Dov Charney (Dov Charney) — American Apparel (American Apparel)
American Apparel founder and CEO Dov Charney was suspended and removed as chairman by his own board on June 18, 2014, the day of the annual shareholder meeting. He borrowed from hedge fund Standard General to raise his stake to about 43%, and the board promptly adopted a poison pill. In July the sides signed a standstill and support agreement: five of the seven directors (including Charney) stepped down and were replaced, but his voting rights were tied up and the question of his reinstatement was handed to a newly formed Suitability Committee. In December 2014 the reconstituted board fired him for cause anyway, and then used a second poison pill, a temporary restraining order from the Delaware court, a settlement with his ally and the bankruptcy process to block every one of his attempts to return. The company filed for bankruptcy in October 2015; in January 2016 the court approved handing it to bondholders, wiping out his stake. It went bankrupt a second time in November 2016 and the brand was sold to Gildan. He went on to found Los Angeles Apparel and, unable to repay what he had borrowed from Standard General, filed for personal bankruptcy in 2022.
How they were ousted
On 2014-06-18 the board removed him as chairman, suspended him immediately and gave notice that it would terminate him as CEO for cause after a 30-day cure period. On 2014-12-15 the new board voted to fire him formally.
What happened to the board
In favor of the thesis: of the seven-member board that ousted him in June 2014, four of the six directors other than Charney himself (Robert Greene, Marvin Igelman, William Mauer and Alberto Chehebar) resigned on 2014-08-02, about a month and a half later, under the agreement he and Standard General brought about. Interim CEO John Luttrell also resigned on 2014-09-29. David Danziger, the co-chairman who led the move, resigned as a director on 2015-06-14, and the other co-chairman, Allan Mayer, was no longer on the board by early 2016, when the company emerged from bankruptcy and the board was completely reconstituted. Against the thesis: this was not a case of "he came back and settled scores"—he never came back. Mayer and Danziger stayed on after the shake-up and kept leading; the new board (most of it appointed or jointly approved by Standard General) instead voted on 2014-12-15 to fire him formally and kept blocking him for more than a year afterward. In the end the board and shareholders alike were wiped out in bankruptcy, and the company fell into creditors' hands.
Timeline
- Company press release: Mayer and Danziger named co-chairmen, Luttrell interim CEO The press release announced that Allan Mayer and David Danziger would serve as co-chairmen and CFO John Luttrell would also serve as interim CEO, and that a search firm had been retained to find a permanent CEO. Mayer said the board took no joy in the decision but believed it was the right thing to do, and that the company had grown bigger than any one individual. [American Apparel 新聞稿(SEC 附件 99.1)]
- Ousting him could itself put the company in default 8-K disclosure: under the credit agreement with Lion Capital, Charney ceasing to be CEO constituted an event of default, which would in turn trigger a default under the Capital One credit facility. The company was seeking waivers from both lenders and warned that if it were required to repay early, it could be forced into bankruptcy. [SEC 8-K(2014-06-18)]
- On the day of the annual meeting, the board moves against the founder The company's 2014 annual meeting was scheduled for 11 a.m. at the New York offices of law firm Skadden. Greene, Mayer and Danziger were standing for reelection, and Charney had said beforehand that he would vote for them. That same day, the board voted to remove Charney as chairman, suspend him immediately and give notice that it would terminate him as CEO for cause after a 30-day cure period. [American Apparel 2014 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [SEC 8-K(2014-06-18)]
- Charney files for arbitration over his suspension The company's annual report states that Charney filed a demand for arbitration over his suspension on or about June 23. The arbitration was stayed after the standstill agreement was signed, and the stay was lifted only when he was formally fired. Through his lawyers he also argued that the termination was unlawful and demanded reinstatement. [American Apparel 2014 年度 10-K] [Wikipedia:American Apparel]
- Charney signs a letter of intent with Standard General Charney signed a letter agreement with hedge fund Standard General under which it would finance his purchase of additional shares. The company's poison pill press release three days later specifically stated that on the strength of this June 25 letter alone he would not be deemed the beneficial owner of the shares held by Standard General, but that he would be if loan documents or a cooperation agreement were signed. [American Apparel 新聞稿(SEC 附件 99.1,2014-06-28)]
- The board adopts a poison pill A special committee of the board adopted a one-year shareholder rights plan: triggered by an acquisition of 15%, or by a further 1% increase for anyone already above 15%. The rights had an exercise price of $2.75 and would expire at 5 p.m. New York time on 2015-06-27. The company said the aim was to prevent anyone from gaining control through "creeping" acquisitions. [American Apparel 新聞稿(SEC 附件 99.1,2014-06-28)]
- Standstill and support agreement: board overhauled, Charney leaves the board After the market closed, the company announced an agreement with Standard General: the fund would provide up to $25 million in financing; five of the seven directors (including Charney) would step down voluntarily, with co-chairmen Mayer and Danziger staying on; Standard General would appoint three directors and the other two would be chosen jointly. Charney would become a strategic consultant while a newly formed independent committee completed its investigation and decided whether he could return. [American Apparel 新聞稿(SEC 附件 99.1,2014-07-09)] [BuzzFeed News]
- Stake raised to about 43%, but voting rights tied up With Standard General's loan, Charney raised his holding to 74,560,813 shares, about 42.81%, but the cooperation agreement signed the same day provided that those shares could not be voted without the written consent of both parties. BuzzFeed reported that he had wanted to reach 51% but was stopped by the board's poison pill. Lion Capital, meanwhile, demanded early repayment of a $10 million loan because his removal had triggered a default. [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明] [BuzzFeed News]
