Rob Kalin (Rob Kalin) — Etsy (handmade goods marketplace) (Etsy)
Etsy founder Rob Kalin handed the CEO job to former NPR digital chief Maria Thomas in July 2008 and stepped back to become chief creative officer; the other two co-founders left that summer. In December 2009 Thomas departed and he announced his return. But he lasted only about a year and a half: in July 2011 the board replaced him with chief technology officer Chad Dickerson, and Wikipedia says he was fired. This is a counterexample—during and after his return, directors Fred Wilson, Jim Breyer and Caterina Fake all stayed in place, and it was the founder who was out again.
How they were ousted
A half-willing handover: directors Fred Wilson and Jim Breyer wanted him to bring in someone with management experience. He first hired Maria Thomas as COO, then a few months later gave her the CEO job and became chief creative officer himself. He says it was a personal decision.
How they came back
Maria Thomas left the company, and he announced on the blog that he would return as CEO starting in January 2010.
What happened to the board
No reckoning. The three key figures on the board in 2008 all stayed on through his year and a half back, and remained long after sending him off: Caterina Fake did not resign until July 2014; Jim Breyer was still a director at the 2015 IPO; and Fred Wilson, who joined the board in June 2007 and became lead independent director in October 2014, is still listed as chairman today. If anything, the board added a new director, Jonathan Klein, in June 2011, the month before Kalin was replaced.
Timeline
- Etsy founded Kalin, Chris Maguire and Haim Schoppik launched the site under the iospace name; the first version took about two and a half months. [Wikipedia: Etsy]
- Seed round closes; Caterina Fake invests The $615,000 seed round closed, with Flickr co-founder Fake among the participants; Union Square Ventures also invested during this period. [Nature Manipulated(轉述 TheDeal.com 專訪)]
- Fred Wilson joins the board Wilson of Union Square Ventures became an Etsy director. [Etsy S-1(美國證管會)]
- $27 million raised; Jim Breyer joins the board The round was led by Union Square Ventures and Accel, and Accel's Breyer joined the board. [TechCrunch] [Wikipedia: Jim Breyer]
- Maria Thomas becomes COO Wilson and Breyer wanted Kalin to bring in executives with management experience; after a yearlong search, Kalin hired Thomas, the former head of digital at NPR. [Nature Manipulated(轉述 TheDeal.com 專訪)]
- Kalin writes to directors proposing to hand the CEO job to Thomas After returning from a family gathering in North Carolina, he began emailing the directors about a handover. [Nature Manipulated(轉述 TheDeal.com 專訪)]
- Thomas becomes CEO; Kalin becomes chief creative officer Fred Wilson wrote on his blog that day that it had quickly become clear Thomas should run day-to-day operations; the hiring of Chad Dickerson as chief technology officer was announced at the same time. (The Kalin blog post cited by Wikipedia is dated July 9; the two do not match.) [AVC(Fred Wilson 部落格)] [Wikipedia: Etsy]
- Co-founder Maguire posts a farewell Chris Maguire said goodbye in a post on the Etsy blog; both he and Haim Schoppik left the company in August. [Wikipedia: Etsy]
- Chad Dickerson starts as chief technology officer Dickerson left Yahoo to join Etsy. [Wikipedia: Etsy] [Nature Manipulated(轉述 TheDeal.com 專訪)]
- Kalin announces his return as CEO TechCrunch reported (published at 12:40 Pacific time) that Kalin had announced on the blog that he would return as CEO starting in January 2010 and that Thomas would be leaving. He disclosed for the first time that the company was profitable, with sales on the site approaching $200 million for the year. [TechCrunch]
- Reason for Thomas's departure unclear Current, the public media trade publication, reported that Thomas would leave the following month and stated that the reason was unclear. [Current]
- Kalin formally returns He told TechCrunch he would remain CEO for as long as that was good for Etsy. [TechCrunch]
- Getty Images CEO Jonathan Klein joins the board The new director joined the month before Kalin was replaced. [Etsy S-1(美國證管會)]
- Kalin out again; Dickerson becomes CEO The company announced that chief technology officer Chad Dickerson would take over. Wilson posted the same day that Kalin had just finished a product roadmap and was once again stepping back from day-to-day management; Wikipedia says flatly that Kalin was fired. [VentureBeat] [AVC(Fred Wilson 部落格)] [Wikipedia: Etsy]
- Dickerson joins the board The new CEO was given a board seat. [Etsy S-1(美國證管會)]
- Caterina Fake resigns from the board A director since 2006, she left the year before the IPO. [Etsy S-1(美國證管會)] [Wikipedia: Caterina Fake]
- Dickerson becomes chairman; Wilson becomes lead independent director The board's division of roles ahead of the IPO was settled. [Etsy S-1(美國證管會)]
- Etsy lists on the Nasdaq It raised $237 million. The prospectus listed five directors—Dickerson, Breyer, Michele Burns, Klein and Wilson—and not founder Kalin. [Wikipedia: Etsy] [Etsy S-1(美國證管會)]
