🏢 Companies👑 Thrones

Richard Schulze (Richard Schulze) — Best Buy (Best Buy)

In April 2012 Best Buy CEO Brian Dunn resigned during a board investigation. The audit committee report released on May 14 found that founder and chairman Richard Schulze had received a complaint as early as December 2011 but confronted Dunn himself instead of reporting it to the audit committee; the board announced at the same time that Hatim Tyabji would take over as chairman and Schulze would move to an honorary position. On June 7 he resigned from the board early, and on August 6, building on his roughly 20% stake, he put forward a going-private proposal at US$24 to US$26 per share. The board first amended the bylaws and demanded a standstill provision, and hired Hubert Joly as CEO the day after talks broke down; the two sides did not sign a due diligence agreement until August 26. The deadline was extended to February 28, 2013, and Schulze never made a formal offer. On March 25, 2013 he returned as chairman emeritus and nominated his longtime colleagues Brad Anderson and Al Lenzmeier to the board.

How they were ousted

The audit committee's investigation report found that he failed to report a complaint against the CEO after learning of it; the board elected Hatim Tyabji to take over as chairman and moved him to an honorary position. Three weeks later he resigned from the board early of his own accord.

How they came back

His going-private bid never produced a formal offer. After the deadline passed he settled with the new CEO, Hubert Joly, and returned to the company as "Founder and Chairman Emeritus"; he does not sit on the board himself but may nominate two directors.

What happened to the board

When the decision was made in May 2012, the board had 9 members besides Schulze. Two had already left before his return (Rebolledo's term ended on 2012-06-20 under the retirement policy; Mikan moved to become president of ESL Investments on 2012-12-26); two more left within three months of his return (Paull departed on 2013-04-20 under the retirement policy, which had been notified as early as 2012-12-26; James did not stand for re-election on 2013-06-20), and company filings stated in each case that there was no disagreement with the company. The other 5 were not purged: Tyabji, who replaced him as chairman, stayed until retiring on 2015-06-09, Khosla retired the same day, Vittecoq stayed until 2018 and Higgins Victor until 2020, and Caputo was still listed as a director in the 2026 proxy statement. Schulze himself did not return to the board; his two nominees were a minority among ten or so seats, Lenzmeier and Anderson retired in 2015 and 2016 respectively, and his nomination right expired when he turned 75.

