William Durant (Billy Durant) (William C. Durant) — General Motors (General Motors)
Durant founded General Motors in 1908 and bought more than twenty companies within two years; in 1910 the money ran out and the banking syndicate sidelined him by means of a five-year voting trust. He turned around and founded Chevrolet, made money on the Model 490, then enlisted the du Pont family and the banker Kaufman as backers, bought his way back into GM around the time the trust expired in October 1915, and became president again in June 1916. The three key figures on the bankers' side — Storrow, Nash and Neal — all left around the time of his return, and Storrow and Nash went on to found Nash Motors. But the du Ponts, who helped him come back, also became the new major shareholder: when the stock market slumped in 1920, his attempt to prop up the share price on margin failed and left him owing more than US$20 million; du Pont and Morgan put up the money to clean up, and the condition was again that he go. On 1920-11-30 he left for the second and final time.
How they were ousted
In 1910 the company ran short of cash, and a banking syndicate led by Lee, Higginson and J. & W. Seligman lent money to rescue it, on condition that the shares be placed in a five-year voting trust (the bankers held four of the five trustee seats); he stayed on as vice president and director but gave up management control (stripped of power, not fired; the exact month and day could not be confirmed from the sources consulted).
How they came back
He founded Chevrolet in 1911; in 1915, together with the banker Kaufman and the du Pont family, he bought GM stock and exchanged five Chevrolet shares for one GM share; on 1915-09-16 the board was reorganized with six seats for each side, in May 1916 he obtained a majority of the votes, and on June 1 Nash resigned and he became president again.
What happened to the board
The management core left behind by the 1910 banking syndicate all departed after his return: chairman Thomas Neal served until 1915-11-16 according to Wikipedia and was replaced by Pierre du Pont; president Charles Nash resigned on 1916-06-01; James Storrow, who had led the 1910 trust, left on 1916-06-04. None of the three was ruined — Storrow and Nash promptly co-founded Nash Motors, and Neal moved on to a truck company and a trust company. The only one he kept on, at a high salary, was Walter Chrysler, whom Storrow had brought in (he still left in 1919 after falling out with Durant). Two points should be noted: the individual names and fates of the six directors appointed by the bankers' side in September 1915 could not be found in the sources consulted; and this "purge" lasted only four and a half years, with du Pont and Morgan showing him the door in 1920.
Timeline
- Durant takes over Buick He used the capital and production capacity of the Durant-Dort Carriage Company to turn around the loss-making Buick, and took more than a thousand orders at the 1905 New York auto show alone. [Wikipedia: William C. Durant]
- General Motors founded Set up as a holding company, it bought Buick the next day; on November 12 it bought Olds Motor Works. [Wikipedia: William C. Durant] [Wikipedia: General Motors] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
- Cadillac, Oakland and others bought within a year In 1909 he bought Cadillac (US$4.5 million), Oakland, Cartercar, Elmore and two truck makers; he also bought the Heany Lamp Company with US$7 million of GM stock, later regarded as a major mistake. [Wikipedia: William C. Durant] [Wikipedia: History of General Motors] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)]
- US$8 million deal to buy Ford falls through Durant had agreed to buy Ford for US$8 million, but the banks refused to lend him the US$2 million down payment. [Wikipedia: General Motors] [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)]
- Cash runs out, banking syndicate steps in The economy turned down, cars were not selling, and Durant could not meet payroll. The First National Bank of Boston, which Buick owed US$7 million, brought in a banking syndicate: the company received US$12.75 million in cash, issued US$15 million of five-year notes at 6% annual interest, and gave the banks more than US$6 million in stock besides. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)] [Detroit Historical Society:General Motors]
- Five-year voting trust set up, Durant stripped of power The syndicate led by Lee, Higginson and J. & W. Seligman required the shares to be placed in trust for five years, with four of the five trustees representing the banks. Durant stayed on as vice president and director but no longer ran the business; Storrow became interim president and later moved to chairman of the finance committee. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)] [Wikipedia: James J. Storrow]
