Akimitsu Sano (Akimitsu Sano) — Cookpad (クックパッド) (Cookpad)
Akimitsu Sano, founder of the recipe site Cookpad, handed the presidency in 2012 to Yoshiteru Akita (former president of Kakaku.com), whom he had brought in himself, and went to the US to work on the overseas business. Akita sent results and the share price soaring through acquisitions and diversification, while Sano felt the company was drifting away from cooking. In 2015-11 he presented a new business plan to the board and asked to return as president; a special committee of the five outside directors recommended keeping the existing course. In January 2016, as the largest shareholder, he proposed replacing every director other than himself; in February the two sides compromised on a single nine-person slate. Two days before the shareholders' meeting the board removed him as executive officer; after the meeting on 24 March the new board reinstated him and demoted Akita to executive officer without representative authority, with the presidency going to Rimpei Iwata, whom Sano had recruited. Afterwards employees left in large numbers, the share price fell to a third of its peak, and the company posted losses year after year and cut staff repeatedly.
How they were ousted
This is not a typical founder firing. In May 2012 he himself handed the presidency to Yoshiteru Akita; at the end of 2015 he asked to return as president and was blocked by a special committee of outside directors and by the board; on 2016-03-22 the board went further and, with four outside directors in favour, removed him as executive officer.
How they came back
As the largest shareholder with about 43.6%, he submitted a shareholder proposal to replace the board; two days later the shareholders' meeting elected a new board in which his nominees held the majority (6 of 9 seats); after the meeting the board re-elected him as executive officer and removed Akita as president. He himself did not return as representative executive officer and CEO until 2023-10-01.
What happened to the board
Of the 7 directors at the time of the dispute, the 6 other than Sano himself all left within a year. Three outside directors (Kenji Kumasaka, Hiroyuki Yamada, Masakazu Iwakura) completed their terms on the day of the 2016-03-24 shareholders' meeting and were not renominated; Akita was removed as president that day, resigned as executive officer on 2016-12-31, and left the board at the end of his term on 2017-03-23; Masaaki Shintaku, an outside director who had stayed on, resigned on 2016-12-31, and Kiyohiko Nishimura was also absent from the new slate of 2017-03-23. But to be accurate: after Sano's return the company's revenue declined year by year, it posted consecutive losses from 2021, and in 2023 it cut roughly 30% or more of its workforce — "replacing the board" did not bring good results.
Timeline
- Akimitsu Sano starts the business Set up the limited company Coin in Fujisawa, Kanagawa Prefecture; began the recipe-submission service in March 1998 and renamed it Cookpad in 1999. (The source gives only October 1997.) [維基百科(日文):クックパッド] [Cookpad 適時開示:代表執行役の異動に関するお知らせ(2023-05-18)]
- Yoshiteru Akita joins the board; the company becomes a company with committees Akita, former president of Kakaku.com, joined as an outside director. The same month the company adopted the three-committee system (nominating, compensation, audit), with Sano as representative executive officer. (The source gives only July 2007.) [維基百科(日文):穐田誉輝] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [Cookpad 適時開示:代表執行役の異動に関するお知らせ(2023-05-18)]
- Lists on the Tokyo Stock Exchange Mothers market Moved to the First Section of the Tokyo Stock Exchange in 2011. (The source gives only July 2009.) [維基百科(日文):クックパッド]
- Sano hands the presidency to Akita Sano stepped down as representative executive officer and Akita took over; Sano became director and executive officer, moved to the US to focus on the overseas business, and from July of that year was a director only. This handover was his own decision. (The source gives only May 2012.) [Cookpad 適時開示:代表執行役の異動に関するお知らせ(2023-05-18)] [維基百科(日文):穐田誉輝] [現代 Business(伊藤博敏,2016-04-28)]
- Share price hits a post-listing high of ¥2,880 Under Akita, revenue and market value grew substantially through acquisitions and diversification. [NetIB-News(2016-11)]
- Sano asks to return as president; the board sets up a special committee Sano presented to the board a new plan to concentrate resources on the membership and overseas businesses, and proposed that he return as president. The board set up a special committee of the five outside directors to review it. [NetIB-News(2016-03-31,前篇)] [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口拓郎律師,2016-04-19)] [Cookpad 適時開示:特別委員会の設置(2015-11-27,JPX)]
