall of Ullman were, by Ackman's own account, unanimous board decisions. So this was not Ullman settling scores with the board; rather, the board majority stood with Ullman and squeezed out the activist shareholder.
Timeline
- Ullman becomes CEO Former Macy's CEO Ullman takes charge of J.C. Penney. (The source gives only December 2004.) [Wikipedia:Myron E. Ullman]
- Ackman and Vornado buy heavily; the company adopts a poison pill Pershing Square and Vornado disclosed a combined stake of about 26% (16.5% and 9.9% respectively according to the 2011 proxy statement), and the company promptly adopted a shareholder rights plan in defence. (The source gives only October 2010.) [Chain Store Age(2013-08-22)] [J.C. Penney 2011 年委託書(SEC)] [HuffPost(2013-08-26)]
- The company agrees to let Ackman and Roth join the board The board announced it would elect the two by 22 February, increasing the number of seats from 11 to 13. They took their seats in February. [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2011-01-24,SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2011 年委託書(SEC)]
- Ron Johnson announced as next CEO The company announced that Johnson, Apple's senior vice president of retail, would take over on 1 November, joining the board first on 1 August; Ullman would then become executive chairman. Johnson spent US$50 million of his own money on warrants for 7.257 million shares at an exercise price of US$29.92. The press release did not mention Ackman. [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2011-06-14,SEC)]
- Johnson takes office; Ullman becomes executive chairman Ullman handed over the CEO post he had held for seven years. [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2011-06-14,SEC)] [CBS News Texas/AP(2012-01-10)]
- The company announces that Ullman will step down as chairman Lead independent director Engibous would become chairman on 28 January. AP said this ended Ullman's last executive tie to the company; the year-end holiday selling season had been weak. [CBS News Texas/AP(2012-01-10)] [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2012-01-10,PR Newswire)]
- Engibous becomes chairman; Ullman leaves The 2014 proxy statement records Ullman's term as director as 2004 to 2012, meaning that at this point he ceased even to be a director. Later that month Johnson presented his transformation vision, and the share price at one point surged 24% to US$43. [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2012-01-10,PR Newswire)] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)] [Wikipedia:Ron Johnson (businessman)]
- Vornado sells about half its stake Roth's company cut its position first, which was seen as a sign of lost confidence in Johnson. (The source gives only March 2013.) [HuffPost(2013-08-26)]
- Ackman: execution has been close to a disaster He said at an investor conference in Boston that the company had changed too much too fast without adequate testing. AP called it the heaviest blow yet to Johnson. [AP(2013-04-08,MPR News 轉載)]
- Engibous phones Ullman to ask him back A company spokesperson said the chairman called Ullman on Saturday to ask him to return. [AP(2013-04-08,MPR News 轉載)]
- Board replaces Johnson; Ullman returns as CEO Announced on Monday evening, effective immediately, with Ullman also rejoining the board. In fiscal 2012 under Johnson revenue fell 25% to US$12.98 billion, with a loss of US$985 million. The share price rose nearly 13% after hours when CNBC first reported Johnson's exit, but once news of Ullman's return came out it fell to as much as 11% below the closing price. [AP(2013-04-08,MPR News 轉載)] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)]
- The board puts CEO succession on the agenda for the first time According to Ackman's letter, this was nearly four months after Ullman's return; only afterwards was a search committee formed and a headhunting firm hired. [CNBC(2013-08-08 17:08 EDT)]
- Ackman's letter comes to light: replace Ullman within 30 to 45 days CNBC obtained his letter to the board. He said he had supported Ullman's return because the chairman had promised to look for a long-term candidate immediately, and proposed former CEO Allen Questrom as chairman. The share price rose as much as 8% intraday. (CNBC's report was timed 17:08 EDT.) [CNBC(2013-08-08 17:08 EDT)]
- The board hits back after the close: Ullman is the right person In a statement on the board's behalf Engibous strongly disagreed, criticised him for giving the letter to the media at the same time, and noted that two years earlier he had led the recruitment of the previous CEO and that his present conduct was both disruptive and counterproductive. [J.C. Penney 董事會聲明(2013-08-08,SEC)] [CNBC(2013-08-08 17:08 EDT)] [The Motley Fool(2013-08-09)]