- Dickerson is replaced too After a first-quarter loss and under shareholder pressure, the board replaced Dickerson with director Josh Silverman and laid off 8% of staff at the same time. [Wikipedia: Etsy]
People
- Rob Kalin (Rob Kalin) — Etsy founder, CEO. In 2005, working with Chris Maguire and Haim Schoppik under the name of a small company, iospace, he built the first version of Etsy in about two and a half months. By his own account he became CEO out of necessity, had no prior management experience, and enjoys woodworking. Company founder. The 2006 seed round brought in Flickr co-founder Caterina Fake and Union Square Ventures. Fred Wilson joined the board in 2007 and was also the person who introduced Maria Thomas to him. In January 2008 Accel's Jim Breyer joined the board with a $27 million funding round. Gave up the CEO job again in July 2011, succeeded by Chad Dickerson; Wikipedia's account is that he was fired. No reliable source was found in this research on his role at Etsy or his whereabouts afterward. [Wikipedia: Etsy] [Nature Manipulated(轉述 TheDeal.com 專訪)] [VentureBeat]
- Fred Wilson (Fred Wilson), 1961-08-20 — Co-founder of Union Square Ventures, Etsy director. Bachelor's degree in mechanical engineering from MIT, MBA from Wharton. At Euclid Partners from 1987 to 1996; co-founded Flatiron Partners in 1996 and founded Union Square Ventures with Brad Burnham in 2004. Union Square Ventures was an early investor in Etsy; he joined the board in June 2007. Together with Jim Breyer, he asked Kalin to bring in executives with management experience, and he was the one who introduced Maria Thomas to Kalin. On both occasions when the CEO changed, he publicly praised Kalin on his blog as the creator of Etsy. Has stayed on the board throughout: lead independent director from October 2014, and currently listed by Wikipedia as Etsy's chairman. [Wikipedia: Fred Wilson] [Etsy S-1(美國證管會)] [Wikipedia: Etsy]
- Jim Breyer (Jim Breyer), 1961-07-26 — Partner at Accel Partners, Etsy director. Born in 1961 in New Haven, Connecticut. Bachelor's degree from Stanford, MBA from Harvard; worked at McKinsey, joined Accel in 1987 and became managing partner in 1995. Founded Breyer Capital in 2006. Has served on the boards of Facebook and Walmart. Joined the board in January 2008 when Etsy raised $27 million. Came to know Kalin as an investor; together with Fred Wilson, pushed Kalin to bring in seasoned managers. Stayed on during Kalin's return and after 2011; the prospectus for the 2015 IPO still listed him as a director. Wikipedia says he later left the board; the date of his departure was not found in this research. [Wikipedia: Jim Breyer] [Etsy S-1(美國證管會)] [TechCrunch]
- Caterina Fake (Caterina Fake), 1969-06-13 — Co-founder of Flickr, Etsy director (Wikipedia says she once served as chairman). Born in Pittsburgh in 1969; graduated from Vassar College with a degree in English. Co-founded Ludicorp in 2002, launched Flickr in 2004 and sold it to Yahoo in 2005; co-founded Hunch with Chris Dixon in 2007. Took part in Etsy's $615,000 seed round in June 2006 and became a director that year. An early angel investor in Kalin. According to an interview on TheDeal.com, she once sent Kalin Jack Welch's autobiography. No public record of her position in either CEO change was found in this research. On the board through both Kalin's return and his second departure; she did not resign until July 2014, three years after Kalin was out. [Wikipedia: Caterina Fake] [Etsy S-1(美國證管會)] [Nature Manipulated(轉述 TheDeal.com 專訪)]
- Maria Thomas (Maria Thomas) — Etsy CEO from July 2008 to the end of 2009. Ran NPR's digital business for six years; before that spent three years at Amazon. Fred Wilson had introduced her to Kalin more than a year earlier. She became COO in May 2008 and was promoted to CEO in July. Someone Kalin spent a year finding himself; he says that after watching her for a few months he concluded she was better suited than he was to run the company. Announced her departure in December 2009; no reason was given publicly. Kalin said the company went from losses to profit on her watch. [Current] [Nature Manipulated(轉述 TheDeal.com 專訪)]
- Chad Dickerson (Chad Dickerson) — Etsy chief technology officer; became CEO in July 2011. Held technology leadership roles at InfoWorld and then Yahoo; left Yahoo in September 2008 to join Etsy as chief technology officer. Kalin hired him to run engineering during the 2008 reorganization. He joined the board in September 2011 and became chairman in October 2014. He was Kalin's own hire, and on taking over he publicly thanked Kalin for hiring him. Fred Wilson praised him for turning Etsy's engineering team into the most sought-after place to work in New York. Replaced by the board in May 2017 after the company swung to a loss and shareholders applied pressure; director Josh Silverman took over, and 8% of staff were laid off at the same time. [Etsy S-1(美國證管會)] [Wikipedia: Etsy] [VentureBeat]