- Storrow appoints Nash vice president of Buick Acting on advice, Storrow promoted Nash, Durant's long-time subordinate, to vice president of Buick. [Wikipedia: Charles W. Nash]
- Thomas Neal becomes president of GM Neal, a Detroit paint manufacturer, succeeded Storrow as president and concentrated production of the five brands in the most efficient plants; the bankers separately cut five unprofitable brands. [Wikipedia: Thomas Neal (industrialist)] [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)]
- Chevrolet Motor Car Company founded Durant and the racing driver Louis Chevrolet co-founded the Chevrolet Motor Car Company in Detroit; the same year he also set up the Little Motor Car Company in Flint. [Wikipedia: Chevrolet] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
- Nash elected president of GM Nash became the fifth president and Neal moved to chairman; Walter Chrysler, introduced by Storrow, took over production at Buick. (Wikipedia's Nash article places Durant being "fired by the board" at the end of 1912, which is inconsistent with the 1910 given by other sources.) [Wikipedia: Thomas Neal (industrialist)] [Wikipedia: Charles W. Nash] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
- GM stock at US$82, Durant's camp starts accumulating shares GM common stock stood at US$82 at the start of the year. Durant, the banker Kaufman and Pierre du Pont bought in successively, the du Pont side putting in about US$27 million, and the share price rose sharply over the year. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
- Chevrolet holding company set up in Delaware Durant set up the Chevrolet Motor Company of Delaware with capital of US$80 million, preparing to exchange Chevrolet stock for GM stock. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
- Boardroom showdown: six against six, plus three neutral seats GM's directors and major shareholders met; Kaufman and du Pont were elected directors, with du Pont as chairman. The new board had six seats nominated by Durant, six for the bankers and three for the du Pont side. American Heritage places the line "Gentlemen, I now control this company" at this meeting. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [American Heritage(John Steele Gordon,1996 年 2/3 月號)] [The Auto Channel(Richard A. Wright 汽車產業百年史第 5 章,1996)]
- Voting trust expires The trust that had bound him for five years expired on this day. The Nation sets the scene of his announcing that he had regained control on this day, but also says the details are probably unreliable. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)]
- Neal steps down as chairman According to Wikipedia's Neal article, his term as chairman ran until this day, when Pierre du Pont succeeded him — two months later than American Heritage's account that du Pont took office on September 16. [Wikipedia: Thomas Neal (industrialist)]
- Chrysler kept with a high salary Chrysler, who was close to the bankers, handed in his resignation. Durant took the first train to Flint and offered US$10,000 a month for three years plus US$500,000 at the end of each year; Chrysler asked him to say it again before he believed it. [Wikipedia: Walter Chrysler] [The Auto Channel(Richard A. Wright 汽車產業百年史第 5 章,1996)]
- Offer of five Chevrolet shares for one GM share closes The share-exchange offer ended on this day, with heavy take-up. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
- Durant holds a majority of the votes By May 1916 he once again controlled a majority of the voting shares; the Chevrolet company became GM's largest shareholder (Wikipedia says Chevrolet held 54.5%). [Wikipedia: Charles W. Nash] [Wikipedia: History of General Motors] [American Heritage(John Steele Gordon,1996 年 2/3 月號)]
- Nash resigns, Durant president again Nash, the president of the bankers' era, left, and Durant became president of GM again after nearly six years. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [Wikipedia: Charles W. Nash]
- Storrow leaves GM Storrow, who had led the 1910 trust, left after Durant regained control. He and Nash bought the Jeffery company and reorganized it as Nash Motors, with Storrow as chairman. [Wikipedia: James J. Storrow] [Wikipedia: Charles W. Nash]
- Reorganized as General Motors Corporation of Delaware On this day GM was reincorporated as General Motors Corporation. Earlier the same year Durant had merged several parts makers into United Motors, bringing in Kettering and Sloan. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [Wikipedia: History of General Motors]
