Li Guoqing (Li Guoqing) — Dangdang (Dangdang (E-Commerce China Dangdang Inc.))
Dangdang was founded in 1999 by the married couple Li Guoqing and Yu Yu; it listed on the New York Stock Exchange in 2010 and was taken private and delisted in 2016. Li Guoqing announced his departure on 2019-02-20, filed for divorce the same year, and publicly accused Yu Yu of leading management in driving him out. On 2020-04-26 he led people into the company, took 47 company seals and posted a letter to employees, claiming to have held an extraordinary shareholders' meeting and re-elected the leadership; Dangdang declared the seals void and called the police. On 2020-07-07 he again led people into the company and pried open safes, and was placed in administrative detention for 10 days by police in Chaoyang, Beijing. He then turned to a reading community and selling liquor by livestream; on 2025-06-13 he announced that the two had divorced in 2023 and reached a settlement on the division of property, and publicly wished Dangdang well in continuing to operate "under Yu Yu's leadership" — in effect acknowledging that he would not return.
How they were ousted
Stripped of power, then forced out: by Li Guoqing's own account, early on the morning of 2018-01-15 he received a letter signed by management telling him to no longer take part in the company (he calls it the "palace coup letter"); Dangdang says he has held no position since January 2019. On 2019-02-20 he announced his departure in an open letter, with his wife and co-founder Yu Yu serving as both chairman and CEO.
What happened to the board
After delisting Dangdang was a limited liability company, and according to Dangdang's legal department its articles of association provide for no board of directors, only an executive director, Yu Yu, and a supervisor, Kan Min; so in this case there was no "group of directors" on whom scores could be settled. The boards and senior executive line-ups Li Guoqing twice announced he had formed (2020-04-24, 2020-07-07) never actually took over the company. Yu Yu has remained in office throughout, and in February 2025 was still giving public speeches as founder and executive director; no public reports could be found on whether vice presidents Kan Min and Chen Lijun, who spoke on her side, stayed or left after 2020. The ones punished were instead those who tried to come back: Li Guoqing and three others, 4 people in all, were placed in administrative detention.
Timeline
- Li Guoqing and Yu Yu meet in the US and marry about three months later Li Guoqing, who was in book publishing, met Yu Yu, who was working on Wall Street, on a trip to the US, and they married after about three months of courtship. [維基百科:李國慶(企業家)] [Wikipedia:Peggy Yu]
- Dangdang goes online Dangdang, the online bookstore founded by the couple, began operating; Li Guoqing later said in his open letter that the two started out in Zhongguancun, Beijing, in November 1999. [維基百科:當當網] [澎湃新聞]
- Dangdang lists on the New York Stock Exchange Dangdang became the first Chinese B2C e-commerce company to list in the US, with a market value approaching US$3 billion at its peak. At the listing Li Guoqing held 38.9% and Yu Yu 4.9%. [維基百科:當當網] [澎湃新聞]
- Division of labour between the couple: Yu Yu runs the core business, Li Guoqing the new businesses At the end of 2014 the two agreed that from January 2015 Yu Yu would run Dangdang's original core business, while Li Guoqing would take charge of new businesses such as e-books, film and physical bookstores. Dangdang's side later said he had not been responsible for operations since 2015. [鈦媒體] [每日經濟新聞]
- Privatisation proposed; minority shareholders protest that the offer is too low Yu Yu and Li Guoqing proposed buying out the company and delisting it at an offer of less than half the valuation at listing; minority shareholders set up a website in protest. [Wikipedia:Dangdang] [Wikipedia:Peggy Yu]
- Privatisation completed; delisted from the New York Stock Exchange The shareholders' meeting approved it on 2016-09-12, and Dangdang completed its privatisation at US$6.7 per American depositary share, with a market value of about US$536 million at delisting. According to Dangdang's legal department, the equity agreed at the time was Yu Yu 52.23%, Li Guoqing 22.38%, their son 18.65% and management 6.74%. [維基百科:當當網] [每日經濟新聞(當當法務部聲明)]
- Li Guoqing says he received a "palace coup letter" By his account, at 6:30 that morning he received a letter written by management telling him to no longer take part in the new businesses, though his office and pay would be kept; at 7 that evening he told Yu Yu by WeChat that they were separating, and told the vice presidents to report to Yu Yu instead. This is his one-sided account. [騰訊新聞稜鏡深網(36氪轉載)] [網易科技(IT之家轉載)]
- HNA's Tianhai Investment announces plan to buy Dangdang for RMB 7.5 billion Tianhai Investment announced that it planned to acquire all the equity of two companies, Beijing Dangdang Kewen and Beijing Dangdang Information Technology, through a share issue plus cash at a preliminary price of RMB 7.5 billion. Li Guoqing later said he had originally intended to leave once the company was sold. [36氪] [界面新聞]
