Roy E. Disney (Roy E. Disney) — The Walt Disney Company (The Walt Disney Company)
On 30 November 2003 Roy E. Disney, nephew of Walt Disney, was told he would not be renominated because of the age rule; he resigned as director and publicly demanded that chairman and CEO Michael Eisner step down. His ally Stanley Gold followed the next day, and the two launched the Save Disney campaign. At the shareholders' meeting on 3 March 2004 about 43% of votes did not support Eisner, and that night the board stripped him of the chairmanship. Eisner first announced in September 2004 that he would retire in 2006, then in March 2005 moved it a year earlier, with Bob Iger to succeed him. Roy and Gold, dissatisfied with the selection process, sued; on 8 July 2005 they settled: Roy came back as director emeritus and consultant, but without a vote, and promised not to launch another proxy fight for five years. Eisner left the company on 30 September 2005.
How they were ousted
Stripped of power and forced out: the nominating and governance committee declined to renominate him as director on the grounds that he was past the retirement age of 72, and he resigned in anger as director and as chairman of the animation division.
How they came back
First used a roughly 43% no-confidence vote at the shareholders' meeting to force Eisner to give up the chairmanship and step down early, then settled with new CEO Iger on condition of withdrawing his lawsuit, returning to the company as a non-voting director emeritus and consultant.
What happened to the board
Eisner, the prime target Roy wanted to drive out, lost the chairmanship under shareholder pressure on 2004-03-03 and resigned as both CEO and director on 2005-09-30, less than two years in all. But the board that actually decided not to renominate Roy faced no reckoning: Mitchell was instead promoted to chairman and served out his term to the end of 2006, and independent directors such as Bryson and Estrin stayed on for years (Estrin until 2014). What Roy got on his return was a non-voting emeritus title, and he signed a clause barring him from challenging the board for five years; Gold did not return to the board.
Timeline
- Roy E. Disney resigns as director and chairman of the animation division; open letter demands Eisner step down The nominating and governance committee decided not to renominate him on the grounds that he was past the director retirement age of 72; he resigned first and sent a three-page letter saying bluntly that after nineteen years at the helm Eisner was no longer the best person for the job, and that it was Eisner who should leave. The letter was first reported by The Wall Street Journal. [NBC News(2003-12-01)] [Wikipedia(Roy E. Disney)]
- Presiding director Mitchell issues a statement: the age rule was adopted unanimously by the board George Mitchell expressed regret, confirmed that the committee had told Roy the age rule should apply, and said Roy was using the occasion to revive criticisms the board had previously rejected. Also not renominated on age grounds in the same round were Raymond Watson, 76, and Thomas Murphy, 77. [NBC News(2003-12-01)]
- Stanley Gold follows by resigning as director Gold sent a resignation letter to the board effective immediately, seconding the demand to replace Eisner, criticising the board as having become a rubber stamp, and arguing that the age rule applied only to non-management directors, that Roy had always been treated as a management director, and that the committee's explanation did not hold up. The board had been due to meet in New York that Monday and Tuesday to discuss the director slate. [Stanley Gold 辭職信全文(NYU Stern 存檔)] [NBC News(2003-12-01)]
- Comcast makes a hostile takeover bid for Disney Cable operator Comcast made an all-stock acquisition proposal then worth about US$54 billion. Disney's board rejected it as too low. Roy and Gold blamed management for the company having become a takeover target. [Deseret News(2004-04-28)] [AP(Lawrence Journal-World 轉載,2004-03-04)]