- Ackman's second letter: the board has broken down He demanded the replacement of Engibous. The same day Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz went to the media of his own accord to defend Ullman, calling the leaking of the letter despicable. The Wall Street Journal reported that Ackman held 17.7% directly, plus a derivative position equivalent to 7.3%. [The Motley Fool(2013-08-09)] [HuffPost(2013-08-09)]
- Ackman resigns as director The resignation took effect the same day; the board elected Ronald Tysoe, former vice chairman of Federated Department Stores, on the same day and said it would add one more director shortly. The company announced on 13 August that the board reaffirmed its strong support for Ullman and Engibous; Ackman said this was the most constructive course for all parties. [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2013-08-13,SEC)]
- The company adopts a one-year poison pill It would be triggered by anyone acquiring 10% or more of the shares. The company said it was not aimed at any attempt to take control; the holdings of Pershing Square and Vornado under the original agreement were not affected. [Chain Store Age(2013-08-22)]
- Pershing Square sells its entire stake About 39.1 million shares (about 18%) were taken up in a block by Citigroup and resold. Bloomberg reported proceeds of about US$504 million, roughly half the cost. Ackman admitted to investors that retail was not his strong suit. [HuffPost(2013-08-26)] [Bloomberg(2013-08,Star Tribune 轉載)]
- Steven Roth resigns as director Vornado had said only days earlier that it would sell its stake. The company said his departure was not because of any disagreement with the board. [CBS News Texas/AP(2013-09-13)]
- Poison pill threshold lowered to 4.9% and extended to 2017 The company said the purpose was to preserve the tax benefits arising from its losses. [Dallas Morning News(2014-01-28)]
- Marvin Ellison announced as successor Home Depot executive Ellison would first become president on 1 November and take over as CEO on 2015-08-01; Ullman would then become executive chairman for one year. This time the handover went according to plan. [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2014-10-13,SEC)]
- Ullman hands over the CEO post for the second time Two years and four months after his return, Ellison took over. [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2014-10-13,SEC)] [Wikipedia:Myron E. Ullman]
- Ullman retires; Ellison also becomes chairman Carried out under the transition plan announced in 2014. [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2016-07,SEC)]
- Ullman becomes chairman of Starbucks He succeeded Howard Schultz and served until 2021. [Wikipedia:Myron E. Ullman]
- J.C. Penney files for bankruptcy protection The company filed for reorganisation under Chapter 11 of the US Bankruptcy Code, and in December of that year its retail and operating assets were sold to Simon Property and Brookfield. This was four years after Ullman had left. [J.C. Penney Form 8-K(2020,破產相關,CapEdge)] [Retail TouchPoints(2020-12)]
- Ullman dies He died in Colorado, aged 77. [Retail Dive(Ullman 訃聞,2024-08)] [Wikipedia:Myron E. Ullman]
People
- Mike Ullman (Myron E. "Mike" Ullman III), 1946-11-26 — Chairman and CEO (2004–2011); returned as CEO in 2013-04. Born in Youngstown, Ohio; graduated from the University of Cincinnati in 1969 and worked at IBM. Joined Macy's in 1988 and was its CEO from 1992 to 1995; then headed the duty-free group DFS (acquired by LVMH during that time). Hired as chairman and CEO of J.C. Penney in December 2004. Engibous was lead independent director during his tenure and personally phoned him in 2013 to ask him back. After joining the board in 2011 Ackman pushed to find someone to replace him, and in 2013 again publicly demanded his replacement. He was also a Starbucks director, and Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz therefore spoke up for him publicly. After returning he served until handing over to Marvin Ellison on 2015-08-01, then a further year as executive chairman, retiring on 2016-08-01 under the transition plan. Succeeded Schultz as chairman of Starbucks on 2018-06-26 (until 2021). Died on 2024-08-06, aged 77. [Wikipedia:Myron E. Ullman] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)] [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2014-10-13,SEC)] [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2016-07,SEC)] [Retail Dive(Ullman 訃聞,2024-08)]