- Shareholder Bigger Capital calls on Mayer and Danziger to resign Investors including Bigger Capital Fund wrote to the board and went public with a demand that the two remaining co-chairmen resign immediately, arguing that they bore direct responsibility for the loss of company value and damage to its reputation and had lost shareholders' confidence. Neither resigned. [Retail Dive]
- Information statement mailed; new directors' names revealed The company mailed its Schedule 14F-1. Those resigning were Charney, Alberto Chehebar, Robert Greene, Marvin Igelman and William Mauer; the new directors were David Glazek and Thomas Sullivan (appointed by Standard General) and Colleen Brown and Joseph Magnacca (jointly approved), with one more Standard General designee to be named. The document also stated that the Suitability Committee would consist of Danziger, one Standard General-appointed director and one jointly chosen director. [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明]
- Five directors' resignations take effect; new directors seated The five directors' resignations took effect on this day, and Brown, Glazek, Sullivan and Magnacca took their seats the same day. Of the six directors who had ousted Charney, only Mayer and Danziger remained. [American Apparel 2014 年度 10-K] [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- Standard General's third designee, Laura Lee, takes her seat Laura A. Lee filled the third appointment slot reserved for Standard General and joined the board on this day. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- Interim CEO Luttrell resigns; a restructuring adviser steps in The company announced the resignation of interim CEO and CFO John Luttrell without giving a reason. Scott Brubaker, 43, a managing director at Alvarez & Marsal, became interim CEO, and Hassan Natha, 55, became CFO. The investigation into Charney was still under way, and he was awaiting the outcome as a consultant. [BuzzFeed News(2014-09-29)]
- The new board votes: formally fired After 27 meetings, the Suitability Committee concluded that Charney should not be reinstated as CEO or serve as any officer or employee. The board then voted to terminate him for cause under his employment agreement and to end the consulting relationship. The committee was dissolved once the investigation concluded. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- Company announces Charney's firing; Paula Schneider named CEO The company announced that it had fired its founder for cause and named Paula Schneider CEO, effective January 5. The grounds the company formally cited included violations of company policy and misuse of corporate assets. Charney has consistently denied them, and his lawyer called the investigation a sham. The stock closed that day at 58 cents. [CBS News(AP)] [BuzzFeed News]
- Irving Place Capital bid surfaces; stock jumps 45% in a day The Wall Street Journal reported that private equity firm Irving Place Capital was interested in a buyout: its first offer was rejected as too low, it then raised the offer to $1.30–$1.40 a share, and the board had not yet responded. The stock rose from $0.69 to $1.00 that day. The report also said Charney might sue over his firing, which would complicate a sale. [Fortune(Reuters,2014-12-18)] [International Business Times]
- The board adopts a second poison pill On a Sunday the board adopted a new one-year shareholder rights plan; Reuters reported a trigger threshold of 10%. [Yahoo Finance(Reuters)] [American Apparel 2014 年度 10-K]
- Colleen Brown becomes chairperson; company confirms it received a buyout proposal The company announced that Colleen Brown would become chairperson; Mayer and Danziger stepped down as co-chairmen but remained directors, continuing to chair the compensation and audit committees respectively. The company also confirmed it was evaluating a buyout proposal at $1.30–$1.40 a share (about $226 million to $243 million) but did not name the bidder. [Yahoo Finance(Reuters)] [Print & Promo Marketing] [MR Magazine]
- Charney says Standard General betrayed him; Fortune: the bidder would not make him CEO In an interview with Bloomberg, Charney said Standard General had betrayed him by not returning him to a leadership position after the investigation, and that he was down to his last $100,000. Standard General denied it. The same day, Fortune reported that Irving Place's bid was not made in partnership with Charney and that if a deal went through he would not return as CEO or hold a management role—a consultant at most. [Fortune(2014-12-22)] [Retail Dive] [Wikipedia:Dov Charney]
- Paula Schneider takes office as CEO Schneider formally took up the post as the company's first female CEO. With Brown as chairperson, media described the company as now led by women. [Wikipedia:American Apparel] [MR Magazine]
- Lyndon Lea of lender Lion Capital joins the board Lyndon Lea, the director designated by Lion under its investment agreement, took his seat. A Lion designee had already joined on 2014-09-15 (Robert Mintz, who resigned on 2015-03-06 and was replaced by Jeff Chang on March 24). The board expanded to nine seats, seven of them filled only after July 2014. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [American Apparel 2014 年度 10-K]
- Schneider writes to workers: outside forces are trying to cause trouble The CEO emailed workers in Spanish, saying their jobs were secure and warning that outside forces were trying to cause trouble and disrupt the company's business. [BuzzFeed News]
- Charney addresses more than 300 workers in a South Los Angeles backyard More than 300 current and former factory workers (many of them also shareholders) gathered in the backyard of a home in South Los Angeles. Speaking through a Spanish interpreter, Charney recounted the events of the summer of 2014, said he had trusted Standard General only to have it install a compliant board, and urged the workers to unite and organize. Immigrant rights group Hermandad Mexicana was on hand to sign people up, and a workers' coalition was formed. [BuzzFeed News] [Refinery29]
- Charney seeks $40 million over his termination Three months after being fired, Charney revived his claim against the company, seeking about $40 million for breach of contract and wrongful termination, including $6 million in severance, $1.3 million in unused vacation pay and at least $10 million for emotional distress. The company said his claims were baseless. The sources found do not say how this claim was ultimately resolved. [Retail Dive] [Fortune(2015-05-14)]
- Charney sues Standard General, then the company and its chairperson, for defamation Fortune reported that in early May Charney first sued Standard General for defamation, seeking up to $30 million and arguing that it had falsely claimed he was fired for cause when the investigation was a sham. That week he also sued the company and chairperson Colleen Brown, seeking more than $20 million, over Brown's letter to all employees. The company responded that the claims had no merit in fact or law; Standard General denied the allegations. [Fortune(2015-05-14)]