- HNA acquisition falls through Tianhai Investment said on 13 September that external conditions had changed and that going ahead involved great uncertainty, and subsequently terminated the acquisition plan. Unable to sell the company, the couple had to go on as shareholders. [36氪] [網易科技(IT之家轉載)]
- Dangdang issues an official statement distancing itself from Li Guoqing After Li Guoqing made controversial remarks, Dangdang publicly said he had left management and decision-making and that he was not permitted to use Dangdang's logo on his personal platforms. [盒飯財經(36氪轉載)] [TechNode]
- Li Guoqing announces his departure from Dangdang in an open letter He said that after his departure Dangdang would end its mom-and-pop style of governance and be led by Yu Yu, and that he would go on to run a book club and paid-knowledge business. Dangdang stated the same day that he had held no position since January 2019 and remained a shareholder, with Yu Yu as chairman and concurrently CEO. [澎湃新聞] [界面新聞]
- Li Guoqing files for divorce in court He said he filed the divorce petition at the end of July (Dangdang's legal department says 2019-07-18); Yu Yu refused on the grounds that the relationship had not broken down. How Dangdang's equity would be divided became from then on the core of the divorce case. [新浪財經] [每日經濟新聞(當當法務部聲明)]
- Interview video released: Li Guoqing smashes a glass on the spot when talking about being driven out The Tencent News interview programme released the episode, in which he said leaving Dangdang was not voluntary and that Yu Yu had led management in forcing him out; at an agitated moment he smashed a glass on the floor. On 12 October he apologised for smashing the glass. [騰訊新聞稜鏡深網(36氪轉載)] [網易科技(IT之家轉載)]
- The couple trade public accusations on social media Late at night Yu Yu posted a rebuttal on WeChat Moments, saying that apart from the "palace coup" nothing he described was true; that evening Li Guoqing posted on Weibo disclosing the progress of the divorce suit, saying that this time he would "fight to the end" over the equity of the domestic company. At noon the next day Dangdang officially confirmed to the media that the screenshots were genuine. [新浪財經] [每日經濟新聞] [澎湃新聞]
- First hearing in the divorce case The case was heard in Beijing, mainly for the exchange of evidence; the point at issue was how to divide Dangdang's equity, and the two sides reached no agreement. [中新網] [每日經濟新聞(當當法務部聲明)]
- Li Guoqing claims to have held an extraordinary shareholders' meeting electing himself chairman By his account, the extraordinary shareholders' meeting that day resolved to establish a five-person board and elect him chairman and general manager, with Yu Yu ceasing to be executive director, legal representative and general manager. His arithmetic was that the couple together held 91.7%, of which half, 45.855%, should be his, plus the two minority-shareholder partnerships, for 53.87% in support. Dangdang said no shareholder had received any notice. [每日經濟新聞] [澎湃新聞] [北京商報(新浪財經轉載)]
- Dangdang declares the seals void and calls the police; hits back in an evening conference call In the afternoon Dangdang issued a solemn statement: 11 company seals and 36 finance seals were void with immediate effect, no document sealed with them while out of its control would be recognised, and the police had been called. In the evening vice president Kan Min held a conference call, saying his shareholders' meeting had been held in private and had no legal effect, and disclosing each party's shareholding. [第一財經] [澎湃新聞] [每日經濟新聞]
- Li Guoqing: taking the seals is only the first step In a voice message to a WeChat group he said taking over the seals was only the first step, to be followed by forming a team, with moving into Dangdang only the third step; he also said he had the minority shareholders' support and his stake was "certainly over 51%". That evening he posted a sealed announcement saying that statements without a seal could not represent the company. [每日經濟新聞] [Sixth Tone]
- Li Guoqing leads people into Dangdang's offices and takes 47 seals The time given in Dangdang's statement is 9:34 a.m. He led several people into the office area, took the company and finance seals, left a handwritten receipt, and posted a "Letter to All Dangdang Employees" at the front desk, all in about 15 minutes. He said those with him were directors, the board secretary, lawyers, a cameraman and security guards; Dangdang said two of them were employees who had just left the company and the others were dressed in black and did not know one another. [澎湃新聞] [每日經濟新聞] [澎湃新聞]
- Li Guoqing denies "seizing" them: there were resolutions and he wrote a receipt He posted on Weibo that he had gone to take over the seals carrying shareholders' meeting and board resolutions, had written a receipt for the previous custodian, and that it took 15 minutes with no scuffle whatsoever. [澎湃新聞] [中國經濟周刊(人民網)]
- Li Guoqing issues a "personnel adjustment" announcement using the seals he took The announcement bore the company seal of Beijing Dangdang Kewen: it appointed Wang Xi, Zhang Wei, Tang Xiaohun and Li Zheng as group vice presidents and Li Xuemei as assistant to the president, reassigned Kan Min as vice president of finance, and arranged for Yu Yu to run the Dangdang charity fund. Dangdang responded that he was staging a farce with seals already reported lost. [澎湃新聞] [鳳凰網科技]