- Special committee recommends keeping the existing course The board accepted the recommendation and resolved to continue the incumbent management team's strategy; Sano's proposal to return was blocked. [NetIB-News(2016-03-31,前篇)] [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口拓郎律師,2016-04-19)]
- Sano submits a shareholder proposal As the largest shareholder he proposed electing eight directors at the March shareholders' meeting, replacing all incumbent directors other than himself. (NetIB-News says notice was given on 8 January; BUSINESS LAWYERS says it was delivered on 12 January.) [NetIB-News(2016-03-31,前篇)] [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口拓郎律師,2016-04-19)]
- The company makes public the conflict between founder and president The company announced that it had received a shareholder proposal from Sano and three others; Sano's reason was that the company was putting its effort into businesses unrelated to cooking and that its management vision had become distorted. That evening the company held an emergency all-hands meeting at headquarters, where Akita asked employees to keep building user-centred services. [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2016-01-20)] [東洋經濟 Online(山田泰弘,2016-02-06)] [現代 Business(伊藤博敏,2016-04-28)]
- Share price hits limit-down, falling 23% in one day It fell a further 6% the next day. Hideto Fujino of Rheos Capital Works said his fund sold its entire Cookpad holding after Sano's proposal. [現代 Business(伊藤博敏,2016-04-28)] [東洋經濟 Online(關田真也,2016-05-19)]
- The two sides reach a basic agreement on "a single slate" The company and Sano agreed to merge the director election proposals into a company proposal, and Sano withdrew his shareholder proposal. [NetIB-News(2016-03-31,前篇)] [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口拓郎律師,2016-04-19)]
- Nine-person slate announced, with Sano's nominees taking six seats Under the agreement the nominating committee nominated nine people: the six proposed by Sano plus three incumbents (including both Sano and Akita); the board grew from seven seats to nine, and three outside directors were not renominated. On the same day the board elected Sano and the newly arrived Rimpei Iwata as executive officers. [NetIB-News(2016-03-31,前篇)] [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口拓郎律師,2016-04-19)]
- Notice of meeting includes an outside director's critical opinion Masakazu Iwakura questioned the whole process in a supplementary opinion to the audit report. Proxy adviser ISS also considered it inappropriate for a major shareholder to demand changes to a plan the board had already approved, and recommended that shareholders vote against Sano's re-election as director. (The source does not give the exact date of the ISS recommendation.) [NetIB-News(森村和男,2016-04-01,後篇)]
- Board removes Sano as executive officer An outside director moved for his removal, and it passed with four outside directors in favour. The announcement stated the reason: for more than 40 days he had not explained the new structure after the shareholders' meeting, and when asked whether he would return to Japan to serve as representative executive officer he answered that it was not yet decided, which was contrary to the duties of an executive officer. [Cookpad 適時開示:執行役の解任に関するお知らせ(2016-03-22)]
- Shareholders' meeting elects a new board The 12th annual general meeting of shareholders, held at Yebisu Garden Place, approved the nine-person slate, with Sano receiving 85.41% of votes and Akita 95.57%. All five newcomers (Iwata, Toru Kitagawa, Daisuke Yanasawa, Kyoko Deguchi, Koichiro Fujii) were nominated by Sano's side; outside directors Kumasaka, Yamada and Iwakura left. [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [NetIB-News(森村和男,2016-04-01,後篇)] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)]
- Post-meeting board: Akita steps down as president, Sano reinstated The new board elected Rimpei Iwata as representative executive officer, demoted Akita to executive officer without representative authority (still a director), and re-elected as executive officer Sano, who had been removed only two days earlier. The chairs of all three committees were also replaced with new outside directors. [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [ITmedia NEWS(2016-03-25)] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)]
- New president apologises; share price falls another 10% On the company website Iwata apologised for the worry the management turmoil had caused shareholders, saying the company would return to its strength of "making everyday cooking fun". That day the share price fell at one point by ¥354 to ¥1,770. [ITmedia NEWS(2016-03-25)]
- Employees petition for Sano's removal Managers emailed all employees launching a petition, which more than 80% of the roughly 240 full-time employees supported, and a labour union was later formed. In the same period the five executive officers other than Akita were removed at once, and the company was for a time in internal disarray. [現代 Business(伊藤博敏,2016-04-28)] [東洋經濟 Online(山田泰弘,2016-04-18)]