- The Lelands, father and son, resign Cadillac's Henry Leland and his son resigned because Durant refused to convert the body plant to build aircraft engines; six weeks later they founded Lincoln. [The Auto Channel(Richard A. Wright 汽車產業百年史第 5 章,1996)] [Wikipedia: William C. Durant]
- Chevrolet merged into GM The Chevrolet Motor Company was formally merged into GM as a division; the same year GM bought United Motors for about US$44 million. [Wikipedia: Chevrolet] [Wikipedia: General Motors] [Wikipedia: William C. Durant]
- du Pont stake rises to 28.7%, Chrysler leaves The expansion plan needed large amounts of capital, and by 1919 the du Pont side held 28.7% of the common stock. Chrysler left over a dispute about a frame plant in Flint. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [Wikipedia: Walter Chrysler]
- Stock split ten for one, share price US$42 GM common stock was split ten for one at the start of the year and stood at US$42 at the end of March. Automobile stocks then led the market down. [American Heritage(John Steele Gordon,1996 年 2/3 月號)] [Encyclopedia.com: William Crapo Durant]
- Stock underwritten by Morgan sold out GM was raising capital for expansion, and on this day the Morgan side announced that the US$28 million of stock had been fully sold. American Heritage records that the share price kept falling afterwards and Durant went into the market himself to support it. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
- Inventories out of control Internally the aim had been to keep inventories below US$150 million, but they reached US$168 million in April, US$185 million in June and US$209 million in October. At the end of October the share price was down to US$17. [Old Cars Weekly:GM survived 1920] [American Heritage(John Steele Gordon,1996 年 2/3 月號)]
- Deal done in four days: du Pont and Morgan take over The du Pont family was willing to put up as much as US$10 million in securities and Morgan arranged a US$20 million loan to buy out his holdings (The Auto Channel records US$9.50 a share), so that a forced liquidation of his position would not drag GM down. He was left with only about US$3 million in stock. [Old Cars Weekly:GM survived 1920] [The Auto Channel(Richard A. Wright 汽車產業百年史第 5 章,1996)] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
- du Pont and Morgan partners force a showdown The share price was US$14. The two major shareholders demanded that he spell out his own position; he did, and they were shocked: he had bought GM stock heavily on 10% margin and owed more than US$20 million to 21 brokerages and 3 banks. That same day he also had a US$150,000 margin call to meet the next morning. [American Heritage(John Steele Gordon,1996 年 2/3 月號)] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [Old Cars Weekly:GM survived 1920]
- Durant resigns as president for the second time He resigned as president of GM; Sloan recalled that he was smiling as he left. Pierre du Pont succeeded him as president. The next day he went back to the office to clear out his desk drawers. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [Wikipedia: Pierre S. du Pont]
- Durant Motors founded Wikipedia records that Durant Motors was incorporated on January 12 (American Heritage writes January 21); within 48 hours he raised US$7 million from 67 friends. [Wikipedia: Durant Motors] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
- Sloan becomes president of GM du Pont resigned as president and recommended Sloan to succeed him. The Detroit headquarters building, begun during Durant's tenure and originally to be called the Durant Building, was completed this year and was eventually named the General Motors Building. [Wikipedia: Pierre S. du Pont] [Wikipedia: History of General Motors]
- Storrow dies Storrow died at the Plaza Hotel in New York, having remained chairman of Nash Motors until his death. The same year GM's share price reached US$210. [Wikipedia: James J. Storrow] [American Heritage(John Steele Gordon,1996 年 2/3 月號)]
- Durant Motors liquidated After the stock market crash and the Great Depression, Durant Motors went into liquidation in 1933. [Wikipedia: Durant Motors] [Wikipedia: William C. Durant]
- Durant declares bankruptcy His debts were nearly US$1 million; the only assets he declared were US$250 worth of clothing. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [Wikipedia: William C. Durant]
- Durant dies He died in his apartment in New York City and was buried at Woodlawn Cemetery in the Bronx. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [Wikipedia: William C. Durant]
- Nash dies Nash died in Beverly Hills, aged 84. [Wikipedia: Charles W. Nash]