- Police close the case: no unlawful conduct on Li Guoqing's side in the April taking of the seals The media reported that police in Chaoyang, Beijing had closed the case reported as "seizing the company seals", the finding being that there was no unlawful conduct on Li Guoqing's side, which Li Guoqing's side confirmed; Dangdang said it was shocked and applied for administrative reconsideration. This was a step favourable to him and unfavourable to Dangdang. [每日經濟新聞(鳳凰網轉載)] [中國企業家(鳳凰網財經轉載)]
- Second hearing in the divorce case at Beijing's Dongcheng court; no judgment pronounced Both appeared in court, and Yu Yu still did not agree to a divorce; because the division of Dangdang's equity was involved, the court did not rule from the bench. Two days later Li Guoqing issued a statement saying that after an equal split of the equity under the law each side would hold about 45%, that a further 8% of minority shareholders supported him, and proposing that a shareholders' meeting decide. [澎湃新聞] [每日經濟新聞(鳳凰網轉載)]
- Li Guoqing announces a new team: Yao Danqian as acting CEO He announced organisational and personnel changes on Weibo: he himself would serve only as chairman, with Yao Danqian as acting CEO, Chen Lijun as COO, and Li Jian, Zhang Wei, Tang Xiaohun and Li Zheng as vice presidents, and he hoped Yu Yu would cooperate with the handover. [鳳凰網科技《風眼》] [每日經濟新聞]
- After more than ten hours of questioning, Li Guoqing's party is taken from the police station in police vehicles He and the managers and minority shareholders accompanying him were questioned at the Xiangheyuan police station for more than ten hours and driven away in police vehicles at about 10:10 p.m.; people from the reporting side were also taken along. He left a Weibo post dated that evening saying his actions were reasoned and well-founded and that he was willing to bear whatever penalty came. [鳳凰網科技《風眼》] [中新網]
- Second entry into the company: safes pried open, company seals and bank USB keys taken The time given in the police notice is about 7 a.m. Dangdang said he forced his way in with more than twenty people, pried open several safes and took materials, and said security guards were injured; he denied any physical clash, saying he was taking over the company and starting work under shareholders' meeting and board resolutions. Dangdang made the matter public at 9:43 a.m. and called the police. [鳳凰網科技《風眼》] [每日經濟新聞] [中新網]
- Chaoyang police notice: Li Guoqing and three others, 4 in all, placed in administrative detention In the evening the Chaoyang branch of the Beijing Municipal Public Security Bureau announced on its official Weibo: a 55-year-old man surnamed Li (Li Mouqing) had gathered others and disrupted work order at the offices of a company in the Jing'an Centre, Chaoyang District, by means including forcibly opening locks and restricting others' personal freedom; he and three others, 4 people in all, were placed in administrative detention according to law. Dangdang said the detention was for 10 days. At 3:10 that afternoon Yu Yu had gone to the Chaoyang branch, leaving about 20 minutes later. [中新網] [雷帝觸網(36氪轉載)] [中國企業家(鳳凰網財經轉載)]
- Dangdang hopes for a criminal case; Yu Yu issues an open letter Dangdang said it hoped the police would open a criminal case against Li Guoqing and recover the seals, and released surveillance footage of him leading people in prying open the safes. In the evening Yu Yu issued an open letter saying what angered her was Li Guoqing using the Marriage Law as a shield to evade the Company Law and constantly harassing the company, and calling on the public not to smear husband-and-wife entrepreneurship. [中新網] [Yicai Global] [鳳凰網科技]
- Dangdang internal letter leaks: the seals and USB keys taken on 7 July have been recovered The leaked internal letter said the company seals, bank USB keys and other items taken on 7 July had been recovered by the relevant government departments and returned to the company, and that operations were fully restored; The Paper confirmed with a Dangdang source that the letter was genuine. After his release Li Guoqing questioned how it was that the police had issued a decision preserving the evidence by seizing it for 30 days only on 13 July, yet the items were returned to Dangdang the next day. [澎湃新聞] [鳳凰網科技]
- Dangdang sets up a "rights protection department"; legal department says Li Guoqing is only a minority shareholder Dangdang sent two internal letters announcing the creation of an independent company rights protection department, recruiting people with experience in judicial organs, military veterans and security guards, to guard against his coming again once his detention ended. That evening the legal department published a piece saying the business registration showed Yu Yu 64.2%, Li Guoqing 27.51% and management 8.29%, that the articles of association provide for no board of directors, and that his resolutions did not stand in law. [央廣網(鳳凰網財經轉載)] [每日經濟新聞]