- Resolution to spin off the fresh-food information and health businesses In line with Sano's policy of "focusing on recipes", the company began disposing of the businesses expanded in the Akita era. [東洋經濟 Online(關田真也,2016-05-19)]
- Share price falls below ¥1,000 It touched ¥992 intraday, about a third of the 2015 peak. [NetIB-News(2016-11)]
- Akita resigns as executive officer; outside director Masaaki Shintaku resigns The company terminated the shareholders' agreement it had signed with Akita over Minna no Wedding, which ceased to be a subsidiary; Akita resigned as executive officer on 31 December, remaining only a director. On the same day it was announced that Masaaki Shintaku would resign as director on 31 December. [Cookpad 適時開示:取締役の辞任(2016-12-22,JPX)] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [維基百科(日文):クックパッド]
- Akita leaves the board at the end of his term The 13th shareholders' meeting began at 10 a.m. and ended at 12:08, attended by 313 shareholders, fewer than half the previous year's 657; questions centred on distrust of management. After the meeting the board consisted of Sano, Iwata and five outside directors; neither Akita nor Kiyohiko Nishimura was on the list. [東洋經濟 Online(長瀧菜摘,2017-03-25)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制(2017-03-23,JPX)] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)]
- Second round of job cuts within a month In February the company first sought 40 voluntary redundancies, then on 10 March announced a cut of 80 in the overseas business — together about 30% of the 409 employees at the end of 2022. Revenue for fiscal 2022 was ¥9.1 billion with an operating loss of ¥3.5 billion, the second consecutive annual loss. [Business Insider Japan(2023-03-29)] [Media Innovation(2023-07-21)]
- Board decides Sano will return as CEO The company announced that Sano would become representative executive officer and CEO, with Iwata remaining a director after stepping down; the stated reason was to speed up service development. Nikkei reported it at 18:50, calling it his return as president after 11 years. [Cookpad 適時開示:代表執行役の異動に関するお知らせ(2023-05-18)] [日本經濟新聞(2023-05-18 18:50)]
- Another 110 jobs cut Before Sano took office the company cut a further 110 people through encouraged resignations; the media described this as clearing the ground for his return. (The source gives only June 2023.) [Media Innovation(2023-07-21)]
- Sano formally returns as representative executive officer and CEO More than 11 years after the handover of May 2012. [Cookpad 適時開示:代表執行役の異動に関するお知らせ(2023-05-18)] [日本經濟新聞(2023-05-18 18:50)] [Media Innovation(2023-07-21)]
People
- Akimitsu Sano (Akimitsu Sano), 1973-05-01 — Founder, director, largest shareholder (about 43.6%); in charge of the overseas business. Born in Tokyo; lived eight years in Singapore and four in Los Angeles as a child; graduated from Keio University's Faculty of Environment and Information Studies in 1997. In October of that year he set up the limited company Coin in Fujisawa, Kanagawa Prefecture, and in 1998 began a recipe-submission website, which later became Cookpad. Founder. Representative director from 2004; representative executive officer after the company became a company with committees in 2007; stepped down in May 2012. Akita was the man he brought in as an outside director in 2007 and personally designated as his successor in 2012; Rimpei Iwata was the man he recruited in 2016 to replace Akita. Removed as executive officer on 2016-03-22 and reinstated two days later; afterwards he led the company as director and executive officer, but left the presidency to Rimpei Iwata. On 2023-05-18 the board decided he would become representative executive officer and CEO, effective 1 October — 11 years after stepping down in 2012. [維基百科(日文):佐野陽光] [Cookpad 適時開示:代表執行役の異動に関するお知らせ(2023-05-18)] [Cookpad 適時開示:執行役の解任に関するお知らせ(2016-03-22)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [日本經濟新聞(2023-05-18 18:50)]
- Yoshiteru Akita (穐田誉輝) (Yoshiteru Akita), 1969-04-29 — Representative executive officer (president), director, second-largest shareholder (about 14.8%). Born in Sosa, Chiba Prefecture; graduated from Aoyama Gakuin University's Faculty of Economics. Joined the venture capital firm Nippon Godo Finance (now JAFCO) in 1993; became president of Kakaku.com in 2001 and took the company public; stepped down in 2006. Became an outside director of Cookpad in 2007 as an investor and helped the company go public in 2009; designated by Sano to succeed him as representative executive officer in May 2012. The successor Sano brought in. During his tenure he expanded the business through acquisitions into weddings, e-publishing, childcare and other fields, with record revenue and profit year after year; Sano felt this strayed from cooking, and the two fell out over it. Removed as representative executive officer after the 2016-03-24 shareholders' meeting and demoted to executive officer without representative authority; resigned as executive officer on 2016-12-31 and left the board at the end of his term on 2017-03-23. Around the time of his departure he bought O-uccino and Minna no Wedding; chairman of Kufu Company from 2018. [維基百科(日文):穐田誉輝] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [ITmedia NEWS(2016-03-25)] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [東洋經濟 Online(長瀧菜摘,2017-03-25)] [NetIB-News(2016-11)]