- Philadelphia shareholders' meeting: about 43% of votes do not support Eisner's re-election as director About three thousand shareholders attended the nearly five-hour meeting at the Pennsylvania Convention Center, where Roy and Gold took the stage and received standing ovations. In the preliminary count 43% of the shares voted withheld support from Eisner (later reports mostly say about 45%), and about 24% from Mitchell. The California Public Employees' Retirement System, CalPERS, withheld its 9.9 million shares and called for Eisner to resign. [WSJ(NYU Stern 存檔,2004-03-04)] [AP(Lawrence Journal-World 轉載,2004-03-04)] [Deseret News(2004-04-28)]
- That night the board strips Eisner of the chairmanship and gives it to Mitchell Late that night the board resolved to separate the roles of chairman and CEO with immediate effect and unanimously elected Mitchell non-executive chairman; Eisner remained CEO, and the board stated its unanimous support for him and the management team. It also again rejected Comcast's reiterated proposal. [AP(Lawrence Journal-World 轉載,2004-03-04)] [WSJ(NYU Stern 存檔,2004-03-04)]
- Eisner on Nightline: he will serve until his contract expires in 2006 That night Eisner told ABC's Nightline that he did not take such a high withhold vote lightly, but intended to serve out his contract to 2006. Gold said splitting the two roles was not enough, that Eisner had to go now, and hinted at possible litigation. [WSJ(NYU Stern 存檔,2004-03-04)] [AP(Lawrence Journal-World 轉載,2004-03-04)]
- After a two-day closed-door meeting the board declares its full support for management The board ended a two-day closed-door meeting and issued a late-night statement expressing full support for the management team, including Eisner and president Iger. [Deseret News(2004-04-28)]
- Comcast withdraws its takeover proposal Comcast CEO Brian Roberts announced he was giving up, saying Disney's management had made clear it had no interest in a merger and that being disciplined means knowing when to walk away. The report also noted that the withhold vote against Eisner at the March shareholders' meeting was 45.3%. [Deseret News(2004-04-28)]
- Eisner writes to the board: he will retire when his contract expires on 2006-09-30 In a letter to the board Eisner said he would step down as CEO when his contract expired, and strongly recommended president Iger as his successor. Greg Taxin of proxy adviser Glass Lewis thought this would ease the pressure on the board; media analysis suggested the move might weaken the force of a competing director slate from Roy and Gold the following year. [AP(CBS News 轉載,2004-09-10)]
- Roy and Gold write to the independent directors: waiting two more years is unacceptable; otherwise a competing slate next year The Wall Street Journal reported that the two had written to the non-employee directors, alleging that Eisner wanted to hold the company hostage for two more years, install Iger and then return as chairman himself; they demanded that an independent search firm be hired immediately and that Eisner leave both as CEO and as director when the search was complete. Gold said that if he was not replaced before the 2005 shareholders' meeting, they would put forward five or six director candidates. Disney declined to comment. [WSJ(NYU Stern 存檔,2004-09-14)]
- Board chooses Iger as next CEO; Eisner to step down a year early at the end of September Disney announced that president Iger would become CEO at the end of September, earlier than the June deadline the board had originally set. Eisner said he would not seek the chairmanship and had originally intended to remain a director until the 2006 shareholders' meeting. Only days earlier Roy and Gold had written to the directors alleging that the board was undermining the CEO search. [The Irish Times(2005-03-14)] [Wikipedia(Bob Iger)]
- Roy and Gold sue Disney and its directors in Delaware The two filed suit in the Delaware Court of Chancery, the defendants including eight directors such as Iger, Eisner, Mitchell and Estrin, arguing that the board's public statements about the CEO search were false and had been used to win re-election at the 2005 shareholders' meeting and to dissuade the two from nominating a competing slate; they sought to have the 2005 director election declared void and held again. [Animation World Network(2005-06)] [AP(Taipei Times 轉載,2005-07-10)]