- Released at the end of his detention; issues an open letter saying he still intends to take over Dangdang Zaowan Dushu confirmed in the evening that he had been released. He issued an open letter saying he would continue to defend his shareholder rights within the legal framework, and alleging that Dangdang's profit growth had been bought by laying off about 1,300 people; Dangdang responded that the 1,300 layoffs were not factual and that it reserved the right to sue. [雷帝觸網(36氪轉載)] [鳳凰科技(IT之家轉載)]
- Son sues his parents, seeking confirmation that the nominee shareholding is valid At 7:30 p.m. Li Guoqing said on Weibo that he and Yu Yu had been sued by their son, who asked the court to confirm that the agreement under which the two hold Dangdang shares on his behalf is valid. Li Guoqing said he supported his son in defending his rights but suspected that both the evidence and the lawyers had been arranged by Yu Yu, believing this would let Yu Yu first carve off a piece of the joint property and keep control; this is his conjecture. [每日經濟新聞] [中新網] [Caixin Global]
- Dangdang statement: the lawsuit is real, and the three-way equity split is 56:24:20 Dangdang confirmed the son's lawsuit and said Yu Yu and Li Guoqing had a "marital agreement" under which the equity ratio among Yu Yu, Li Guoqing and their son was 56:24:20, with the business registration already changed accordingly. Li Guoqing had earlier said that the domestic company had bought out the offshore company and that there was no such thing as the son holding shares. [中新網]
- Chaoyang court accepts the case: Dangdang claims damages from Li Guoqing and four others Dangdang sued Li Guoqing and four others, five in all, alleging that they had damaged the anti-theft system, security doors and several safes and taken away the company seals, finance seals and so on of several companies, and claiming more than RMB 100,000. The jurisdictional objection raised by the defendants was rejected in December 2020; no public reports could be found on the judgment. [IT之家]
- Li Guoqing's first livestream selling session on Douyin He listed 39 products, 24 of them in the books and entertainment category, with sales of about RMB 615,800. In July of the same year he formed a livestream team and switched to baijiu as the mainstay, under the slogan "Lao Li's Selection". [派代網(投資界轉載)]
- Shows off the Dangdang seals hanging at his waistband during a livestream He said in the livestream that he felt uneasy leaving the seals anywhere, so he kept them all hidden on his belt, and showed them on the spot. A year and a half on, the seals he took had become a talking point in his livestream room, but Dangdang had long since declared them void. [IT之家] [派代網(投資界轉載)]
- The two dissolve their marriage The divorce Li Guoqing filed for in 2019 was not resolved until 2023; he revealed on a television programme in December 2023 that he was already divorced. How the property (including the Dangdang equity) would be divided was not yet settled at the time. [界面新聞] [澎湃號(斑馬消費)]
- Yu Yu gives a public speech as Dangdang's founder and executive director At the 25th annual meeting of the Yabuli China Entrepreneurs Forum (2025-02-21 to 23), Yu Yu spoke as founder and executive director of Dangdang on her observations from 25 years in books. Five years after the events, she is still the one at the helm. [新浪財經(老虎社區轉載)]
- Li Guoqing announces a property settlement and wishes Dangdang well "under Yu Yu's leadership" He said on social media that the two had divorced in 2023 and had recently reached a final settlement on the division of property, and thanked the court. He wished Dangdang well in continuing to operate under Yu Yu's leadership now that it was free of its equity-governance deadlock, and said he would travel light and work on AI applications. Neither the specific terms of the settlement nor how Dangdang's equity was finally divided has been made public. [21世紀經濟報道(老虎社區轉載)] [界面新聞] [澎湃號(斑馬消費)]
People
- Li Guoqing (Li Guoqing), 1964-10-01 — Co-founder; formerly co-president and CEO; held no position at the time of the events but remained a shareholder (27.51% per the business registration). Born in Beijing; graduated from Peking University's sociology department in 1987, then joined the Rural Policy Research Office of the CPC Central Committee Secretariat, leaving after about five years. Began his own business in book publishing at 27, and founded Beijing Kewen Economic and Trade Corporation in 1993. Co-founder. Launched Dangdang with Yu Yu in November 1999; from January 2015 took charge of the "new businesses", handing the original core business to Yu Yu. Met Yu Yu, then working on Wall Street, in the US in 1996 and married her after about three months of courtship. He told the media that most of the vice presidents he had brought up later left, and that in the end management jointly declared it did not support him. Twice led people into the company without managing to take it over; the second time he was placed in administrative detention for 10 days by police in Chaoyang, Beijing. Afterwards he ran Zaowan Dushu and sold liquor and tea by livestream on Douyin; on 2025-06-13 he announced a settlement with Yu Yu on the division of property and said he would next work on AI applications. He did not return to Dangdang. [維基百科:李國慶(企業家)] [騰訊新聞稜鏡深網(36氪轉載)] [鈦媒體] [雷帝觸網(36氪轉載)] [界面新聞]