People
- William Durant (William C. Durant), 1861-12-08 — Founder of General Motors; vice president and director after 1910, president again from 1916-06-01. Born in Boston; his maternal grandfather was Michigan governor Henry Crapo. He left high school without finishing to work at his grandfather's lumberyard, co-founded a carriage company with Dort in 1886, and by 1900 it was the largest carriage maker in the United States. He took over the loss-making Buick on 1904-11-01 and by 1908 had made it the best-selling car brand in the United States. Founded General Motors as a holding company on 1908-09-16, bought Buick the next day, and went on to acquire more than twenty companies including Oldsmobile, Cadillac and Oakland. Nash was a worker he hired into the carriage factory in 1890 at one dollar a day; Kaufman and du Pont were the financial backers he brought in in 1915; Sloan came in when he was buying up parts companies. Resigned as president for the second time on 1920-11-30, founded Durant Motors in 1921 (liquidated in 1933), and declared bankruptcy in 1936. In his later years he ran a bowling alley in Flint and lived on a pension arranged by Sloan and others; he died in New York on 1947-03-18. [Wikipedia: William C. Durant] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [Wikipedia: Durant Motors]
- James J. Storrow (James J. Storrow), 1864-01 — Partner at Lee, Higginson & Co.; leader of the 1910 voting trust and interim president of GM, later chairman of the finance committee. Born in Boston, the son of a prominent lawyer. He gave up a legal career to become a partner at the investment bank Lee, Higginson, also served on the Boston City Council, and was active in the Boy Scout movement. In 1910 he led a group of financiers in forming a voting trust that took control of GM out of Durant's hands. Acting on advice, he appointed Nash vice president of Buick on 1910-12-13; and, as a director of the American Locomotive Company (ALCO), he introduced that company's Walter Chrysler to Nash. After Durant regained control of the company, he left GM on 1916-06-04 and promptly became chairman of Nash Motors, a post he held until his death. He died at the Plaza Hotel in New York on 1926-03-13. His firm, Lee, Higginson, collapsed in 1932 over the scandal surrounding the Swedish match king Kreuger. [Wikipedia: James J. Storrow] [Wikipedia: Charles W. Nash] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [Wikipedia: Lee, Higginson & Co.]
- Charles W. Nash (Charles W. Nash), 1864-01-28 — Vice president of Buick (from 1910-12); president of GM from 1912-11-19. Born into a poor farming family in Illinois. In 1890 Durant hired him at one dollar a day to stuff seat cushions at the carriage factory in Flint; within ten years he had risen to vice president and general manager of the Durant-Dort Carriage Company. Durant himself brought him into Buick to run production; after the bankers took over, Storrow appointed him vice president of Buick on 1910-12-13, and in 1912 he became president of GM because he had the confidence of the bankers who controlled the board. A long-time subordinate whom Durant had personally promoted, yet he became the bankers' president. The Nation says GM's net profit under him grew from US$2.47 million in 1910 to more than ten times that in 1915. Resigned on 1916-06-01 (The Auto Channel's account is that he was fired by Durant). After his clash with Durant he resolved never to work for anyone else again, and the same year bought the Thomas B. Jeffery Company and renamed it Nash Motors. He died in Beverly Hills on 1948-06-06, aged 84. [Wikipedia: Charles W. Nash] [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)] [The Auto Channel(Richard A. Wright 汽車產業百年史第 5 章,1996)] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
- Thomas Neal (Thomas Neal), 1858-09-27 — President of GM (1911-01-26 to 1912-11-19), chairman (1912-11-19 to 1915-11-16). Born in Ontario, Canada, he moved to Detroit with his family in 1866. In 1884 he helped found the paint company Acme White Lead & Color Works and served as its chairman for many years. Elected to the board when the financiers took over GM in 1910, he succeeded Storrow as president in January 1911 and during his tenure concentrated production of the five brands in the most efficient plants. He belonged to the financiers' side that came in in 1910; his personal relationship with Durant is not recorded in the sources consulted. According to Wikipedia, he served as chairman until 1915-11-16, was succeeded by Pierre du Pont, and left GM in 1915. In 1916 he became chairman of the executive committee of Signal Motor Truck, and in 1927 he helped found the Equitable Trust of Detroit. He died on 1940-10-06. [Wikipedia: Thomas Neal (industrialist)]