Timeline

  1. Schulze opens the audio store Sound of Music in St. Paul Richard Schulze and a partner opened Sound of Music, a store specializing in hi-fi audio, in St. Paul, Minnesota; this was the forerunner of Best Buy. [維基百科(英文):Best Buy]
  2. Company renamed Best Buy In 1981 a tornado tore the roof off the Roseville store, and the "Tornado Sale" Schulze held sold more in four days than in a typical month. In 1983 the company, with seven stores and annual revenue of about US$10 million, was renamed Best Buy and took the low-price superstore route. [維基百科(英文):Best Buy] [MPR News(2012-05-15)]
  3. Schulze hands over the CEO post, stays on as chairman After more than thirty years as CEO, Schulze handed the post to Brad Anderson, who had been with him for nearly thirty years, and stayed on as chairman himself; in June 2009 Anderson in turn handed over to Brian Dunn. [Best Buy 2012 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [Best Buy 2013 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
  4. Schulze receives a written complaint against the CEO and confronts Dunn himself An executive gave chairman Schulze a written statement by another employee alleging that Dunn's relationship with a female subordinate might be inappropriate. Schulze showed the statement to Dunn, who denied it; afterwards Schulze did not tell the audit committee, the general counsel, the head of human resources or any other director. [審計委員會調查報告(2012-05-12)]
  5. Audit committee learns of it only in mid-March, hires a law firm to investigate After the complaint reached a senior human resources executive, the general counsel reported it to the board and the audit committee in mid-March, the first they had heard of it. The audit committee promptly retained outside law firm WilmerHale to conduct an independent investigation. [審計委員會調查報告(2012-05-12)] [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-05-14)]
  6. CEO Dunn resigns; director Mike Mikan becomes interim CEO Dunn tendered his resignation to the board on April 9, effective the 10th, and resigned as a director at the same time. The company's press release said both sides agreed it was time for new leadership, and specifically noted that founder Schulze remained chairman. Director Mike Mikan was named interim CEO. [Best Buy 8-K(2012-04-11)] [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-04-10)]
  7. Audit committee delivers its report; board elects Tyabji as chairman On a Saturday, the audit committee presented its investigation report to the board; the same day the board elected audit committee chairman Hatim Tyabji to replace Schulze, to take effect after the close of the June 21 shareholder meeting. [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-05-14)] [審計委員會調查報告(2012-05-12)]
  8. Report made public: chairman mishandled the matter; Schulze to step down as chairman The company released the full text of the report. It concluded that Dunn violated company policy but did not misuse company resources; that Schulze's failure to report to the audit committee was improper handling, and that by giving Dunn the written statement, which named its author, he exposed the employees concerned to the risk of retaliation. Schulze said he understood and accepted the audit committee's conclusions and would move to the honorary position of "Founder and Chairman Emeritus", remaining a director until his term ended in June 2013. The share price edged up about 1.5% that day to close at US$19.56. [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-05-14)] [審計委員會調查報告(2012-05-12)] [MPR News(2012-05-14)]
  9. Independent directors switch to backing "annual election of directors" The same press release announced that the independent directors had changed their position on the shareholder proposal to eliminate the staggered board from neutral to recommending a vote in favour. Tyabji said that from now on every director would face shareholders' scrutiny every year, without exception. [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-05-14)]
  10. Schulze resigns early as director and chairman, to seek a way forward for his 20.1% stake That morning Schulze notified the board that he was resigning as chairman and director with immediate effect, and issued his own press release saying the company urgently needed to return to growth, that he had shared his views with the board, and that he was resigning in order to explore all options for his 20.1% stake. The board announced the same day that Tyabji would take over as chairman immediately, and amended the bylaws to provide for an independent chairman. The share price fell as much as 8.5% intraday and closed down 1% at US$19.70. [Schulze 新聞稿(2012-06-07)] [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-06-07)] [Best Buy 8-K(2012-06-08)] [MPR News(2012-06-07)]
  11. Board amends bylaws: threshold for calling a special shareholder meeting over a change of control raised from 10% to 25% The day before the shareholder meeting, the board amended the company bylaws, raising the ownership threshold for shareholders to demand a special shareholder meeting over a change of control from 10% to 25%, saying it was conforming to Minnesota state law. Schulze held about a fifth of the shares, which fell below the new threshold. [Best Buy 8-K(2012-06-21)] [Twin Cities Business(2012-07-06)]
  12. Shareholder meeting: three directors re-elected, executive compensation proposal rejected Tyabji chaired the shareholder meeting for the first time as chairman. Caputo, Higgins Victor and Vittecoq were re-elected by wide margins; the shareholder proposal to eliminate the staggered board passed; the advisory vote on executive compensation, however, was rejected by shareholders, with proxy adviser ISS having recommended a vote against mainly because of the separation terms given to Dunn. The same day the compensation committee granted retention awards to four senior executives. [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-06-21)] [Best Buy 8-K(2012-06-21)] [Best Buy 8-K(2012-06-25)]