- Yu Yu (Peggy Yu Yu), 1965-05-01 — Co-founder, chairman and CEO; executive director and legal representative under the articles of association (64.2% per the business registration). Born in Chongqing; graduated from Beijing Foreign Studies University in 1986, worked as an interpreter and secretary at the Beijing company of boiler maker Babcock & Wilcox, went to the US in 1987, earned an MBA from New York University's Stern School of Business in 1992 and gave the address on behalf of the graduating class, then worked on Wall Street. (Date of birth per Chinese Wikipedia; English Wikipedia gives only May 1965.) Co-founder; founded Dangdang with Li Guoqing in 1999; from January 2015 in charge of Dangdang's core business; from August 2018 executive director of Beijing Dangdang Information Technology Co., and from February 2019 its legal representative and general manager. Li Guoqing's wife (the two married in 1996 and divorced in 2023). Dangdang vice president Kan Min said during the events that management was entirely on Yu Yu's side. Has remained in office throughout and was never replaced. In February 2025 she was still speaking at the Yabuli forum as founder and executive director of Dangdang; after the property settlement of 2025-06-13, the media described her as having complete control of Dangdang. [維基百科:俞渝] [Wikipedia:Peggy Yu] [鈦媒體] [新浪財經(老虎社區轉載)] [澎湃號(斑馬消費)]
- Kan Min (Kan Min) — Dangdang vice president, company supervisor; spoke for the company during the events. No citable public source could be found for year of birth, education or career. According to Dangdang's legal department, the supervisor under the registered articles of association is Kan Min; reports mention that Kan Min was mainly responsible for finance and had also run the general merchandise and marketing departments. No public information could be found on when Kan Min joined Dangdang. The main spokesperson for Yu Yu's side: on 2020-04-26 chaired the conference call disclosing the shareholdings and rejecting Li Guoqing's shareholders' meeting, and said the one thing most worth saying to him was "the further from Dangdang the better". Li Guoqing, for his part, said Yu Yu together with the supervisor had twice refused in writing his proposal to convene a shareholders' meeting. Both of Li Guoqing's "personnel adjustment" announcements sought to reassign Kan Min (once to vice president of finance, once to run marketing and general merchandise); neither took actual effect. On 2020-07-14 Kan Min was still responding to the media as Dangdang vice president; no public reports could be found on what happened afterwards. [每日經濟新聞] [每日經濟新聞(當當法務部聲明)] [澎湃新聞] [中國企業家(鳳凰網財經轉載)] [每日經濟新聞]
- Chen Lijun (Chen Lijun) — Dangdang vice president. No citable public source could be found for year of birth, education or career. In 2019 he explained the company's situation publicly as Dangdang vice president. No public information could be found on when Kan Min joined Dangdang. In early 2019 he said on the company's behalf that Li Guoqing had been fading out of management for more than three years and that Yu Yu was chairman, that this was the result of the two's discussions and the company's choice, and that Dangdang had long ceased to be a "mom-and-pop shop". Yet he was on the five-person board list Li Guoqing published on his own on 2020-04-24, and on 2020-07-07 Li announced him as COO. No public statement of his own attitude to these two appointments could be found. Named by Li Guoqing as director and COO, but that line-up never actually took over the company. No public reports could be found on what happened to him after 2020. [每日經濟新聞] [北京商報(新浪財經轉載)] [鳳凰網科技《風眼》]
- Zhang Wei (Zhang Wei) — Member of the board announced by Li Guoqing; appointed by him as group vice president (in charge of investment and financing). No citable public source could be found for year of birth, education or career. Li Guoqing's announcement said he had served the company for 11 years. According to Li Guoqing's announcement he had worked at Dangdang for 11 years; the exact time he joined and his position were not found. On the five-person board list Li Guoqing published on his own on 2020-04-24 (Li Guoqing, Yu Yu, Pan Yuexin, Zhang Wei, Chen Lijun); appointed by him as vice president on both 2020-04-28 and 2020-07-07. No public information was found on his personal relationship with Li Guoqing. Li Guoqing's takeover did not succeed, so these appointments never took actual effect. Those taken away by police for questioning on 2020-07-07 were Li Guoqing and a group of managers he had brought; whether they included Zhang Wei, and what became of him afterwards, could not be found in public reports. [澎湃新聞] [鳳凰網科技] [北京商報(新浪財經轉載)] [鳳凰網科技《風眼》]
- Pan Yuexin (Pan Yuexin) — Member of the board announced by Li Guoqing. No citable public source could be found for identity, education or career. Appears only on the five-person board list Li Guoqing published on his own on 2020-04-24; Dangdang's side does not recognise this board. No public information was found on his relationship with Li Guoqing or Yu Yu. That board never actually operated; no public reports could be found on what became of him. [北京商報(新浪財經轉載)]