- Rimpei Iwata (Rimpei Iwata) — Executive officer (joined 2016-02); representative executive officer from 2016-03-24. Former McKinsey consultant; aged 42 in 2016. Recruited by Sano as executive officer in February 2016; a month later he was put on the director slate and took over as president. The man Sano recruited to replace Akita. Served as president for seven and a half years. After the company posted losses two years running, it was announced on 2023-05-18 that Sano would take over as CEO; he stepped down as representative executive officer and executive officer and remained a director. This is an example of "the person the founder brought in ends up being replaced by the founder too". [現代 Business(伊藤博敏,2016-04-28)] [NetIB-News(2016-03-31,前篇)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [Cookpad 適時開示:代表執行役の異動に関するお知らせ(2023-05-18)] [日本經濟新聞(2023-05-18 18:50)]
- Masaaki Shintaku (Masaaki Shintaku) — Outside director, chair of the compensation committee, chair of the special committee. Outside director at the time of the events; detailed education and career could not be verified because the company's notice of meeting could not be opened. Year of appointment not found. Chaired the special committee that rejected Sano's plan at the end of 2015; yet he was one of the few old directors kept on the new 2016 slate. Re-elected on 2016-03-24, but submitted his resignation on 22 December of that year and resigned on 31 December; the reason given in the company's announcement was personal reasons. [Cookpad 適時開示:特別委員会の設置(2015-11-27,JPX)] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [Cookpad 適時開示:取締役の辞任(2016-12-22,JPX)]
- Kiyohiko Nishimura (西村淸彦) (Kiyohiko Nishimura) — Outside director. Economist, former deputy governor of the Bank of Japan. Year of appointment not found. Member of the special committee. At the 2016 shareholders' meeting he publicly pointed out that if Sano carried out business in the US in a representative capacity, the company risked being taxed there. Re-elected on 2016-03-24, but no longer on the list of directors after the 2017-03-23 shareholders' meeting; the exact date and reason for his departure were not found. [現代 Business(伊藤博敏,2016-04-28)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制(2017-03-23,JPX)]
- Kenji Kumasaka (Kenji Kumasaka) — Outside director, chair of the nominating committee. Outside director at the time of the events; detailed education and career could not be verified because the company's notice of meeting could not be opened. Year of appointment not found. Member of the special committee; although he was chair of the nominating committee, the director candidates were decided by agreement between the two major shareholders. Not on the unified slate; left at the end of his term on the day of the 2016-03-24 shareholders' meeting. [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)]
- Hiroyuki Yamada (Hiroyuki Yamada) — Outside director, chair of the audit committee. Outside director at the time of the events; detailed education and career could not be verified because the company's notice of meeting could not be opened. Year of appointment not found. Member of the special committee. Not on the unified slate; left at the end of his term on the day of the 2016-03-24 shareholders' meeting. [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)]
- Masakazu Iwakura (Masakazu Iwakura) — Outside director, member of the audit committee. Partner at the law firm Nishimura & Asahi, specialising in corporate law. Year of appointment not found. Member of the special committee. Wrote a supplementary opinion in the audit report in the notice of the 2016 shareholders' meeting, publicly criticising Sano's conduct. Not on the unified slate; left at the end of his term on the day of the 2016-03-24 shareholders' meeting. [NetIB-News(森村和男,2016-04-01,後篇)] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)]
- Daisuke Yanasawa (Daisuke Yanasawa) — New outside director, chair of the nominating committee (from 2016-03). New outside director nominated by Sano's side in 2016; detailed education and career could not be verified because the company's notice of meeting could not be opened. Put on the unified slate of candidates on 2016-02-12; elected at the 2016-03-24 shareholders' meeting. One of the six nominated by Sano; became a committee chair after the shareholders' meeting, replacing the previous outside director. Still on the list of directors after the 2017-03-23 shareholders' meeting. [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制(2017-03-23,JPX)]