  13. MPR: board and founder both appear to be preparing for battle MPR reported that Wall Street sources said Schulze was studying a buyout plan with Credit Suisse; an earlier Wall Street Journal report on the subject had at one point sent the share price jumping about 15%. Analysts regarded both the bylaw amendment and the retention awards as defensive moves by the board, and estimated that a buyout group would have to borrow US$8 billion to US$12 billion. [MPR News(2012-07-02)]
  14. Schulze publicly proposes a buyout at US$24 to US$26 per share to take the company private Schulze wrote to chairman Tyabji and made the letter public: he would buy the shares he did not own for US$24 to US$26 per share in cash, 36% to 47% above the August 3 closing price of US$17.64; the funding would come from private equity funds, his own stake worth about US$1 billion and debt, with Credit Suisse stating it was "highly confident" of raising the debt financing. He said he had spoken with members of the old team including Anderson and Lenzmeier, but that under Minnesota state law he needed the board's consent before he could team up with partners. [Schulze 致董事會信(2012-08-06)] [Schulze 新聞稿(2012-08-06)]
  15. Company responds: an unsolicited and highly conditional indication of interest Best Buy confirmed receipt of the letter, calling it an unsolicited and highly conditional indication of interest, and said the board would review it "in due course" with its financial and legal advisers. The share price closed at US$19.99 that day, up 13%, with an intraday high of US$21.60, never reaching US$24; two credit rating agencies cut Best Buy to below investment grade. [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-08-06)] [MPR News(2012-08-06)]
  16. Schulze's second open letter: I am not going away Schulze wrote to the board again, saying that if he were allowed to conduct due diligence and form a group, it could be verified whether the proposal was for real; he was willing to commit at least US$1 billion of his stake, possibly all of it, and made clear that as the largest shareholder he would not stand idly by. The company responded that state law did not prevent him from talking with private equity funds, and that submitting a proposal naming his partners did not require board consent either. [Schulze 致董事會信(2012-08-16)] [AP(2012-08-16,MPR News 刊登)]
  17. Board meets, authorizes advisers to negotiate a cooperation agreement with Schulze On Friday the board met to assess Schulze's indication of interest and authorized its advisers to negotiate a cooperation agreement with him: the company would provide financial, operating and legal information and waive the state-law restriction so that he could team up with private equity funds, on condition that he accept a standstill provision. The two sides negotiated throughout the weekend. [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-08-19)]
  18. Company announces: due diligence proposal offered, Schulze refuses On Sunday Best Buy issued a press release saying the board's proposal included due diligence, a state-law waiver and the opportunity to make a fully financed offer within 60 days, and that it was willing to let him appeal directly to shareholders from January if the board rejected the offer, but Schulze had not accepted. The press release said that because he had so far not disclosed his funding sources and partners, the board had no basis on which to evaluate the indication of interest. [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-08-19)]
  19. Schulze hits back: board unilaterally broke off in the middle of talks Schulze issued a statement saying he was disappointed and surprised by the board's abrupt termination of negotiations: the board had initially demanded an 18-month standstill period, which he could not accept, and while the two sides were negotiating an acceptable period, the company made a public announcement without notifying him or his advisers. He said he still hoped the board would return to the table. [Schulze 聲明(2012-08-20,SEC 13D/A 附件 F)]
  20. Board hires Hubert Joly as CEO The same day, Best Buy announced it had hired Hubert Joly, CEO of the hotel and travel group Carlson, as president and CEO and a member of the board, expected to start in early September once his work permit came through. Schulze responded that Joly was an accomplished executive, but the company needed a team that knew retail and knew Best Buy, and he would continue to pursue the buyout. [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-08-20)] [Schulze 聲明(2012-08-20,SEC 13D/A 附件 G)]
  21. The two sides sign a confidentiality agreement: due diligence opened in exchange for a standstill provision Best Buy and Schulze signed an agreement (announced on the 27th): he and his advisers, private equity partners and financing banks could review non-public information immediately, and the company waived the state-law restriction; he had to make a fully financed offer within 60 days of the start of due diligence and accept a one-year standstill provision. The board separately promised him two board seats in proportion to his stake. On the 27th the share price rose about 3% to close at US$17.87, still far below the price he had named. [Best Buy 8-K(2012-08-27)] [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-08-27)] [MPR News(2012-08-27)]
  22. Joly takes office With his US work permit approved, Joly formally took office as president and CEO and joined the board. Mikan stepped down as interim CEO, returning to being a director and taking over as audit committee chairman; Tyabji stayed on the audit committee but left the compensation committee. [Best Buy 8-K(2012-09-04)]