- Yao Danqian (Yao Danqian) — Dangdang's "acting CEO" as announced by Li Guoqing on 2020-07-07. No citable public source could be found for year of birth, education or career. On the day Li Guoqing entered the company for the second time he issued a personnel announcement declaring that he himself would serve only as chairman, with Yao Danqian as acting CEO in overall charge. No public information was found on his ties to Li Guoqing. On the day of the announcement Li Guoqing's party was taken away by police, and this appointment never took actual effect; no public reports could be found on what became of him afterwards. [鳳凰網科技《風眼》]
- Tang Xiaohun (Tang Xiaohui) — Former general manager of Dangdang Pictures, major shareholder of Zaowan Dushu; appointed group vice president by Li Guoqing. According to Li Guoqing's announcement he worked at Dangdang for 7 years, served as general manager of Dangdang Pictures, and later left to start a business with Li Guoqing; the media call him a major shareholder of Zaowan Dushu. Year of birth could not be found. A former Dangdang employee who joined Li Guoqing's new venture after leaving; appointed group vice president by Li Guoqing on 2020-04-28, in charge of film and television, HR, administration and legal affairs, and listed as vice president again on 2020-07-07. Li Guoqing's business partner after he left Dangdang. Li Guoqing's takeover did not succeed and the appointment never took actual effect; no public reports could be found on what became of him afterwards. [鳳凰網科技] [鳳凰網科技《風眼》]
Moves to block a return
- By Li Guoqing's later account, early that morning he received a letter, instigated by Yu Yu and written by management, to the effect that the new businesses no longer needed his involvement but that his office, driver, secretary and pay would be kept; the new businesses he ran were also taken back in January 2018. This is his one-sided account; Yu Yu later said only that, apart from the "palace coup", nothing he described was true. [騰訊新聞稜鏡深網(36氪轉載)] [鈦媒體] [澎湃新聞]
- After Li Guoqing made controversial remarks on social media, Dangdang issued an official statement distancing itself from him, saying he had been out of management and decision-making for some time and that he was not permitted to use Dangdang's logo on his personal platforms. Dangdang also later said publicly that he had been on indefinite leave since the end of 2018. [盒飯財經(36氪轉載)] [TechNode]
- Dangdang stopped paying Li Guoqing's social insurance contributions. This was stated in the report materials Dangdang gave the police in July 2020, to show that he had long ceased to be a company employee; Dangdang's legal department later also said the company had stopped paying his salary and social insurance. [中新網] [每日經濟新聞]
- On the day Li Guoqing took the seals, Dangdang issued a "solemn statement" and called the police: it declared the company seals, finance seals and finance department seals void with immediate effect, said the company would not recognise any contract or document anyone sealed with them while they were out of its control, attached a list of what was missing (11 company seals, 36 finance seals), and set about having new seals made. [第一財經] [澎湃新聞] [澎湃新聞]
- That evening Dangdang sent an internal letter and vice president Kan Min held a conference call, rebutting his "extraordinary shareholders' meeting" point by point: Yu Yu and the other management shareholders had known nothing of it beforehand; amending the articles of association requires more than two thirds of the voting rights, and he did not have the votes, so the resolution was invalid; the executive director under the articles was still Yu Yu, and he held no position at Dangdang. Kan Min also disclosed the shareholdings: Yu Yu 52.23%, Li Guoqing 22.38%, their son 18.65% (held on his behalf by his parents), and two management partnerships 3.58% and 2.93%. [澎湃新聞(當當內部信)] [每日經濟新聞] [澎湃新聞]
- After the police closed the case on 2020-06-13 finding "no unlawful conduct on Li Guoqing's side", Dangdang said it was shocked and applied for administrative reconsideration of the outcome. [每日經濟新聞(鳳凰網轉載)] [北京商報(新浪財經轉載)]
- Yu Yu applied to Beijing's Dongcheng court for a personal safety protection order against Li Guoqing, which was rejected on 2020-07-03; on 2020-07-09 her lawyer applied for reconsideration. Li Guoqing, for his part, said such applications had twice been rejected by the court. [每日經濟新聞(當當法務部聲明)] [鳳凰網科技] [每日經濟新聞]
- On the day Li Guoqing led people into the company for the second time, Dangdang again called the police and said publicly that the shareholders' meeting and board resolutions he claimed did not stand, and that the company had sued in Beijing's Chaoyang court to have them revoked. Two days later Dangdang further said it hoped the police would open a criminal case against him and recover the seals. (No public reports could be found on how this suit to revoke the resolutions was decided.) [鳳凰網科技《風眼》] [中新網]