- Court of Chancery lets the suit proceed and schedules an expedited trial for August Chancellor Chandler denied Disney's motion to dismiss (reported on 7 June), holding that the plaintiffs' allegations, if true — for example that only one outside candidate was interviewed, that Mitchell had told her she was not a serious candidate, and that Eisner was present and influenced the interview — could amount to misleading shareholders. The court made no ruling on the merits. [Animation World Network(2005-06)]
- The two sides settle: Roy returns to Disney as director emeritus and consultant Disney, Roy and Gold issued a joint statement on Friday afternoon: the company would engage Roy as director emeritus (non-voting) and consultant, and the two would withdraw all litigation, express their support for Iger, and promise not to nominate a competing slate of directors or submit shareholder proposals for five years. The statement was reached after Iger met the two several times; Gold obtained no position. [AP(Taipei Times 轉載,2005-07-10)] [MousePlanet] [Wikipedia(Roy E. Disney)]
- SaveDisney.com shuts down A month after the settlement, Roy and Gold closed the SaveDisney.com website they had used to rally shareholders, and the Save Disney campaign formally came to an end. [Wikipedia(Roy E. Disney)]
- Eisner steps down as CEO and resigns as director the same day Eisner ended his 21-year tenure and, rather than remaining a director until the 2006 shareholders' meeting as he had earlier said, resigned as director the same day, ending any formal relationship with the company. Iger became CEO the following day. [History.com] [Wikipedia(Michael Eisner)] [Wikipedia(Bob Iger)]
- Disney announces acquisition of Pixar for US$7.4 billion Less than four months into the job, Iger announced the all-stock acquisition of Pixar; the breakdown of relations with Pixar had been one of the main points of Roy's criticism of Eisner in his 2003 resignation letter. [Wikipedia(Bob Iger)] [NBC News(2003-12-01)]
- Mitchell steps down as chairman, succeeded by John Pepper Mitchell, who took the chairmanship in 2004, served until the end of 2006 and was succeeded by John Pepper Jr. on 2007-01-01. The board leader who had blocked Roy left at the end of his term rather than being driven out. [Wikipedia(George J. Mitchell)]
- Roy E. Disney dies Roy died of stomach cancer in Newport Beach, California, aged 79, still director emeritus. Iger said his commitment to animation was unmatched; reports noted that in his later years he did not attend board meetings and was no longer a major shareholder at his death. [AP(NBC News 轉載,2009-12-16)] [Wikipedia(Roy E. Disney)]
People
- Roy E. Disney (Roy E. Disney), 1930-01-10 — Vice chairman of Disney, chairman of the animation division (Walt Disney Feature Animation) (until 2003-11-30). Born in Los Angeles, only son of co-founder Roy O. Disney and nephew of Walt Disney; graduated from Pomona College in 1951. Worked in the family company from the 1950s as an editor, writer and producer, and joined the board in 1967. Resigned his executive post in 1977 over differences in management philosophy, and resigned as director in 1984 to launch a shake-up. A family member who started out in film production at the working level; after the successful 1984 shake-up he returned to the board, became vice chairman and took charge of the animation division. In 1984, together with Stanley Gold, he brought about the installation of Michael Eisner and Frank Wells; Gold was CEO of his private investment company Shamrock Holdings and his ally of many years. Twenty years later the two turned around and demanded that Eisner step down. Resigned as director and chairman of the animation division on 2003-11-30; after the settlement of 2005-07-08 he returned to the company as a non-voting director emeritus and consultant, but did not attend board meetings. Died of stomach cancer on 2009-12-16, aged 79, still director emeritus at his death. [Wikipedia(Roy E. Disney)] [NBC News(2003-12-01)] [AP(NBC News 轉載,2009-12-16)] [AP(Taipei Times 轉載,2005-07-10)]