- Ron Johnson (Ron Johnson), 1958 — CEO (2011-11 to 2013-04), director. Economics at Stanford University, MBA from Harvard Business School. Spent 15 years at Target, rising to vice president of merchandising; joined Apple in 2000 as senior vice president of retail, creating the Apple Store and the Genius Bar. (His Wikipedia article gives the birth year as both 1958 and 1959; the company's June 2011 press release says he was 52 and the 2013 proxy statement says 54, consistent with 1958.) On 2011-06-14 the company announced his hiring as next CEO; he joined the board on 1 August and took office on 1 November; he spent US$50 million of his own money on company warrants. Ackman was the main driving force in bringing him in. For his first three months in office he nominally reported to Ullman, then executive chairman. Replaced by the board after about 16 months, leaving the board at the same time. In 2014 he founded the home-service company Enjoy, which filed for bankruptcy in 2022. [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2011-06-14,SEC)] [Wikipedia:Ron Johnson (businessman)] [J.C. Penney 2013 年委託書(SEC)] [AP(2013-04-08,MPR News 轉載)]
- Bill Ackman (William A. (Bill) Ackman), 1966-05-11 — Director, chair of the finance and planning committee; founder of Pershing Square (about 18% stake, largest shareholder). Born in Chappaqua, New York; graduate of Harvard College and Harvard Business School; founded the hedge fund Pershing Square in 2004. Began buying in 2010, at an average cost of about US$22 a share, about 39 million shares in all. On 2011-01-24 the company agreed to let him and Roth join the board; they took their seats in February. Came in together with Roth and joined the board together. The board said he led the effort to recruit Johnson; in April 2013 he supported bringing back Ullman, and in August he publicly demanded that Ullman and Engibous be replaced. Resigned as director after a public rupture with the board (effective 12 August, announced on the 13th). On 26 August he sold all of his roughly 39.1 million shares through Citigroup; the media estimated the loss at about US$470 million to US$500 million. [Wikipedia:Bill Ackman] [J.C. Penney 2011 年委託書(SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2013 年委託書(SEC)] [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2013-08-13,SEC)] [Bloomberg(2013-08,Star Tribune 轉載)] [HuffPost(2013-08-26)]
- Steven Roth (Steven Roth), 1941 — Director; chairman of Vornado Realty Trust (about 9.9% stake). Raised in the Bronx, New York; graduate of Dartmouth College and the Tuck School of Business; founded the real estate investment trust Vornado in 1980. Bought in at the same time as Ackman at the end of 2010; joined the board with him in February 2011. Ackman's investment partner. In March 2013 Vornado had already sold about half its stake. He resigned as director a few days after Vornado told investors it intended to sell its entire stake; the company said this was not because of any disagreement with the company or the board. [Wikipedia:Steven Roth] [J.C. Penney 2011 年委託書(SEC)] [CBS News Texas/AP(2013-09-13)] [HuffPost(2013-08-26)]
- Thomas Engibous (Thomas J. Engibous) — Lead independent director (from 2008); non-executive chairman from 2012-01-28. Retired chairman of Texas Instruments; joined the company in 1976 and was president and CEO from 1996 to 2004; also a director of TSMC. The 2013 proxy statement gives his age as 60. Director from 1999, lead independent director from 2008; succeeded Ullman as chairman on 2012-01-28. Announced Johnson's appointment in 2011 as lead independent director; personally phoned Ullman on 2013-04-06 to ask him back; publicly rebutted Ackman on the board's behalf in August. Besides Ullman, he was the person Ackman demanded be replaced. Continued as chairman after Ackman left, and was still listed as a candidate for re-election in the 2014 proxy statement. When he later stepped down was not checked. [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2012-01-10,PR Newswire)] [CBS News Texas/AP(2012-01-10)] [J.C. Penney 董事會聲明(2013-08-08,SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2013 年委託書(SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)] [AP(2013-04-08,MPR News 轉載)]
- Geraldine Laybourne (Geraldine B. Laybourne) — Independent director. Co-founder and former chairman and CEO of Oxygen Media, earlier president of Nickelodeon. The 2013 proxy statement gives her age as 65. Director from 2009. An ordinary independent director who took no public position. Still on the board in April 2013, but not on the 2014 re-election slate; date and reason for departure not found. [J.C. Penney 2013 年委託書(SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)]