- Walter Chrysler (Walter P. Chrysler), 1875-04-02 — Works manager of Buick, later president of Buick. Born in Kansas, he started as a railroad mechanic and rose to be a manager at the American Locomotive Company (ALCO). Storrow, an ALCO director, asked him whether he had ever thought about building automobiles and arranged for him to meet Nash; Nash brought him in to head production at Buick. He was close to the bankers. After Durant returned he handed in his resignation; Durant personally took the train to Flint to keep him, offering a salary of US$10,000 a month plus US$500,000 at the end of each year (or the equivalent in stock), and he stayed. He disagreed with Durant's ideas about GM's future and left in 1919; Durant paid US$10 million to buy back his shares. He later founded the Chrysler Corporation. He died on 1940-08-18. [Wikipedia: Walter Chrysler] [Wikipedia: James J. Storrow] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [The Auto Channel(Richard A. Wright 汽車產業百年史第 5 章,1996)]
- Louis G. Kaufman (Louis G. Kaufman), 1870-11-13 — President of the Chatham and Phenix bank in New York; GM director. Born in Marquette, Michigan, he started as a bank messenger, became president of the First National Bank of Marquette in 1906, and in 1910 also became president of the Chatham National Bank in New York, growing the bank fiftyfold. Wikipedia records that he joined the GM board in 1910; American Heritage instead writes that he was elected a director together with du Pont at the meeting on 1915-09-16. The two accounts differ. He raised financing for Durant's Chevrolet and for the GM reorganization; The Nation says it was he and Raskob who bought GM stock on the open market, paving the way for Durant's return. He remained on the GM board for 22 years in all, served as chairman of the finance committee, and retired in 1932. He died on 1942-03-10. [Wikipedia: Louis G. Kaufman] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)]
- Pierre S. du Pont (Pierre S. du Pont), 1870-01-15 — President of the DuPont company; GM director and chairman from 1915. Born on the family estate near Wilmington, Delaware, he was president of the DuPont company from 1915 to 1919. DuPont made large profits from munitions in the First World War. In 1915 he was nominated to the board by Durant and became chairman, bringing in three neutral directors at the same time. At first he was the backer behind Durant's return; by 1919 the du Pont side already held 28.7% of GM's common stock. In 1920 he became, in turn, the one who asked Durant to go. He succeeded Durant as president of GM in 1920, handed over to Sloan in 1923, and remained a director until 1928. When Durant left, he personally lent Durant US$500,000. He died on 1954-04-04. [Wikipedia: Pierre S. du Pont] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [The Auto Channel(Richard A. Wright 汽車產業百年史第 5 章,1996)]
- John J. Raskob (John J. Raskob), 1879-03-19 — Financial executive of the DuPont company and assistant to Pierre du Pont; GM director. Born in Lockport, New York. He became assistant treasurer of DuPont in 1911 and treasurer in 1914, and in 1918 was in charge of the finances of both DuPont and GM. He later built the Empire State Building. He bought GM stock on his own account early on and, after being persuaded by Durant, brought about DuPont's investment; in 1915 he joined the board as a neutral director. A driving force behind Durant's return, and also the person who, together with du Pont, put forward the 1920 plan to buy out Durant's shares. He was the architect of DuPont's 43% stake in GM. He served as chairman of the Democratic National Committee from 1928 to 1932. He died on 1950-10-15. [Wikipedia: John J. Raskob] [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)] [The Auto Channel(Richard A. Wright 汽車產業百年史第 5 章,1996)]
- Louis Chevrolet (Louis Chevrolet), 1878-12-25 — Racing driver; co-founder of the Chevrolet Motor Car Company. Born in La Chaux-de-Fonds, Switzerland, he was a racing driver and mechanic. When Durant ran Buick, he hired him to drive Buicks in promotional races. Not a GM man. After Durant was stripped of power, he drew on Chevrolet's racing fame and the two co-founded the Chevrolet Motor Car Company on 1911-11-03. He disagreed with Durant over car design and sold his shares back to Durant (Wikipedia's various articles give 1914 or 1915). Having sold his shares, he did not share in Chevrolet's later success. He died of a heart attack in Detroit on 1941-06-06. [Wikipedia: Louis Chevrolet] [Wikipedia: Chevrolet] [Wikipedia: General Motors]