- Company sues Charney in Delaware for violating the standstill agreement The company asked the Delaware Court of Chancery for a temporary restraining order to stop Charney from violating the standstill agreement. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- Court issues temporary restraining order: no removing directors, no criticizing the company The Delaware Court of Chancery issued a temporary restraining order barring Charney from seeking to remove directors or making public statements disparaging the company and its employees. His lawyer, Stephen Brauerman, said he would comply fully but stressed that it was only a preliminary order and did not affect his other lawsuits against the company. [Investing.com(Reuters)] [ASI Central]
- Charney agrees to extend the restrictions through the annual meeting Charney agreed that the restraining order's restrictions would remain in place until the conclusion of the 2015 annual meeting. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- Company settles with Kolb, a shareholder allied with Charney Shareholder Jeffrey Kolb, who had threatened to seek board seats, signed a letter agreement with the company and withdrew his nominations and proposals. The company agreed to form an advisory committee to assist the CEO and to use its best efforts to add an independent director before the 2016 annual meeting. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [The Irish Times(Bloomberg)]
- Danziger, who led the ouster, resigns from the board Former co-chairman David Danziger resigned as a director, and CEO Paula Schneider filled his seat. That left Allan Mayer as the only director from the June 2014 ouster of Charney still on the board. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [The Irish Times(Bloomberg)]
- 2015 annual meeting: the largest shareholder can't vote freely The annual meeting was held in Chicago, with three seats up for election: Laura Lee, Thomas Sullivan and Lyndon Lea. Charney still held about 41.4% but under the agreements could not vote on his own; Standard General said it would consent only to his supporting the proposals recommended by the board. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- Court rejects Charney's request for advancement of legal fees Chancellor Bouchard of the Delaware Court of Chancery ruled that the company did not have to advance Charney's costs in the standstill agreement litigation: the alleged breaches had no causal connection to his role as an officer, and the charter did not protect former officers. [Potter Anderson(判決摘要)]
- American Apparel files for bankruptcy protection The company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in Delaware, having already signed a restructuring support agreement with lenders holding 95% of its secured debt: a debt-for-equity swap, debt cut from about $300 million to no more than $135 million, and $90 million in bankruptcy financing from the lenders. Stores and factories kept operating as usual. The stock closed at 11.2 cents on October 2. [Retail TouchPoints] [Wikipedia:American Apparel]
- Investors backing Charney submit a $300 million takeover bid Hagan Capital Group and Silver Creek Capital Partners submitted a roughly $300 million proposal, including $90 million in new equity and a $40 million term loan, built on Charney's operating plan. The same day, the company announced that every class of creditors had voted for its own plan and raised the recovery for unsecured creditors to $2.5 million. [MarketScreener(Reuters)]
- Media report: board rejects $300 million bid Retail Dive, citing Bloomberg sources, reported that the board had rejected the bid, even though it exceeded the $180 million to $270 million valuation range the company had itself given in court filings. Judge Shannon, meanwhile, wrote that witnesses for Charney's side would be allowed to appear at the January 20 hearing. [Retail Dive]
- Charney testifies in bankruptcy court On the second day of a two-day hearing (Schneider testified on January 20), Charney testified for about two hours, saying his original departure had been "extortion" and that his repeated attempts to regain control had been blocked by a board that was "impossible to communicate with." The company's lawyers did not cross-examine him. [HeraldNet] [Fortune(Reuters)]
- Bankruptcy court approves the company's plan; Charney is out Judge Brendan Shannon approved the company's reorganization plan and rejected Charney's objections: the company would be delisted and taken over by bondholders including Monarch Alternative Capital, with shareholders wiped out entirely. Charney said he was disappointed but did not plan to appeal because he lacked the money; he would continue his other lawsuits against the company and Standard General. [Fortune(Reuters)] [HeraldNet] [Retail TouchPoints]
- Company exits bankruptcy as a private company (date of report) ASI reported on February 8 that the company had emerged from Chapter 11: about $230 million of debt was converted to equity, it obtained $40 million in exit financing and a $40 million credit line, and it was reorganized as American Apparel, LLC, controlled by bondholders including Monarch. The sources consulted do not give the exact date of emergence. [ASI Central(2016-02-08)] [Retail & Restaurant Facility Business]
- Board completely reconstituted: Schneider the only old director left ASI reported that the seven-member post-bankruptcy board was chaired by former Liz Claiborne CEO Paul Charron, with two other new directors, Susan Davidson and Bruce Fetter, and three bondholder representatives. Of the old board, only CEO Schneider remained. [ASI Central(2016-03-31)]
- Schneider resigns as CEO Media reported that Paula Schneider had resigned, effective October 3. In her resignation letter she said the company was seeking a buyer for some or all of its assets, which might make the turnaround plan impossible to carry out. Chief administrative officer Chelsea Grayson took over. [PYMNTS]
- Second bankruptcy filing in 13 months; Gildan bids for the brand American Apparel filed for Chapter 11 again. Canadian apparel maker Gildan Activewear agreed to buy the brand's intellectual property and certain assets for about $66 million in cash, serving as the floor bid for an auction. [Retail TouchPoints]
- Gildan wins the brand for $88 million (date of report) Gildan acquired the American Apparel brand at the bankruptcy auction for $88 million and bought inventory for about $15 million more. The 110 U.S. stores were not part of the deal, and analysts expected most to close. The transaction closed in February 2017, and about 3,500 workers at the Los Angeles factories were laid off. [The Fader] [ASI Central(2018-10-24)]