- Kent Foster (Kent B. Foster) — Independent director, chair of the human resources and compensation committee. Retired chairman and CEO of Ingram Micro, former president of GTE. The 2013 proxy statement gives his age as 69. Director from 1998. One of the senior independent directors. Stayed on after Ullman's return and was still listed as a candidate for re-election in the 2014 proxy statement; his later date of departure was not checked. [J.C. Penney 2013 年委託書(SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)]
- Leonard Roberts (Leonard H. Roberts) — Independent director, chair of the audit committee. Retired chairman and CEO of RadioShack, earlier CEO of Shoney's and Arby's. The 2013 proxy statement gives his age as 64. Director from 2002. One of the senior independent directors. Stayed on after Ullman's return and was still listed as a candidate for re-election in the 2014 proxy statement; his later date of departure was not checked. [J.C. Penney 2013 年委託書(SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)]
- Colleen Barrett (Colleen C. Barrett) — Independent director. Former president, COO and corporate secretary of Southwest Airlines. The 2013 proxy statement gives her age as 68. A director since 2004. Joined the board in the same year as Ullman. Stayed on after Ullman's return and was still listed as a candidate for re-election in the 2014 proxy statement; his later date of departure was not checked. [J.C. Penney 2013 年委託書(SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)]
- Javier Teruel (Javier G. Teruel) — Independent director. Retired vice chairman of Colgate-Palmolive. The 2013 proxy statement gives his age as 62. Director from 2008. Joined the board during Ullman's first tenure; took over as chair of the finance and planning committee in 2014 (previously Ackman). Stayed on after Ullman's return and was still listed as a candidate for re-election in the 2014 proxy statement; his later date of departure was not checked. [J.C. Penney 2013 年委託書(SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)]
- Gerald Turner (R. Gerald Turner) — Independent director. President of Southern Methodist University (SMU), former chancellor of the University of Mississippi. The 2013 proxy statement gives his age as 67. Director from 1995, the longest-serving of all. One of the senior independent directors. Stayed on after Ullman's return and was still listed as a candidate for re-election in the 2014 proxy statement; his later date of departure was not checked. [J.C. Penney 2013 年委託書(SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)]
- Mary Beth West (Mary Beth West) — Independent director, chair of the corporate governance committee. Executive vice president and chief category and marketing officer of Mondelez International, previously at Kraft Foods. The 2013 proxy statement gives her age as 50. Director from 2005. Joined the board during Ullman's first tenure. Stayed on after Ullman's return and was still listed as a candidate for re-election in the 2014 proxy statement; his later date of departure was not checked. [J.C. Penney 2013 年委託書(SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)]
- Ronald Tysoe (Ronald W. Tysoe) — New director from 2013-08-12 (filling the seat vacated by Ackman). Vice chairman of Federated Department Stores (now Macy's) for 16 years, also CFO from 1990 to 1997. Elected by the board on the same day Ackman resigned, as part of the terms of the settlement between the two sides. Like Ullman, came from the Macy's/Federated organisation. Listed as a candidate for re-election in the 2014 proxy statement. [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2013-08-13,SEC)] [J.C. Penney 2014 年委託書(SEC)]
Moves to block a return
- Ackman gave his letter to the board to the media at the same time, demanding that a permanent CEO be found to replace Ullman within 30 to 45 days and complaining that the board had taken nearly four months to put succession on the agenda. [CNBC(2013-08-08 17:08 EDT)] [HuffPost(2013-08-09)]
- In the letter Ackman proposed that former CEO Allen Questrom return to replace Engibous as chairman; Questrom said he would be willing only if the situation was not hostile and he agreed with the choice of new CEO. [CNBC(2013-08-08 17:08 EDT)] [The Motley Fool(2013-08-09)]
- Ackman issued another open letter of about 2,500 words, saying the board could no longer function effectively and that important information was not being properly made known to directors, and demanding the replacement of chairman Engibous. [The Motley Fool(2013-08-09)]
Rumors
- Ron Johnson has been replaced. [Later confirmed] CNBC reported it before the company's announcement The company made the formal announcement that evening. [AP(2013-04-08,MPR News 轉載)]