- Stanley Gold (Stanley Gold), 1942-09-10 — Disney director; president and CEO of Shamrock Holdings. Born in Los Angeles; BA in political science from UCLA, JD from the University of Southern California (1967), with further study at the University of Cambridge. Practised from 1968 at the law firm Gang, Tyre, Ramer & Brown, rising to managing partner; president and CEO of Shamrock Holdings from 1985 to 2013. Served as director in 1984 and took part in replacing Ron Miller and recruiting Eisner; director again from 1987 until 2003. Roy E. Disney's long-time business partner and lawyer, who managed Shamrock Holdings for Roy; the two resigned one after the other and jointly launched the Save Disney campaign. Resigned as director the day after Roy (2003-12-01), his resignation letter criticising the board for having become a shield protecting management from criticism. Obtained no position in the 2005 settlement and went back to running Shamrock; according to Wikipedia he is now chairman of Shamrock's board. [Wikipedia(Stanley Gold)] [Stanley Gold 辭職信全文(NYU Stern 存檔)] [NBC News(2003-12-01)] [MousePlanet]
- Michael Eisner (Michael Eisner), 1942-03-07 — Chairman and CEO of Disney (from 1984). Born in Mount Kisco, New York; graduated in English from Denison University in 1964. Worked at NBC and CBS, was promoted by Barry Diller at ABC, and in 1976 became president and COO of Paramount Pictures. In 1984, with no prospect of succession at Paramount, he was recruited by major shareholder Sid Bass and Roy E. Disney as Disney's chairman and CEO, partnered with Frank Wells. Originally the man Roy and Gold brought in; after Wells died in 1994 the two sides drifted apart, and in his 2003 resignation letter Roy said bluntly that the one who should leave was Eisner. Stripped of the chairmanship after a no-confidence vote of about 43% (about 45% in the final tally) at the 2004-03-03 shareholders' meeting; announced in 2004-09 that he would retire when his contract expired (2006-09), changed on 2005-03-13 to a year earlier; resigned as both CEO and director on 2005-09-30, ending any formal relationship with the company. Has since run The Tornante Company. [Wikipedia(Michael Eisner)] [AP(Lawrence Journal-World 轉載,2004-03-04)] [AP(CBS News 轉載,2004-09-10)] [The Irish Times(2005-03-14)] [History.com]
- George Mitchell (George J. Mitchell), 1933-08-20 — Disney's presiding director; non-executive chairman from 2004-03-03. Born in Waterville, Maine; US senator from Maine from 1980 to 1995 and Senate majority leader from 1989 to 1995. After leaving office he joined a Washington law firm and served as its chairman. Disney director from 1995; presiding director of the board at the time of the events. In his resignation letter Gold singled him out as having been a consultant to the company, with his law firm having received more than US$1 million in legal fees from Disney, and questioned his independence. On 2003-11-30 he issued a statement as presiding director confirming that the committee had told Roy the age rule applied. At the 2004 shareholders' meeting about 24% of votes were withheld from him too, yet that night the board unanimously elected him chairman, and he led the selection of Iger in 2005. He continued as chairman after Roy returned as director emeritus, and was succeeded by John Pepper on 2007-01-01; this entry did not find when he left the board. [Wikipedia(George J. Mitchell)] [NBC News(2003-12-01)] [Stanley Gold 辭職信全文(NYU Stern 存檔)] [AP(Lawrence Journal-World 轉載,2004-03-04)]
- John Bryson (John Bryson), 1943-07-24 — Disney director, chair of the nominating and governance committee; chairman and CEO of Edison International. Born in New York City. Joined Edison International (parent of Southern California Edison) in 1984 and was its CEO from 1990 to 2008. Joined Disney's board as an independent director (this entry did not find the year) and became chair of the nominating and governance committee. The committee he chaired decided not to renominate Roy; in his resignation letter Gold questioned his independence, noting that his spouse was an executive at the Lifetime television network, 50% owned by Disney. Remained a director after the events; this entry did not find the date he left Disney's board. Became US Secretary of Commerce in 2011 (the photograph is his official portrait from that time). Died on 2025-05-13, aged 81. [Wikipedia(John Bryson)] [Stanley Gold 辭職信全文(NYU Stern 存檔)] [NBC News(2003-12-01)]