- California appeals court upholds dismissal: defamation suit against Standard General fails (date a law firm summary was published) Charney v. Standard General (10 Cal. App. 5th 149, 2017): the trial court granted Standard General's anti-SLAPP motion and dismissed the suit. The appeals court affirmed, finding that the fund's press release saying it "supported the investigation and respected the board's decision" did not accuse him of a crime and could not be proven false. [Proskauer 加州勞動法部落格]
- Charney appeals the judgment ordering him to repay nearly $20 million Standard General sued in Delaware in July 2015 for repayment. In December 2017 Chancellor Bouchard of the Court of Chancery ruled that Charney must repay nearly $20 million plus interest, finding that the oral promises he alleged contradicted the eight written agreements he had signed and could not reasonably be relied on. On this day Charney's lawyers filed their appeal brief with the state Supreme Court. [ASI Central(2018-03)]
- Delaware Supreme Court upholds the ruling (date of report) ASI reported that the state Supreme Court had upheld the judgment requiring Charney to repay Standard General's $19.5 million loan. Charney said he would keep fighting in California, where he was arguing that the agreements were void for fraud. His new company, Los Angeles Apparel, had about 400 employees at the time. [ASI Central(2018-10-24)]
- Charney files for personal bankruptcy (date of report) ASI reported that Charney had filed for personal bankruptcy in Delaware bankruptcy court the previous week, listing assets and liabilities of up to $50 million each. The main cause was his debt to Standard General, about $30 million including interest. The report said he was not the owner of Los Angeles Apparel and that its operations were unaffected. [ASI Central(2022-03-14)]
People
- Dov Charney (Dov Charney), 1969-01-31 — Founder, chairman and CEO (the one ousted). Born in Montreal, Canada. Attended Choate Rosemary Hall, a boarding school in Connecticut, and dropped out of Tufts University in 1990. Began selling T-shirts under the American Apparel name in 1989, starting the business with $10,000 borrowed from his parents. By 1997 he had moved all manufacturing to downtown Los Angeles, building the brand on made-in-USA, sweatshop-free production. He founded the company and served as chairman and CEO after it went public through a reverse merger on 2007-12-12. He held about 27% before the ouster. Most of the directors at the time had joined the board during his tenure: Robert Greene was a consultant he brought in in 2001, and Allan Mayer and Greene had been directors since the 2007 listing. Media described it as a board he had handpicked, one that had never before moved against him. Formally fired on 2014-12-15; never reinstated. Founded Los Angeles Apparel in 2016. In December 2017 a Delaware court ruled that he must repay the $19.5 million in principal he had borrowed from Standard General, plus interest; the state Supreme Court upheld the ruling, and he filed for personal bankruptcy in March 2022. [Wikipedia:Dov Charney] [American Apparel 2014 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [BuzzFeed News] [ASI Central(2022-03-14)] [ASI Central(2018-10-24)]
- Allan Mayer (Allan Mayer) — Lead independent director, chairman of the compensation committee; co-chairman from 2014-06-18. Listed as 64 in the 2014 proxy statement. A principal partner at public relations firm 42West (from 2006); previously at crisis PR firm Sitrick and Company, and before that a journalist and author. Bachelor's degree from Cornell University. A director since the company went public on 2007-12-12; one of the longest-serving independent directors on the board. Joined the board at the same time as Charney and worked with him for nearly seven years; he and Robert Greene were both veteran directors dating from 2007. The sources found say nothing about any personal ties beyond that. Stayed on in the July 2014 shake-up. On 2014-12-22 he handed the co-chairmanship to Colleen Brown while remaining a director and chairman of the compensation committee; he was still serving as of the June 2015 proxy statement (term running to 2017). He was not on the list after the board was completely reconstituted when the company emerged from bankruptcy in early 2016; the exact date of his departure could not be found. [American Apparel 2014 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明] [MR Magazine] [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [ASI Central(2016-03-31)]
- David Danziger (David Danziger) — Independent director, chairman of the audit committee; co-chairman from 2014-06-18. Listed as 57 in the 2014 proxy statement. Senior vice president of assurance services at Canadian accounting firm MNP LLP (formerly MSCM LLP); a chartered professional accountant with more than 25 years of audit and advisory experience. Bachelor of Commerce from the University of Toronto. Elected a director by the board on 2011-06-24; also served as chairman of the audit committee. Elected by the board on the same day (2011-06-24) as Marvin Igelman. The standstill agreement designated him as one of the members of the Suitability Committee. The sources found say nothing about personal ties to Charney. Stayed on in the July 2014 shake-up and gave up the co-chairmanship on 2014-12-22. He resigned as a director on 2015-06-14 and his seat was filled by CEO Paula Schneider; media described this as part of board changes following the company's settlement with shareholder Jeffrey Kolb. [American Apparel 2014 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明] [The Irish Times(Bloomberg)] [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- Robert Greene (Robert Greene), 1959-05-14 — Director, chairman of the nominating and corporate governance committee; member of the board's special committee. Born in Los Angeles. Bachelor's degree in classics from the University of Wisconsin–Madison. Author of the bestseller The 48 Laws of Power; formerly an editor and Hollywood screenwriter. Charney had read his book, sought him out in 2001 and hired him as a consultant. He joined the board (2007-12-12) after helping the company go public in 2007, and was described as its in-house strategist. He and Charney had a consultant-and-boss relationship lasting more than a decade. Yet in June 2014 he was one of the three members of the board's special committee that adopted the poison pill and oversaw the investigation (the other two were Igelman and Mauer). Resigned as a director under the July 2014 standstill and support agreement, effective 2014-08-02—just a month and a half after the annual meeting at which he was reelected to a three-year term. He went on writing; he suffered a stroke before the publication of a new book in 2018. [Wikipedia:Robert Greene] [American Apparel 2014 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [American Apparel 新聞稿(2014-07-09)] [American Apparel 2014 年度 10-K]