- Toru Kitagawa (Toru Kitagawa) — New outside director, chair of the audit committee (from 2016-03). New outside director nominated by Sano's side in 2016; detailed education and career could not be verified because the company's notice of meeting could not be opened. Put on the unified slate of candidates on 2016-02-12; elected at the 2016-03-24 shareholders' meeting. One of the six nominated by Sano; became a committee chair after the shareholders' meeting, replacing the previous outside director. Still on the list of directors after the 2017-03-23 shareholders' meeting. [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制(2017-03-23,JPX)]
- Koichiro Fujii (Koichiro Fujii) — New outside director, chair of the compensation committee (from 2016-03). New outside director nominated by Sano's side in 2016; detailed education and career could not be verified because the company's notice of meeting could not be opened. Put on the unified slate of candidates on 2016-02-12; elected at the 2016-03-24 shareholders' meeting. One of the six nominated by Sano; became a committee chair after the shareholders' meeting, replacing the previous outside director. Still on the list of directors after the 2017-03-23 shareholders' meeting. [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制(2017-03-23,JPX)]
- Kyoko Deguchi (Kyoko Deguchi) — New outside director (from 2016-03). New outside director nominated by Sano's side in 2016; detailed education and career could not be verified because the company's notice of meeting could not be opened. Put on the unified slate of candidates on 2016-02-12; elected at the 2016-03-24 shareholders' meeting. One of the six nominated by Sano; became a committee chair after the shareholders' meeting, replacing the previous outside director. Still on the list of directors after the 2017-03-23 shareholders' meeting. [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制(2017-03-23,JPX)]
Moves to block a return
- Sano presented a new business plan to the board and asked to return as president himself; the board instead had all five outside directors form a special committee (chaired by Masaaki Shintaku) to compare the two strategies, on the grounds of protecting minority shareholders. [NetIB-News(2016-03-31,前篇)] [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口拓郎律師,2016-04-19)] [Cookpad 適時開示:特別委員会の設置(2015-11-27,JPX)]
- The special committee submitted its recommendation, and the board resolved to continue the incumbent management team's strategy, in effect rejecting Sano's return as president; the content of the recommendation was not disclosed, on grounds of trade secrecy. [NetIB-News(2016-03-31,前篇)] [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口拓郎律師,2016-04-19)]
- In the audit report included in the notice of the shareholders' meeting, outside director Masakazu Iwakura (a lawyer) attached a supplementary opinion: Sano had first said he would accept the special committee's conclusion, then turned around and launched a proposal as a shareholder; having two major shareholders privately decide the director candidates, bypassing the nominating committee, might raise issues of violating the Companies Act. [NetIB-News(森村和男,2016-04-01,後篇)]
- Two days before the shareholders' meeting, the board removed Sano as executive officer with four outside directors in favour. The reason given was that for more than 40 days after withdrawing his shareholder proposal he had not explained the new structure after the meeting, and when asked whether he would return to Japan to serve as representative executive officer he said it was not yet decided. [Cookpad 適時開示:執行役の解任に関するお知らせ(2016-03-22)] [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口拓郎律師,2016-04-19)] [NetIB-News(森村和男,2016-04-01,後篇)]
- Four days after the shareholders' meeting, managers emailed all employees launching a petition demanding Sano's removal as executive officer; more than 80% of the roughly 240 full-time employees signed, and a labour union was formed. This was an action by employees, not the board, and in the end it did not change the outcome. [現代 Business(伊藤博敏,2016-04-28)]
Rumors
- Sano launched the proposal in order to return as president himself. [Proven false] Headlines in Nikkan Kogyo Shimbun and other media; in 2015-11 he did indeed propose his own return to the board The person who took the presidency in 2016 was Rimpei Iwata; Sano served only as director and executive officer, and before the shareholders' meeting would not even say whether he would return to Japan to take representative authority. However, he did return as CEO on 2023-10-01, so one can only say "not at the time". [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2016-01-20)] [NetIB-News(2016-03-31,前篇)] [Cookpad 適時開示:執行役の解任に関するお知らせ(2016-03-22)] [Cookpad 適時開示:新役員体制に関するお知らせ(2016-03-24)] [Cookpad 適時開示:代表執行役の異動に関するお知らせ(2023-05-18)]