- Bob Iger (Bob Iger), 1951-02-10 — Disney president and COO, director; CEO from 2005-10-01. Born in New York City; graduated from Ithaca College in 1973. Joined ABC in 1974 and worked his way up, becoming president of ABC Entertainment in 1989 and president and COO of Capital Cities/ABC in 1994. Came over when Disney acquired Capital Cities/ABC; promoted to Disney president and COO on 2000-01-24. Eisner's preferred successor, whom Roy and Gold initially opposed and named as a defendant in their lawsuit; after his selection he met the two several times, brought about the 2005-07 settlement and invited Roy back to company events. Became CEO on 2005-10-01 and announced the acquisition of Pixar on 2006-01-24. Later served as CEO until 2020 and returned in 2022-11; according to Wikipedia, he stepped down as CEO on 2026-03-18, succeeded by Josh D'Amaro, staying on as director and senior adviser until the end of 2026. [Wikipedia(Bob Iger)] [AP(Taipei Times 轉載,2005-07-10)] [The Irish Times(2005-03-14)] [AP(NBC News 轉載,2009-12-16)]
- Judith Estrin (Judith Estrin) — Disney independent director; technology entrepreneur. BS in mathematics and computer science from UCLA, MS in electrical engineering from Stanford (1977), where she took part in early TCP/IP research. Co-founded several networking companies and was Cisco's chief technology officer from 1998 to 2000. Wikipedia gives her birth year only as 1954 or 1955. Disney director from 1998. Named as one of the defendants when Roy and Gold sued the board in 2005-05; like Mitchell and Bryson, one of the independent directors who stayed on through the events. Continued as director after the settlement; according to Wikipedia her term ran until 2014, some fifteen or sixteen years in all. She did not leave because of Roy's return. [Wikipedia(Judith Estrin)] [Animation World Network(2005-06)]
Moves to block a return
- The nominating and governance committee (chaired by John Bryson) decided not to renominate Roy under the director retirement age of 72 newly established in the September 2002 governance reforms; presiding director Mitchell publicly endorsed it. Gold argued that the rule applied only to non-management directors and was a pretext for silencing a critic. [NBC News(2003-12-01)] [Stanley Gold 辭職信全文(NYU Stern 存檔)]
- After about 43% of votes were withheld at the shareholders' meeting, the board only took away Eisner's title of chairman, giving it to Mitchell, while unanimously stating its support for Eisner continuing as CEO; it did not accept Roy and Gold's demand for his "immediate replacement". [AP(Lawrence Journal-World 轉載,2004-03-04)] [WSJ(NYU Stern 存檔,2004-03-04)]
- After a two-day closed-door meeting the board again declared its full support for the management team of Eisner and Iger. [Deseret News(2004-04-28)]
- Three months ahead of its deadline the board chose Iger, Eisner's preferred candidate, rather than the outsider Roy and Gold had demanded; the two subsequently sued, alleging the selection was a sham, which Mitchell denied. [The Irish Times(2005-03-14)] [Animation World Network(2005-06)]
- Under the settlement terms, Roy and Gold promised that for five years (until before the 2011 shareholders' meeting) they would not nominate a competing slate of directors or submit shareholder proposals, and withdrew all litigation; what Roy got in exchange was the non-voting, largely honorary title of director emeritus. [AP(Taipei Times 轉載,2005-07-10)] [MousePlanet]
Rumors
- The age rule was only a pretext; the board's real aim was to drive Roy, who criticised Eisner, off the board. [Still unclear] Stanley Gold's resignation letter (the claim of one party); Andrea Van de Kamp, another critic in the same period, had also not been renominated The company and Mitchell's account is that they acted under a governance rule adopted unanimously by the board, and that two other over-age directors were not renominated in the same round; the matter was never determined by a court or third party. [Stanley Gold 辭職信全文(NYU Stern 存檔)] [NBC News(2003-12-01)]
- Eisner's announcement that he would retire in 2006 was only a stalling tactic; he intended to install Iger and then return as chairman himself. [Proven false] Roy and Gold's letter to the independent directors, as reported by The Wall Street Journal Eisner would not commit himself at the time; but on 2005-03-13 he made clear he would not seek the chairmanship, and on 2005-09-30 he resigned even as a director, and did not return. [WSJ(NYU Stern 存檔,2004-09-14)] [The Irish Times(2005-03-14)] [Wikipedia(Michael Eisner)]