- Marvin Igelman (Marvin Igelman) — Director, member of the audit committee; member of the board's special committee. Listed as 51 in the 2014 proxy statement. Formerly chief strategy officer of Poynt Corporation and CEO of Unomobi Incorporated. Elected by the board on 2011-06-24, effective 2011-07-01. Elected by the board on the same day as David Danziger. The sources found say nothing about personal ties to Charney. Resigned as a director under the standstill and support agreement, effective 2014-08-02. No information was found on what he did afterward. [American Apparel 2014 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明] [American Apparel 新聞稿(2014-07-09)]
- William Mauer (William Mauer) — Director, member of the audit, compensation and nominating committees; member of the board's special committee. Listed as 72 in the 2014 proxy statement. Senior partner at law firm Lapin Mauer since 1986, specializing in real estate and financial transactions. Appointed a director on 2011-11-28. The sources found say nothing about personal ties to Charney. Resigned as a director under the standstill and support agreement, effective 2014-08-02. No information was found on what he did afterward. [American Apparel 2014 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明] [American Apparel 新聞稿(2014-07-09)]
- Alberto Chehebar (Alberto Chehebar) — Director, member of the nominating and corporate governance committee. Listed as 45 in the 2014 proxy statement. Founder and director of Stilotex S.A.; partner and director of Colombian retail chain Pepe Ganga and of Blu Logistics. Appointed a director on 2012-02-17. The sources found say nothing about personal ties to Charney, and there is no public information confirming his individual position in the 2014-06-18 vote, so his stance is marked as neutral. Resigned as a director under the standstill and support agreement, effective 2014-08-02. No information was found on what he did afterward. [American Apparel 2014 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明]
- John Luttrell (John Luttrell) — Executive vice president and CFO; also interim CEO from 2014-06-18. Listed as 59 in the July 2014 information statement. Formerly CFO of Old Navy, The Wet Seal and Cost Plus. Joined in February 2011 as executive vice president and CFO. The board named him interim CEO the day Charney was suspended, raising his monthly salary from $36,750 to $62,500 and granting him 350,000 shares. CFO during Charney's tenure. On 2014-09-29 the company announced his resignation without giving a reason. Scott Brubaker of consulting firm Alvarez & Marsal took over as interim CEO, and Hassan Natha became CFO. [SEC 8-K(2014-06-18)] [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明] [BuzzFeed News(2014-09-29)]
- Soo Kim (Soohyung Kim) (Soohyung Kim) — Co-founder, managing partner and chief investment officer of hedge fund Standard General. Co-founded Standard General in New York with Nicholas Singer in 2007; managing partner and chief investment officer from 2013. Formerly CEO of ALST Casino Holdco and a director of Media General. Not a director of American Apparel. Standard General lent Charney money to increase his stake in late June 2014, then in July provided the company with up to $25 million in financing in exchange for the right to appoint three directors and jointly choose two more. After his suspension, Charney turned to Standard General as his backer, pledging his shares and voting rights to it. Standard General later said publicly that it supported the investigation and respected the board's decision to fire him. Charney accused it of betrayal, and the two sides sued each other for years. Standard General prevailed in Delaware: in December 2017 the Court of Chancery ruled that Charney must repay $19.5 million plus interest, and the state Supreme Court upheld the ruling in 2018. Kim himself joined the board of casino operator Twin River in 2016 and was elected chairman in late 2019. [Wikipedia:Standard General(Soohyung Kim 條目轉址)] [American Apparel 新聞稿(2014-07-09)] [BuzzFeed News] [ASI Central(2018-10-24)]
- David Glazek (David Glazek) — Director from 2014-08-02 (appointed by Standard General; the only new director affiliated with the fund). Listed as 36 in the July 2014 information statement. Joined Standard General in 2008 and became a partner in 2012; formerly an investment banker at Lazard and a lawyer at Weil, Gotshal & Manges. J.D. from Columbia Law School. Appointed by Standard General under the standstill and support agreement; took his seat on 2014-08-02. A partner at Standard General and the representative of Charney's financial backer on the board; the board he sat on voted to fire Charney on 2014-12-15. Still serving as of the June 2015 proxy statement (term running to 2017). The sources found do not say whether he stayed on after the board was reconstituted when the company emerged from bankruptcy in early 2016. [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明] [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- Colleen Brown (Colleen B. Brown) — Director from 2014-08-02 (jointly approved by the company and Standard General); chairperson from 2014-12-22. Listed as 55 in the July 2014 information statement. President and CEO of Fisher Communications from 2005 to 2013; formerly a senior vice president at Belo Corporation. MBA from the University of Colorado. American Apparel's first female director. Took her seat on 2014-08-02 under the standstill and support agreement, after being jointly approved by Standard General and the previous board. On 2014-12-22 she succeeded Mayer and Danziger as chairperson. Joined the company only after the ouster and had no prior relationship with Charney. On April 24, 2015, she wrote to all employees saying Charney had agreed in writing not to return to the company. Charney denied this and sued her and the company for defamation over it, seeking more than $20 million. Served as chairperson until the company's bankruptcy reorganization. When the company emerged from bankruptcy in early 2016, former Liz Claiborne CEO Paul Charron became chairman, and she was not on the new board. The exact date of her departure could not be found. [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明] [MR Magazine] [Fortune(2015-05-14)] [ASI Central(2016-03-31)]