- Alfred P. Sloan (Alfred P. Sloan Jr.), 1875-05-23 — President of the Hyatt Roller Bearing Company; president of United Motors, later GM vice president of operations. Born in New Haven, Connecticut, he graduated in electrical engineering from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 1895. Durant merged several parts companies into United Motors and asked him to be its president; United Motors was merged into GM in 1918. His view of Durant was deeply mixed: he admired his vision but thought he did not understand accounting and managed too casually. In the summer of 1920 he went abroad on leave, and after returning in August decided to "stay on a while longer and see". He stayed on after Durant left, became president of GM in 1923, and built the company into the world's largest automaker; in later years he also arranged a pension for the bankrupt Durant. He died in 1966. [Wikipedia: Alfred P. Sloan] [Old Cars Weekly:GM survived 1920] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [Wikipedia: William C. Durant]
Moves to block a return
- The banking syndicate tied the loan and control together: US$15 million in five-year notes in exchange for a five-year voting trust, with the bankers holding four of the five trustee seats and Durant only one, barred from any say in management. Until the loan matured, he could not come back. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)]
- A 1937 retrospective in The Nation said president Nash joined the "not very forceful" fight against Durant's return; Wikipedia's entry on Nash says he was caught in the power struggle between Durant and the bankers. The sources consulted give no details of what specific means were used. [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)] [Wikipedia: Charles W. Nash]
- At the board meeting before the trust expired the two sides were deadlocked, and the result was a compromise: six seats nominated by Durant, six by the bankers' side, and three further neutral directors provided by the du Pont side, with Pierre du Pont as chairman. The bankers' side failed to keep him off the board, but did delay his recovery of the presidency by more than eight months. [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [American Heritage(John Steele Gordon,1996 年 2/3 月號)] [The Auto Channel(Richard A. Wright 汽車產業百年史第 5 章,1996)]
- At his second ouster, the company's banks demanded his resignation on the grounds that GM owed the banks about US$80 million and that he personally might face a margin wipeout; du Pont and Raskob put forward a plan to buy out his holdings, and Morgan arranged a US$20 million loan, the price being that he hand over the company. [The Auto Channel(Richard A. Wright 汽車產業百年史第 5 章,1996)] [Old Cars Weekly:GM survived 1920] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
Rumors
- GM's stock was "watered" — Durant bought companies by issuing large amounts of stock, and the book values were not real. [Still unclear] Critics around 1910 (as recalled by The Nation in 1937) The Nation says only that such whispers existed at the time and reaches no verified conclusion; what is certain is that after the bankers took over they cut five unprofitable brands, and the US$7 million in stock paid for the Heany Lamp Company was also regarded as a failed investment. [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
- Durant was "fired" by the GM board at the end of 1912. [Proven false] Wikipedia's article on Charles W. Nash The other sources consulted (American Heritage, The Nation, and the Storrow and Neal articles) all write that he was stripped of management control by the voting trust in 1910 and kept the titles of vice president and director throughout; what happened on 1912-11-19 was Nash's election as president. [Wikipedia: Charles W. Nash] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)] [Wikipedia: Thomas Neal (industrialist)]
- Durant walked into the boardroom and said to the bankers' faces: "Gentlemen, I now control this company." [Still unclear] A story that circulated in the automobile industry; recorded by both The Nation in 1937 and American Heritage in 1973 The two sources do not even agree on the date: American Heritage places it at the meeting of 1915-09-16, while The Nation places it on October 1, the day the trust expired, and The Nation itself says the details are probably unreliable. In reality the outcome that year was a six-against-six compromise board, and he did not return as president until June 1916. [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)] [American Heritage(Niemeyer & Flink〈The General of General Motors〉,1973-08)]
Views