  23. Reuters: four private equity funds are examining the books Reuters, citing sources, reported that Cerberus, Apollo, Leonard Green and TPG were reviewing Best Buy's books together with Schulze, and that a new offer could be worth US$11 billion, with terms not yet settled. The share price rose more than 3% in early trading that day. [InvestorPlace(2012-10-03,引述 Reuters)]
  24. Joly and Schulze meet for the first time According to Fortune, Joly's attempts over several months to meet Schulze directly had all been rebuffed, and the two finally met only just before Thanksgiving. Joly handed Schulze his own résumé, as if he were still applying for the job; the person who brought the two together was Brad Anderson, who knew Joly well. [Fortune(2013-04-03)]
  25. Offer deadline extended to February 2013; share price falls nearly 16% in one day The two sides announced an amended agreement: Schulze would instead make his offer between February 1 and 28, 2013, so that the year-end holiday shopping season and full-year results could be taken into account; the standstill period was extended in step to October 31, 2013. The day before, the Star Tribune had reported that he would bid within the week, and the share price surged 16%; once news of the amendment came out, it fell 15.8% in early trading to US$11.88. [Best Buy 新聞稿(2012-12-14)] [Best Buy 8-K(2012-12-14)] [AP(2012-12-14,MPR News 刊登)]
  26. Two directors give notice of departure: Mikan resigns immediately, Paull schedules retirement for April Former interim CEO Mikan resigned from the board, effective immediately, to become president of ESL Investments. Lead independent director Paull gave notice under the company's director retirement policy that he would retire on April 20, 2013. The company said neither had expressed any disagreement with the company. [Best Buy 8-K(2012-12-31)]
  27. Days before the deadline, analysts are downbeat MPR reported that with only days left before the month-end deadline there was still no offer in sight. Edward Jones analyst Yarbrough said the longer it dragged on, the lower the odds of a bid; retail consultant Davidowitz said that if the money could not be borrowed, the reason would be that the company's fundamentals could not support that much debt. [MPR News(2013-02-23)]
  28. Deadline expires; Schulze makes no offer The offer period expired at the end of the day on February 28. Best Buy said the next day that it had received no offer and would continue to focus on its own transformation. [Best Buy 聲明(2013-03-01)] [Best Buy 8-K(2013-03-01)]
  29. Schulze filing: private equity funds had proposed taking stakes; company did not accept Schulze said in an SEC filing that over the past several months he had facilitated proposals by up to three private equity funds to take stakes, with each firm getting one board seat and him nominating two more; the company ultimately did not accept those terms. He wrote that the company deserved the chance to execute its own plan, and that he had not yet decided whether to exercise his right to nominate two directors. Reuters the same day cited sources as saying that what had been rejected was a minority equity investment totalling US$1 billion by Leonard Green, Cerberus and TPG. [Schulze 13D/A 第 8 次修正(2013-03-01)] [Reuters(2013-03-01,Fox Business 轉載)]
  30. Schulze returns as chairman emeritus; Anderson and Lenzmeier join the board Best Buy and Schulze jointly announced his return as "Founder and Chairman Emeritus", in support of Joly's Renew Blue transformation; his nominees Brad Anderson and Al Lenzmeier were elected directors by the board the same day. The agreement specified an annual salary of US$150,000, compensation of up to US$2.125 million for consulting on the operating plan over the following year, an office at headquarters for life, and the right to nominate two directors until age 75. The share price rose 1.6% that day to US$23.14. [Best Buy 新聞稿(2013-03-25)] [Best Buy 8-K(2013-03-25)] [協議信(2013-03-25,8-K 附件 99.2)] [Reuters(2013-03-25,Fox Business 轉載)]
  31. Compensation committee chairman James announces he will not stand for re-election; Fradin joins the board Director Ronald James notified the board that he would not seek re-election at the June 20 shareholder meeting, saying that with the new CEO and team in place it was a good time to leave. The same day the board elected SunGard CEO Russell Fradin as a new director; Anderson joined the finance and investment policy committee, and Lenzmeier joined the audit committee and the finance and investment policy committee. Paull retired three days later on the originally scheduled timetable. [Best Buy 8-K(2013-04-18)] [Best Buy 新聞稿(2013-04-18)]
  32. Tyabji announces retirement, Joly to become chairman as well; Lenzmeier and Khosla leave at the same time Best Buy announced that chairman Tyabji would retire at the June 9 shareholder meeting, with Joly taking on the chairmanship as well and Fradin becoming lead independent director; Khosla and Schulze's nominee Lenzmeier also retired the same day. Schulze notified the company that he would not nominate a replacement. In his farewell letter Tyabji recalled that it was Schulze who invited him onto the board in 1998, and thanked him for his trust and friendship. [Best Buy 8-K(2015-04-13)] [Best Buy 新聞稿(2015-04-13)] [Tyabji 致股東信(2015-04-13)]
  33. Anderson announces retirement; Schulze's right to nominate directors has expired Best Buy announced that Brad Anderson would serve until the June 14 shareholder meeting. Company filings stated that Schulze's right to nominate two directors lasted until he turned 75, and he had turned 75 in January 2016; that year's proxy statement recorded his stake at about 13.6%. [Best Buy 8-K(2016-03-15)] [Best Buy 新聞稿(2016-03-15)] [Best Buy 2016 年委託書(DEF 14A)]

People

Moves to block a return

Rumors

Views

Photos & videos