- Thomas Sullivan (Thomas J. Sullivan) — Director from 2014-08-02 (appointed by Standard General). Listed as 51 in the July 2014 information statement. Managing partner of Smallwood Partners from 2009 and a director of Media General from November 2013; formerly executive chairman of New Young Broadcasting and a managing director at Investcorp. Appointed by Standard General under the standstill and support agreement; took his seat on 2014-08-02. Served on Media General's board alongside Standard General's Soohyung Kim. No prior relationship with Charney was found. Nominated for reelection to a three-year term at the July 2015 annual meeting. The sources found do not say whether he stayed on after the company emerged from bankruptcy in early 2016. [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明] [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [Wikipedia:Standard General(Soohyung Kim 條目轉址)]
- Joseph Magnacca (Joseph Magnacca) — Director from 2014-08-02 (jointly approved by the company and Standard General). Listed as 52 in the July 2014 information statement. CEO and director of RadioShack from February 2013; previously held senior executive posts at Walgreens, Duane Reade and Shoppers Drug Mart. Took his seat on 2014-08-02 under the standstill and support agreement, after being jointly approved by Standard General and the previous board. Joined the company only after the ouster; no prior relationship with Charney was found. Still serving as of the June 2015 proxy statement (term running to 2016). No information was found on what he did afterward. [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明] [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- Laura Lee (Laura A. Lee) — Director from 2014-08-08 (appointed by Standard General). Listed as 39 in the 2015 proxy statement. Nothing else about her education or career appeared in the sources consulted. Filled the third appointment slot reserved for Standard General under the agreement; took her seat on 2014-08-08, six days after the other new directors. No prior relationship with Charney was found. Nominated for reelection to a three-year term at the July 2015 annual meeting. The sources found do not say whether he stayed on after the company emerged from bankruptcy in early 2016. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- Paula Schneider (Paula Schneider) — Successor CEO (took office 2015-01-05); also a director from 2015-06-14. Listed as 57 in the 2015 proxy statement. A veteran apparel executive who held senior posts at Warnaco, Gores Group and BCBG Max Azria; president of ESP Group before her appointment. The first female CEO in the company's history. The board named her CEO on 2014-12-16, when it announced Charney's firing; she took office on 2015-01-05. On 2015-06-14 she filled Danziger's board seat. No prior relationship with Charney. Charney said he had actually supported hiring her, and claimed he had turned down terms the board offered him to stay on because it would not immediately give the incoming CEO a board seat. The two later clashed across the board—over the workers, in litigation and in bankruptcy court. Stayed on as CEO and director after the company emerged from bankruptcy. She submitted her resignation in September 2016, effective October 3; her resignation letter said the company's search for a buyer made it impossible for her to carry out her turnaround plan. Chelsea Grayson took over. [CBS News(AP)] [Wikipedia:American Apparel] [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [International Business Times] [PYMNTS]
Moves to block a return
- On the day of the annual shareholder meeting, the board removed him as chairman, suspended him immediately, gave notice that it would terminate him for cause after a 30-day cure period, and said it would then ask him to resign as a director. A later analysis by Harvard's Program on Negotiation says the board had offered him two options: give up his roughly 27% stake in exchange for a multimillion-dollar severance package and a four-year consulting contract, or be fired for misconduct. He rejected both. [SEC 8-K(2014-06-18)] [American Apparel 新聞稿(SEC 附件 99.1)] [Harvard Program on Negotiation]
- A special committee of the board adopted a one-year shareholder rights plan (poison pill): it would be triggered by any person or group acquiring 15% or more, and for anyone already holding 15% or more (that is, Charney) by an increase of just 1%. The press release named him directly, saying the purpose was to limit the ability of any person, including Charney, to seize control without appropriately compensating all shareholders. Expiration date: 2015-06-27. [American Apparel 新聞稿(SEC 附件 99.1,2014-06-28)] [BuzzFeed News]
- The company signed a nomination, standstill and support agreement with Standard General and Charney: Charney would leave the board, and neither the company nor Standard General would nominate him as a director again. Until the 2015 annual meeting, Standard General and Charney could not add to their holdings, solicit proxies or seek the removal of directors; their voting power was capped at one-third, with any excess to be voted in proportion to other shareholders' votes. Whether he could return as CEO or in any other role would be decided entirely by a newly formed independent committee (the Suitability Committee) based on the results of an investigation. [American Apparel 新聞稿(SEC 附件 99.1,2014-07-09)] [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明]
- (Counterparty: Standard General) Under a cooperation agreement signed the same day, neither Charney nor Standard General could vote the 74,560,813 shares in his name (about 42.81%) without the written consent of both. Those shares were also the collateral for his loan from Standard General. In effect, the shares he had bought could not be used to elect a new board. [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明] [Yahoo Finance(Reuters)]
- The information statement spelled out the restrictions during the investigation: he would receive only base salary as a consultant, have no supervisory authority over employees, and agreed not to interfere with the investigation or access the company's computer systems. He could not serve as CEO or as any officer or employee until the investigation was complete and the Suitability Committee had made a finding in his favor. [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明]
- After the Suitability Committee (which met 27 times over the period) concluded that he should not be reinstated as CEO or serve as any officer or employee, the board voted to terminate him for cause under his employment agreement and ended the consulting relationship as well. The decision was announced on December 16, along with the appointment of Paula Schneider as CEO. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [CBS News(AP)]