- Ullman is only a transitional interim CEO; the board will soon find someone else, or even take the company private. [Proven false] The expectation of analysts such as Brian Sozzi; many media outlets subsequently called him interim CEO, and Ackman also said the chairman had promised to look for a long-term candidate immediately The company's announcement said throughout only that he was CEO, effective immediately. He served until 2015-08-01, when he handed over as planned, and the company was not taken private. [AP(2013-04-08,MPR News 轉載)] [CNBC(2013-08-08 17:08 EDT)] [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2014-10-13,SEC)]
- J.C. Penney will install its third CEO of the year within 45 days. [Proven false] Ackman's letter and media reports The board reaffirmed its support for Ullman, and Ackman, who had made the demand, resigned himself. [CNBC(2013-08-08 17:08 EDT)] [J.C. Penney 新聞稿(2013-08-13,SEC)]
- Ackman lost more than US$700 million on this investment. [Still unclear] BuzzFeed Estimates differ: Bloomberg said about US$500 million, and there is also a figure of about US$470 million. The difference may come from whether the derivative position is counted; there is no official figure. [HuffPost(2013-08-26)] [Bloomberg(2013-08,Star Tribune 轉載)]
Views
- Bill Ackman (largest shareholder, director): The execution was close to a disaster; the problem was changing too much too fast without adequate testing. [AP(2013-04-08,MPR News 轉載)]
- Thomas Engibous (chairman): The company is fortunate to have Ullman, with his experience and leadership, take over at this critical moment. [AP(2013-04-08,MPR News 轉載)]
- Craig Johnson (consultant, Customer Growth Partners): The company needs stability and adult supervision, but what Ullman did in his previous tenure was only tinkering; what the company needs is major surgery. [AP(2013-04-08,MPR News 轉載)]
- Brian Sozzi (analyst, Belus Capital): He had expected the board to give Johnson until the end of 2013; this removal amounted to a verdict on his strategy. [AP(2013-04-08,MPR News 轉載)]
- Liz Dunn (retail analyst, Macquarie): The company needs a large-scale turnaround, and time is running out. [CNBC(2013-08-08 17:08 EDT)]
- Allen Questrom (former CEO of J.C. Penney): He would consider it only if the terms were right and the situation was not hostile; he also said that in April he had strongly supported bringing back Ullman. [CNBC(2013-08-08 17:08 EDT)]
- Howard Schultz (Starbucks CEO; Ullman was a Starbucks director): For a director to leak a letter to the media is despicable; the main driving force behind bringing in Johnson and jointly devising that strategy was Ackman himself, and now he wants to rewrite history. [HuffPost(2013-08-09)]
- Bill Ackman: He said Schultz did not really understand the facts. [CNN Money(2013-08-14)]
- Bill Ackman: He admitted retail was not his strong suit; he also said outsiders wrongly assumed he could call the shots, when in fact he had only one seat on an 11-member board, and the decisions on Johnson and Ullman were all unanimous. [HuffPost(2013-08-26)]
- An unnamed J.C. Penney executive: Called it the best news of the year. [HuffPost(2013-08-26)]
Photos & videos
Bill Ackman at a US Senate hearing in April 2016; he was the shareholder director who pushed to replace Ullman in 2011 and demanded another change in 2013. — Senate Democrats / CC BY 2.0
Ron Johnson at TechCrunch Disrupt in September 2015; after leaving J.C. Penney he founded Enjoy. — TechCrunch / CC BY 2.0
Former Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz, January 2019; in 2013 he spoke up publicly for Ullman and criticised Ackman. — Gage Skidmore / CC BY-SA 3.0
A J.C. Penney store, April 2014, a year after Ullman returned as CEO. — Loadmaster (David R. Tribble) / CC BY-SA 3.0
The J.C. Penney at Westland Mall in Hialeah, Florida, January 2018. — Phillip Pessar / CC BY 2.0
The J.C. Penney at Dadeland Mall in Miami, August 2022, after the company's bankruptcy reorganisation and change of ownership. — Windows for Noobies2 / CC BY-SA 4.0
Side entrance of the J.C. Penney at Springfield Town Center, Virginia; the land of this shopping centre was bought by Roth's Vornado in November 2010. — Ser Amantio di Nicolao / CC BY-SA 4.0
The home of J.C. Penney's founder in Kemmerer, Wyoming, September 2024; the company started out in this small town in 1902. — Xnatedawgx / CC BY-SA 4.0- Nightly Business Report on Ron Johnson's ouster and Ullman's return (2013-04-08) (Nightly Business Report)
- Bloomberg report: J.C. Penney replaces Ron Johnson, with Myron Ullman taking over (Bloomberg Originals)