- While Li Guoqing was still in detention, Dangdang sent two internal letters in succession announcing the creation of an independent "company rights protection department", recruiting mainly people with experience in judicial organs, military veterans and security personnel, the aim being to guard against his coming again once his detention ended; the letters also warned suppliers to beware of letters he might send in the company's name. The same evening Dangdang's legal department published a piece saying he had the status of "only a minority shareholder". [央廣網(鳳凰網財經轉載)] [每日經濟新聞]
- The line of defence on equity: Dangdang's legal department publicly asserted that Yu Yu and Li Guoqing had signed a written agreement dividing family property in 2016 and that the equity had always followed that agreement, so his demand for an equal split had no legal basis. On 2020-08-10 Dangdang further stated that the two had a "marital agreement" under which the ratio among Yu Yu, Li Guoqing and their son was 56:24:20, and that the business registration had already been changed accordingly. On this reckoning, even after a divorce he would not get enough equity to turn the tables. Li Guoqing denies that any such agreement exists. [每日經濟新聞] [中新網] [Caixin Global]
- Dangdang sued Li Guoqing and four others, five people in all, in Beijing's Chaoyang court, alleging that they had damaged the anti-theft system, security doors and several safes, and claiming more than RMB 100,000; the court accepted the case that day. The defendants raised a jurisdictional objection, which was rejected in December 2020. (No public reports could be found on the final judgment.) [IT之家]
Rumors
- HNA's RMB 7.5 billion deal to acquire Dangdang is about to fall through. [Later confirmed] 36Kr exclusive report of 2018-09-17 Tianhai Investment had already said on 13 September that external conditions had changed and that going ahead involved great uncertainty; later media retrospectives all state that Tianhai Investment terminated the acquisition plan in September 2018. [36氪] [網易科技(IT之家轉載)]
- Dangdang carried out mass layoffs under Yu Yu (he first said more than a hundred people were to be cut, later that the profits had been bought by cutting about 1,300). [Still unclear] Li Guoqing in his own video programme, in the letter to employees and in his open letter of 2020-07-19 Dangdang denied it twice: Kan Min said the company had made no layoffs, only a few unsuitable people had left, and it was preparing to sue those spreading rumours; in July it again responded that "1,300 layoffs is untrue". There are no third-party figures by which to judge who is right. [澎湃新聞] [鳳凰科技(IT之家轉載)]
- Li Guoqing obtained the support of a majority of shareholders (53.87%), and the extraordinary shareholders' meeting resolution is valid. [Still unclear] Li Guoqing's "Letter to All Dangdang Employees" and WeChat group voice message His arithmetic first splits the couple's combined shareholding in half. Dangdang says he has only 27.51% on the business register and that management fully supports Yu Yu, and questions whether the other partners in the minority-shareholder partnerships knew anything about it; several lawyers also consider that before a divorce judgment voting can only follow the registered shares. Dangdang says it has sued to revoke the resolution, but no public reports could be found on how the court ruled; what is certain is that he never took over the company. [澎湃新聞] [每日經濟新聞] [中新網]
- The April case reported as "seizing the company seals" has been closed, with police finding no unlawful conduct on Li Guoqing's side. [Later confirmed] China News Service (chinanews.com) report of 2020-06-13, followed up by other media Li Guoqing's side confirmed it to the media; Dangdang did not deny that the case was closed, but said it was shocked and applied for administrative reconsideration. The same police branch, however, imposed administrative detention in July for his second entry into the company. [每日經濟新聞(鳳凰網轉載)] [中國企業家(鳳凰網財經轉載)]
- The son's nominee-shareholding lawsuit was directed behind the scenes by Yu Yu, to keep her control of Dangdang and delay the divorce judgment. [Still unclear] Li Guoqing's Weibo post on the evening of 2020-08-09 This is Li Guoqing's own conjecture, and Yu Yu did not respond at the time; Dangdang confirmed only that the lawsuit was real and disclosed the 56:24:20 ratio. Lawyers pointed out that if the nominee holding were found valid, the equity he could receive would indeed be less than half; but no public information could be found on who directed the lawsuit or how the court finally ruled. [每日經濟新聞] [中新網]
Views
- Ding Daoshi (internet industry observer): He believed that if Dangdang wanted to revive, it should make a clean break with both founders and have new directors restructure it, but he also acknowledged that this would be hard to do. [每日經濟新聞]
- Tang Xin (independent analyst): He judged that since Li Guoqing had already left Dangdang, his influence over the company would only diminish from then on. [每日經濟新聞]
- Kan Min (Dangdang vice president): Kan Min said it was absurd and that Li Guoqing often acts on impulse; asked what was most worth saying to him, the answer was "the further from Dangdang the better". [每日經濟新聞] [燃財經(新浪財經轉載)]