- Buyout proposal from private equity firm Irving Place Capital: the first offer (about $1 a share, according to media citing The Wall Street Journal) was rejected by the board as too low. After it was raised to $1.30–$1.40 a share, the board said only that it was "evaluating" the offer and never accepted. Media reported at the time that Charney was looking for a financial partner to return to the company, but Fortune reported that the offer was not made in partnership with him and would not have restored him as CEO. [Fortune(Reuters,2014-12-18)] [International Business Times] [Fortune(2014-12-22)]
- Five days after firing him, the board adopted another new one-year shareholder rights plan (poison pill); Reuters reported that the trigger threshold was lowered to 10%. The company's annual report states an exercise price of $3.25 per unit of preferred stock, with one right distributed per share to shareholders of record on 2015-01-02. The board said the plan was not meant to deter bidders but to ensure all shareholders were treated fairly. [Yahoo Finance(Reuters)] [American Apparel 2014 年度 10-K]
- The day before a gathering of factory workers called by Charney, CEO Paula Schneider sent employees a letter in Spanish assuring them their jobs were secure and warning that "outside forces" were trying to cause trouble and disrupt the company's business. [BuzzFeed News] [Refinery29]
- The company asked the Delaware Court of Chancery for a temporary restraining order, arguing that Charney had violated the standstill agreement (which barred him from seeking the removal of directors and from disparaging the company). The company said he was waging a "scorched earth" campaign to regain control. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [The Irish Times(Bloomberg)]
- The Delaware Court of Chancery issued a temporary restraining order barring Charney from violating the standstill agreement, including by seeking to remove directors or making public statements disparaging the company or its employees. On June 5 he agreed to extend those restrictions through the end of the 2015 annual meeting. [Investing.com(Reuters)] [ASI Central] [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- The company signed a settlement letter with shareholder Jeffrey Kolb. Kolb had once worked for Charney and was seen as his ally in the proxy fight; he had threatened to nominate directors. Under the settlement he withdrew his nominations and proposals, and the company agreed to set up an advisory committee and look for a new independent director. With that, the battleground of a board election disappeared. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)] [The Irish Times(Bloomberg)]
- 2015 annual meeting: the proxy statement said that although Charney held about 41.4%, under the cooperation agreement and standstill agreement he could not vote at the meeting unless he reached agreement with Standard General. Standard General said it would consent only to his voting for the proposals recommended by the board. [American Apparel 2015 年委託書(DEF 14A)]
- Charney asked the company to advance his legal fees in the standstill agreement litigation. The Delaware Court of Chancery refused: he had signed the standstill agreement in his personal capacity, and the advancement obligation in the company's charter did not cover former officers. He had to pay out of his own pocket to fight the company in court. [Potter Anderson(判決摘要)]
- During the bankruptcy, Hagan Capital Group and Silver Creek Capital Partners, which supported Charney's return, submitted a roughly $300 million takeover bid on January 11 (including $90 million in new equity and a $40 million term loan). The board rejected it that same week. CEO Schneider testified in court that it was rejected because creditors did not support it. [MarketScreener(Reuters)] [Retail Dive] [HeraldNet]
- Bankruptcy Judge Brendan Shannon approved the company's own reorganization plan and rejected Charney's objections and his request to delay the ruling: the company would be delisted and nearly all its equity handed to its largest bondholders, with shareholders, Charney included, receiving nothing. The judge found that every class of creditors had accepted the plan and that the company had no obligation to pursue a sale instead. [Fortune(Reuters)] [HeraldNet]
Rumors
- Charney was looking for a financial partner to return to the company, and Irving Place Capital's buyout would bring him back if it went through. [Still unclear] Reports by the New York Post (citing anonymous sources) and The Wall Street Journal, relayed by multiple outlets Fortune reported on 2014-12-22 that the bid was not made in partnership with him and that a deal would not restore him as CEO—a consultant at most. Retail Dive, by contrast, thought Irving Place seemed to want him back in some capacity. The board never accepted the bid and no deal took place, so the claim cannot be verified. [International Business Times] [Fortune(2014-12-22)] [Retail Dive]
- A few weeks before firing him, the board offered him a multimillion-dollar compensation package to stay; he refused over the composition of the board (it would not immediately give the incoming CEO a board seat). [Still unclear] Charney's own account, reported by Yahoo News and relayed by International Business Times This is Charney's account alone; in the sources consulted, the company neither confirmed nor denied the terms of the offer. [International Business Times]
- Standard General promised to return Charney to a leadership position after the investigation, then betrayed him; the whole affair was a scheme by the fund and the board to take control away from the founder. [Still unclear] Charney's own account in a Bloomberg interview, later written into his several 2015 lawsuits Standard General denies it. In December 2017 the Delaware Court of Chancery found that the oral promises he alleged contradicted the eight written agreements he had personally signed and could not reasonably be relied on, and ordered him to repay the loan; the state Supreme Court affirmed. A California court also dismissed his defamation suit against the fund. The courts did not accept his account, but they also made no factual finding on whether any oral promise was ever made. [Fortune(2014-12-22)] [ASI Central(2018-03)] [Proskauer 加州勞動法部落格]
- Charney agreed in writing never to return to the company. [Still unclear] Chairperson Colleen Brown's letter to all employees (as described in Charney's complaint), reported by Fortune Charney denies signing any such agreement and sued Brown and the company for defamation over it. The public standstill agreement says that he may not serve as a director again and that whether he could return as CEO was for the Suitability Committee to decide. The final outcome of the defamation suit was not found in the sources consulted. [Fortune(2015-05-14)] [SEC Schedule 14F-1 資訊聲明]