- Charles Nash (the president he replaced): From then on he resolved never to work for anyone again, so he bought a company and became his own boss. [Wikipedia: Charles W. Nash]
- Family: The sources consulted record no comment from his wife Catherine or his children on his two ousters; the only thing found is that in a late-life interview Catherine spoke about the origin of the Chevrolet emblem. [Wikipedia: Chevrolet]
- Durant himself: Speaking of being attacked for buying Cartercar, he asked in return: who knew at the time that friction drive would not become the mainstream? How was he to know what the engineers would say next? [Wikipedia: William C. Durant]
- Walter Chrysler (president of Buick): He disagreed with Durant's ideas about GM's future and preferred to give up a high salary and leave. [Wikipedia: Walter Chrysler]
- Alfred Sloan (GM executive, later president): He said Durant's chances of holding up the share price were like trying to stop Niagara Falls with a hat; he also said he was "of two minds" about him, believing he did not understand sound accounting and was too casual as an administrator. [American Heritage(John Steele Gordon,1996 年 2/3 月號)] [Old Cars Weekly:GM survived 1920]
- Samuel Romer (reporter for The Nation): He found something endearing in Durant, because he came from industry rather than Wall Street and had always looked down on vested interests; he also described Durant after his 1915 return as the "king" and du Pont as the "parliament", with Morgan becoming king only after 1920. [The Nation(Samuel Romer〈Profile of General Motors〉,1937-01-23;VCU 社會福利史計畫轉載)]
- John Steele Gordon (financial history writer, American Heritage): He regards him as the most important figure in American automobile history after Henry Ford; had he done nothing in 1920 and not tried to support the stock, he would have had the largest fortune in the automobile industry after Ford's. [American Heritage(John Steele Gordon,1996 年 2/3 月號)]
Photos & videos
The Durant-Dort Carriage Company office building in Flint (photographed in 1977). Durant got his start here, and GM also had its offices here when it was founded in 1908. — Ralph J Christian / Public domain
The Buick factory in Flint in 1907 — three years after Durant took over, and the year before he founded GM. — 作者不詳 / Public domain
Durant in 1909 talking with Hinz, president of the Lowell Automobile Club of Massachusetts, as published in the Los Angeles Herald. He was then in the middle of a frenzy of acquisitions; the following year the banking syndicate stripped him of power. — 作者不詳 / Public domain
James J. Storrow, partner at Lee, Higginson, around 1910; that year he led the voting trust that took GM over from Durant. — 作者不詳 / Public domain
The racing driver Louis Chevrolet in 1911; after being stripped of power, Durant used his name to found Chevrolet. — 作者不詳 / Public domain
A 1917 Chevrolet 490 (photographed in 2024 at a vintage car show in Wisconsin). It was this car that made Durant his money, and he then used Chevrolet stock to win back GM. — Michael Barera / CC BY-SA 4.0
Durant around 1916 — on June 1 of that year he became president of GM again. — 作者不詳 / Public domain
Pierre S. du Pont around 1910. In 1915 he became chairman of GM and helped Durant return; in 1920 he succeeded Durant as president. — 作者不詳 / Public domain
John J. Raskob (photo by Harris & Ewing, date unknown): the financial executive who brought about DuPont's investment in GM and in 1920 put forward the plan to buy out Durant's shares. — Harris & Ewing, photographer. / Public domain
The General Motors Building in Detroit (photographed in 1981 for the Historic American Buildings Survey). Construction began in 1919 during Durant's tenure and it was originally to be called the Durant Building; by the time it was completed he was out. — Historic American Buildings Survey / Public domain
A Durant Motors stock certificate, issued 1925-03-06. He founded this company after leaving GM; it was liquidated in 1933. — 作者不詳(掃描:EDHAC e.V.) / Public domain
Durant and his wife Catherine in 1926 (photo by Bain News Service). At this time he was a big Wall Street speculator. — George Grantham Bain Collection / Public domain
Alfred P. Sloan in 1922 (photo by Pirie MacDonald); the following year he became president of GM, and in later years he arranged a pension for the bankrupt Durant. — Pirie MacDonald / Public domain
Durant's family mausoleum at Woodlawn Cemetery in the Bronx, New York (photographed in 2008). — Anthony22 (talk) / CC BY-SA 3.0- "Story Stones" lecture at the Sloan Museum of Discovery in Flint: Kevin Kerbitz speaks from a GM executive's perspective about the automotive heritage of Flint (the city where Durant got his start). (SloanMuseumofDiscovery)