- Chris Maguire (Chris Maguire) — Etsy co-founder (engineering). Wrote the first version of Etsy with Haim Schoppik and in 2006 rewrote nearly the entire service. Co-founder; formed iospace with Kalin and Schoppik. Kalin's startup partner. Left the company with Schoppik in August 2008, the month after Kalin gave up the CEO job. [Wikipedia: Etsy] [AVC(Fred Wilson 部落格)]
Moves to block a return
- A year and a half after his return, the company announced that chief technology officer Chad Dickerson would take over as CEO. Fred Wilson wrote on his blog that the job of management and the board is to have the right people in the right seats at the right time. No record was found in this research of the board trying to block his return in 2009. [AVC(Fred Wilson 部落格)] [VentureBeat]
Rumors
- Kalin was forced by the venture capital directors to give up the CEO job in 2008. [Still unclear] Speculation in the seller community and the tech press; TheDeal.com put the question to him directly in an interview. Kalin said it was entirely a personal decision; but the same article also states that Wilson and Breyer did ask him to bring in someone with more management experience, which is how Thomas came to be hired. [Nature Manipulated(轉述 TheDeal.com 專訪)]
- Thomas was brought in only as the "adult supervision," to keep watch until the young Kalin learned how to be a CEO. [Still unclear] Speculation by a TechCrunch writer, relayed by Current. Purely media speculation; neither the company nor those involved confirmed it. Why Thomas left was never explained publicly either. [TechCrunch] [Current]
- Kalin did not hand over voluntarily in 2011; he was fired by the board. [Still unclear] The line from the company and Fred Wilson at the time was that he was "stepping back again"; later accounts (Wikipedia's Etsy entry) say outright that he was fired. This research turned up only Wikipedia's account and the company's line that day, and no report in which Kalin or a director confirmed it firsthand, so no conclusion is drawn. [Wikipedia: Etsy] [AVC(Fred Wilson 部落格)]
Views
- Fred Wilson (director, Union Square Ventures): He said it had quickly become clear that Thomas should run day-to-day operations, and that the chief creative officer role seemed tailor-made for Kalin. [AVC(Fred Wilson 部落格)]
- Rob Kalin himself: He said he had become CEO out of necessity, that the process management the company needed did not suit his temperament, and that he had concluded Thomas was better suited than he was. [Nature Manipulated(轉述 TheDeal.com 專訪)]
- Etsy sellers (blog comments): Some sellers praised him for putting the company's interests ahead of his own; others hoped Thomas would raise Etsy's profile. [Nature Manipulated]
- Erick Schonfeld (TechCrunch writer): He argued that Kalin had a long-term commitment to the company, which had just turned profitable, making this a good time to hand the CEO job back to him. [TechCrunch]
- Fred Wilson (director, Union Square Ventures): He said no one cares about the company more than Kalin and Etsy will always be his creation, but the duty of management and the board is to have the right people in the right seats at the right time. [AVC(Fred Wilson 部落格)]
- Chad Dickerson (new CEO): He thanked Kalin for hiring him early on, said he owed Kalin a great debt, and said his aim now was to make the company more efficient and bolder about taking risks. [VentureBeat]
Photos & videos
Early investor Caterina Fake, photographed in July 2008, the month Kalin first handed over the CEO job. — Joi / CC BY 2.0
Etsy's then headquarters in Brooklyn, New York (the clock tower), photographed in September 2008, shortly after Maria Thomas took over as CEO. — Jared Tarbell / CC BY 2.0
Engineers and customer support staff in the Etsy office, photographed in July 2010, during Kalin's return as CEO. — Charles & Hudson / CC BY-SA 2.0
A lighting installation in the Etsy office, photographed in July 2010. — Charles & Hudson / CC BY-SA 2.0
Etsy Labs, the community workspace in the Etsy office, photographed in January 2011, six months before Kalin was out again. — Jenn Vargas / CC BY-SA 2.0
Chad Dickerson, the CEO who replaced Kalin, speaking at the XOXO Festival in Portland, September 2012. — Zack Sheppard / CC BY-SA 2.0
Josh Silverman, the CEO who replaced Dickerson in 2017, on stage at Web Summit 2024 in Lisbon. — Web Summit / CC BY 2.0
Etsy's current headquarters building in Brooklyn, photographed in December 2024. — Bylan2 / CC BY-SA 4.0- The Deal interviews Etsy founder and CEO Rob Kalin about how Etsy raised its funding. (TheDealVideo)
- TechCrunch interviews Etsy founder Rob Kalin, who by then had handed over the CEO job and become chief creative officer. (TechCrunch)
- IdeasLab at the World Economic Forum Annual Meeting 2009 in Davos: Rob Kalin presents on stage. (World Economic Forum)
- Chad Dickerson, who took over as CEO, talks about Etsy at XOXO Festival 2012. (XOXO Festival)
- Bloomberg report: Etsy prepares to go public, drawing a backlash from handmade sellers. (Bloomberg Originals)
- CNBC interviews Etsy's new CEO Josh Silverman about the changes he has pushed since taking over. (CNBC)