- Sano refused to take a post with representative authority because he was in the US, and taking one would cause the company to be regarded as having a permanent establishment there and be taxed. [Still unclear] Outside director Kiyohiko Nishimura raised the tax risk at the shareholders' meeting; Gendai Business, Takafumi Horie and others went further in speculating about the motive Sano told the media only that he could not comment, and the company offers no explanation beyond its public disclosures; there has been no official finding. [現代 Business(伊藤博敏,2016-04-28)]
- Akita would soon leave and take with him the businesses he had built. [Later confirmed] Media and market observations after the shareholders' meeting He bought O-uccino in October 2016, bought Minna no Wedding in December and resigned as executive officer, and left the board on 2017-03-23. [維基百科(日文):穐田誉輝] [The社史:クックパッド 2016 年創業者復歸(整理自有價證券報告書)] [東洋經濟 Online(長瀧菜摘,2017-03-25)]
Views
- Akimitsu Sano (founder): The company had not put resources into the high-growth overseas business and had instead gone into things unrelated to cooking; its management vision had become seriously distorted. [東洋經濟 Online(山田泰弘,2016-02-06)] [日刊工業新聞/Newswitch(2016-01-20)]
- Masakazu Iwakura (outside director, lawyer): Sano set aside his position as a director and put his position as a shareholder first; the agreement management reached with him is also not without problems. [NetIB-News(森村和男,2016-04-01,後篇)]
- ISS (proxy voting adviser): It is inappropriate for a major shareholder to demand changes to a business plan the board has already approved; recommended that shareholders vote against. [NetIB-News(森村和男,2016-04-01,後篇)]
- Kazuo Morimura (NetIB-News contributor): A listed company is not the founder's private property; if he wants to run it his own way, he should make a tender offer and take the company private. [NetIB-News(森村和男,2016-04-01,後篇)]
- Cookpad employee (quoted by Toyo Keizai): The representative authority that had been agreed was suddenly overturned at the board meeting; the executive officers were replaced all at once, and operations on the ground were in chaos. [東洋經濟 Online(山田泰弘,2016-04-18)]
- Takuro Yamaguchi (lawyer, Oh-Ebashi LPC & Partners): A major shareholder exercising his rights is not in itself illegal, but the director candidates were in practice negotiated between Sano and management rather than decided by the nominating committee, and shareholders voted without knowing the new structure after the meeting; the process was not transparent enough. [BUSINESS LAWYERS(山口拓郎律師,2016-04-19)]
- Takafumi Horie (entrepreneur, quoted by Gendai Business): Praised Akita's management ability; argued that if Sano wants to treat the company as his own, he should buy it with his own money. [現代 Business(伊藤博敏,2016-04-28)]
- Hirotoshi Ito (journalist): Insisting on living in the US while not taking representative authority — the founder has a duty to explain this clearly to shareholders. [現代 Business(伊藤博敏,2016-04-28)]
- Hideto Fujino (president of Rheos Capital Works, fund manager): What he valued was Akita's management ability; a three-committee governance structure is incompatible with direct intervention by a major shareholder, so he sold the entire holding as soon as the proposal came out. [東洋經濟 Online(關田真也,2016-05-19)]
- Individual shareholders attending the shareholders' meeting (quoted by Toyo Keizai): Some left early and said they were considering selling their shares; others said they could not sense any sincerity towards shareholders from the company. [東洋經濟 Online(長瀧菜摘,2017-03-25)]
- Media Innovation (media industry website): Both members and advertising are declining, and the company appears to be caught in a vicious circle; the large-scale job cuts before his return looked like clearing the ground for him. [Media Innovation(2023-07-21)]
Photos & videos
Cookpad's logo. — Cookpad Inc. / Public domain
A photograph taken on 28 February 2010 whose file name and original caption both label it as cookpad (uploaded by a Flickr user), a little over six months after the company listed. — Tatsuo Yamashita / CC BY 2.0
A photograph of the event on the same day; the original caption reads "ハック部の部会&新年会" (a developer club gathering), and the file name labels it Cookpad 2010. — Tatsuo Yamashita / CC BY 2.0
Yebisu Garden Place Tower, Tokyo, May 2012. Cookpad moved its headquarters to Ebisu in September 2014, and the 2016 shareholders' meeting was also held at Yebisu Garden Place. — Harani0403 / CC BY-SA 3.0
The office lobby of Yebisu Garden Place Tower, May 2015, six months before the turmoil. — Wpcpey / CC BY-SA 4.0
Exterior of Yebisu Garden Place Tower, 2006. — Acediscovery / CC BY 4.0- Interview with founder Akimitsu Sano on Cookpad's official channel (episode 69 of the series) (Cookpad - クックパッド)