- The CEO search was a show for shareholders: only one outside candidate was interviewed, she was told she was not a serious candidate, and Eisner was present and influenced the interview. [Still unclear] Roy and Gold's complaint The Court of Chancery ruled only that the allegations, if true, could state a claim, and allowed the case to proceed, without finding facts; the case was settled and withdrawn on 2005-07-08. Chairman Mitchell denied that the search was unfair. [Animation World Network(2005-06)] [AP(Taipei Times 轉載,2005-07-10)]
Views
- George Mitchell (Disney's presiding director): Regretted Roy's course of action; believed he was treating the committee's acting under the rules as an opportunity to revive criticisms long since rejected by the board. [NBC News(2003-12-01)]
- Sean Harrigan (president of the CalPERS board, institutional investor): The dissatisfaction in the market was too broad and too deep; after the meeting CalPERS still maintained that Eisner should step down. [AP(Lawrence Journal-World 轉載,2004-03-04)]
- Cheryl Gustitus (spokesperson for proxy adviser ISS): Splitting chairman and CEO deserves credit but is not enough; if the board thinks it is a cure-all, it is mistaken. [AP(Lawrence Journal-World 轉載,2004-03-04)]
- Stanley Gold (former director, Save Disney initiator): Called it the first step in saving the company, but said splitting the roles was not enough and Eisner had to leave immediately. [AP(Lawrence Journal-World 轉載,2004-03-04)] [WSJ(NYU Stern 存檔,2004-03-04)]
- Greg Taxin (proxy adviser Glass Lewis): Believed it would relieve some of the pressure on Disney's board. [AP(CBS News 轉載,2004-09-10)]
- Harold Vogel (head of Vogel Capital Management): The settlement ended a needless distraction that had been diverting management's attention. [AP(Taipei Times 轉載,2005-07-10)]
- Laura Martin (analyst, Soleil-Media Metrics): Praised Iger's ability to build teams, build bridges and mend relationships. [AP(Taipei Times 轉載,2005-07-10)]
- MousePlanet (Disney community media, commentary after the settlement was announced): The title is largely symbolic, and how much influence he can have depends on how much weight the company is willing to give him; Gold got nothing at all. [MousePlanet]
- Stanley Gold (business partner of many years): Described Roy as a modest and courteous gentleman. [AP(NBC News 轉載,2009-12-16)]
Photos & videos
Roy E. Disney in Sweden promoting The Little Mermaid (November 1990), when he was vice chairman and chairman of the animation division. — Towpilot / CC BY-SA 3.0
Roy E. Disney after returning as director emeritus under the settlement (December 2007). — Romina Espinosa / CC BY-SA 3.0
Michael Eisner speaking at The UP Experience in October 2010, after leaving Disney. — Ed Schipul / CC BY-SA 2.0
Bob Iger, who succeeded Eisner (June 2013, Hollywood Walk of Fame ceremony). — Angela George / CC BY-SA 3.0
Stanley Gold, head of Shamrock Holdings and co-initiator of Save Disney. — Stanley Gold / CC BY-SA 4.0
John Bryson's official portrait as US Secretary of Commerce (2011); in 2003 he chaired the nominating and governance committee that decided not to renominate Roy. — United States Department of Commerce / Public domain
The headquarters building at the Disney studio lot in Burbank, California, Team Disney – The Michael D. Eisner Building (2014). — Coolcaesar / CC BY-SA 4.0
The Team Disney headquarters building seen from South Buena Vista Street (2014). — Junkyardsparkle / CC0
The Roy E. Disney Animation Building in Burbank, home of Walt Disney Animation Studios and named after him (2014). — Coolcaesar / CC BY-SA 3.0
George Mitchell (photographed in 2009 as US special envoy for the Middle East); in March 2004 he succeeded Eisner as chairman of Disney. — U.S. Department of State / Public domain- Roy E. Disney looks back on the proud moments and regrets of his career in a Television Academy oral history interview (video posted 2023; year of interview not stated). (FoundationINTERVIEWS)
- Roy E. Disney on bringing the True-Life Adventures nature documentaries to television (Television Academy oral history interview). (FoundationINTERVIEWS)
- Former Disney CEO Michael Eisner on CNBC discussing streaming competition (June 2019). (CNBC Television)