- American Apparel, just seven months out of bankruptcy, was looking for a buyer and preparing to sell some or all of its assets. [Later confirmed] Media reports after the contents of CEO Schneider's resignation letter leaked When the company filed for bankruptcy a second time in November 2016, it simultaneously announced that Gildan Activewear had agreed to buy the brand; in January 2017 Gildan won the auction with an $88 million bid. [PYMNTS] [Retail TouchPoints] [The Fader]
Views
- Allan Mayer (co-chairman, director since the 2007 listing): The board took no pleasure in doing this but believed it had to be done; Charney founded the company, but it had grown bigger than any one person. [American Apparel 新聞稿(SEC 附件 99.1)]
- Dov Charney (the ousted founder, speaking to the Financial Times): He said he was the best person for the CEO job and that the board was using false allegations to advance its own agenda, which saddened him. [BuzzFeed News]
- BuzzFeed News (reporting by Sapna Maheshwari): The report noted that this board was handpicked by Charney and had never before taken action against him; without the hedge fund's help his return would be all but impossible, and it would be stunning if he actually made it back. [BuzzFeed News]
- Bigger Capital Fund and others (company shareholders): Wrote to the board that the two directors bore direct responsibility for the loss of company value and the damage to its reputation, had lost shareholders' confidence and should resign immediately. [Retail Dive]
- Anonymous source quoted by the New York Post: The source believed the affair had little to do with the misconduct allegations and was more of a power struggle. [International Business Times]
- Alice Nutting (columnist for Britain's The Independent): She considered the company's future still up in the air and said she would not rush to celebrate until it had truly made thoroughgoing changes. [International Business Times]
- Maria Luisa Salgado (spokesperson for the factory workers' coalition): She said the current management was out of touch with the culture the company was founded on. The workers' coalition rallied under the banner of saving American Apparel and wanted Charney back. [Refinery29] [BuzzFeed News]
- American Apparel company statement: The company said his claims were wrong on both the facts and the law and entirely baseless, and that it was confident of prevailing on each of them in the appropriate forum. [Fortune(2015-05-14)]
- Stephen Brauerman (Charney's Delaware lawyer): He said the court's order was only preliminary and based on filings his side had not yet had a chance to rebut fully; Charney would comply completely, but it did not affect his other lawsuits against the company. [Investing.com(Reuters)] [ASI Central]
- David Posner (lawyer for the unsecured creditors' committee): He said the bid was "interesting" for unsecured creditors, but the devil was in the details; if the lenders asserted nearly $150 million in claims under that proposal, unsecured creditors would not necessarily be better off. [MarketScreener(Reuters)]
- Retail Dive (trade media commentary): The commentary noted that the company had indeed stumbled in recent years, but that since Schneider took over, results had only gotten worse. [Retail Dive]
- Brendan Shannon (U.S. bankruptcy judge): The judge said he did not doubt that Charney sincerely wanted what was best for the company and its employees, but the plan had won enough creditor votes and he would not second-guess the company's decision. He also described Charney's testimony as resembling free association, with too little bearing on the issues at hand. [HeraldNet] [Fortune(Reuters)]
- Dov Charney (the ousted founder): He said Standard General and the senior lenders had carefully arranged to hand control to the bondholders without a fair market test or competitive bidding, and that he believed he was never going to get a fair chance. [HeraldNet]
- Andrew Herenstein (co-founder of Monarch Alternative Capital, one of the new owners): He said Monarch was pleased the plan had been confirmed and looked forward to continuing to work with the company's management team. [HeraldNet]
- Katie Shonk (writer for the Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School): She argued that the board waited too long to address Charney's conduct and that the mandatory arbitration policy had long left the board short of information; once Charney allied with Standard General, the dispute turned from a negotiation into litigation. [Harvard Program on Negotiation]
- Dov Charney (interviewed by ASI): He said few Americans could repay a sum like that, insisted that the other side's tactics were improper and the agreements should be void, and said the fight would go on for many more years. [ASI Central(2018-10-24)]
Photos & videos
American Apparel's headquarters and main factory in Los Angeles, photographed in 2007. — Coolcaesar / CC BY-SA 3.0
Customers in an American Apparel store in Los Angeles, photographed in 2007. — Cumulus Clouds / CC BY-SA 3.0
American Apparel's "Legalize LA" advertisement, a signature cause of the Charney era. — American_Apparel / CC BY-SA 2.0
Exterior of the American Apparel factory at dusk, April 2013. — American_Apparel / CC BY-SA 2.0
The American Apparel factory at night (released on the company's official Flickr). — American_Apparel / CC BY 2.0
An American Apparel store in Montreal, Canada, photographed in March 2014, three months before Charney was suspended. — bargainmoose / CC BY 2.0
The American Apparel store at Yorkdale Shopping Centre in Toronto, photographed in August 2014, just after the board had been overhauled. — Raysonho @ Open Grid Scheduler / Grid Engine / CC0An American Apparel store in Hamburg, Germany, photographed in May 2015, while the company and Charney were suing each other. — Joergsam / CC BY-SA 4.0
The American Apparel store on Neal Street in Covent Garden, London, photographed in July 2016, a few months before the company's second bankruptcy filing. — Philafrenzy / CC BY-SA 4.0
Closing-down sale at the Lincoln Road store in South Beach, Miami, February 2017, just after Gildan won the bidding for the brand. — Phillip Pessar from Miami, USA / CC BY 2.0
A closed American Apparel store in Malibu, California, July 2017. — Avattire / CC BY-SA 4.0- Los Angeles Times report: American Apparel ousts CEO Dov Charney over alleged misconduct. (Los Angeles Times)
- CNN Business: why American Apparel's CEO was fired. (CNN Business)
- Bloomberg report: Charney fights back and says he will not leave. (Bloomberg Originals)
- Bloomberg report: Charney is officially fired; what comes next for American Apparel. (Bloomberg Originals)
- After being fired, Charney tells Bloomberg in an interview that he is down to his last $100,000. (Bloomberg Originals)
- Bloomberg report: American Apparel files for bankruptcy protection. (Bloomberg Originals)