- An unnamed Dangdang employee: This employee said Yu Yu was extremely strict with staff and that if Li Guoqing came back he or she would certainly welcome it. Kan Min denied the unpaid bonuses the employee spoke of. [燃財經(新浪財經轉載)]
- Su Wu (contributing writer, Tencent's Prism): The author considered that by bypassing the executive director and convening a shareholders' meeting himself he had exceeded his authority procedurally, and that his votes fell short of the threshold for amending the articles, so the takeover could hardly stand; he described Dangdang as more like a mom-and-pop shop dressed up as a company. [澎湃號(稜鏡)]
- Zhao Zhanling (deputy director, Beijing Zhilin Law Firm): He believed that until the divorce case concluded, the two could each vote only their registered shares, so the resolution would very probably be found invalid; but he also said that taking the seals did not necessarily amount to seizure in law, that Dangdang could not void the seals merely by reporting them lost, and that it could not be ruled out that Li Guoqing wanted to add bargaining chips to the divorce negotiations. [澎湃新聞] [中國經濟周刊(人民網)]
- Chen Wenming (lawyer, Zhejiang Xiaode Law Firm): He said that if the shareholders' meeting was unlawful or had never been held at all, walking into the company and taking the seals might constitute the crime of forcible seizure; even if the shareholders' meeting was lawful and the takeover had some legitimacy, the means were problematic. [澎湃新聞]
- Xia Wei (lawyer, Tiantong Law Firm): Citing the Supreme People's Court's conference minutes, he pointed out that what courts look at is whether the person affixing the seal has authority to represent the company, not whether the seal is genuine; Li Guoqing had no position or authority, so even a contract signed with a genuine seal would not automatically be valid. He also cautioned that the police might decline to take the report on the grounds that it was an internal shareholder dispute. [天同律師事務所]
- Song Yixin (deputy director, Shanghai Hanlian Law Firm): He considered the matter mainly a shareholder dispute and corporate deadlock with little to do with public-order administration, and recommended that the shareholders negotiate among themselves or resolve it through civil litigation. The next day the police nonetheless imposed administrative detention. [鳳凰網科技《風眼》]
- Li Jinqing (analyst, BigData-Research): He said netizens' disappointment mostly stems from Dangdang having started so strongly and later fallen behind; yet Dangdang is still profitable while most e-commerce companies lose money, and whether that can last depends on its own strategy and competition from the big platforms. [北京商報(新浪財經轉載)]
- Yu Yu (chairman of Dangdang): In her open letter she said what angered her was Li Guoqing abusing the Marriage Law to dodge the Company Law and constantly harassing the company, and she called on the public not to smear husband-and-wife entrepreneurship, nor companies with shareholder disputes. [Yicai Global] [鳳凰網科技]
- Li Guoqing (the person concerned): He said the two had "parted ways, each to find their own happiness", and wished Dangdang, now free of its equity-governance deadlock, well in continuing as a reading platform for everyone under Yu Yu's leadership. [界面新聞] [21世紀經濟報道(老虎社區轉載)]
- Shen Tuo (writer for the finance self-media outlet Banma Xiaofei): The author considered that after the settlement Dangdang's ownership is clear and Yu Yu has complete control, but the book e-commerce landscape has been taken over by Taobao/Tmall, JD.com and Douyin, and it will be hard for Dangdang to return to the front rank; Li Guoqing's second venture has also fallen short of the goals he once boasted of. [鈦媒體(斑馬消費)] [澎湃號(斑馬消費)]
Photos & videos
Dangdang's logo (wordmark, marked as public domain on Commons). — Dangdang / Public domain
The Hailong Building electronics mall in Zhongguancun, Beijing (file name indicates 2003); Li Guoqing says it was in Zhongguancun that he and Yu Yu started Dangdang in 1999. — Yaohua2000 / CC BY-SA 3.0
The West Gate of Peking University, photographed in 2017; Li Guoqing graduated from PKU's sociology department in 1987. — Harryswordsman / CC BY-SA 4.0
New York University's Stern School of Business, photographed in 2019; Yu Yu earned her MBA here in 1992. — Ajay Suresh from New York, NY, USA / CC BY 2.0The New York Stock Exchange, photographed in August 2010; four months later, on 2010-12-08, Dangdang listed here. — Elbie Ancona / CC BY-SA 3.0
The HNA Building in Wangjing, Beijing, photographed in June 2016; HNA's Tianhai Investment planned in 2018 to buy Dangdang for RMB 7.5 billion, a deal that later fell through. — MNXANL / CC BY-SA 4.0
The HNA Building in Haikou (HNA Group headquarters), photographed in June 2018, during the very months when HNA's acquisition of Dangdang stalled. — Anna Frodesiak / CC0
Beijing Dongcheng District People's Court, photographed in January 2016; the divorce case of Li Guoqing and Yu Yu (the point at issue being Dangdang's equity) was heard here on 2020-06-15. — 冯正虎(zhenghu feng) / CC BY 2.0- Bloomberg interview with Yu Yu: the money raised in Dangdang's IPO will be used to expand its product range (around the time of the 2010 listing). (Bloomberg Originals)